Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks; Charlton v Blackburn (closes Monday lunchtime)

At the Valley or on a live steam, your marks please: 

Phillips: 
Lockyer: 
Pearce: 
Sarr: 
Matthews: 
Davis: 
Cullen: 
McGeady: 
Doughty: 
Taylor: 
Hemed: 
Smith: 
Green: 
Bonne: 
Referee: 


«13

Comments

  • Phillips: 5.5 
    Lockyer: 4.5 most of those are second half marks 
    Pearce: 6 although lucky to get away with the non pen 
    Sarr: 7 1 aberration but good otherwise 
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5.5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 6.5
    Taylor: 5.5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 5 if he’s better than Morgan, I support palace 
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 6 some decent touches 

  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 4
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 4
    Green: 4
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 6
  • RobRob
    edited February 15
    Phillips:  6
    Lockyer:  6 
    Pearce:  6
    Sarr:   7
    Matthews:   6.5
    Davis:  6
    Cullen:  7
    McGeady:  7
    Doughty:  5 
    Taylor:  5
    Hemed:  5
    Smith:  5 
    Green:  5
    Bonne:  5
    Referee:  5
  • At the Valley or on a live steam, your marks please: 

    Phillips:  7 Always good 
    Lockyer:  6.5
    Pearce:  6  battler but we play so deep we play in our own half.  Very frustrating 
    Sarr:  8  our only good performance 
    Matthews:  6
    Davis:  5.5
    Cullen:  5.5  what happened to Josh ?
    McGeady:  5.5 Was excellent a long time ago
    Doughty:  7 Tried hard and our only outlet 
    Taylor:  5 very poor today 
    Hemed:  5 one shot 
    Smith:   5 not sure what the point is
    Green:  5
    Bonne:  5
    Referee:  3 thank goodness 



  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 6
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 6.5
    Matthews: 6,5
    Davis: 5.5
    Cullen: 5.5
    McGeady: 5.5
    Doughty: 6
    Taylor: 5.5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 5
    Green: 4
    Bonne: 4
    Referee: 5.5

  • Phillips: 5 how it takes him 30 seconds to take a goal kick is beyond me, especially when 2-0 down, it's not like it's pinpoint accurate when he eventually kicks it either
    Lockyer: 3 couldn't cope with the wind and should have been hooked at halftime
    Pearce: 5 did better than Lockyer, but was definitely a penalty, awful defending
    Sarr: 5.5 struggled today once he gave it away a couple of times, some great last ditch defending too
    Matthews: 4.5 looked poor on the ball and was caught too far forwards a lot in the first half
    Davis: 4 I fail to see what he offers that Pratley doesn't
    Cullen: 4.5 huffed and puffed but didn't look good today
    McGeady: 5.5 did ok but faded and a couple of short corners to him were awful
    Doughty: 5 lots of running but very raw and has quite poor decision making
    Taylor: 4.5 not a lot happened for him today and didn't win the "battle"
    Hemed: 4 doesn't look like scoring anytime soon
    Smith: 5.5 a couple of decent touches and passes but didn't have much of an influence
    Green: 5 a few flicks and some decent control aside I barely noticed him
    Bonne: 4 had no real influence whatsoever
    Referee: 2 a point for every decision he got correct today

    We were shite today
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 6
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 7.5
    Matthews: 7
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 6
    Doughty: 6.5
    Taylor: 5.5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 5.5
    Green: 6
    Bonne: 5.5
    Referee: 3

  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 4
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 6
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 5
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 6
    Referee: 4



  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 4.5
    Pearce: 4.5
    Sarr: 5
    Matthews: 5
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 6
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 5
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 4
    Referee: 2
  • Phillips:  6
    Lockyer:  5
    Pearce:  6
    Sarr:   7
    Matthews:   7
    Davis:  6
    Cullen:  6.5
    McGeady:  6.5
    Doughty:  5 
    Taylor:  5
    Hemed:  5
    Smith:  5 
    Green:  5
    Bonne:  5
    Referee:  5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 6
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 6
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 6
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 6
    Smith: 6
    Green: 6
    Bonne: 6
    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 4
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews: 5
    Davis: 4
    Cullen: 5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 5
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 5
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 1

