Amos: 4.5 In just a few weeks has declined from being secure to being extremely vulnerable Gunter: 4.5 Anonymous Oshilaja: 4.5 Made basic errors in distribution Famewo: 5.5 Good performance Purrington: 4.5 Anonymous Jaiyesimi 5 Feel sorry for the lad. Had one good move; then made wrong decisions. Has he been Charltonised already? Shinnie: 5 Busy, as usual. Free-kicks and corners are more accurate than those by JFC. Which ain't saying much Pratley: 5 I like Pratley, smiling while he puts the knife in. But his slowness lands him in trouble Millar: 5.5 Our best player this season by a country mile. Shows what a really good academy can produce Stockley: 5 Always willing, but service today was shyte Washington: 4.5 Utterly anonymous Aneke: 5 Has surprisingly close control. Neat footwork that got us precisely nowhere. Red card was right decision Smith: 4.5 As bland and anonymous as his surname Watson: 4.5 Anonymous. Penalty given against him was harsh Maatsen: 4.5 One unforced error after another Referee: 4.5 Second penalty seemed harsh. Right decision to red-card Aneke
Amos: 5 Gunter: 4 Oshilaja: 4 Famewo: 6 Purrington: 6 Jaiyesimi 4.5 - The young players seem to be insructed to play it to an old pro. Shinnie: 3.5 - Patience has run thin on him. Pratley: 2.5 - Never scored lower than a 4 before this year, never below a 3 until recently. Plain stupid. Millar: 4.5 Stockley: 6 Washington: 3 Aneke: 3 Smith: 5 - Better then most we have in CM Watson: 4 How many appearances does he have to make to get an automatic extra 12 months? Maatsen: 4 Referee: 3
Amos: 5.5 thought he could have stopped the 2nd pen Gunter: 5.5 ok'sh Oshilaja: 5 has cost us last couple of games Famewo: 6.5 looked strong Purrington: 6 did nothing wrong Jaiyesimi 5 did little, wheres the player that was at swindon Shinnie: 5.5 poor 1st half but showed more in 2nd, set pieces awful Pratley: 5 foolish to get involved and get 2nd yellow. more experienced than that Millar: 5 did little Stockley: 5.5 didn't seem to win much in the air. clearly onside for the disallowed goal Washington: 5 didn't grab his chance Aneke: 5.5 was ok but then sent off again somewhat harshly. seems to always be getting involved with oppo players doesn't help his cause Smith: 5 not impressed so far Watson: 5.5 did ok but where is the player forest wanted to keep Maatsen: 6 tried hard when he came on. not much quality tho Referee: 2
Amos: 6 still don’t see him at fault Gunter: 4 very poor
Oshilaja: 5 sat so deep Famewo: 6 as above Purrington: 7 MoM in my view don’t get why he was subbed? Jaiyesimi 4 zero impact but don’t blame him some prick told him to stay on the wing Shinnie: 5 never a holding midfield player tries but in a two man midfield no chance Pratley: 3 as above plus being a dick! Millar: 5 don’t blame him some prick told him to stay on the wing Stockley: 7 so unlucky again Washington: 4 waste of space Aneke: 4 not a straight red Smith: 4 would like to see more of him Watson: 3 would like to see less of him Maatsen: 5 don’t know why he came on but did ok ish Referee: 0 total twunt
Amos: 5.5 Another of those "did nothing horrendous but nothing very good either" performances Gunter: 6 Oshilaja: 5 Famewo: 6.5 Did pretty well Purrington: 6.5 Not sure why he came off Jaiyesimi 4.5 Shinnie: 4.5 Pratley: 4 Millar: 5 Stockley: 6 Washington: 5 Aneke: 4 Smith: 5 Watson: 5 Maatsen: 5 Referee: 3
Amos: 3 doesn’t look like saving anything at the moment. If AMB were fit, Amos should be out. Gunter: 3 adds nothing Oshilaja: 4 tries, but not great. Famewo: 6 best of the bunch. Not difficult. Purrington: 5 no idea why he was hooked. Far worse players on the pitch. Jaiyesimi 2 may as well have been playing for Swindon. Shinnie: 2 dreadful. Not a tackle, pass, assist all game. And I had been a fan of his. Worse since he signed - Pringle-esque! Pratley: 1 an accident waiting to happen. Poor management that he wasn’t one of the four hooked at half time. Millar: 4 didn’t get going at all today. Stockley: 5 goal should have stood, but added little else Washington: 4 didn’t notice him Aneke: 3 harsh red, but did nothing when he was on. Smith: 3 anonymous Watson: 3 hapless Maatsen: 4 not the player he was at the start of the season. Referee: 2 awful
Amos: 4 not a patch on Phillips and its starting to show Gunter: 4 nothing special Oshilaja: 4.5 Tried hard Famewo: 4.5 Rusty but to be expected Purrington: 4.5 Ok unlucky to be subbed Jaiyesimi: 3.5 "WHO" Shinnie: 3 Lost the ball for first, where was he for the second Pratley: 2 Total liability Millar: 4 Been found out Stockley: 4.5 Worked hard Washington: 4.5 No worse than the rest Aneke: 4 Like to know what he was saying to himself all the way up to the dressing room Smith: 5 looked composed and can pass Watson: 3 Slow, under hits every pass, could'nt catch a snail Maatsen: 4 Shocking decision making and passing Schwartz: 9 Did nothing wrong because he never touched the ball (MOM) Referee: 2... 1 wrong red card, 1 wrong disallowed goal, 1 wrong penalty
