Amos: 7 - clean sheet and dealt with balls into the box well Inniss: 7 - finally we have a defence that doesn't get dominated in the air Pratley: 6.5 - love him Famewo: 7.5 - will be a key player this year Gunter: 7 - did well against arguably their most dangerous player on the day. Watson: 6 - did ok Shinnie: 6 - did ok Forster-Caskey: 7 good to see him back, was our best midfielder today Doughty: 6 - don't like him at left back at all.. needs to get better in 1v1 situations as he dives in too easily if he's to play there. Aneke: 8 - MoM caused them all sorts of problems and made things happen. Hope he's ready to start starting starting from now. Smyth: 7 lively and offered another outlet up top that we've missed since leko in someone to hold the ball and take on defenders. Much better for the team than having a passenger up top. Bogle: 6 - seemed decent Referee: 10 - world class comedian.
Amos: 7 one fumbled shot, but some good save and catches Inniss: 7 won so many headers. Warrior we needed. Pratley: 6 wonder if he’ll end up starting on the bench this season Famewo: 7 very good all round Gunter: 7 really solid Watson: 6 will improve, I hope Shinnie: 7.5 very positive Forster-Caskey: 7 very good today Doughty: 7 battled on after being taken out by a moron Aneke: 8 Brilliant performance. Smyth: 7 Tricky and nippy Bogle: 7 Good target man. Promising. Referee: 4 Nutter
Amos: 7 - Brilliant save from the corner and made up for his spill Inniss: 7 - Passing aside, I thought he had a solid debut, very good in the air and commanding Pratley: 5.5 - Just didn't work for me with Prat today Famewo: 7.5 - He had Garner in his back pocket all game Gunter: 6.5 - Did well, Not going to judge him to Matthew's on one appearance Watson: 6 - Watson's experience was needed at the end, some good clearances and interceptions, but him and Prat slowed down the midfield today, one or the other please. Shinnie: 6 - He did okay Forster-Caskey: 7 - Poor first half, better on formation change and after his goal. Doughty: 6.5 - tried, not the same after the head injury Aneke: 9 - All he needed was a goal, he was outstanding today MOTM Smyth: 7 - Good stuff from Smyth first half, never stopped trying, quick and good inbehind. Look forward to seeing more Bogle: 6.5 - some good touches and turns, unlucky with his shot, good effort Referee: 3.5 - Awful, I personally thought it was a pen for Wigan, Watson was late and we got away with it
Amos: 7 Steady eddie performance despite one slip that might have proved costly Inniss: 7 Solid aerial unit. Bit of an unsteady start but improved as the game went on. Pratley: 6 Not his best performance, not his best position. Either play him or the Doctor but not both. Famewo: 6.5 Solid enough Gunter: 6.5 A few good interceptions reads the game well Watson: 5 Another yellow card showing Shinnie: 6 Shows promise Forster-Caskey: 7 Good performance. Thought the wall was > 10 yards from his free kick and did the bounce in front of the keeper deceive the stopper? Doughty: 6.5 Played better Aneke: 8 Giant of a man deserved a goal Smyth: 8 Energizer Bunny didn't stop running. Great at long throw-ins Bogle:6 Early days yet but could have a big influence on our season Referee: 5
Amos: 8 some very good saves. Inniss: 7 encouraging debut. Won most things in the air. Passing range needs some fine tuning. Pratley: 5 don’t like him in the diamond unless it’s at the base. Bowyer loves his leadership but, despite getting up and own the pitch pretty well, he’s too defensive in that role for me because he slows the play and gave the ball away a lot and missed two decent chances. Famewo: 7 very solid. Like him. Gunter: 5.5 least impressive of the new boys. Got beat for pace on his outside and failed to stop the cross quite a few times and didn’t get forward much. Will probably improve with games but a slow start. Watson: 5.5 not as bad as some made out, but didn’t exactly boss the midfield either. Shinnie: 6 Neat and tidy without really standing out. Another who will get better with games. Forster-Caskey: 7.5 best he’s played for ages. Perhaps finally starting to shake off the rustiness that’s can be hard to shift after such a long injury lay-off. Doughty: 6 Another fast but not a lot else type performance from him. Decent enough defensively and showed some spikiness in his ongoing confrontation with their winger, but still his decision making and final ball lets him down in the final third. It’ll come for him, I’m sure, but his brain doesn’t work as fast as his feet at the moment. Aneke: 8.5 Beast mode activated. Unplayable at times. Just lacked a goal. Hope we can eventually get more than 60 mins from him. Smyth: 6.5 Lively and the makings of a good foil for Aneke. Encouraging debut. Long throw is a bonus if we can learn how to use it. Bogle: 7 Not quite the same impact as Aneke, but not far short. Certainly looks a very similar player. Referee: 4. Probably went in our favour overall, but he barely got a thing right all afternoon.
