Normal caveats about awful conditions effecting the game but...
Amos: 6.5 - Mostly routine saves and poor distribution Gunter: 4 - As somebody said on the match thread he has been a disappointment all season really and probably on our highest salary out of new signings. Oshilaja: 6.5 - Pick of our defence but there is always a howler waiting Famewo: 6.5 - Good to have him back but a couple of wayward passes Maatsen: 3 - Really poor, what has happened to him? Shinnie: 5 - My 'type' of player but he is looking like a luxury we can't afford. Sublime cross though. Pratley: 6 - We look better with him but he slows everything down and it is a real indictment of the team that he makes us look better Smith: 4.5 - Just starting to get into the game and shouldn't have been taken off Millar: 6.5 - tried really hard but can't do it on hs own. Stockley: 7 - tried really really hard but nobody near him, and can't do it on his on. Good goal. Schwartz: 3 - No service but really poor Washington: 3 - None of the subs, apart from Purrs, had a positive effect Morgan: 3 - Watson: 3 - Polite thing to say is that we should be limiting his playing opportunities and looking at the fine print on the possible second year of the deal. Purrington: 6 - Shored up the left hand side and should not have been dropped. Our defence/midfield is not good enough to play Maatsen (and an out of form Maatsen) ahead of him Referee: 6 - Average which makes him excellent for this division
Amos: 7, Good saves in the second half won the point. Gunter: 7, Good shift and rarely beaten Oshilaja: 7, As above Famewo: 7, Welcome back and just in time too Maatsen: 7, Did well Shinnie: 6, tried, got the assist, didn't track the run for the equaliser Pratley: 6, The usual Smith: 5, Not in it, not his fault Millar: 5, As above Stockley: 8, Proper Striker Schwartz: 5, Feel sorry for him, get a start and doesn't get a touch Washington: 6, We looked slightly better with him on due to him chasing lost causes Morgan: 5, Poor bugger, go on and get hold of the ball, not a chance Watson: 6, Did ok Purrington: 6 As above Referee, 7, Booked all the guilty in the Stockley incident.
As poor a team performance as I can remember for years. Utterly boring and disjointed
Amos: 6 Gunter: 5 Numerous throw-ins to the opponent or aimed at our players face. WTF is he meant to do with that. Oshilaja: 5 one minute he's decent the next minute I am shitting myself Famewo: 6 caught out a few times with the ball over the top/in the channels/ Something he's often done and needs work on. Surprisingly not rusty though Maatsen: 5 Confidence looks shot. Shinnie: 5 Roasted for their goal Pratley: 6 Standard Pratters Smith: 5 Quiet Millar: 6 Most threatening player but disappeared for long periods Stockley: 6.5 Lovely goal but not as dominant as usual Schwartz: 3 Like playing with 10 men. Without service he offers very little Washington: 3 Schwartz with darker hair. Couple of really stupid fouls when they were going nowhere and defending. Morgan: 4 Not the saviour some seem to think he is. Can be decent but often can be anonymous. Today he was the latter Watson: 4 I don't see the point in him Purrington: 6 Didn't do much wrong but, if I am honest, I was half asleep by the time he came on Referee: 5 meh
Worst bunch of ratings I have given in ages but it is worryingly becoming the norm. Performances like that are really worrying
Amos: 7 - a couple of decent saves I’d expect him to make and good on crosses. The ridiculous goal kick routine in the second half - Amos to Oshilaja to Gunter - was clearly management’s brainchild. Man City we aren’t Gunter: 4 - a goal saving clearance in the second half but otherwise very poor. A Bowyer favourite, though, so Matthews remains very much on the outside Oshilaja: 5 - looked a little shaky at times Famewo: 6 - used his pace and physicality to good effect and came through the 90 minutes pretty well Maatsen: 4 - the tone was unfortunately set when their guy skinned him in the first few minutes. A good young player but this was never the game to bring him back into the side Shinnie: 5.5 - faded out of the game but his cross for the goal was excellent Pratley: 5 - as ever, the ball was a bit of a hot potato but did ok Smith: 5 - seemed to be played too far up the field during our first half hoof ball phase. Appeared to be getting into the game in the second half in his more natural deeper role when Lee Bowyer hooked him Millar: 5.5 - starved of service and switched wings today for reasons best known to the manager Stockley: 6 - ploughed a lonely furrow and scored from his only chance Schwartz: 4 - zero service and 3 early free kicks conceded was the sum total of his day Washington: 4 - could only muster the two fouls when he came on. His control of the ball was hopeless Morgan: 4.5 - unable to influence the game Watson: 4 - yesterday’s man Purrington: 6 - steadied the ship in the second half whilst under incessant pressure Referee: 6 - looked a bit off the pace but got most things right. I enjoyed the lino’s comedic, late offside decision - about two phases of play late - in the first half.
