Players Marks: Plymouth Argyle v Charlton Athletic (closes Thursday brekkers)

Bolderhumphreyreid

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 9
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8
Millar: 9
Gunter: 8
Referee: 8

sinceiwasyoung

lancashire lad said:

your marks please:


Amos: 8 Did everything right .
Matthews: 8 Best game for a long time  
.
Famewo: 8.5 Great to see him back .

Pearce: 8 The rich vein of form continues. 
Purrington: 8 Looked so solid .
F-C: 8 Worked tirelessly. 
Watson: 8 Looking a lot fitter .
Gilbey: 7.5 Great finish .
Jaiyesimi: 8 Clever player .

Stockley: 8.5 Took on 3 centre backs and brilliant goal .
Millar: 8.5 Back to his best tonight. 
Gunter: 6.5 Didn't need to do much .
Referee: 6 Ok .

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

SE_7EVEN

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8
Millar: 8
Gunter: 7
Referee: 7

seth plum

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8.5
Pearce: 8.5
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8
Watson: 7.5
Gilbey: 7.5
Jaiyesimi: 7.5
Stockley: 7.5
Millar: 7.5
Gunter: 7

Referee: 7

soapboxsam

Amos: 8.5 two vital saves at 0-0 and 2-0
Matthews: 8.5 two assists and got down the wing
Famewo: 8 strong game
Pearce: 8 ditto
Purrington: 8 so underated by Cafc fans
F-C: 8.5  best football of Cafc career
Watson: 8 passed and tackled well.
Gilbey: 8 gives so much energy and slick finish.
Jaiyesimi: 8 raw but getting there.
Stockley: 8 looks awkward but so effective.
Millar: 8.5 best game for Cafc tonight.
Gunter: 7 did ok.
Referee: 7 decent game.

Shinnie: n/a got involved
Morgan: n/a sprinted around
Aneke: n/a scored 1 and nearly 2.
Pratley: n/a great assist.

Jonniesta

Amos 8 one vital save at 2-0
Matthews 8 great cross for 2nd
Famewo 8
Pearce 8.5
Purrington 8.5
Watson 8
JFC 8.5 great controlled header
Gilbey 8 lovely finish
DJ 8 part of a great trio going forward 
Stockley 8.5
Millar 9 MoM pace, end product, good goal, lovely slice of luck for 3rd! 
Gunter 7
Ref 6 should've given us a pen. 

Honourable mention to the other subs too for their contributions. 

addickson

Amos: 8.5
Matthews: 8.5
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 9
Purrington: 8
F-C: 9.5
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 9
Millar: 8
Gunter: 8
Referee: 7

Jac_52

Amos: 8.5

Matthews: 8

Famewo: 8

Pearce: 8

Purrington: 8 

F-C: 8.5

Watson: 8

Gilbey: 8

Jaiyesimi: 8 

Stockley: 8.5 MOM

Millar: 8.5

Gunter: 6.5

Referee: 6 

Shinnie: n/a

Morgan: n/a

Aneke: n/a

Pratley: n/a

robinofottershaw

Amos: 8

Matthews: 8.5
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8 
Purrington: 8.5
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 7.5
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 7.5
Stockley: 8
Millar: 8
Gunter: 7
Referee: 8

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

Red7Oak

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 7.5
Purrington: 7.5
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 7
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8
Millar: 7.5
Gunter: 6
Referee: 5

covered_end_junior

Amos: 8
Matthews: 7.5
Famewo: 7.5
Pearce: 7.5
Purrington: 7.5
F-C: 8
Watson: 7.5
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 7
Stockley: 7.5
Millar: 8
Gunter: 7
Referee: 9

Hal1x

lancashire lad said:

your marks please:


Amos:          9
Matthews:    8
Famewo:      8 
Pearce:        9
Purrington:   9
F-C:            10
Watson:       7
Gilbey:         9
Jaiyesimi:    7
Stockley:     9
Millar:          8
Gunter:        7
Referee: 

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

Covered End

Amos: 7 A couple of excellent saves.

Matthews: 7.5 Played well set up a goal.
Famewo: 7 Did well, not much to do.
Pearce: 7 Did well, not much to do.
Purrington: 7.5 Pushed forward well at times.
F-C: 8 Excellent game.
Watson: 7.5 Did well.
Gilbey: 8 Excellent
Jaiyesimi: 7.5
Stockley: 8 Excellent
Millar: 9 MOM
Gunter: 7
Referee: 7

killerandflash

Amos: 8.5 (+0.5 for the throw which set up the crucial 3rd goal)
Matthews: 8.5 (+0.5 for the excellent cross)
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8.5 
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 8.5
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8
Millar: 8.5
Gunter: 7
Referee: 7

AddickRam

Amos: 7.5
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 7.5
Pearce: 7.5
Purrington: 7.5
F-C: 8
Watson: 7.5
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 8.5

Gunter: 6.5

Referee: 8

willieduff

Amos:   9.0
Matthews: 8.5
Famewo: 8.5
Pearce:   8.5
Purrington: 8.5
F-C:   9.0   MOM
Watson: 8.5
Gilbey:  8,5
Jaiyesimi:  8.0
Stockley: 8.5
Millar:   8.5
Gunter: 8.0
Referee:  8.0

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

Addictedoldgit

Amos:        8.5
Matthews: 7.5
Famewo:    8
Pearce:       8
Purrington: 7.5
F-C:              7.5
Watson:       7
Gilbey:          7.5
Jaiyesimi:    7.5
Stockley:      8
Millar:            8
Gunter:          7
Referee:         7

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

AddicksAddict

Amos: 9 great save with is backside then a quick throw for a goal
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 7.5
Jaiyesimi: 7.5
Stockley: 8
Millar: 7.5
Gunter: 7
Referee: 7

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: I don't think I've seen him consistently so far up the pitch.

