MacG: 7 Matthews: 7 Lavelle: 7 looked very promising Famewo: 6 Gunter: 7 DJ: 5 Watson: 7 Morgan: 5 Kirk: 5 Lee: 7 Stockley: 4 Leko: 8 Referee 5 ….. have to have a look but both goals had suspicion of off side …
What on earth do you think either player did to justify a 7 out of 10 rating?
MacG: 7 Matthews: 7 Lavelle: 7 looked very promising Famewo: 6 Gunter: 7 DJ: 5 Watson: 7 Morgan: 5 Kirk: 5 Lee: 7 Stockley: 4 Leko: 8 Referee 5 ….. have to have a look but both goals had suspicion of off side …
MacG: 6. Made some decent saves but should have pushed the first around the post rather than back out to them. AGAIN.
Matthews: 6.5 Tried to get forward a few times.
Lavelle: 5.5. Hope he is better than this showing as he looked very slow.
Famewo: 5.5 certainly always gives his all. His ability to play out from the back is woeful though.
Gunter: 3. Totally fucking useless, hope to never see him again ever.
DJ: 4. Ineffective and missed the target completely with a very good chance.
Watson: 2. Moved nearer to home to join us as he wanted to ease into retirement, has no affection for the club and drifts through games. One of my least fav Charlton players of all time.
Morgan: 5.5. Not up to L1. No lack of effort.
Kirk: 4. Completely ineffectual.
Lee: 7 looked to be more effective than most.
Stockley: 6. Tries so hard but so slow of movement and thought. One trick pony. Ref did him no favours
Leko: 7.5 nice goal, made us so much more dangerous. Will be good at this level but someway from fitness and faded quickly.
Washington: 6.5 should have volleyed an effort, tried to bring it down and chance was gone. Like him.
Referee: 4. Didn't effect the score particularly but just poor. Missed a penalty for each team, allowed them to foul Stockely all game and practically take the shirt of Lekos back. Then he wasted 30 seconds to tell their goalie not to waste time without booking him. Genuinely never seen that before.
MacG: 7 MOM again Matthews: 5 Lavelle: 5 Famewo: 5.5 Gunter: 4 - we have a LB now. No need for him to be involved. DJ: 4 - pony Watson: 5 Morgan: 5 - stop finding a place for him in the team. Kirk: 4 - piss poor Lee: 6 - few decent touches, didn’t hide Stockley: 5.5 - works hard but hate the style of play we have adopted to accommodate him. Leko: 7 Washington: 6 Referee: 6
your marks please either watched at the Valley or live on a screen:
MacG: 7.5 maybe could have pushed the first shot for the first goal out for a corner Matthew: 4 partly his fault for first goal Lavelle: 6 slow to react at times Famewo: 6 usual mixed bag Gunter: 3 looked tired DJ: 3.5 messed up everything he was involved in Watson: 3 back to his worst Morgan: 4.5 our best midfielder today Kirk: 3 does nothing , incredibly lazy Lee: 6 quality , but faded badly Stockley: 4.5 worst I've seen from him Leko: 7 the goal went to his head a bit Washington: 6 tried to get into the game Referee: 4 didn't give us much
MacG: 8 - saved us time and again Matthews: 5 Lavelle: 4 Famewo: 1 (there are people here giving him 5. Are you serious. He was terrible. Has been poor all season) Gunter: 0 DJ: 4 Watson: 1 (awful. Just let the scorer for the second walk in front of him( Morgan: 2 (not good enough) Kirk: 3 Lee: 6 (only class player) Stockley: 2 (total moaner) Leko: 6 Washington: 5 Referee:
MacG: 7 Matthews: 7 Lavelle: 7 looked very promising Famewo: 6 Gunter: 7 DJ: 5 Watson: 7 Morgan: 5 Kirk: 5 Lee: 7 Stockley: 4 Leko: 8 Referee 5 ….. have to have a look but both goals had suspicion of off side …
Ffs what game were you watching?
As usual an attention seeking wind-up with players marks from Bexley Boy/Colin/RonnieMoore…he’s been winding up CL for years.