Bowyer: Only one mistake which was not resigning after the Burton match
Amos: 4 not a patch on Phillips and its starting to show Gunter: 4 nothing special Oshilaja: 4.5 Tried hard Famewo: 4.5 Rusty but to be expected Purrington: 4.5 Ok unlucky to be subbed Jaiyesimi: 3.5 "WHO" Shinnie: 3 Lost the ball for first, where was he for the second Pratley: 2 Total liability Millar: 4 Been found out Stockley: 4.5 Worked hard Washington: 4.5 No worse than the rest Aneke: 4 Like to know what he was saying to himself all the way up to the dressing room Smith: 5 looked composed and can pass Watson: 3 Slow, under hits every pass, could'nt catch a snail Maatsen: 4 Shocking decision making and passing Schwartz: 9 Did nothing wrong because he never touched the ball (MOM) Referee: 2... 1 wrong red card, 1 wrong disallowed goal, 1 wrong penalty
Bowyer: Only one mistake which was not resigning after the Burton match
Can you give someone a 9 who never touched the ball?
Comments
Gunter: 4.5 Anonymous
Oshilaja: 4.5 Made basic errors in distribution
Famewo: 5.5 Good performance
Purrington: 4.5 Anonymous
Jaiyesimi 5 Feel sorry for the lad. Had one good move; then made wrong decisions. Has he been Charltonised already?
Shinnie: 5 Busy, as usual. Free-kicks and corners are more accurate than those by JFC. Which ain't saying much
Pratley: 5 I like Pratley, smiling while he puts the knife in. But his slowness lands him in trouble
Millar: 5.5 Our best player this season by a country mile. Shows what a really good academy can produce
Stockley: 5 Always willing, but service today was shyte
Washington: 4.5 Utterly anonymous
Aneke: 5 Has surprisingly close control. Neat footwork that got us precisely nowhere. Red card was right decision
Smith: 4.5 As bland and anonymous as his surname
Watson: 4.5 Anonymous. Penalty given against him was harsh
Maatsen: 4.5 One unforced error after another
Referee: 4.5 Second penalty seemed harsh. Right decision to red-card Aneke
Gunter: 4.5
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 4.5
Jaiyesimi 3
Shinnie: 4
Pratley: 3
Millar: 4
Stockley: 5
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 4.5
Watson: 3
Maatsen: 4
Referee: 2
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 7
Purrington: 5
Jaiyesimi: 5
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 4
Millar: 4
Stockley: 6
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 6
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 4.5 - The young players seem to be insructed to play it to an old pro.
Shinnie: 3.5 - Patience has run thin on him.
Pratley: 2.5 - Never scored lower than a 4 before this year, never below a 3 until recently. Plain stupid.
Millar: 4.5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 3
Aneke: 3
Smith: 5 - Better then most we have in CM
Watson: 4 How many appearances does he have to make to get an automatic extra 12 months?
Maatsen: 4
Referee: 3
Gunter: 5.5 ok'sh
Oshilaja: 5 has cost us last couple of games
Famewo: 6.5 looked strong
Purrington: 6 did nothing wrong
Jaiyesimi 5 did little, wheres the player that was at swindon
Shinnie: 5.5 poor 1st half but showed more in 2nd, set pieces awful
Pratley: 5 foolish to get involved and get 2nd yellow. more experienced than that
Millar: 5 did little
Stockley: 5.5 didn't seem to win much in the air. clearly onside for the disallowed goal
Washington: 5 didn't grab his chance
Aneke: 5.5 was ok but then sent off again somewhat harshly. seems to always be getting involved with oppo players doesn't help his cause
Smith: 5 not impressed so far
Watson: 5.5 did ok but where is the player forest wanted to keep
Maatsen: 6 tried hard when he came on. not much quality tho
Referee: 2
Schwartz: n/a
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 4.5
Famewo: 6.5
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 3
Shinnie: 4
Pratley: 3
Millar: 4
Stockley: 5.5
Washington: 3
Aneke: 3
Smith: 4.5
Watson: 4
Maatsen: 4
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 3
Famewo: 7
Purrington: 5
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 4
Pratley: 3
Millar: 4
Stockley: 6
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 3
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4 very poor
Famewo: 6 as above
Purrington: 7 MoM in my view don’t get why he was subbed?
