Amos: had nothing to do cos Hull were awful Gunter: excellent Pratley: I think the insanity of tactics and selection has finally worn down our warrior chief Pearce: gave it his all but nowadays running thru treacle Matthews: needlessly played out of position Maatsen: given a job he doesn’t have the tools for by a manager on the brink Gilbey: hopeless weak Morgan: given a job he doesn’t have the tools for then pulled off by the manager who clearly hates him Forster-Caskey: huge effort Bogle: Bow hates him nearly as viciously as he hates Morgan. Limited but honest Washington: ran miles never gives up Smyth: tried hard with what he has Williams: didn’t try a leg jogged about bounced off a weak challenge in his usual juvenile pathetic attempt to win a free kick So phoney he can’t even fool this prat referee. Shameful Referee: Inconsistent pointing pillock
Jacko or Basey or someone needs to sit Bow in front of the video of the last 2 games and keep hitting him with how utterly idiotic his setup was until he gets it.
Amos: 6 no chance with either goal. Nothing spectacular Gunter: 4 poor Pratley: 2 clearly not a CB. That red card is a blessing in disguise. Pearce: 5 we just looked so disorganised Matthews: 4 square peg in a round hole. So much better second half Maatsen: 5 What is a LB doing playinv RW!!! So much better second half Gilbey: 4 I just don’t think he’s very good. Stood still for their first Morgan: 6.5 arguably our only creative player gets hooked off on 60 minutes Forster-Caskey: 5 tried but hard to perform when everyone around you is having a mare Bogle: 2 get rid. The bloke is really not very good. Lacked effort, lacked desire, would rather see one of the kids step in. Washington: 5.5 not a good game Smyth: 5 nothing clicked Williams: victim of negative tactics, and a pathetic red card. Referee: 3 was pretty crap, but definitely not to blame for the loss. The red card was a red card. The penalty shout after the red card, you’d be pissed off if that was given against you.
I’d arguably make 4 or 5 changes vs Accrington. I don’t mind a lack of quality but a lack of effort and desire leaves a Bitter taste.
Missed Albie Morgan on my marks, make him 7 as was our best player IMHO! Strange to take him off!
Amos was MOM. Strange that too. 13 goals conceded in 6 games isn't good.
Amos was MOM because he did nothing wrong. He may have conceded 13 goals in 6 games (not checked), but none of the goals were down to him iirc and in any case marks are supposed to be judged on 1 game not 6.
Missed Albie Morgan on my marks, make him 7 as was our best player IMHO! Strange to take him off!
Amos was MOM. Strange that too. 13 goals conceded in 6 games isn't good.
Amos was MOM because he did nothing wrong. He may have conceded 13 goals in 6 games (not checked), but none of the goals were down to him iirc and in any case marks are supposed to be judged on 1 game not 6.
So Bogle missing one chance is an indication of failure but 13 goals in 6 games (4 v Burton, 1 v MK, 2 v Wimbledon, 2 v Swindon 2v Plymouth, 2 v Hull ( satisfied? ) constitutes being on the ball . He must have some culpability otherwise drop him.and play 11 outfield players!
You appear to be "playing a different game" to everyone else. The rest of us were correctly marking players on the Hull v Charlton game.
If you are going to play your own game and mark players on the last 6 games, it would at least be fair to pick the last 6 consecutive games, which were - Hull 2, Plymouth 2, Swindon 2, AFC 2, Shrewsbury 1, MK Dons1. As opposed to manipulating your case to add the Burton 4 game. So 10 goals in the last 6 games, none of which were the fault of Amos in my opinion.
NB I should imagine only your good self would advocate not playing a goalkeeper because they are faultless. Personally I wouldn't play 11 outfield players even if the goalkeeper was culpable.