MacG: 5 would like to see Henderson back in goal from now on. Matthews: 3 a shadow of the player that he was Lavelle: 5 not bad but no cigar yet. Famewo: really poor hoofball distribution. Like Matthews a shadow of his former self. Gunter: 1 Taxi!!! DJ: 3 Dr. Jekyll and Mr Hide ??? Watson: 1 Share the taxi with Gunter mate. Morgan: 3 works hard but not a league 1 consistent. Kirk: 2 completely ineffective. I know he has had a tough time recently so don't play him yet. Just looks lost. Lee: 6 like him a lot , key player for us this season. Stockley: 2 that was just rubbish and soooo predictable. Leko: 6.5 motm brought energy and pace and a good finish. Washington: 6 Should have started. Referee: 1 garbage.
Souaré: can't really give a mark but should have the left back birth now that Gunter is in a taxi.
Any player that played the second half deserves at least a 4. MacG: 6 Matthews: 4 Lavelle: 4 Famewo: 4 Gunter: 4 DJ:4 Watson: 4 Morgan: 4 - was the only positive one in the group of players Kirk: 3- very poor down the wing. Lee: 5- Better in second half Stockley: 4- Kept on falling over the place. Leko: 6- Glad he is back and score wonderful goals (He doesn't deserve to be playing in League One) Washington: 5- better in second half
Souaré: Didn't notice. Be cruel to rate due to limited time on the field.
Atkins: 4- First half was tactically rubbish just pinging it from side to side. The change he made at half time impacted the game (Leko, Washington).
That Guy who did the crossbar challenge at halftime: 10 (did his job - hit the crossbar-got the crowd going- hope he enjoys his £8,500.
Referee: I don't like rating the referee due to bias- I felt he let a lot of their players off at times, and the fact he only talked to the Goalkeeper about the time wasting was stupid.
Very harsh some of the scores posted by other Lifers. I dont think we were that bad for players to be getting 2's & 3's. What happens when we lose 5-0......minus scores?
MacG. 7 Matthews - 2 worse defender and can understand why he has the worse stats of passing and defending of any other Charlton player this season . At fault for first goal Lavelle 6 Famewo 5 Gunter 6 - please play him at Right back and get rid of Matthews DJ 5 Morgan 7.5 worked hard and the only player looking to pass forward on the floor Watson 7 - at least always tries to play to a Charlton player Kirk 4 - hopefully he will improve Elliot 5 started well but just stopped running Stockley - 5 - his worse game for us Leko 7 Washington 6.5 Ref 3
Comments
Matthews: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 3.5
DJ: 4
Watson: 4
Morgan: 4
Kirk: 4
Lee: 5
Stockley: 4
Leko: 7
Washington: 6.5
Referee: 6
Matthews: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 3
DJ: 4
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 4
Lee: 6
Stockley: 4
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 4
Souaré: n/a
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5.5
Gunter: 4 - we have a LB now. No need for him to be involved.
DJ: 4 - pony
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5 - stop finding a place for him in the team.
Kirk: 4 - piss poor
Lee: 6 - few decent touches, didn’t hide
Stockley: 5.5 - works hard but hate the style of play we have adopted to accommodate him.
