Amos: 7.5 - one good save and commanded his area well again Gunter: 7 - Excellent again Inniss: 6.5 - 2 avoidable bookings Famewo: 8.5 - outstanding Maatsen: 7.5 - Nailed the left back slot Pratley: 7 didn’t start too well, but soon changed that Watson: 7 -Gradually showing he is the player we all know he is Shinnie: 7.5 - Qualify player at this level Washington: 7 another goal and a decent showing Bogle: 6 - bang average Smyth: 7 - works really hard, and pest for the opposition Referee: 5
Amos: 7.5 - Couple of good stops that we needed him for to keep us in the game, not particularly tested. Gunter: 7 - Solid, got himself about, never really looked troubled. Inniss: 5.5 - It was bound to happen, otherwise a good performance Famewo: 8 - Cleaned up the mess like The Wolf from Pulp Fiction but with less fuss Maatsen: 6.5 - Pretty strong defensively let them in behind a couple of times, want to see more of him getting forward. Pratley: 6 - Didn't notice him much frankly Watson: 7 - Gave away a silly foul for his 5th yellow, put himself out about well otherwise Shinnie: 8.5 - Made one goal and scored the second, he's going to become more and more important as the season moves on. Washington: 7.5 - Well taken goal slipping it under the keeper Bogle: 6 - Struggled to get anything to stick tonight. Smyth: 6 - Lots of movement, got hacked down a lot. Referee: 4
Amos: 8 - Couple of good saves Gunter: 8 - Mr consistent Inniss: 7 - didn't think it was a fair second yellow. First was brainless Famewo: 8 - Strong performance again Maatsen: 7 - Better forward than back at the moment, but defensive side will improve as he plays Pratley: 7 - All over the park Watson: 6 - don't like Watson and Prats in a team together, thought his yellow was a touch harsh, but he does love a card Shinnie: 8.5 - Great performance, still needs to improve his fitness Washington: 7.5 - Strong finish and a great run, worked hard Bogle: 6 - flattered to deceive a bit. Think yesterday would have suited Aneke more. Expect Bogle to be better when we play more defensive sides Smyth: 7.5 - Tireless, an upgrade on Bonne, what were QPR thinking? Referee: 3 - Either both teams end with 11 or 10, so inconsistent. held up the game when could have played advantage.
Purrington n/a - thought he looked steady when he came on. Forster-Caskey: n/a
Amos - 7.5 controlled his area. His defence is keeping his scores down by giving him quiet games, but what he did was all first class. Gunter - 7.5 underappreciated involvement in our first goal which helped unlock the defence. Otherwise usual solid self. Inniss - 6 outshone by his partner today even before the red. Silly booking put him in danger Famewo - 8 class act throughout Maatsen - 7.5 very exciting prospect... should've gone down for penalty. Impressive. Watson - 6.5 Harsh yellow, but could've got a red. More 'in the game' with some key challenges than some previous weeks. Pratley- 7 covered centre back well, did a Pratley job Shinnie - 8.5 MoM take a bow, son, that's why you were Luton's poty. Picks great passes, carries it, great shot on the second goal, even if the keeper had a mare Washington - 7.5 poor for 30 minutes, but much more involved after his well taken goal Bogle 6.5 - still not totally convinced. Terrible free kick Smyth - 7 - put himself about but needs a but more in and around the box Ref - 4 bang average, inconsistent and overly pedantic about throw ins and should've booked their guy who took out Bogle.
Maatsen: 8 Very good again. Solid at the back, strong attacking threat.
Pratley: 6 Couldn't get near them. Terrible passing.
Watson: 6 Also couldn't get near them. Another silly yellow.
Shinnie: 8.5 Class above everyone on the pitch.
Washington: 7.5 Makes good runs in behind. Will score for us.
Bogle: 5.5 Really off the pace today. Doesn't look fit.
Smyth: 7 Worked really, really hard. But execution wasn't there today.
Referee: 2.5 DREADFUL
Harsh sending off ? Really ? First he tramples the goalie who has the ball in his arms under control which stops a quick release with him out of position.
Then he slid tackles someone in front of the ref who is CARD happy and he has one card already Slide tackles are frowned on if not illegal now.