Amos: 7 - Saved us, ensured we left the North West with at least a point Gunter: 6 - Sent it long too often but great stop when Fleetwood had an empty net in front of them Oshilaja: 6 - Dont think he did much wrong Famewo: 7 - Impressed with his return, solid display Maatsen: 6 - Had two good moments going forward, exposed for the equaliser Shinnie: 5 - Unfortunately involved in both goals Pratley: 5 - Couldnt handle the Fleetwood players today Smith: 5 - Echos of Levitt @ Northampton, not the game for him Millar: 5 - Really struggled to get involved, a bit like Schwartz, the long balls took him out of the game Stockley: 6 - Really nice goal but really ineffective up top and bringing others in to play Schwartz: 5 - Really dont want to mark him any lower
Washington: 5 - Same as Schwartz, we're not playing to their strengths Morgan: 5 - No different to Smith really Watson: 5 - Has really regressed as the season has progressed Purrington: 6 - The defence as a whole were pretty on song for the majority of the game
Referee: 5 - A bit too trigger happy with free kicks at times, few baffling moments amongst the officials as a whole
Amos: 8 Gunter: 6 Oshilaja: 6 Famewo: 7 Maatsen: 4 plays too far forward and never comes across to cover. We are making him worse Shinnie: 6 responsible for both the goals Pratley: 6 Smith: 5 just looked like he was coming into the game when he got hooked Millar: 6 they knew he was our outlet and marked him really tightly Stockley: 7 Schwartz: 0 how can you mark someone who made no contribution whatsoever Washington: 2 not much better than Schwartz, good job Chucks is back Tuesday Morgan: 5 Watson: 5 Purrington: 6 Referee: 6
Amos: 7 MoM despite poor distribution. good saves Gunter: 6 great tackles, shocking passing Deji: 5.5 some weird headers Famewo: 6 not good playing from back, important clearances Maatsen: 5 unfortunately shown up again Smith: 6 thought he was better than the commentators did Shinnie: 6.5 inc +1 for cross Pratley: 5 one of his worse games Millar: 6.5 a threat, but not much of one Stockley: 7 isolated, came up against two defenders a lot. Good goal. Schwhere are you?: 4
Washington: 4 added nothing Morgan: 4 worse than that for a while, but was growing into it last 10 Watson: 5.5 better than Pratley today Purrington: 6 the dull Ben returns, but we looked less likely to concede once he was on. Ref: 6 handled the flashpoint ok
Bowyer: am getting very worried we don't seem up for the fight any more. The only time I remember being truly happy about a 90 minute Charlton performance in 3 months or so is Rochdale... that's not good enough. For me, the next 3 are must-wins. If we don't get at least 7 points, reckon I'll be joining the Bowyer-out brigade.
Gunter: 5.5 Meh, I hope we have better next season. Oshilaja: 6 Ok, I hope we have better next season. Famewo: 7 Cool, composed, fast, struggled late on & looked a touch heavy. Maatsen: 5 Not a good defender, I'd play Purrington every time. (Obvs bags of potential). Shinnie: 6 Assisted goal brilliantly, then addressed it by giving one back. Hope we have better next season. Pratley: 7 We totally lost the battle when he went off. Smith: 6 Quiet game. Millar: 7 Started really well & faded, but is generally a class above. Stockley: 7.5 One of a few of our decent players. Schwartz: 3 Once again he may as well not be out there. Touches the ball about 3 times each game. Washington: 4 Didn't barely touch the ball either. Morgan: 4 Didn't get involved at all. Watson: 4 Got involved but he's so slow and I panic when the ball comes to him. Purrington: 6 Played ok, far more solid than Maatsen. Referee: 7 Did well enough.
Amos: 7 MoM Gunter: ( dog shit Oshilaja: 5 meh Famewo: 6 will improve but a bit tubby Maatsen: 4 go home whilst you can Shinnie: 4.5 disappears Pratley: 5.5 mm Smith: 5 just getting in when off Millar: 5 not his day. But right wing ????? Stockley: 7 a player Schwartz: 4 no service Washington: 3 meh Morgan: 4 Watson: 2 letting himself down Purrington: 5 should have started Referee: 5
Don't usually give player marks, but today I actually questioned whether Millar, Smith and Schwartz were still on the pitch at one point as they appeared to go missing.
