Player of the season

Bedsaddick

Gallagher

Briston_Addick

1. Gallagher

2. Lockyer

3. Photo-finish between Williams and Cullen.

Leuth

Early odds, fellas?

I reckon Gunter is very, very slight favourite over Inniss and Shinnie, with Maatsen a potential. Hard to see past those four but we have a lot of very good players

seth plum

If Pratley sustains his appearances his form and his overall contribution to results (like the odd goal or two) he will be in the running.
Right now is way too early of course.

Dazzler21

Leuth said:

Early odds, fellas?

I reckon Gunter is very, very slight favourite over Inniss and Shinnie, with Maatsen a potential. Hard to see past those four but we have a lot of very good players

Washington with his 23 goals he's currently on target for. 

Leuth

For sure, Pratley is playing well enough right now, but the question is whether he can keep it up for 46 games, and whether Bowyer keeps faith in him as the pivot when Gilbey etc return. I personally think he'll rotate out of the side enough that one of the four I mentioned will take it on sheer weight of minutes played

ForeverAddickted

One of those seasons where a lot of players could be in contention:

Gunter is bit of a Mr Dependable like Pratley yet might get over looked by others who do things a bit more special
Inniss will no doubt get votes for his no nonsense defending but Famewo is just as good if not slightly better yet does things slightly quieter
Shinnie gets my vote at the moment, is playing like I hoped Billy Clarke would play... Really is the conductor in this orchestra for me
Washington if he get close to 20-goals will also get votes, as too could Aneke for the way he imposes himself in games

LonelyNorthernAddick

I'm going to go with an early shout of Shinnie. Think he's got the tank and skill to stick in the side for a large number of games, and could cut defenses open when our attack gets sharper

ForeverAddickted

LonelyNorthernAddick said:

I'm going to go with an early shout of Shinnie. Think he's got the tank and skill to stick in the side for a large number of games, and could cut defenses open when our attack gets sharper

I pity teams when we got Shinnie doing it one side and Gilbey doing the exact same thing the other

Teams arent going to know what to do or who to mark when they start ghosting about the Midfield

Leuth

I just find it beyond belief that Shinnie could have played for Birmingham City. It's so weird, like a poet who goes to work as a tax collector or something

Leuth

Even weirder is that the nation of Scotland could have produced him

801912601

I would add Amos to the shortlist 

CafcWest

Leuth said:

I just find it beyond belief that Shinnie could have played for Birmingham City. It's so weird, like a poet who goes to work as a tax collector or something

You mean like Albert Einstein?

Redrobo

You are all peaking way too early. It is a bloody long season and there will be a lot of twists and turns and injuries and recalls and new players.

Weegie Addick

Leuth said:

Even weirder is that the nation of Scotland could have produced him

Oi, watch it 

Must admit I hadn't even realised he was Scottish till I saw his brother playing for Derby and looked them up!!

Dazzler21

cafc-west said:

Leuth said:

I just find it beyond belief that Shinnie could have played for Birmingham City. It's so weird, like a poet who goes to work as a tax collector or something

You mean like Albert Einstein?

When did he play for Birmingham?

PopIcon

Player of the month for Oct?

Pratley, Shinnie, Famewo, Gunter. They've all done so well.

cafcsinger

Gilbey

ForeverAddickted

Redrobo said:

You are all peaking way too early. It is a bloody long season and there will be a lot of twists and turns and injuries and recalls and new players.

At the moment in January I'd love it if we could add Shinnie on a permanent basis and use his loan slot to bring in a Premier League U23 Striker

Dazzler21

Maddison when fit. 

soapboxsam

I would like it to be a 18 man tie for POTY.
I was going to say 25 but that might be pushing it.

Addick Addict

This thread reminds me of one of those bookmaker markets where punters blindly back those at the front of the market. Only to find that the ultimate winner isn't even in the market let alone being backed at this present time.

Step forward Marcus Maddison!

CafcWest

Dazzler21 said:

cafc-west said:

Leuth said:

I just find it beyond belief that Shinnie could have played for Birmingham City. It's so weird, like a poet who goes to work as a tax collector or something

You mean like Albert Einstein?

When did he play for Birmingham?

The genius Einstein, in his early days, worked as a simple patent inspector in Switzerland...I was attempting a very subtle comparison!

Dazzler21

I was joking. Missed the smiley. 

LTKapal

Surprised nobody has mentioned aneke, he's changed the pace and feel of every game he's come on so far 

JohnnyJoeyDeeDee

I really hope it’s someone we sign in January

LonelyNorthernAddick

LTKapal said:

Surprised nobody has mentioned aneke, he's changed the pace and feel of every game he's come on so far 

I would if I thought if he would start enough games, oozed confidence when he came on on Tuesday.