MacG: 5 - something not right about him. Gunter: 3 - useless. Lavelle: 5 - Good honest trier. Cant see him becoming much more. Famewo: 4 - he clearly had a less talented twin brother who we’ve taken on. Souaré: 3 - makes Purrington look good. Clare: 4 - makes me look good. Gilbey: 7.5. Very good effort and not a little skill Morgan: 5 - poor but never stopped trying. Leko: 7 - good performance. Must be tearing his hair out. Stockley: 5 - I know he scored but he’s a donkey really and forces us to play in a certain way. B-T: 2. Nearly missed him. Five minutes effort out of however many he was on just isn’t good enough. Referee: 4 apart from missing a goal and having the piss generally taken out of him all evening I thought he did alright.
MacG: 4 to slow to react and kicking woeful Gunter: 2 turned shocking player Lavelle: 4 lightweig MacG: 5 Famewo: 5 tried Souaré: 4 courts out Clare: 5 to many fouls and slow Gilbey: 7. Played ok Morgan: 6 tried Leko: 6 tried Stockley: 6 - took goal well Referee: 3 mugged
simply not good enough not only Adkins has to go coaching looks awful
Hard to say any mark is harsh on a Charlton player, but that's harsh on Blackett-Taylor
MacG: 5 - I still think he's well dodgy Gunter: 5 Lavelle: 5 Famewo: 3 - too many mistakes today Souaré: 1 should have been sent off Clare: 5 Gilbey: 6 Morgan: 5 Leko: 6 Stockley: 5 B-T: 5 Referee: 6 Adkins: 1 - Totally Clueless, has to go in my opinion!
MacG: 4 can't deal with shots from distance Gunter: 2.5 his time is up surely Lavelle: 5.5 best of our so called defenders Famewo: 3 shite tonight Souaré: 3 always out of position Clare: 4 tries , but no real ability Gilbey: 7 played well Morgan: 4.5 a couple of good passes , but should have prevented their third goal Leko: 6.5 skilful Stockley: 5 missed a free header B-T: 4.5 had a good 10 mins 2nd half Referee: 0.5 horrendous
MacGillivray: 3 - Worst performance for us, mugged twice by the Free-Kicks and distribution, well...!! Gunter: 3 - Yup we need a new Right-Back in January, cost us for the third goal, no attacking sense Lavelle: 4 - Again one of the better performers, but doesnt say a lot about them Famewo: 5 - Going through a poor spell Souare: 2 - Dont see the improvement on Purrington, should have been sent off Clare: 5 - Game passes through him too easily Gilbey: 6 - At least tried to get things moving Morgan: 5 - Cant fault his effort at least Leko: 5 - Showed plenty of attacking sense, but no end product Stockley: 5 - Took his goal well, unlucky not to score more Blackett-Taylor: 4 - Invisible first half, better in the second
Referee: 3 - Embarrasing - Twice spoke to the GK about time wasting yet didnt book him... Why???