Schwartz can certainly finish, but you have to question that every game when we are attacking and dominating for periods, he never touches the ball.
Amos: 6.5 kept us in it Gunter: 6 some good some bad, crucial block in 2nd half Oshilaja: 6 Famewo: 6.5 played well but showed he was rusty Maatsen: 6 not as bad as some are making out Shinnie: 6 Pratley: 6 Smith: 5 a bit anonymous Millar: 6 Stockley: 7.5 looked like he cared Schwartz: 4.5 no service, so not really his fault Washington: 4.5 as Schwartz Morgan: 5.5 bit anonymous, one good bit of play Watson: 5 anonymous Purrington: 6.5 put in a shift Referee: 7 thought he was alright actually. Nothing major wrong and kept the game flowing as best he could in the conditions.
Amos 7.5 - Did very well in the conditions and had a fair bit to do (unlike his counterpart) Gunter 6 - Great clearance. Maatsen 5.5 - Didn't look comfortable one on one but got little help from Shinnie. Oshilaja 6.5 - Won a lot of headers. Famewo 7 - Looked overweight but played ok. Stays on his feet. Shinnie 6 - Beautiful skill and ball in for the goal. Pratley 6 - Was doing ok but the booking killed him off. Smith 6 - Took ages to get into it but clearly has energy and ability. A grade up on Levitt. Millar 6 - Tried but was double-marked and couldn't get going. Schwartz 4 - No service but also not enough energy. Stockley 7 - Tried hard and did really well for his goal.
Watson - A couple of good blocks. Morgan - Didn't notice him. Purrington - Did ok apart from some clumsy fouling. Washington - Didn't notice him.
Comments
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 7
Famewo: 6.5
Maatsen: 5.5
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5.5
Millar: 5.5
Stockley: 6.5
Schwartz: 6
Washington: 5.5
Morgan: 5.5
Watson: 5
Purrington 5
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6
Maatsen: 5
Shinnie: 5.5
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5
Millar: 6
Stockley: 6
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 4
Watson: 4
Purrington: 6
Referee: 6
Gunter: 6.0
Oshilaja: 6.0
Famewo: 6.0
Maatsen: 4.0
Shinnie: 5.0
Pratley: 5.0
Smith: 4.0
Millar: 5.0
Stockley: 6.0
Schwartz: 5.0
Washington: 4.5
Morgan: 4.5
Watson: 4.0
Purrington: 6.0
Referee: 6.0
Amos: 6.5 - Mostly routine saves and poor distribution
Gunter: 4 - As somebody said on the match thread he has been a disappointment all season really and probably on our highest salary out of new signings.
Oshilaja: 6.5 - Pick of our defence but there is always a howler waiting
Famewo: 6.5 - Good to have him back but a couple of wayward passes
Maatsen: 3 - Really poor, what has happened to him?
Shinnie: 5 - My 'type' of player but he is looking like a luxury we can't afford. Sublime cross though.
Pratley: 6 - We look better with him but he slows everything down and it is a real indictment of the team that he makes us look better
Smith: 4.5 - Just starting to get into the game and shouldn't have been taken off
Millar: 6.5 - tried really hard but can't do it on hs own.
Stockley: 7 - tried really really hard but nobody near him, and can't do it on his on. Good goal.
Schwartz: 3 - No service but really poor
Washington: 3 - None of the subs, apart from Purrs, had a positive effect
Morgan: 3 -
Watson: 3 - Polite thing to say is that we should be limiting his playing opportunities and looking at the fine print on the possible second year of the deal.
Purrington: 6 - Shored up the left hand side and should not have been dropped. Our defence/midfield is not good enough to play Maatsen (and an out of form Maatsen) ahead of him
Referee: 6 - Average which makes him excellent for this division
Gunter: 7, Good shift and rarely beaten
Oshilaja: 7, As above
Famewo: 7, Welcome back and just in time too
Maatsen: 7, Did well
Shinnie: 6, tried, got the assist, didn't track the run for the equaliser
Pratley: 6, The usual
Smith: 5, Not in it, not his fault
Millar: 5, As above
Stockley: 8, Proper Striker
Schwartz: 5, Feel sorry for him, get a start and doesn't get a touch
Washington: 6, We looked slightly better with him on due to him chasing lost causes
Morgan: 5, Poor bugger, go on and get hold of the ball, not a chance
Watson: 6, Did ok
Purrington: 6 As above
Referee, 7, Booked all the guilty in the Stockley incident.