Comments
Amos: 7
Gunter: 7
Pratley: 5
Pearce: 6
Matthews: 6
Maatsen: 6
Gilbey: 1
Morgan: 6
Forster-Caskey: 8
Bogle: 6
Washington: 7
Smyth: 5
Williams: 0
Referee: 3
Amos: had nothing to do cos Hull were awful
Gunter: excellent
Pratley: I think the insanity of tactics and selection has finally worn down our warrior chief
Pearce: gave it his all but nowadays running thru treacle
Matthews: needlessly played out of position
Maatsen: given a job he doesn’t have the tools for by a manager on the brink
Gilbey: hopeless weak
Morgan: given a job he doesn’t have the tools for then pulled off by the manager who clearly hates him
Forster-Caskey: huge effort
Bogle: Bow hates him nearly as viciously as he hates Morgan. Limited but honest
Washington: ran miles never gives up
Smyth: tried hard with what he has
Williams: didn’t try a leg jogged about bounced off a weak challenge in his usual juvenile pathetic attempt to win a free kick So phoney he can’t even fool this prat referee. Shameful
Referee: Inconsistent pointing pillock
Jacko or Basey or someone needs to sit Bow in front of the video of the last 2 games and keep hitting him with how utterly idiotic his setup was until he gets it.
Gunter: 5
Pratley: 3
Pearce: 5
Matthews: 6
Maatsen: 6
Gilbey: 5
Morgan: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7
Bogle: 4
Washington: 6
Smyth: 5
Williams: 5
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Pratley: 2
Pearce: 6
Matthews: 6
Maatsen: 5
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6
Bogle: 5
Washington: 5
Smyth: 5
Williams: 5
Amos: 6 no chance with either goal. Nothing spectacular
Gunter: 4 poor
Pratley: 2 clearly not a CB. That red card is a blessing in disguise.
Pearce: 5 we just looked so disorganised
Matthews: 4 square peg in a round hole. So much better second half
Maatsen: 5 What is a LB doing playinv RW!!! So much better second half
Gilbey: 4 I just don’t think he’s very good. Stood still for their first
Morgan: 6.5 arguably our only creative player gets hooked off on 60 minutes
Forster-Caskey: 5 tried but hard to perform when everyone around you is having a mare
Bogle: 2 get rid. The bloke is really not very good. Lacked effort, lacked desire, would rather see one of the kids step in.
Washington: 5.5 not a good game
Smyth: 5 nothing clicked
Williams: victim of negative tactics, and a pathetic red card.
Referee: 3 was pretty crap, but definitely not to blame for the loss. The red card was a red card. The penalty shout after the red card, you’d be pissed off if that was given against you.
Are you Omar's Dad?
Gunter: 6
Pratley: 4
Pearce: 4.5
Matthews: 5
Maatsen: 5
Gilbey: 4.5
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Bogle: 4.5
Washington: 6
Smyth: 5
Williams: 5
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Pratley: 3
Pearce: 5
Matthews: 6
Maatsen: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Bogle: 5
Washington: 5
Smyth: 5
Williams: 6
Gunter: 5
Pratley: 4
Pearce: 5.5
Matthews: 5.5
Maatsen: 6
Gilbey: 4.5
Morgan: 5.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Bogle: 3
Washington: 5
Smyth: 5
Williams: 5.5
Referee: 4
Strange to take him off!
He may have conceded 13 goals in 6 games (not checked), but none of the goals were down to him iirc and in any case marks are supposed to be judged on 1 game not 6.
The rest of us were correctly marking players on the Hull v Charlton game.
If you are going to play your own game and mark players on the last 6 games, it would at least be fair to pick the last 6 consecutive games, which were - Hull 2, Plymouth 2, Swindon 2, AFC 2, Shrewsbury 1, MK Dons1.
As opposed to manipulating your case to add the Burton 4 game.
So 10 goals in the last 6 games, none of which were the fault of Amos in my opinion.
NB I should imagine only your good self would advocate not playing a goalkeeper because they are faultless.
Personally I wouldn't play 11 outfield players even if the goalkeeper was culpable.