Mac - 4 - seems to take an absolute eternity to release the ball and even then it’s really poor Gunter - 3 - The bloke retired a couple of years ago but hasn’t had the decency to tell anyone Souare - 4 - Purrington’s not the answer but he’s better than this Lavelle - 6 - Solid enough. Lovely second half dribble Famewo - 3 - Is this guy a shit footballing lookie likey of the guy from last season - All over the shop, torried night Morgan - 5 - Never ever a DM, criminal to be put him in that role Clare 5 - The levels of inconsistency even with one half is alarming Gilbey- 7 - God loves a trier. Played well CBT - 4 - ineffective Leko - 5 - Dribbles, cuts in, hits a weak shot …. Repeat. Stockley - 5 - I know he gets targeted but at times he was like brick wall with the ball bouncing of him all over the place (particularly first half)
Mac - 4 - seems to take an absolute eternity to release the ball and even then it’s really poor Gunter - 3 - The bloke retired a couple of years ago but hasn’t had the decency to tell anyone Souare - 4 - Purrington’s not the answer but he’s better than this Lavelle - 6 - Solid enough. Lovely second half dribble Famewo - 3 - Is this guy a shit footballing lookie likey of the guy from last season - All over the shop, torried night Morgan - 5 - Never ever a DM, criminal to be put him in that role Clare 5 - The levels of inconsistency even with one half is alarming Gilbey- 7 - God loves a trier. Played well CBT - 4 - ineffective Leko - 5 - Dribbles, cuts in, hits a weak shot …. Repeat. Stockley - 5 - I know he gets targeted but at times he was like brick wall with the ball bouncing of him all over the place (particularly first half)
A great take this one, but I’d go in on Morgan a little more to say it’s criminal he’s ever put a charlton shirt on, embarrassing footballer
MacG: 5.5 Gunter: 4 Lavelle: 5 best defender, which is a bit like being the tallest dwarf I guess Famewo: 4.5 what's happened to him? Souaré: 4 from where I was it looked like Pell faked being headbutted by him, hence the angry reaction of the crowd and the response from the players. I think all our cards were for fouls on Pell Clare: 5.5 gave something back Gilbey: 5.5 Morgan: 5 Leko: 5.5 some came off most didn't Stockley: 5 B-T: 5 Referee: 5.5 thought he was OK, can't really complain about the bookings and he did try and stop the time wasting and niggly stuff from AS. I was surprised Gilbey wasn't booked, but then he hadn't fouled Pell so maybe it didn't count
Why was Washington not on sooner? I like him more than all the rest put together because he actually tries
MacG: 4 Vulnerable both from distance and at close range Gunter: 4 Strewn with errors Lavelle: 4.5 Famewo: 4 Gets increasingly worse: prone to basic errors Souaré: 4.5 Clare: 4 Anonymous Gilbey: 5 The only player with a modicum of intelligence Morgan: 2 No, no, no! How many times have we watched those misplaced passes? Leko: 4 Anonymous Stockley: 4.5 Let down as usual by incompetent team-mates B-T: 4 Utterly ineffective Referee: 6 Had a better game than any one of our players
MacG: 5 Gunter: 4 Lavelle: 5 Famewo: 3 really regressed from last season Souaré: 4 Clare: 4.5 a couple of nice runs, but too anonymous Gilbey: 6 a couple of nice runs, but faded Morgan: 5.5 flawed defensively, but didn't hide and unlike some players can actually play a full 90 Leko: 6 Stockley: 5 B-T: 4.5 Referee: 4
MacG: 3 Doesn't deserve a place. Come in Hendo, come in anyone Gunter: 2 Go and play golf with your mate Bale because you can't play football. Lavelle: 6 Shown effort and determination in this freak show Famewo: 2 Norwich please take him back in January. Thinks he is Beckenbauer, but plays like the 80 year old version Souaré: 2 Sadly hasn't recovered from his accident. I think he is finished as a pro. Please play Purrington Clare: 5.5 He tried his best Gilbey: 7 Showed pride and gave his all Morgan: 4 Not up to it don't think he ever will be Leko: 6.5 Inconsistent but still our greatest danger up front Stockley: 5 Slow and limited but tried B-T: 5 a few cameo moments Referee: 4 Never seemed in control
MacG: 3 Can’t catch a cross, can’t kick out to a Charlton player and gets beaten too often from free kicks. One decent save. Gunter: 3 Lost his winger and then let him get into the box and cross for the second goal. He does look like he’s trying but just can’t defend. Lavelle: 6 Won his challenges and tries but can’t shoot like most of his fellow players. Famewo: 5.5 Works hard & tries but distribution is poor but then there weren’t many options for him. Souaré: 2 Second game running he has been total crap. Can’t control the ball, pass to a red shirt or make a tackle. Extra point for standing up to Pell. Clare: 3 Majority of time the game passes him by Gilbey: 7.5 Showed pride and gave his all Morgan: 4.5 Worked his socks off, made challenges and some decent corners but bad free kicks. Looked devastated at the end. Leko: 6.5 Inconsistent but still our greatest danger up front. Poor shooting. Stockley: 5 Slow and limited but tried & took his goal well B-T: 3 Not playing to his strengths but needs to be more involved. Referee: 2 Fell for the AS tactics all night. Why did he let Pell walk the full width of the pitch after treatment when he was on the AC stand touch line. Gave AS a free kick every time one of them fell over.