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 7
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 5
Smith: 4
Millar: 5
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 5
Watson: 4
Purrington: 6
Amos: 6
Gunter: 5 Numerous throw-ins to the opponent or aimed at our players face. WTF is he meant to do with that.
Oshilaja: 5 one minute he's decent the next minute I am shitting myself
Famewo: 6 caught out a few times with the ball over the top/in the channels/ Something he's often done and needs work on. Surprisingly not rusty though
Maatsen: 5 Confidence looks shot.
Shinnie: 5 Roasted for their goal
Pratley: 6 Standard Pratters
Smith: 5 Quiet
Millar: 6 Most threatening player but disappeared for long periods
Stockley: 6.5 Lovely goal but not as dominant as usual
Schwartz: 3 Like playing with 10 men. Without service he offers very little
Washington: 3 Schwartz with darker hair. Couple of really stupid fouls when they were going nowhere and defending.
Morgan: 4 Not the saviour some seem to think he is. Can be decent but often can be anonymous. Today he was the latter
Watson: 4 I don't see the point in him
Purrington: 6 Didn't do much wrong but, if I am honest, I was half asleep by the time he came on
Referee: 5 meh
Worst bunch of ratings I have given in ages but it is worryingly becoming the norm. Performances like that are really worrying
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 7
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 5
Smith 4:
Millar: 5
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 6 (made the only decent pass of the second half)
Watson: 4
Purrington: 5
Referee: 5
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 6
Maatsen: 5
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 5
Smith: 5
Millar: 6
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 5
Morgan: 5
Watson: 5
Purrington: 6
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 5.5
Famewo: 6
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 5.5
Pratley: 5.5
Smith: 5
Millar: 5.5
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 4
Watson: 4
Purrington: 6
Gunter: 4 - a goal saving clearance in the second half but otherwise very poor. A Bowyer favourite, though, so Matthews remains very much on the outside
Oshilaja: 5 - looked a little shaky at times
Famewo: 6 - used his pace and physicality to good effect and came through the 90 minutes pretty well
Maatsen: 4 - the tone was unfortunately set when their guy skinned him in the first few minutes. A good young player but this was never the game to bring him back into the side
Shinnie: 5.5 - faded out of the game but his cross for the goal was excellent
Pratley: 5 - as ever, the ball was a bit of a hot potato but did ok
Smith: 5 - seemed to be played too far up the field during our first half hoof ball phase. Appeared to be getting into the game in the second half in his more natural deeper role when Lee Bowyer hooked him
Millar: 5.5 - starved of service and switched wings today for reasons best known to the manager
Stockley: 6 - ploughed a lonely furrow and scored from his only chance
Schwartz: 4 - zero service and 3 early free kicks conceded was the sum total of his day
Washington: 4 - could only muster the two fouls when he came on. His control of the ball was hopeless
Morgan: 4.5 - unable to influence the game
Watson: 4 - yesterday’s man
Purrington: 6 - steadied the ship in the second half whilst under incessant pressure
Referee: 6 - looked a bit off the pace but got most things right. I enjoyed the lino’s comedic, late offside decision - about two phases of play late - in the first half.
Gunter: 6 - Sent it long too often but great stop when Fleetwood had an empty net in front of them
Oshilaja: 6 - Dont think he did much wrong
Famewo: 7 - Impressed with his return, solid display
Maatsen: 6 - Had two good moments going forward, exposed for the equaliser
Shinnie: 5 - Unfortunately involved in both goals
Pratley: 5 - Couldnt handle the Fleetwood players today
Smith: 5 - Echos of Levitt @ Northampton, not the game for him
Millar: 5 - Really struggled to get involved, a bit like Schwartz, the long balls took him out of the game
Stockley: 6 - Really nice goal but really ineffective up top and bringing others in to play
Schwartz: 5 - Really dont want to mark him any lower
Washington: 5 - Same as Schwartz, we're not playing to their strengths
Morgan: 5 - No different to Smith really
Watson: 5 - Has really regressed as the season has progressed
Purrington: 6 - The defence as a whole were pretty on song for the majority of the game
Referee: 5 - A bit too trigger happy with free kicks at times, few baffling moments amongst the officials as a whole
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 7
Maatsen: 4 plays too far forward and never comes across to cover. We are making him worse
Shinnie: 6 responsible for both the goals
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5 just looked like he was coming into the game when he got hooked
Millar: 6 they knew he was our outlet and marked him really tightly
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 0 how can you mark someone who made no contribution whatsoever
Washington: 2 not much better than Schwartz, good job Chucks is back Tuesday
Morgan: 5
Watson: 5
Purrington: 6
Referee: 6
Gunter: 6 great tackles, shocking passing
Deji: 5.5 some weird headers
Famewo: 6 not good playing from back, important clearances
Maatsen: 5 unfortunately shown up again
Smith: 6 thought he was better than the commentators did
Shinnie: 6.5 inc +1 for cross
Pratley: 5 one of his worse games
Millar: 6.5 a threat, but not much of one
Stockley: 7 isolated, came up against two defenders a lot. Good goal.
