Amos
Gunter - Oshilaja - Pearce - Maatsen
F.Caskey
Morgan Maddison
Williams
Bogle - Aneke
Subs: M.Brewer, Matthews, Purrington, Millar, Smyth, Washington, Schwartz. Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
STATBANK: Hull 2-0 Charlton
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,698
many thanks to the 68 Lifers who gave what must be the lowest set of marks so far this season:
5
Comments
-
Cheers Lancs.
Feels like there should be a minimum score required before someone can win “man of the match”!1 -
Must be the first time a keeper has won MOTM when not making any real saves - its not like he kept us in the game !!
Looks like the team took one for the manager.0 -
Maybe we should issue marks for the managers tactics.1
-
Oops, forgot to vote!
The referee missed the chance to claim a rare MOTM award but blew it by also being rubbish
0 -
Feels a bit harsh for Bogle to be stranded at the bottom, when neither Washington nor Smyth had a shot.0
-
He was proper rubbish though, and didn’t do well with our only half decent chance. I think his score is probably also influenced by the fact that people were getting sick of him prior to the match due to his previous performances. Ratings should probably only be based on that specific game, but people’s general impression of a player would likely still be a factor.killerandflash said:Feels a bit harsh for Bogle to be stranded at the bottom, when neither Washington nor Smyth had a shot.0 -
It did cross my mind to make it a non MoM match, but after 10 years of doing the stats I thought it wrong to change the systemse9addick said:Cheers Lancs.
Feels like there should be a minimum score required before someone can win “man of the match”!2 -
He was rubbish I agree, but was Smyth any better? He barely seemed to touch the ball and never looked remotely like scoringse9addick said:
He was proper rubbish though, and didn’t do well with our only half decent chance. I think his score is probably also influenced by the fact that people were getting sick of him prior to the match due to his previous performances. Ratings should probably only be based on that specific game, but people’s general impression of a player would likely still be a factor.killerandflash said:Feels a bit harsh for Bogle to be stranded at the bottom, when neither Washington nor Smyth had a shot.0 -
I guess people will mark you worse if a player does something bad (I.e. misses a decent chance) compared to doing nothing at all. Who knows, it’s not an exact science. I didn’t even score the players as I was so annoyed after the match that I just wanted to forget all about it!killerandflash said:
He was rubbish I agree, but was Smyth any better? He barely seemed to touch the ball and never looked remotely like scoringse9addick said:
He was proper rubbish though, and didn’t do well with our only half decent chance. I think his score is probably also influenced by the fact that people were getting sick of him prior to the match due to his previous performances. Ratings should probably only be based on that specific game, but people’s general impression of a player would likely still be a factor.killerandflash said:Feels a bit harsh for Bogle to be stranded at the bottom, when neither Washington nor Smyth had a shot.1 -
To win MoM with a score of just 5.8 ....... ouch!
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Thanks Lancs. Is Bogle's 2.8 average rating the lowest we've had? I don't recall any worse than that.0
-
It's funny really if you look at it as Goal Interactions, rather than just goals, Bogle's doing almost as well as the other two.
Top 10 GI for All comps
1. Aneke 9 (7/2) 692 mins played / 76.8 mins per GI
2. Washington 7 (6/1) 1,382 mins played / 197.4 mins per GI
3. Morgan 7 (2/5) 879 mp / 125.5 per gi
4. Bogle 5 (2/3) 769 mp / 153.8 per gi
5. JFC 5 (2/3) 1,154 /230.8 per gi
6. Williams 4 (2/2) 731 / 182.8
7. Shinnie 4 (1/3) 952 / 238
8. Maddison 3 (1/2) 511 / 170.3
9. Doughty 3 (1/2) 815 / 271.6
10. Smyth 3 (1/2) 555 / 185
Best GI/ Mins according to the above
76.8 - Aneke
125.5 - Morgan
153.8 - Bogle
170.3 - Maddison
182.8 - Williams
185.0 - Smyth
197.4 - Washington
230.8 - JFC
238.0 - Shinnie
271.6 - Doughty
This leads me to a very odd conclusion... We should play the following formation:
You can have that one for free Lee.
(G/A data = Statbank on Charlton Life, Minutes played = all comps on Transfermarkt)0 -
I see your point, but at the same time, he plays up front so inevitably will be involved more in the attacks. Doughty has 2 less GI than him and hasn't been played since October.Dazzler21 said:It's funny really if you look at it as Goal Interactions, rather than just goals, Bogle's doing almost as well as the other two.
Top 10 GI for All comps
1. Aneke 9 (7/2) 692 mins played / 76.8 mins per GI
2. Washington 7 (6/1) 1,382 mins played / 197.4 mins per GI
3. Morgan 7 (2/5) 879 mp / 125.5 per gi
4. Bogle 5 (2/3) 769 mp / 153.8 per gi
5. JFC 5 (2/3) 1,154 /230.8 per gi
6. Williams 4 (2/2) 731 / 182.8
7. Shinnie 4 (1/3) 952 / 238
8. Maddison 3 (1/2) 511 / 170.3
9. Doughty 3 (1/2) 815 / 271.6
10. Smyth 3 (1/2) 555 / 185
Best GI/ Mins according to the above
76.8 - Aneke
125.5 - Morgan
153.8 - Bogle
170.3 - Maddison
182.8 - Williams
185.0 - Smyth
197.4 - Washington
230.8 - JFC
238.0 - Shinnie
271.6 - Doughty
This leads me to a very odd conclusion... We should play the following formation:AmosSubs: M.Brewer, Matthews, Purrington, Millar, Smyth, Washington, Schwartz.
Gunter - Oshilaja - Pearce - Maatsen
F.Caskey
Morgan Maddison
Williams
Bogle - Aneke
You can have that one for free Lee.
(G/A data = Statbank on Charlton Life, Minutes played = all comps on Transfermarkt)0 -
i know Bogle werent great but 2.8?
0 -
But if you look at GI/minutes he is almost twice as good as Doughty 🤔LonelyNorthernAddick said:
I see your point, but at the same time, he plays up front so inevitably will be involved more in the attacks. Doughty has 2 less GI than him and hasn't been played since October.Dazzler21 said:It's funny really if you look at it as Goal Interactions, rather than just goals, Bogle's doing almost as well as the other two.
Top 10 GI for All comps
1. Aneke 9 (7/2) 692 mins played / 76.8 mins per GI
2. Washington 7 (6/1) 1,382 mins played / 197.4 mins per GI
3. Morgan 7 (2/5) 879 mp / 125.5 per gi
4. Bogle 5 (2/3) 769 mp / 153.8 per gi
5. JFC 5 (2/3) 1,154 /230.8 per gi
6. Williams 4 (2/2) 731 / 182.8
7. Shinnie 4 (1/3) 952 / 238
8. Maddison 3 (1/2) 511 / 170.3
9. Doughty 3 (1/2) 815 / 271.6
10. Smyth 3 (1/2) 555 / 185
Best GI/ Mins according to the above
76.8 - Aneke
125.5 - Morgan
153.8 - Bogle
170.3 - Maddison
182.8 - Williams
185.0 - Smyth
197.4 - Washington
230.8 - JFC
238.0 - Shinnie
271.6 - Doughty
This leads me to a very odd conclusion... We should play the following formation:AmosSubs: M.Brewer, Matthews, Purrington, Millar, Smyth, Washington, Schwartz.
Gunter - Oshilaja - Pearce - Maatsen
F.Caskey
Morgan Maddison
Williams
Bogle - Aneke
You can have that one for free Lee.
(G/A data = Statbank on Charlton Life, Minutes played = all comps on Transfermarkt)0
