Stan and Ollie BBC1 8.25 Friday 19th

Masterbrew

The film was not factually accurate - it is set in 1953 but mention of a film was during a previous tour, although it was not developed. The 1953 tour started in Ireland then moved to the UK, where Hardy was taken ill and they never performed again. https://cinemaetc.co.uk/2019/02/04/fact-vs-fiction-how-far-is-too-far-for-biopics/

As a bonus Laurel & Hardy plus trains - what more could a Charlton supporter need? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aiZ3oOhhIho

McBobbin

Lovely film.

I remember a summer holiday where everyday there was a laurel and hardy double bill, absolute class.ust have been early 90s? They should definitely do that again. Me and my brother used to watch them in tears of laughter

cfgs

Factually correct or not I really enjoyed it.

Algarveaddick

Chippycafc said:

Missed it but watched a documentary about them once, where Stan Laurels telephone number was in the phone book, and if you called him he would chat to you, and lived in the same modest house for years.

Kevin Nolan lived in LA at the time, and saw his number in the book. Not realising that Stan was happy to chat to anyone, he never made the call. He always says it is one of the big regrets in his life. 

Addickted

Looking forward to settling down Sunday afternoon to watch this.

Personally, I always found Abbott and Costello funnier.

Algarveaddick

It is a lovely film and Reilly and Coogan are excellent in the roles. 

stonemuse

Wonderful film 

Stuart_the_Red

AddicksAddict said:

addick1956 said:

captainbob said:

Deciding who was funnier out of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton is as difficult as deciding who is the better footballer, Messi or Ronaldo. Yet, Keaton was decisive on the former question, stating, 'Chaplin wasn't the funniest. I wasn't the funniest. Stan Laurel was the funniest.'

I wish the BBC would show the Laurel and Hardy films again, as they did in the Eighties, otherwise these classics will fade into obscurity. 

I would add the Marx Bros to that list of genius.

Sadly, quite a few of the Marx Bros' films don't do justice to their talent.

The Marx Brothers were as crazy off-stage as on! When I read Harpo’s or Groucho’s autobiographies I end up laughing as much as when I watch their films.

The Marx Brothers were zanier than Laurel and Hardy, but Stan and Ollie were the best!

captainbob

There can't be many people who prefer Abbott and Costello to Laurel and Hardy. That's like finding Cannon and Ball superior to Morecambe and Wise. 

soapboxsam

I find it hard to believe the provincial small theatres in England would've been half empty when Laurel and Hardy were performing. Seeing actual footage from Ireland and the above from Dymchurch in Kent, where big crowds were an enthusiastic audience.

bobmunro

Stuart_the_Red said:

AddicksAddict said:

addick1956 said:

captainbob said:

Deciding who was funnier out of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton is as difficult as deciding who is the better footballer, Messi or Ronaldo. Yet, Keaton was decisive on the former question, stating, 'Chaplin wasn't the funniest. I wasn't the funniest. Stan Laurel was the funniest.'

I wish the BBC would show the Laurel and Hardy films again, as they did in the Eighties, otherwise these classics will fade into obscurity. 

I would add the Marx Bros to that list of genius.

Sadly, quite a few of the Marx Bros' films don't do justice to their talent.

The Marx Brothers were as crazy off-stage as on! When I read Harpo’s or Groucho’s autobiographies I end up laughing as much as when I watch their films.

The Marx Brothers were zanier than Laurel and Hardy, but Stan and Ollie were the best!

Stan and Ollie were the best, I can't disagree.