Amos: 7 couple of good saves and claimed crosses Inniss: 7.5 just the sort of CB you need in this division Pratley: 6.5 got better as game went on Famewo: 7 showed good strength against wily opponent Gunter: 6.5 his experience in the back line will be invaluable Watson: 6 slow start but showed his experience Shinnie: 6 steady Forster-Caskey: 6.5 in and out of the game Doughty 6 still don’t think LB knows what his best position is to get the most from his pace Aneke: 8 deserved a goal, best display in a Charlton shirt Smyth: worked hard but not particularly threatening Bogle: 6 will take a few games to get sharp Referee: 4 some odd decisions
Purrington: n/a helped shore us up at the end Washington: n/a good energy to see us over the line
Amos: 7 couple of good saves and claimed crosses Inniss: 7.5 just the sort of CB you need in this division Pratley: 6.5 got better as game went on Famewo: 7 showed good strength against wily opponent Gunter: 6.5 his experience in the back line will be invaluable Watson: 6 slow start but showed his experience Shinnie: 6 steady Forster-Caskey: 6.5 in and out of the game Doughty 6 still don’t think LB knows what his best position is to get the most from his pace Aneke: 8 deserved a goal, best display in a Charlton shirt Smyth: worked hard but not particularly threatening Bogle: 6 will take a few games to get sharp Referee: 4 some odd decisions
Purrington: n/a helped shore us up at the end Washington: n/a good energy to see us over the line
Amos: 7.5 Inniss: 7.5 looked good Pratley: 6 contributed but out of position Famewo: 7.5 Gunter: 7.5 Watson: 5 hope he gets better as he gets fitter, jury still out Shinnie: 7 Forster-Caskey: 7.5 extra for the goal. Frustrating player but made a big impact today Doughty: 7 Aneke: 8 showed us what he is capable of today. Hope he can last a whole game soon Smyth: 7 promising start Bogle:6.5 will get better Referee: 4 bizarre decisions at times.
Amos: 7 Inniss: 7 Pratley: 6 Famewo: 8.5 - Must be one of the best CBs in the league. Gunter: 7 Watson: 5 - Stinker Shinnie: 6.5 Forster-Caskey: 7.5 - Found his role today? Doughty: 6 Aneke: 8.5 - Unplayable. If he starts scoring, what a player we have on our hands. Smyth: 7 Bogle: 6.5 Referee: 5
Amos: 7 couple of good saves and claimed crosses Inniss: 7.5 just the sort of CB you need in this division Pratley: 6.5 got better as game went on Famewo: 7 showed good strength against wily opponent Gunter: 6.5 his experience in the back line will be invaluable Watson: 6 slow start but showed his experience Shinnie: 6 steady Forster-Caskey: 6.5 in and out of the game Doughty 6 still don’t think LB knows what his best position is to get the most from his pace Aneke: 8 deserved a goal, best display in a Charlton shirt Smyth: worked hard but not particularly threatening Bogle: 6 will take a few games to get sharp Referee: 4 some odd decisions
Purrington: n/a helped shore us up at the end Washington: n/a good energy to see us over the line
Amos: 7 - spilled one in the second half but generally very sound Inniss: 7 - a very solid debut and perhaps the physical presence we've lacked since Bauer's departure Pratley: 6 - ok but slowed our tempo (as did Watson) and the formation didn't suit him. The blend will be better once we get Maddison and Gilbey back and Shinnie gets up to speed Famewo: 7 - classy Gunter: 6 - did alright against a tricky winger and will get better with more games Watson: 5.5 - a bit one-paced Shinnie: 6 - did alright for someone who'd only played once this season Forster-Caskey: 6.5 - a poor first half but picked up in the second, especially after the goal Doughty: 7 - one of our main attacking threats, even if it was a little sporadic. Hope he's ok for Tuesday Aneke: 8: MoM - a couple of sublime pieces of control and a real handful for the Wigan defence Smyth: 7: scuttled around to good effect and long throws for Innis to flick on at the near post could be a useful weapon Bogle: 6 - did ok and the minutes will help him get up to speed Referee: 4 - poor
