MacG: 6 doesn’t command his area Gunter: 3 too central Lavelle: 7 only shining light Famewo: 4 poor disruption Souaré: 4 grew into the game second half but again too central Arter: 3 needs to lead the team Gilbey: 2 headless chicken Leko: 6 one touch too many Kirk: 0 not prepared to go in the inside line Davison: B-T:3 Stockley: Referee:
Really struggled with a score for Kirk. Anything lower than a three seems like being unnecessarily brutal, but in reality he contributed absolutely nothing. In the end I decided on three points, one for playing in each half and one because he was out of position for a fair chunk of the match.
MacG: 7 Sold performance Gunter: 8 Got forward well, some great crosses Lavelle: 7.5 Nothing got past him Famewo: 8.5 Immense Souaré: 7.5 Looks a decent signing Arter: 8 Ran the midfield Gilbey:7.5 Back to his best Leko: 8 A real handful Kirk: 9 MOTM. Took all 3 goals brilliantly Davison: 8 Showed real class B-T: 8 They couldn't handle him Stockley 8 Scores with the back of his head, just to rub it in
I normally don't go below 5 because I see 6 as average 5 as poor . Yesterday I award a few 4's because the player was poor and their actions led to conceded goals .
MacG: 5 Unlucky with the goal with Stockley Gunter: 6 Looked effective at times Lavelle: 6 Took his goal well Famewo: 5 Really not looking the player he was last season Souaré: 5 Shows flashes of playing at a higher level and has a sweet left foot . Then he flatters to deceive Arter: 7 Extra point for the well taken corner . Fear he is not fit . If his hammy has gone he could be out for a few weeks . Gilbey: 4 Loses a point for not challenging Maguire at the end which led to their second goal Leko: 4 Loses a point for not getting an effective challenge to Poole's header Kirk: 5 Still settling in ? Davison: 6 Felt he made a couple of good defensive contributions from corners B-T: 5 Typical winger . Either outstanding or terrible Stockley: 4 Sorry . He loses a point for the own goal
MacG: 4 poor for the first goal. Really should have done better
Gunter: 4 Is he any good for Wales? If so, who is the player we have using his name? Lavelle: 5 extra point for sticking his leg out for the goal Famewo: 3 seems clueless, complete opposite of the player we first got last year. Charltonised. Souaré: 3 nothing of any note except the wild swing that sent the ball backwards as he tried to clear Arter: 6 tried hard, but should have been subbed before somehow getting away without being sent off Gilbey: 4 pretty anonymous yesterday Leko: 3 just nothing Kirk: 3 same as Leko Davison: 3 nothing came off for him & no real service to him B-T: 3 surprised he didn’t start, then saw why. Worst performance from him. Stockley: 3 nothing he could do about the o.g. but did nothing else Referee: 6 let Arter off, but pretty decent for the game.
Comments
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 7
Famewo: 6
Souaré: 5
Arter: 6
Gilbey: 6
Leko: 6
Kirk: 4
Davison: 5
B-T:5
Stockley: 6
Referee: 3
Watson: n/a
MacG: 5
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 3
Arter: 3
Gilbey: 4
Leko: 2
Kirk: 2
Davison: 3
B-T: 2
Stockley: 5
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 4.5
Famewo: 3.5
Souaré: 1.5
Arter: 5
Gilbey: 4.5
Leko: 4
Kirk: 1
Davison: 4.5
B-T: 4
Stockley: 5.5
MacG: 6 doesn’t command his area
Gunter: 3 too central
Lavelle: 7 only shining light
Famewo: 4 poor disruption
Souaré: 4 grew into the game second half but again too central
Arter: 3 needs to lead the team
Gilbey: 2 headless chicken
Leko: 6 one touch too many
Kirk: 0 not prepared to go in the inside line
Davison:
B-T:3
Stockley:
Referee:
Watson: n/a
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 4
Arter: 5
Gilbey: 5
Leko: 5
Kirk: 3
Davison: 5
B-T: 5
Stockley: 5
Referee: 6
Really struggled with a score for Kirk. Anything lower than a three seems like being unnecessarily brutal, but in reality he contributed absolutely nothing. In the end I decided on three points, one for playing in each half and one because he was out of position for a fair chunk of the match.
Gunter: 6
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 6
Souaré: 5
Arter: 5
Gilbey: 4.5
Leko: 4
Kirk: 1
Davison: 4
B-T: 3
Stockley: 5
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6.5
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 4
Arter: 6.5
Gilbey: 5.5
Leko: 5
Kirk: 4
Davison: 5
B-T:4.5
Stockley: 4.5
ReF 6
MacG: 5 Unlucky with the goal with Stockley
Gunter: 6 Looked effective at times
Lavelle: 6 Took his goal well
Famewo: 5 Really not looking the player he was last season
Souaré: 5 Shows flashes of playing at a higher level and has a sweet left foot . Then he flatters to deceive
Arter: 7 Extra point for the well taken corner . Fear he is not fit . If his hammy has gone he could be out for a few weeks .
Gilbey: 4 Loses a point for not challenging Maguire at the end which led to their second goal
Leko: 4 Loses a point for not getting an effective challenge to Poole's header
Kirk: 5 Still settling in ?
Davison: 6 Felt he made a couple of good defensive contributions from corners
B-T: 5 Typical winger . Either outstanding or terrible
Stockley: 4 Sorry . He loses a point for the own goal
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 4
Arter: 4
Gilbey: 4
Leko: 4
Kirk: 4
Davison: 4
B-T: 6
Stockley: 4
Lavelle: 5 extra point for sticking his leg out for the goal
Famewo: 3 seems clueless, complete opposite of the player we first got last year. Charltonised.
Souaré: 3 nothing of any note except the wild swing that sent the ball backwards as he tried to clear
Arter: 6 tried hard, but should have been subbed before somehow getting away without being sent off
Gilbey: 4 pretty anonymous yesterday
Leko: 3 just nothing
Kirk: 3 same as Leko
Davison: 3 nothing came off for him & no real service to him
B-T: 3 surprised he didn’t start, then saw why. Worst performance from him.
Stockley: 3 nothing he could do about the o.g. but did nothing else
Referee: 6 let Arter off, but pretty decent for the game.
Watson: n/a
MacG: 4
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 6
Souaré: 4
Arter: 6.5 MOM
Gilbey: 6
Leko: 2
Kirk: 1
Davison: 2
B-T: 4
Stockley: 4
Referee: 6