Players Marks: Birmingham v Charlton (closes Thursday teatime)

msomerton

Phillips: 7
Matthews: 5
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 5
Doughty: 8
McGeady: 6
Cuillen: 5
Field: 6
Williams: 5
Bonne: 6
Hemed: 4
Aneke: 7
Refere

EveshamAddick

Phillips: 8 - great penalty save and kept us in it, unlucky with the goal 
Matthews: 7.5 mostly solid, didn’t get forward much 
Lockyer: 7.5 - strong and solid, took an elbow in the face 
Pearce: 7.5 - strong and solid but was can’t rely on him to play forward balls out of defence
Doughty: 8.5 Great assist, our biggest threat but playing too deep
McGeady: 8 - his best game for us
Cuillen: 6 - not sure what’s happened to him since his 3 MoM performances he’s not been at the races.
Field: 7.5 did ok, looked a bit ponderous at times
Williams: 7 - stop diving!
Bonne: 8 - got the goal and unlucky not to score a second
Hemed: 7 - not ever going to score for us, hold up play is reasonable 
Aneke: 8- looked good when he came on
Referee: 6 bit of a homer. Pen looked harsh.

Purrington: n/a
Pratley: n/a 
Morgan: n/a
Sarr: n/a

redman

Phillips: 9
Matthews: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7
Doughty: 6
McGeady: 7
Cuillen: 6
Field: 7
Williams: 6
Bonne: 5
Hemed: 6.5
Aneke: 7
Referee: 5

golfaddick

lancashire lad said:

your marks here and please do not comment on other Lifers marks, we all have our own ideas please respect them:

Phillips:    8.5
Matthews: 7
Lockyer:     8
Pearce:       7.5
Doughty:     8
McGeady:    8
Cuillen:        5
Field:           7.5
Williams:    7.5
Bonne:         7.5
Hemed:        6
Aneke:         7
Referee: 

Purrington: n/a
Pratley: n/a 
Morgan: n/a
Sarr: n/a

As above assuming the daft post with 5 "1's" is null & voided. Otherwise add 10 to all the above.

thewolfboy

Phillips: 8 My POTY
Matthews: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7
Doughty: 8
McGeady: 6.5
Cullen: 6
Field: 7
Williams: 6
Bonne: 5
Hemed: 4
Aneke: 6
Referee: 5