Amos: 7 Good performance Inniss: 7 Looked nervous early on withn his distribution but I have a feeling he will become a legend Pratley: 6 Doesn't work alongside Watson in midfield. Which one of them starts Tuesday ? Famewo: 7 I like him . Hopefully he can build an effective partnership with Inniss Gunter: 7 Good sound performance . Watson: 6 Gains a point for the excellent way he saw out the game . See also Pratley Shinnie: 6 Early days Forster-Caskey: 9 I would not have complained had he followed Lapslie and Ozzy on loan . He proved me wrong MOTM looks a good player again Doughty: 6 Prefer him further up the pitch Aneke: 8 I wish he could last longer was unplayable at times Smyth: 7 Promising debut . His long throws could be useful at this level Bogle: 6 Kept the pressure going . A good rotation option for Aneke
Amos: 6 Lost one for the spill Inniss: 6.5 Grew into it, bad clearance in first half which he and Gunter struggled to clear Gunter: 6.5 Against their best player held his own well, but outpaced by the end Famewo: 7.5 Pick of the defenders Doughty: 6 clash on the head seemed to affect him Pratley: 7 covered a lot of ground with very few mistakes Watson: 5 did the same but with plenty of mistakes, far too many Shinnie: 7 promising debut, great touch through to Smyth JFC: 8 his flick in the first half was class, well saved. +1 for the goal Smyth: 7.5 I like the look of this guy, think he'll give us plenty Aneke: 8 MOM. Unstoppable, held it up very well. Bogle: 5.5 hopefully we'll see better Ref: 5 Annoying.
Comments
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
Watson: 5
Shinnie: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 6
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7 - finally we have a defence that doesn't get dominated in the air
Pratley: 6.5 - love him
Famewo: 7.5 - will be a key player this year
Gunter: 7 - did well against arguably their most dangerous player on the day.
Watson: 6 - did ok
Shinnie: 6 - did ok
Forster-Caskey: 7 good to see him back, was our best midfielder today
Doughty: 6 - don't like him at left back at all.. needs to get better in 1v1 situations as he dives in too easily if he's to play there.
Aneke: 8 - MoM caused them all sorts of problems and made things happen. Hope he's ready to start starting starting from now.
Smyth: 7 lively and offered another outlet up top that we've missed since leko in someone to hold the ball and take on defenders. Much better for the team than having a passenger up top.
Bogle: 6 - seemed decent
Referee: 10 - world class comedian.
Purrington: n/a
Washington: n/a
Inniss: 7 won so many headers. Warrior we needed.
Pratley: 6 wonder if he’ll end up starting on the bench this season
Famewo: 7 very good all round
Gunter: 7 really solid
Watson: 6 will improve, I hope
Shinnie: 7.5 very positive
Forster-Caskey: 7 very good today
Doughty: 7 battled on after being taken out by a moron
Aneke: 8 Brilliant performance.
Smyth: 7 Tricky and nippy
Bogle: 7 Good target man. Promising.
Referee: 4 Nutter
Inniss: 7 - Passing aside, I thought he had a solid debut, very good in the air and commanding
Pratley: 5.5 - Just didn't work for me with Prat today
Famewo: 7.5 - He had Garner in his back pocket all game
Gunter: 6.5 - Did well, Not going to judge him to Matthew's on one appearance
Watson: 6 - Watson's experience was needed at the end, some good clearances and interceptions, but him and Prat slowed down the midfield today, one or the other please.