How dumb is that.
Did we watch the same game? He didn't slide tackle anyone. You might wanna watch the highlights again.
Any reasonable ref would've given him a final warning. He's made two challenges and got two cards. Their player isn't going anywhere. Then, down the other end, Bogle is running through on the edge of the box and gets dragged back, stopping a shot at least, and no card at all. So yeah, I'd say it was hard to be sent off.
Amos: 7.5 - didn't put a foot or hand wrong Gunter: 7 Inniss: 5 - stupid to get sent off Famewo: 7.5 Maatsen: 7 - some encouraging runs down the flank and some decent defending Pratley: 6.5 - did well Watson: 6.5 - did well Shinnie: 8 - lovely stuff Washington: 7 - worked hard and finished his chance Bogle: 6 - did ok Smyth: 6.5 - did well Referee: 3 - their guy who got booked in the first half should have been sent off with a second yellow. Inconsistent rubbish L1 ref as seems to be the norm.
Amos: 9.5 Gunter: 7.5 Inniss: 6.5 Famewo: 8 Maatsen: 8 Pratley: 7.5 Watson: 6 - that handball was SO stupid - already down to ten men and he risks a second yellow. How did he manage to play 45 games for Forest last year? Shinnie: 9 Washington: 8 Bogle: 7.5 Smyth: 7 Referee: 6 got a lot right, especially most if not all of the cards he gave out, but seemed to let Oxford get away with fouls without the bookings they deserved and I have no idea why Smyth(?) got a free kick awarded against him instead of a penalty in his favour. Still, he couldn't do anything about our goals.
Amos: 7 another clean sheet Gunter: 8 Really effective Inniss: 5 Would have been much higher but for the sending off Famewo: 7 Very Sound Maatsen: 7 Effective going forward Pratley: 8 Good game in both positions Watson: 8 Really knows how to see a game out Shinnie: 9 MOTM Washington: 7 Well taken goal Bogle: 6 Good hold up play Smyth: 7 Very good at the corner flag time wasting towards the end of the game . Reminded me of Garry Nelson and Colin Walsh who perfected it during the Upton Park era .
Amos: 8.0 We are not missing Phillips Gunter: 7.5. again very steady Inniss: 7.0 would have been 9 but for the needless sending off Famewo: 8.5 cool and calm under pressure Maatsen: 7.5 another good game Pratley: 8.0 captains performance. Watson: 6.5 stuggled a bit to get into Oxfords pacey mid field Shinnie: 9.0 MOM very classy midfielder, picked some good passes especially for Connors goal. Good free kick although the keeper really should have saved it. Washington: 8.0 extra point for goal very hard working performance Bogle: 7.0 not a bad performance by any means Smyth: 8.0 worried Oxford with his pace, should a had a penalty. Referee: 2.0 The most inconsistent refereeing performance I have seen in a long time. I say this as a retired referee myself who officiated for 38 years including at a semi profesional level.
Amos: 7.5 Mr Dependable Gunter: 7 Goes about his work and gets the job done Inniss: 6.5 Docked one point for the red but hopefully the man mountain will lean from this Famewo: 7.5 Can we sign him on a permanent please Norwich Maatsen: 7 Looks really good going forward but mustn't forget his defensive duties Pratley: 6.5 Not a bad performance Watson: 7 The Doc showed his value to the team. Shinnie: 8.5 Great all round mom performance Washington: 7.5 Took his goal well I thought Bogle: 7 I think he's getting there. A few more games needed to sharpen things up Smyth: 8 Energizer Bunny never stopped running. Great member of the squad Referee: 3 It couldn't last could it after two comparatively good refs.
Comments
Gunter: 7 - Excellent again
Inniss: 6.5 - 2 avoidable bookings
Famewo: 8.5 - outstanding
Maatsen: 7.5 - Nailed the left back slot
Pratley: 7 didn’t start too well, but soon changed that
Watson: 7 -Gradually showing he is the player we all know he is
Shinnie: 7.5 - Qualify player at this level
Washington: 7 another goal and a decent showing
Bogle: 6 - bang average
Smyth: 7 - works really hard, and pest for the opposition
Referee: 5
Gunter: 7 - Solid, got himself about, never really looked troubled.
Inniss: 5.5 - It was bound to happen, otherwise a good performance
Famewo: 8 - Cleaned up the mess like The Wolf from Pulp Fiction but with less fuss
Maatsen: 6.5 - Pretty strong defensively let them in behind a couple of times, want to see more of him getting forward.
Pratley: 6 - Didn't notice him much frankly
Watson: 7 - Gave away a silly foul for his 5th yellow, put himself out about well otherwise
Shinnie: 8.5 - Made one goal and scored the second, he's going to become more and more important as the season moves on.
Washington: 7.5 - Well taken goal slipping it under the keeper
Bogle: 6 - Struggled to get anything to stick tonight.
Smyth: 6 - Lots of movement, got hacked down a lot.
Referee: 4
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 8
Maatsen: 7
Pratley: 7
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 9
Washington: 7
Bogle: 6
Smyth: 6
Referee: 5
Gunter: 8 - Mr consistent
Inniss: 7 - didn't think it was a fair second yellow. First was brainless
Famewo: 8 - Strong performance again
Maatsen: 7 - Better forward than back at the moment, but defensive side will improve as he plays
Pratley: 7 - All over the park
Watson: 6 - don't like Watson and Prats in a team together, thought his yellow was a touch harsh, but he does love a card
Shinnie: 8.5 - Great performance, still needs to improve his fitness
Washington: 7.5 - Strong finish and a great run, worked hard
Bogle: 6 - flattered to deceive a bit. Think yesterday would have suited Aneke more. Expect Bogle to be better when we play more defensive sides
Smyth: 7.5 - Tireless, an upgrade on Bonne, what were QPR thinking?
Referee: 3 - Either both teams end with 11 or 10, so inconsistent. held up the game when could have played advantage.
Purrington n/a - thought he looked steady when he came on.
Forster-Caskey: n/a
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 8
Maatsen: 7.5
Pratley: 7.5
Watson: 7
Shinnie: 8.5
Washington: 7
Bogle: 7
Smyth: 7.5
Referee: 5
Purrington 7
Forster-Caskey: n/a
Gunter - 7.5 underappreciated involvement in our first goal which helped unlock the defence. Otherwise usual solid self.
Inniss - 6 outshone by his partner today even before the red. Silly booking put him in danger
Famewo - 8 class act throughout
Maatsen - 7.5 very exciting prospect... should've gone down for penalty. Impressive.
Watson - 6.5 Harsh yellow, but could've got a red. More 'in the game' with some key challenges than some previous weeks.
Pratley- 7 covered centre back well, did a Pratley job
Shinnie - 8.5 MoM take a bow, son, that's why you were Luton's poty. Picks great passes, carries it, great shot on the second goal, even if the keeper had a mare
Washington - 7.5 poor for 30 minutes, but much more involved after his well taken goal
Bogle 6.5 - still not totally convinced. Terrible free kick
Smyth - 7 - put himself about but needs a but more in and around the box
Ref - 4 bang average, inconsistent and overly pedantic about throw ins and should've booked their guy who took out Bogle.
Gunter 7
Inniss 6
Famewo 7.5
Maatsen 7
Pratley 7
Watson 6.5
Shinnie 7.5
Washington 7
Bogle 6.5
Smyth 7
Ref 6
Gunter: 8
Inniss: 5.5
Famewo: 8.5
Maatsen: 8
Pratley: 7.5
Watson: 7
Shinnie: 9
Washington: 8
Bogle: 7
Smyth: 7.5
Referee: 6
Any reasonable ref would've given him a final warning. He's made two challenges and got two cards. Their player isn't going anywhere. Then, down the other end, Bogle is running through on the edge of the box and gets dragged back, stopping a shot at least, and no card at all. So yeah, I'd say it was hard to be sent off.
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 9
Maatsen: 8
Pratley: 8
Watson: 7
Shinnie: 7
Washington: 7
Bogle: 6
Smyth: 6
Referee: 0.5 for turning up
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 6.5
Famewo: 8
Maatsen: 7.5
Pratley: 6
Watson: 6
Shinnie: 8.5
Washington: 7
Bogle: 5
Smyth: 6.5
Referee: 3
Gunter: 7.5
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 8
Maatsen: 7.5
Pratley: 7.5
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 9
Washington: 7.5
Bogle: 7
Smyth: 7.5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7.5
Maatsen: 7
Pratley: 7.5
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 8
Washington: 7.5
Bogle: 6.5
Smyth: 7.5
Referee 5
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 5 - stupid to get sent off
Famewo: 7.5
Maatsen: 7 - some encouraging runs down the flank and some decent defending
Pratley: 6.5 - did well
Watson: 6.5 - did well
Shinnie: 8 - lovely stuff
Washington: 7 - worked hard and finished his chance
Bogle: 6 - did ok
Smyth: 6.5 - did well
Referee: 3 - their guy who got booked in the first half should have been sent off with a second yellow. Inconsistent rubbish L1 ref as seems to be the norm.
Purrington n/a
Forster-Caskey: n/a
Gunter: 7.5
Inniss: 6.5
Famewo: 8
Maatsen: 8
Pratley: 7.5
Watson: 6 - that handball was SO stupid - already down to ten men and he risks a second yellow. How did he manage to play 45 games for Forest last year?
Shinnie: 9
Washington: 8
Bogle: 7.5
Smyth: 7
Referee: 6 got a lot right, especially most if not all of the cards he gave out, but seemed to let Oxford get away with fouls without the bookings they deserved and I have no idea why Smyth(?) got a free kick awarded against him instead of a penalty in his favour. Still, he couldn't do anything about our goals.
Gunter: 7.5
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 8.5
Maatsen: 7.5
Pratley: 7
Watson: 6.5
Shinnie: 8.5
Washington: 7
Bogle: 6.5
Smyth: 6.5
Referee: 3.5
Gunter: 7
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 7
Maatsen: 7
Pratley: 8
Watson: 8
Shinnie: 9
Washington: 7
Bogle: 7
Smyth: 7
Referee:
Gunter: 8 Really effective
Inniss: 5 Would have been much higher but for the sending off
Famewo: 7 Very Sound
Maatsen: 7 Effective going forward
Pratley: 8 Good game in both positions
Watson: 8 Really knows how to see a game out
Shinnie: 9 MOTM
Washington: 7 Well taken goal
Bogle: 6 Good hold up play
Smyth: 7 Very good at the corner flag time wasting towards the end of the game . Reminded me of Garry Nelson and Colin Walsh who perfected it during the Upton Park era .
Gunter: 7.5. again very steady
Inniss: 7.0 would have been 9 but for the needless sending off
Famewo: 8.5 cool and calm under pressure
Maatsen: 7.5 another good game
Pratley: 8.0 captains performance.
Watson: 6.5 stuggled a bit to get into Oxfords pacey mid field
Shinnie: 9.0 MOM very classy midfielder, picked some good passes especially for Connors goal. Good free kick although the keeper really should have saved it.
Washington: 8.0 extra point for goal very hard working performance
Bogle: 7.0 not a bad performance by any means
Smyth: 8.0 worried Oxford with his pace, should a had a penalty.
Referee: 2.0 The most inconsistent refereeing performance I have seen in a long time. I say this as a retired referee myself who officiated for 38 years including at a semi profesional level.
Purrington n/a
Forster-Caskey: n/a
Gunter: 7 Goes about his work and gets the job done
Inniss: 6.5 Docked one point for the red but hopefully the man mountain will lean from this
Famewo: 7.5 Can we sign him on a permanent please Norwich
Maatsen: 7 Looks really good going forward but mustn't forget his defensive duties
Pratley: 6.5 Not a bad performance
Watson: 7 The Doc showed his value to the team.
Shinnie: 8.5 Great all round mom performance
Washington: 7.5 Took his goal well I thought
Bogle: 7 I think he's getting there. A few more games needed to sharpen things up
Smyth: 8 Energizer Bunny never stopped running. Great member of the squad
Referee: 3 It couldn't last could it after two comparatively good refs.
Purrington n/a
Forster-Caskey: n/a