Schwhere are you?: 4
Washington: 4 added nothing
Morgan: 4 worse than that for a while, but was growing into it last 10
Watson: 5.5 better than Pratley today
Purrington: 6 the dull Ben returns, but we looked less likely to concede once he was on.
Ref: 6 handled the flashpoint ok
Bowyer: am getting very worried we don't seem up for the fight any more. The only time I remember being truly happy about a 90 minute Charlton performance in 3 months or so is Rochdale... that's not good enough. For me, the next 3 are must-wins. If we don't get at least 7 points, reckon I'll be joining the Bowyer-out brigade.
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6.5
Maatsen: 4.5
Shinnie: 6.5
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5.5
Millar: 5.5
Stockley: 6
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 5.5
Watson: 5
Purrington: 5.5
Referee: 6
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6.5
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6.5
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 4
Watson: 4
Purrington: 5
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 7.5
Famewo: 5
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 7
Smith: 5
Millar: 6
Stockley: 6
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 5
Watson: 4
Purrington: 6
Referee: 4
Amos: 6.5
Amos: 7
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 5
Maatsen: 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 4
Smith: 3
Millar: 5
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 3
Morgan: 3
Watson: 2
Purrington: 5
Referee: 5
Schwartz can certainly finish, but you have to question that every game when we are attacking and dominating for periods, he never touches the ball.
It's like playing with 10 men!
Gunter: 6 some good some bad, crucial block in 2nd half
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6.5 played well but showed he was rusty
Maatsen: 6 not as bad as some are making out
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5 a bit anonymous
Millar: 6
Stockley: 7.5 looked like he cared
Schwartz: 4.5 no service, so not really his fault
Washington: 4.5 as Schwartz
Morgan: 5.5 bit anonymous, one good bit of play
Watson: 5 anonymous
Purrington: 6.5 put in a shift
Referee: 7 thought he was alright actually. Nothing major wrong and kept the game flowing as best he could in the conditions.
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6
Maatsen: 5
Shinnie: 5.5
Pratley: 5
Smith: 5
Millar: 6
Stockley: 6.5
Schwartz: 4
Washington: 4
Morgan: 4
Watson: 4
Purrington: 6
Referee: 7
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6
Maatsen: 6
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 6
Smith: 5
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Schwartz: 2
Washington: 3
Morgan: 4
Watson: 5
Purrington: 5
Referee: 9
Gunter 6 - Great clearance.
Maatsen 5.5 - Didn't look comfortable one on one but got little help from Shinnie.
Oshilaja 6.5 - Won a lot of headers.
Famewo 7 - Looked overweight but played ok. Stays on his feet.
Shinnie 6 - Beautiful skill and ball in for the goal.
Pratley 6 - Was doing ok but the booking killed him off.
Smith 6 - Took ages to get into it but clearly has energy and ability. A grade up on Levitt.
Millar 6 - Tried but was double-marked and couldn't get going.
Schwartz 4 - No service but also not enough energy.
Stockley 7 - Tried hard and did really well for his goal.
Watson - A couple of good blocks.
Morgan - Didn't notice him.
Purrington - Did ok apart from some clumsy fouling.
Washington - Didn't notice him.
Ref 7.5 - Thought he did well.
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6.5
Maatsen: 5.5
Shinnie:6
Pratley: 5.5
Smith: 5
Millar: 5.5
Stockley: 6.5
Schwartz: 5
Washington: 4
Morgan: 4
Watson:4.5
Purrington: 5.5
Referee:6
Amos: 6.5
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 7
Famewo: 7
Maatsen: 5,5
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 5.5
Smith: 5,5
Millar: 6
Stockley: 7
Schwartz: 5
Washington: 5.5
Morgan: 5.5
Watson: 5.5
Purrington: 6
Referee: 6