But all this talk of the Marx Brothers (brilliant), and Abbot and Costello (not in the same league) made me think of this genius - a contemporary. Up there with the very best and this scene is still hilarious however many times I've watched it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEIUW5Rslrc

killerandflash

Great performances, a reminder of how naturally funny Laurel and Hardy were together

A name not mentioned here, but someone else I really liked was Harold Lloyd. Some great physical stunts, but also in many ways a forerunner of later romantic comedies as there was often a girl involved in the stories, and Lloyd unlike the other silent era comedians wasn't "funny" looking

SoundAsa£

soapboxsam said:

SoundAsa£ said:

soapboxsam said:

Stan and Ollie and the Marx brothers were magic for me as a kid. I also liked the Road films with Eltham's finest Bob Hope and the man who last hit was a golf ball, Bing Crosby.

?....doesn’t make sense sam?

What part SoundAsa£ ?

That Bob Hope was born in Eltham or that the man who's last big hit was a golf ball.   Unfortunately Bing Crosby's last big hit was on a golf course and he died hours later after leaving the 18th.
I consider 1977 fair game for a comedic response even if it's at the old crooner's expense.

Ah right......you wrote the word who instead of who’s in your first post.😏

Fumbluff

bobmunro said:

Stuart_the_Red said:

AddicksAddict said:

addick1956 said:

captainbob said:

Deciding who was funnier out of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton is as difficult as deciding who is the better footballer, Messi or Ronaldo. Yet, Keaton was decisive on the former question, stating, 'Chaplin wasn't the funniest. I wasn't the funniest. Stan Laurel was the funniest.'

I wish the BBC would show the Laurel and Hardy films again, as they did in the Eighties, otherwise these classics will fade into obscurity. 

I would add the Marx Bros to that list of genius.

Sadly, quite a few of the Marx Bros' films don't do justice to their talent.

The Marx Brothers were as crazy off-stage as on! When I read Harpo’s or Groucho’s autobiographies I end up laughing as much as when I watch their films.

The Marx Brothers were zanier than Laurel and Hardy, but Stan and Ollie were the best!

Stan and Ollie were the best, I can't disagree.

But all this talk of the Marx Brothers (brilliant), and Abbot and Costello (not in the same league) made me think of this genius - a contemporary. Up there with the very best and this scene is still hilarious however many times I've watched it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEIUW5Rslrc

Oh my Bob.....that’s just a nothing of nothing. 

Incomparable to any 1-minute clip you like from Music Box

The Prince-e-Paul

Watched the film last night and thoroughly enjoyed it. As a fan of the genre, it did them justice I felt. 

As an aside, my dad got me into some of the old b&w classics and I have grown to love the Will Hay, Graham Moffatt, Moore Marriott films, 'Ask a Policeman' & Oh Mr Porter' and are in my Saturday afternoons by myself list. 

johnny73

The Prince-e-Paul said:

Watched the film last night and thoroughly enjoyed it. As a fan of the genre, it did them justice I felt. 

As an aside, my dad got me into some of the old b&w classics and I have grown to love the Will Hay, Graham Moffatt, Moore Marriott films, 'Ask a Policeman' & Oh Mr Porter' and are in my Saturday afternoons by myself list. 

Will Hay was a genius. Recommend the Graham rinaldi book.

Vincenzo

I really is a special film. 

MuttleyCAFC

They were geniuses 

cafckev

killerandflash said:

Great performances, a reminder of how naturally funny Laurel and Hardy were together

A name not mentioned here, but someone else I really liked was Harold Lloyd. Some great physical stunts, but also in many ways a forerunner of later romantic comedies as there was often a girl involved in the stories, and Lloyd unlike the other silent era comedians wasn't "funny" looking

Harold Lloyd was excellent but didn’t beat Laurel and Hardy. 

My absolute favourite was Will Hay who absolutely blew away any other comedians in black and white films

Johnnysummers5

Excellent film, Laurel and Hardy were the best for me, amongst the very funny films they made Music Box has already been mentioned my favourite, Sons Of The Desert, Our Relations and Way Out West and many more

KettsJohn

Yeah great film. Love Laurel & Hardy. Loved them as a kid and still have a lot of affection for them. Although not factually correct, the film was well acted and seemed to reflect their relationship well.