Shinnie: 6 - He did okay
Forster-Caskey: 7 - Poor first half, better on formation change and after his goal.
Doughty: 6.5 - tried, not the same after the head injury
Aneke: 9 - All he needed was a goal, he was outstanding today MOTM
Smyth: 7 - Good stuff from Smyth first half, never stopped trying, quick and good inbehind. Look forward to seeing more
Bogle: 6.5 - some good touches and turns, unlucky with his shot, good effort
Referee: 3.5 - Awful, I personally thought it was a pen for Wigan, Watson was late and we got away with it
Inniss: 7.5
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 6.5
Gunter: 6.5
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 7.5
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7
Bogle:6.5
Referee: 4
Inniss: 7 Solid aerial unit. Bit of an unsteady start but improved as the game went on.
Pratley: 6 Not his best performance, not his best position. Either play him or the Doctor but not both.
Famewo: 6.5 Solid enough
Gunter: 6.5 A few good interceptions reads the game well
Watson: 5 Another yellow card showing
Shinnie: 6 Shows promise
Forster-Caskey: 7 Good performance. Thought the wall was > 10 yards from his free kick and did the bounce in front of the keeper deceive the stopper?
Doughty: 6.5 Played better
Aneke: 8 Giant of a man deserved a goal
Smyth: 8 Energizer Bunny didn't stop running. Great at long throw-ins
Bogle:6 Early days yet but could have a big influence on our season
Referee: 5
Purrington: n/a
Washington: n/a
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6
Watson: 5
Shinnie: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 6
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 6
Bogle: 6
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 7
Famewo: 7.5
Gunter: 7.5
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Doughty: 6.5
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7.5
Bogle: 6.5
Referee: 5
Purrington: n/a
Washington: n/a
Inniss: 7 encouraging debut. Won most things in the air. Passing range needs some fine tuning.
Pratley: 5 don’t like him in the diamond unless it’s at the base. Bowyer loves his leadership but, despite getting up and own the pitch pretty well, he’s too defensive in that role for me because he slows the play and gave the ball away a lot and missed two decent chances.
Famewo: 7 very solid. Like him.
Gunter: 5.5 least impressive of the new boys. Got beat for pace on his outside and failed to stop the cross quite a few times and didn’t get forward much. Will probably improve with games but a slow start.
Watson: 5.5 not as bad as some made out, but didn’t exactly boss the midfield either.
Shinnie: 6 Neat and tidy without really standing out. Another who will get better with games.
Forster-Caskey: 7.5 best he’s played for ages. Perhaps finally starting to shake off the rustiness that’s can be hard to shift after such a long injury lay-off.
Doughty: 6 Another fast but not a lot else type performance from him. Decent enough defensively and showed some spikiness in his ongoing confrontation with their winger, but still his decision making and final ball lets him down in the final third. It’ll come for him, I’m sure, but his brain doesn’t work as fast as his feet at the moment.
Aneke: 8.5 Beast mode activated. Unplayable at times. Just lacked a goal. Hope we can eventually get more than 60 mins from him.
Smyth: 6.5 Lively and the makings of a good foil for Aneke. Encouraging debut. Long throw is a bonus if we can learn how to use it.
Bogle: 7 Not quite the same impact as Aneke, but not far short. Certainly looks a very similar player.
Referee: 4. Probably went in our favour overall, but he barely got a thing right all afternoon.
Purrington: n/a
Washington: n/a
Amos: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
Watson: 5
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 8
Doughty: 6.5
Aneke: 8 hope he can stay fit this season
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 6
Referee: 3 yet another very poor ref
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 6
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Doughty: 6.5
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7.5
Bogle:6
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7.5
Bogle: 6.5
Referee: 5
Purrington: n/a
Washington: n/a
Inniss: 7.5 just the sort of CB you need in this division
Pratley: 6.5 got better as game went on
Famewo: 7 showed good strength against wily opponent
Gunter: 6.5 his experience in the back line will be invaluable
Watson: 6 slow start but showed his experience
Shinnie: 6 steady
Forster-Caskey: 6.5 in and out of the game
Doughty 6 still don’t think LB knows what his best position is to get the most from his pace
Aneke: 8 deserved a goal, best display in a Charlton shirt
Smyth: worked hard but not particularly threatening
Bogle: 6 will take a few games to get sharp
Referee: 4 some odd decisions
Purrington: n/a helped shore us up at the end
Washington: n/a good energy to see us over the line
Inniss: 7.5 looked good
Pratley: 6 contributed but out of position
Famewo: 7.5
Gunter: 7.5
Watson: 5 hope he gets better as he gets fitter, jury still out
Shinnie: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7.5 extra for the goal. Frustrating player but made a big impact today
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 8 showed us what he is capable of today. Hope he can last a whole game soon
Smyth: 7 promising start
Bogle:6.5 will get better
Referee: 4 bizarre decisions at times.