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 6
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 4.5
DJ: 4.5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 4
Lee: 5.5
Stockley: 5
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 5
Matthews: 4
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 3.5
DJ: 3.5
Watson: 5.5
Morgan: 5.5
Kirk: 2
Lee: 6
Stockley: 6
Leko: 5.5
Washington: 6.5
Matthews 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 4
DJ: 4
Watson: 5
Morgan: 6
Kirk: 3
Lee: 5
Stockley: 5
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 3
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5.5
Gunter: 5.5
DJ: 4.5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 4.5
Kirk: 4.5
Lee: 6
Stockley: 6
Leko: 6.5
Washington: 6
Referee: 2 Useless
MacG: 8 - saved us time and again
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 4
Famewo: 1 (there are people here giving him 5. Are you serious. He was terrible. Has been poor all season)
Gunter: 0
DJ: 4
Watson: 1 (awful. Just let the scorer for the second walk in front of him(
Morgan: 2 (not good enough)
Kirk: 3
Lee: 6 (only class player)
Stockley: 2 (total moaner)
Leko: 6
Washington: 5
Referee:
Matthews: 4.5
Lavelle: 4.5
Famewo: 4.5
Gunter: 4.5
DJ: 4.5
Watson: 4.5
Morgan: 4
Kirk: 3.5
Lee: 5
Stockley: 5
Leko: 6
Washington: 5
Referee: 6.5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 5 shades of Jason Pearce about him to me. Looks slow and uncomfortable on the ball
Famewo: 4 woeful
Gunter: 5
DJ: 5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 4
Lee: 7
Stockley: 6
Leko: 7
Washington: 7
Referee: 4
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 3
DJ: 4
Watson: 4
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 5
Lee: 7
Stockley: 7
Leko: 7
Washington: 7
Matthews: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 5
DJ: 4
Watson: 4
Morgan: 4
Kirk: 4
Lee: 6
Stockley: 5
Leko: 6
Washington: 5
Referee: 5
Souaré: n/a
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Gunter:3
DJ: 4
Watson: 6
Morgan: 6
Kirk: 3
Lee: 6.5
Stockley: 5
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 3.5
DJ: 3.5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 4
Kirk: 2
Matthews: 3 a shadow of the player that he was
Lavelle: 5 not bad but no cigar yet.
Famewo: really poor hoofball distribution. Like Matthews a shadow of his former self.
Gunter: 1 Taxi!!!
DJ: 3 Dr. Jekyll and Mr Hide ???
Watson: 1 Share the taxi with Gunter mate.
Morgan: 3 works hard but not a league 1 consistent.
Kirk: 2 completely ineffective. I know he has had a tough time recently so don't play him yet. Just looks lost.
Lee: 6 like him a lot , key player for us this season.
Stockley: 2 that was just rubbish and soooo predictable.
Leko: 6.5 motm brought energy and pace and a good finish.
Washington: 6 Should have started.
Referee: 1 garbage.
Souaré: can't really give a mark but should have the left back birth now that Gunter is in a taxi.
MacG: 6
Matthews: 4
Lavelle: 4
Famewo: 4
Gunter: 4
DJ:4
Watson: 4
Morgan: 4 - was the only positive one in the group of players
Kirk: 3- very poor down the wing.
Lee: 5- Better in second half
Stockley: 4- Kept on falling over the place.
Leko: 6- Glad he is back and score wonderful goals (He doesn't deserve to be playing in League One)
Washington: 5- better in second half
Souaré: Didn't notice. Be cruel to rate due to limited time on the field.
Atkins: 4- First half was tactically rubbish just pinging it from side to side. The change he made at half time impacted the game (Leko, Washington).
That Guy who did the crossbar challenge at halftime: 10 (did his job - hit the crossbar-got the crowd going- hope he enjoys his £8,500.
Referee: I don't like rating the referee due to bias- I felt he let a lot of their players off at times, and the fact he only talked to the Goalkeeper about the time wasting was stupid.
Leko: 7
Referee: 3
Matthews - 2 worse defender and can understand why he has the worse stats of passing and defending of any other Charlton player this season . At fault for first goal
Lavelle 6
Famewo 5
Gunter 6 - please play him at Right back and get rid of Matthews
DJ 5
Morgan 7.5 worked hard and the only player looking to pass forward on the floor
Watson 7 - at least always tries to play to a Charlton player
Kirk 4 - hopefully he will improve
Elliot 5 started well but just stopped running
Stockley - 5 - his worse game for us
Leko 7
Washington 6.5
Ref 3
Matthews: 6.5
Lavelle: 5.5
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5.5
DJ: 5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 4
Lee: 6.5
Stockley: 6
Leko: 7
Washington: 6
Referee: 5
Matthews: 5.5
Lavelle: 6.5
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5
DJ: 5
Watson: 5
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 4
Lee: 7
Stockley: 6
Leko: 6.5
Washington: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 4
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 5
DJ: 5
Watson: 6
Morgan: 5
Kirk: 5
Lee: 6
Stockley: 5
Leko: 6
Washington: 6
Referee: 6