Jaiyesimi 4 zero impact but don’t blame him some prick told him to stay on the wing
Shinnie: 5 never a holding midfield player tries but in a two man midfield no chance
Pratley: 3 as above plus being a dick!
Millar: 5 don’t blame him some prick told him to stay on the wing
Stockley: 7 so unlucky again
Washington: 4 waste of space
Aneke: 4 not a straight red
Smith: 4 would like to see more of him
Watson: 3 would like to see less of him
Maatsen: 5 don’t know why he came on but did ok ish
Referee: 0 total twunt
Schwartz: n/a
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi: 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 0
Millar: 6
Stockley: 7
Washington: 5
Aneke: 5
Smith: 5
Watson: 4
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 5
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 4
Millar: 5
Stockley: 5
Washington: 5
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 2
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 5
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 4
Millar: 5
Stockley: 5.5
Washington: 5
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 5.5
Pratley: 3
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 5.5
Aneke: 5
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 0.5 not the reason we lost but he was ******* awful
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 6
Pratley: 4
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 4
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 3
Pratley: 3
Millar: 4
Stockley: 4
Smith: 6
Watson: 4
Maatsen: 4
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 5
Jaiyesimi: 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 3
Millar: 4
Stockley: 5
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 4
Watson: 4
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 1 (He had clear line of sight for the 2nd penalty and still gave it - ridiculous)
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 6.5 Did pretty well
Purrington: 6.5 Not sure why he came off
Jaiyesimi 4.5
Shinnie: 4.5
Pratley: 4
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 3
I’d be interested to know if, according to the marks, this is one of the worst games Charlton have played.
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 7
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 4
Millar: 6
Stockley: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 5
Smith: 6
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 3
Gunter: 2
Oshilaja: 2
Famewo: 3
Purrington: 5
Jaiyesimi 2
Shinnie: 3
Pratley: 0
Millar: 3
Stockley: 6
Washington: 3
Aneke: 2
Smith: 2
Watson: 2
Maatsen: 2
Referee: 1
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 5
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 5
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 4.5
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 4.5
Smith: 5
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 4
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 3 Go away.
Millar: 4
Stockley: 5.5
Washington: 4.5
Aneke: 4
Smith: 5
Watson: 2 Go away.
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 2
Gunter: 3 adds nothing
Oshilaja: 4 tries, but not great.
Famewo: 6 best of the bunch. Not difficult.
Purrington: 5 no idea why he was hooked. Far worse players on the pitch.
Jaiyesimi 2 may as well have been playing for Swindon.
Shinnie: 2 dreadful. Not a tackle, pass, assist all game. And I had been a fan of his. Worse since he signed - Pringle-esque!
Pratley: 1 an accident waiting to happen. Poor management that he wasn’t one of the four hooked at half time.
Millar: 4 didn’t get going at all today.
Stockley: 5 goal should have stood, but added little else
Washington: 4 didn’t notice him
Aneke: 3 harsh red, but did nothing when he was on.
Smith: 3 anonymous
Watson: 3 hapless
Maatsen: 4 not the player he was at the start of the season.
Referee: 2 awful
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 6
Purrington: 6.5
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 2
Millar: 4
Stockley: 6
Washington: 4
Aneke: 4
Smith: 4
Watson: 4
Maatsen: 6
Referee: 1
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 5.5
Purrington: 4
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 1
Millar: 4
Stockley: 5
Washington: 4
Aneke: 5
Smith: 4
Watson: 3
Maatsen: 4
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 4
Famewo: 7
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 4
Shinnie: 5
Pratley: 3
Millar: 5
Stockley: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 4
Smith: 6
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 3
Gunter: 4 nothing special
Oshilaja: 4.5 Tried hard
Famewo: 4.5 Rusty but to be expected
Purrington: 4.5 Ok unlucky to be subbed
Jaiyesimi: 3.5 "WHO"
Shinnie: 3 Lost the ball for first, where was he for the second
Pratley: 2 Total liability
Millar: 4 Been found out
Stockley: 4.5 Worked hard
Washington: 4.5 No worse than the rest
Aneke: 4 Like to know what he was saying to himself all the way up to the dressing room
Smith: 5 looked composed and can pass
Watson: 3 Slow, under hits every pass, could'nt catch a snail
Maatsen: 4 Shocking decision making and passing
Schwartz: 9 Did nothing wrong because he never touched the ball (MOM)
Referee: 2... 1 wrong red card, 1 wrong disallowed goal, 1 wrong penalty
Bowyer: Only one mistake which was not resigning after the Burton match
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 2
Famewo: 7
Purrington: 6
Jaiyesimi 2
Shinnie: 4
Pratley: 6
Millar: 5
Stockley: 9
Washington: 7
Aneke: 0
Smith: 2
Watson: 5
Maatsen: 5
Referee: 2