Algarveaddick

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8.5
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 8 
Gilbey: 8
Jaiyesimi: 8.5
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 9
Gunter: 8
Referee: 6 (for missing the penalty shout - though if he had seen it, I accept that the butterfly effect may have seen a very different outcome for us  ) 

AddickNL88

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8
F-C: 8
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 8.5
Jaiyesimi: 8.5
Stockley: 8
Millar: 9
Gunter: 7

Charlton_Stu

Amos: 9
Matthews: 9
Famewo: 8.5
Pearce: 8.5
Purrington: 9
F-C: 9
Watson: 8.5
Gilbey: 9
Jaiyesimi: 8.5
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 9.5
Gunter: 8.5
Referee: 8

Arry Addick

Amos:   8
Matthews:  8.5 
Famewo:  7.5
Pearce:  8
Purrington: 7.5 
F-C:  8
Watson: 7.5 
Gilbey: 7.5
Jaiyesimi: 7.5
Stockley: 7.5
Millar: 8
Gunter: 7
Referee: 8

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Pratley: n/a

EveshamAddick

Amos: 8 - commanding, a couple of good saves and good distribution, great to see him so confident
Matthews: 8 - strong and nice assist
Famewo: 8.5 - good strong performance today
Pearce: 9 - well played the captain!
Purrington: 8.5 - good at the back and going forward 
F-C: 9 - MOM today 
Watson: 8 - very good 
Gilbey: 8 - did well; nice goal
Jaiyesimi: 7.5 - some good, some not so good, decision making needs to improve
Stockley: 8 - worked hard, nice goal “, superb dummy for Millar’s goal 
Millar: 8 - good performance from him today and nice goal.
Gunter: 7 - he did ok
Referee: 7 - mostly ok but missed the penalty shout in the first half.

Shinnie: n/a - couldn’t seem to get into it
Morgan: n/a - did well in his cameo, good involvement for Chuks’ goal
Aneke: n/a - good goal, shame he missed the other chance 
Pratley: n/a - good assist and played well when he came on

Adkins - 10 - superb!
TS - 10 - superb!

kimbo

Amos: 8
Matthews: 8 
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8 
Purrington: 8 
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 8
Gilbey: 8 
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8
Millar: 8
Gunter: 8

NorthbyEast

Amos: 7
Matthews:9
Famewo: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Purrington: 7.5
F-C: 8.5
Watson: 8.5
Gilbey: 8.5
Jaiyesimi: 7
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 9
Gunter: 6
Referee: 6

Pedro45

Amazing that the ref gets good marks (even from me!), yet only gave us one foul all game!

Simonsen

Amos: 8 Saved it when he had to, caught well and his quick throw helped us get a goal.
Matthews: 8 - Defended well and offered decent support out wide. His crossing has been poor in his time at Charlton but his cross last night was superb. 
Famewo: 8 - Won his headers and was largely untroubled.
Pearce: 8 - Threw his body in the way of shots and generally defended really well.
Purrington 8 - Kept his side bottled up well and tidied up when he had to.
F-C: 8 - Usual energetic stuff and very calmly taken header. 
Watson: 8 - Got stuck in well and looked fresh.
Gilbey: 8 - Some nice turns in midfield and makes clever off-ball runs. His finish for the goal was worthy of the European Super League....
Jaiyesimi: 8 - Probably our main threat first half. I like his tight turns. If we can just get him to simplify his game tad more, he's going to be really good.
Stockley: 8 - Another whole hearted effort and fantastic diving header. 
Millar: 9 - Took a while to grow into the game but once he did, he was involved in a lot of the big moments. Took his goal very well and looked fresh. 
Gunter: 7 - Did nothing of particular note but didn't have to. 
Referee: 8 - Unfussy and hardly noticed. 

Shinnie: n/a
Morgan: n/a
Aneke: n/a - Nice goal, looked a threat but a bad miss late on. 
Pratley: n/a

LonelyNorthernAddick

Amos: 8 - Made a number of important saves, especially early on, and set us on our way for at least one goal on the counter as well
Matthews: 8 - Best performance this season, great ball in for Stockley
Famewo: 7.5 - Solid
Pearce: 7.5 - Battled
Purrington: 7.5 - As above
F-C: 7.5 - Classic JFC performance atm, well taken header for the first goal too
Watson: 7.5 - Mopped up really well 
Gilbey: 7.5 - Seeing the player we thought he would be. Powerhouse.
Jaiyesimi: 8.5 - Terrified their defence
Stockley: 8 - Bullied their CBs, could've had more.
Millar: 8.5 - Dangerous from start to finish
Gunter: 7 - tidy
Referee: 7

rananegra

Amos: 8.5
Matthews: 8
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8
F-C: 9
Watson: 8.5
Gilbey: 8.5
Jaiyesimi: 8
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 9
Gunter: 7.5
Referee: 8 there wasn't much for him to do, he was fussy and a bit lenient, but the game flowed. 

Addicktion

Amos: 9
Matthews: 8.5 
Famewo: 8
Pearce: 8
Purrington: 8.5 
F-C: 9
Watson: 8.5 
Gilbey: 9
Jaiyesimi: 8.5
Stockley: 8.5
Millar: 8.5
Gunter: 7
Referee: 7