  • edited February 15
    Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 6
    Sarr: 6.5
    Matthews: 7
    Davis: 5 poor
    Cullen: 5 non existent
    McGeady: 5.5
    Doughty: 6
    Taylor: 6.5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 4
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 7

  • Phillips: 5
    Lockyer: 4
    Pearce: 4
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews: 4.5
    Davis: 4.5
    Cullen: 5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 4.5
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 5
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 2
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 6.5
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews: 6.5 
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6.5
    McGeady: 6
    Doughty: 5.5
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 5.5
    Smith: 5
    Green: 5.5
    Bonne: 6
    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 6  Good
    Lockyer: 4 Really struggled today
    Pearce: 5 slightly better than Locker, but not much
    Sarr: 6 Some v good, some a bit dodgy 
    Matthews: 6 Assured
    Davis: 4 he doesn't like heading the ball does he? Very disappointing
    Cullen: 7 works so hard all game just do the simple things right. A water carrier and a vital player 
    McGeady: 5 nothing quite came off
    Doughty: 6 decent performance
    Taylor: 6 positive direct, but disappointing delivery
    Hemed: 5 needs better movement
    Smith: 4 barely registered
    Green: 5 didn't have much of a chance
    Bonne: 6 looked positive, good touch.

  • Phillips: 6 - Maybe could have done better with the goals today
    Lockyer: 6 - Not bad but struggled at times today
    Pearce: 5 - Poor today, very lucky not to give away a penalty
    Sarr: 6 - Did well today, was hindered going back to a flat four though
    Matthews: 6 - Didnt quite come off for him going forward, did well on the one v ones
    Davis: 5 - Not as good as Tuesday night
    Cullen: 6 - Tried his hardest to control the midfield
    McGeady: 5 - Few good bursting runs but ineffective compared to Williams and Oztumer in that role
    Doughty: 5 - Struggled today, felt he got bullied a bit too much
    Taylor: 6 - Unlucky not to score
    Hemed: 5 - Not as good as his performance on Tuesday, didnt really get the ball to feetr

    Smith: 5 - Better performance today compared to his debut
    Green: 5 - Nothing really came off for him
    Bonne: 5 - Same as Green, game had gone by the time he came on

    Referee: 5 - Poor today, but got a lot of decisions right
  • At the Valley or on a live steam, your marks please: 

    Phillips: 5
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews 6: 
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 6
    Hemed: 3
    Smith: 4
    Green: 5
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 2



  • Phillips: 7 not to blame 
    Lockyer: 6 not his best
    Pearce: 5 looked like a pen to us
    Sarr: 7 good game Nabster only one “moment”
    Matthews: 6 looked knackered 
    Davis: 5 one of 3 holding midfield players possibly the best of them but creates little
    Cullen: 6 not at his best
    McGeady: 4 failed to impress
    Doughty: 6 again looked knackered 
    Taylor: 7 worked hard bugger all service
    Hemed: 2 he’s really not very good
    Smith: 4 wrong sub another holding player
    Green: 4 no impact but tried 
    Bonne: 4 as above
    Referee: 5 glad he did not give the penalty 

    thought we done nothing right today

  • Phillips: 6 couldn't do much about the goals
    Lockyer: 5 looked like he was playing on ice
    Pearce: 5 got away with the non-penalty
    Sarr: 6 got away with the handball
    Matthews: 6 did okay
    Davis: 5.5 not as good as Pratley
    Cullen: 6 needs better players around him
    McGeady: 6 showed some glimpses 
    Doughty: 5 not good defensively
    Taylor: 6.5 deserves a better partner
    Hemed: 5 not good enough
    Smith: 5 why him at half-time? 
    Green: 6.5 looked dangerous 
    Bonne: 6 glad to have him back
    Referee: 4 awful but not why we lost
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 5
    Lockyer: 4
    Pearce: 4
    Sarr: 6.5
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 5.5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 4.5
    Taylor: 5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 4
    Green: 4
    Bonne: 4
    Referee: 6

    LB: 5
  • Phillips: 5
    Lockyer: 4 Worst yet.
    Pearce: 4
    Sarr: 6.5 Ha, sublime, awful, sublime - normal Naby!
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 5.5
    McGeady: 6 
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 6 Maybe should have scored with his header.
    Hemed: 4 Very slow but no chances. 
    Smith: 4
    Green: 4
    Bonne: 4