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 6.5
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 6.5
Bogle: 6
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7.5
Pratley: 7
Famewo: 7.5
Gunter: 7.5
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 8
Smyth: 7.5
Bogle: 6.5
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 8.5 - Must be one of the best CBs in the league.
Gunter: 7
Watson: 5 - Stinker
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7.5 - Found his role today?
Doughty: 6
Aneke: 8.5 - Unplayable. If he starts scoring, what a player we have on our hands.
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 6.5
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 7
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 7
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Doughty: 6.5
Aneke: 7.5 MOM
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 7
Referee: 5
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 8
Gunter: 7.5
Watson: 5
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 8.5
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 5
Inniss: 7 - a very solid debut and perhaps the physical presence we've lacked since Bauer's departure
Pratley: 6 - ok but slowed our tempo (as did Watson) and the formation didn't suit him. The blend will be better once we get Maddison and Gilbey back and Shinnie gets up to speed
Famewo: 7 - classy
Gunter: 6 - did alright against a tricky winger and will get better with more games
Watson: 5.5 - a bit one-paced
Shinnie: 6 - did alright for someone who'd only played once this season
Forster-Caskey: 6.5 - a poor first half but picked up in the second, especially after the goal
Doughty: 7 - one of our main attacking threats, even if it was a little sporadic. Hope he's ok for Tuesday
Aneke: 8: MoM - a couple of sublime pieces of control and a real handful for the Wigan defence
Smyth: 7: scuttled around to good effect and long throws for Innis to flick on at the near post could be a useful weapon
Bogle: 6 - did ok and the minutes will help him get up to speed
Referee: 4 - poor
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6.5
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Doughty: 7
Aneke: 7.5
Smyth: 7
Bogle: 6.5
Referee: 6.5
Inniss: 7 Looked nervous early on withn his distribution but I have a feeling he will become a legend
Pratley: 6 Doesn't work alongside Watson in midfield. Which one of them starts Tuesday ?
Famewo: 7 I like him . Hopefully he can build an effective partnership with Inniss
Gunter: 7 Good sound performance .
Watson: 6 Gains a point for the excellent way he saw out the game . See also Pratley
Shinnie: 6 Early days
Forster-Caskey: 9 I would not have complained had he followed Lapslie and Ozzy on loan . He proved me wrong MOTM looks a good player again
Doughty: 6 Prefer him further up the pitch
Aneke: 8 I wish he could last longer was unplayable at times
Smyth: 7 Promising debut . His long throws could be useful at this level
Bogle: 6 Kept the pressure going . A good rotation option for Aneke
Inniss: 6.5 Grew into it, bad clearance in first half which he and Gunter struggled to clear
Gunter: 6.5 Against their best player held his own well, but outpaced by the end
Famewo: 7.5 Pick of the defenders
Doughty: 6 clash on the head seemed to affect him
Pratley: 7 covered a lot of ground with very few mistakes
Watson: 5 did the same but with plenty of mistakes, far too many
Shinnie: 7 promising debut, great touch through to Smyth
JFC: 8 his flick in the first half was class, well saved. +1 for the goal
Smyth: 7.5 I like the look of this guy, think he'll give us plenty
Aneke: 8 MOM. Unstoppable, held it up very well.
Bogle: 5.5 hopefully we'll see better
Ref: 5 Annoying.
Inniss: 7
Pratley: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7
Doughty: 6
Aneke: 7
Smyth: 7
Bogle:6
Referee 4: