Overall I’m happy. This is the start of rebuilding. I’d rather we got the players we actually want in the summer, than force through buys for players we don’t really want now. Maddison out feels right and despite being a top bloke, I’m not sure JW is a big loss.
Gives the likes of Morgan and Shinnie the chance to nail down those spots and more clarity in the squad.
Sorry, where is the start of rebuilding, I must have missed that.
Clearing out for the rebuild then. Bogle, Williams and Maddison out Stockley, Smith, Miller and Schwartz in.
Overall I’m happy. This is the start of rebuilding. I’d rather we got the players we actually want in the summer, than force through buys for players we don’t really want now. Maddison out feels right and despite being a top bloke, I’m not sure JW is a big loss.
Gives the likes of Morgan and Shinnie the chance to nail down those spots and more clarity in the squad.
Sorry, where is the start of rebuilding, I must have missed that.
Clearing out for the rebuild then. Bogle, Williams and Maddison out Stockley, Smith, Miller and Schwartz in.
3 of those signings are loans, so short term fixes
Yes, as I say, the rebuild begins in earnest in the summer. Hopefully without a wage cap and with Thomas providing the funds. And the time to plan it properly.
Deadline day is weird. In our squad right now he have two players for every position. We have 8 defenders, 8 midfielders and 4 strikers, plus some decent youth prospects. The only place we're a bit short is on the wing, where we could do with some cover for Millar. That's all it would be though, cover. We've moved on some fringe players, lost a good player to a Championship club, though one who doesn't play much, and brought in some seriously good first team players. Despite that though, if more players go out than go in on deadline day it's seen as a disaster. I think people need to get away from the Sky Sports induced mentality that the deadline day signings are the ones that matter. If you said we'd get Schwartz, Millar, Stockley and Smith in in this window I think most of us would have taken that as a very good window. Hopefully we'll manage a winger now but if not we're still looking a hell of a lot better than we were going into this window.
The fact we've been desperately scrabbling about for a winger all day suggests that the management team aren't happy with the way the squad looks, so we shouldn't be happy either
Depends on how much negative spin you want to put on it I suppose. As I said, we could do with a winger to cover Millar if he suffers an injury or loss of form, but given the way we've conducted our business so far this window I think if it was an essential signing we would have done it by now. Obviously they're trying to get someone in and they've been knocked back by a lot of teams. If we don't get someone it will be disappointing, but we won't have a gaping hole in our squad and will have still had a good window. That's my point. It'll never be perfect but we're stronger than before the window opened, so I think some having meltdowns about how deadline day hasn't been their Christmas is a bit silly.
Terrible window for us IMO. 2 potential game changers gone in Williams and Maddison. Bowyer quotes George Graham a lot but I was never impressed with his style of play. Wasn't he the architect of the '1-0 to the Arsenal' teams? You can stick 11 robots out there but where is the creativity coming from.
Just saying it again... we are fairly big net sellers under TS, so far. Just the facts of the matter.
Ins: Conor Washington (Undisc) Alex Gilbey (Undisc) Ben Watson Free Marcus Maddison Free Chris Gunter Free Adam Matthews Free Ryan Inniss (Undisc) Omar Bogle Free
Outs: Macauley Bonne (£2m) Alfie Doughty (£650k plus add ons) Dillon Phillips (Undisc allegedly £500k) Jonny Williams (£200k) Omar Bogle (No Fee allegedly) Marcus Maddison (Loan)
Missed Schwartz. And KAG sell on.
Probs £7M in or thereabouts with £500K or thereabouts spent.
Terrible window for us IMO. 2 potential game changers gone in Williams and Maddison. Bowyer quotes George Graham a lot but I was never impressed with his style of play. Wasn't he the architect of the '1-0 to the Arsenal' teams? You can stick 11 robots out there but where is the creativity coming from.
Just saying it again... we are fairly big net sellers under TS, so far. Just the facts of the matter.
Ins: Conor Washington (Undisc) Alex Gilbey (Undisc) Ben Watson Free Marcus Maddison Free Chris Gunter Free Adam Matthews Free Ryan Inniss (Undisc) Omar Bogle Free
Outs: Macauley Bonne (£2m) Alfie Doughty (£650k plus add ons) Dillon Phillips (Undisc allegedly £500k) Jonny Williams (£200k) Omar Bogle (No Fee allegedly) Marcus Maddison (Loan)
Overall I’m happy. This is the start of rebuilding. I’d rather we got the players we actually want in the summer, than force through buys for players we don’t really want now. Maddison out feels right and despite being a top bloke, I’m not sure JW is a big loss.
Gives the likes of Morgan and Shinnie the chance to nail down those spots and more clarity in the squad.
Sorry, where is the start of rebuilding, I must have missed that.
Clearing out for the rebuild then. Bogle, Williams and Maddison out Stockley, Smith, Miller and Schwartz in.
Three of the in’s are loans, that’s not rebuilding.
Deadline day is weird. In our squad right now he have two players for every position. We have 8 defenders, 8 midfielders and 4 strikers, plus some decent youth prospects. The only place we're a bit short is on the wing, where we could do with some cover for Millar. That's all it would be though, cover. We've moved on some fringe players, lost a good player to a Championship club, though one who doesn't play much, and brought in some seriously good first team players. Despite that though, if more players go out than go in on deadline day it's seen as a disaster. I think people need to get away from the Sky Sports induced mentality that the deadline day signings are the ones that matter. If you said we'd get Schwartz, Millar, Stockley and Smith in in this window I think most of us would have taken that as a very good window. Hopefully we'll manage a winger now but if not we're still looking a hell of a lot better than we were going into this window.
The fact we've been desperately scrabbling about for a winger all day suggests that the management team aren't happy with the way the squad looks, so we shouldn't be happy either
Depends on how much negative spin you want to put on it I suppose. As I said, we could do with a winger to cover Millar if he suffers an injury or loss of form, but given the way we've conducted our business so far this window I think if it was an essential signing we would have done it by now. Obviously they're trying to get someone in and they've been knocked back by a lot of teams. If we don't get someone it will be disappointing, but we won't have a gaping hole in our squad and will have still had a good window. That's my point. It'll never be perfect but we're stronger than before the window opened, so I think some having meltdowns about how deadline day hasn't been their Christmas is a bit silly.
It’s certainly not meltdown worthy but we do have a gaping hole in our squad. We have 0 wide players apart from Millar, he now needs to go the entire season without rotation, unless we’re going to reinvent him as a 10.
All in all it’s a decent window and before today I would say we’ve been massively improved, but I’m now very wary of the lack of width in the squad.
Comments
Erm ..... we're cutting it fine.
And the time to plan it properly.
I'm struggling I've gotta be up at 5.30 but managed to get to 11pm
And KAG sell on.
Probs £7M in or thereabouts with £500K or thereabouts spent.