    Referee: 6
    Me 10 got drenched but stayed until the last minute.
  • edited February 15
    Phillips: 6 - didn’t have much to do. 
    Lockyer: 5 - looked uncertain in the wind. 
    Pearce: 5.5  got away with a penalty. Missed the second half shambles. 
    Sarr: 6 - a few Bambi on ice moments but was our MOM for what it was worth today. 
    Matthews: 5.5. Was generally ok but at fault for their first goal 
    Davis: 4. Disappointing. Expected better. Slow as a cart horse. 
    Cullen: 5. Poor.  Our shape is bypassing him. 
    McGeady: 5 great for 20 minutes, utterly anonymous for 70 
    Doughty: 5. Great effort as always but his rawness is now coming to the fore. Crossing and decision making are poor. 
    Taylor: 5. Poor today with a couple of highlights. 
    Hemed: 3 utterly pointless
    Smith: 4 - we’ve got enough out of their depth youngsters of our own. We don’t need this one as well. 
    Green: 4 - powderpuff
    Bonne: 4 - zero impact 
    Referee: 3. Tool. Lost control of the game although it wasn't his fault that we completely failed to defend the free kick that he gave in error for their second. 
  • edited February 15
    Phillips:  6
    Lockyer:  6 
    Pearce:  6
    Sarr:   6.5
    Matthews:   5.5
    Davis:  6
    Cullen:  7
    McGeady:  6
    Doughty:  6 
    Taylor:  5
    Hemed:  5
    Smith:  5 
    Green:  5
    Bonne:  5
  • edited February 15
    Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 4
    Taylor: 5
    Hemed: 5
    Smith: 6
    Green: 6
    Bonne: 5
  • edited February 15
    Phillips: 5 Poor kicking again.
    Lockyer: 5 
    Pearce: 3 He looks fine as long as the ball isn't anywhere near him
    Sarr: 7 did well.
    Matthews: 4.5 looked scared to move forwards with the ball, even with space in front of him
    Davis: 5 
    Cullen: 4.5 
    McGeady: 3 Lack of effort for their second goal was a disgrace
    Doughty: 5 Poor decision making in final third
    Taylor: 4.5
    Hemed: 4 I'm calling time on Tomer. Josh Davison has scored more goals.
    Smith: 6 tried hard, some tidy play, a few mistakes.
    Green: 6 decent run or two.
    Bonne: Not giving a score. Did he even touch the ball?
    Referee: 5 If he got the Pearce penalty decision right, that's a great call, because it looked a dead cert penalty to me. 
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5.5
    Pearce: 5.5
    Sarr: 7.5 MOM. Just the 1 error. The most creative Cafc player.
    Matthews: 5.5
    Davis: 5.5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 5.5
    Doughty: 6 still learning
    Taylor: 6 100% effort but couldn't take the half chances
    Hemed: 5.5 non scoring striker 
    Smith: 6 difficult for the lad
    Green: 6
    Bonne: 5.5 we need him up to speed.
    Referee: 6 looked a penalty from my seat.



  • Phillips: 6.5 OK

    Lockyer:  6 better in the four
    Pearce:  6 some good work including the shimmy
    Sarr: 7 reliable
    Matthews: 6 got forward well
    Davis: 6 broke up well
    Cullen: 6.5 getting mojo back
    McGeady: 6 prefer him on wing making stuff happen
    Doughty: 5.5 quiet
    Taylor:  6 off day
    Hemed: 4 mate tasked me to mention his highlights. There weren't any.
    Smith: 5 no time to shine
    Green:  5 ditto
    Bonne: 6.5 lively

    Referee:  4 not helped by his useless linos.
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 6
    Davis: 5
    Cullen: 6
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 5.5
    Taylor: 5
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 6
    Green: 4.5
    Bonne: 5
    Referee: 3
  • Phillips: 5
    Lockyer: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Sarr: 5
    Matthews: 5
    Davis: 4.5
    Cullen: 5
    McGeady: 5
    Doughty: 5
    Taylor: 5
    Hemed: 4
    Smith: 4
    Green: 4
    Bonne: 4
    Referee: 6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!