Comments
Gunter: 3 - useless.
Lavelle: 5 - Good honest trier. Cant see him becoming much more.
Famewo: 4 - he clearly had a less talented twin brother who we’ve taken on.
Souaré: 3 - makes Purrington look good.
Clare: 4 - makes me look good.
Gilbey: 7.5. Very good effort and not a little skill
Morgan: 5 - poor but never stopped trying.
Leko: 7 - good performance. Must be tearing his hair out.
Stockley: 5 - I know he scored but he’s a donkey really and forces us to play in a certain way.
B-T: 2. Nearly missed him. Five minutes effort out of however many he was on just isn’t good enough.
Referee: 4 apart from missing a goal and having the piss generally taken out of him all evening I thought he did alright.
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 3 - too many mistakes today
Souaré: 1 should have been sent off
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5
Referee: 6
Adkins: 1 - Totally Clueless, has to go in my opinion!
Washington: n/a
Davison: n/a
DJ: n/a
Gunter 5
Lavelle 6
Famewo 5
Souare 5
Clare 5
Gilbey 6
Morgan 5
Leko 6
Stockley 5
BT 5
Ref 4
Lavelle: 4
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 3
Clare: 4
Gilbey: 5.5
Morgan: 4
Leko: 5.5
Stockley: 4.5
B-T: 4
Referee: 2
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 4.5
Famewo: 4.5
Souaré: 5
Clare: 4
Gilbey: 4.5
Morgan: 5
Leko: 5
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5.5
Referee: 7
Lowest complete set of marks I have ever given
Gunter: 3
Lavelle: 3
Famewo: 2
Souaré: 4
Clare: 3
Gilbey: 5
Morgan: 3
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4
B-T: 4
Referee: 1
Gunter: 3 - Yup we need a new Right-Back in January, cost us for the third goal, no attacking sense
Lavelle: 4 - Again one of the better performers, but doesnt say a lot about them
Famewo: 5 - Going through a poor spell
Souare: 2 - Dont see the improvement on Purrington, should have been sent off
Clare: 5 - Game passes through him too easily
Gilbey: 6 - At least tried to get things moving
Morgan: 5 - Cant fault his effort at least
Leko: 5 - Showed plenty of attacking sense, but no end product
Stockley: 5 - Took his goal well, unlucky not to score more
Blackett-Taylor: 4 - Invisible first half, better in the second
Referee: 3 - Embarrasing - Twice spoke to the GK about time wasting yet didnt book him... Why???
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 4
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5
Referee: 5
Washington: n/a
Davison: n/a
DJ: n/a
Gunter - 3 - The bloke retired a couple of years ago but hasn’t had the decency to tell anyone
Souare - 4 - Purrington’s not the answer but he’s better than this
Lavelle - 6 - Solid enough. Lovely second half dribble
Famewo - 3 - Is this guy a shit footballing lookie likey of the guy from last season - All over the shop, torried night
Morgan - 5 - Never ever a DM, criminal to be put him in that role
Clare 5 - The levels of inconsistency even with one half is alarming
Gilbey- 7 - God loves a trier. Played well
CBT - 4 - ineffective
Leko - 5 - Dribbles, cuts in, hits a weak shot …. Repeat.
Stockley - 5 - I know he gets targeted but at times he was like brick wall with the ball bouncing of him all over the place (particularly first half)
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5 best defender, which is a bit like being the tallest dwarf I guess
Famewo: 4.5 what's happened to him?
Souaré: 4 from where I was it looked like Pell faked being headbutted by him, hence the angry reaction of the crowd and the response from the players. I think all our cards were for fouls on Pell
Clare: 5.5 gave something back
Gilbey: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Leko: 5.5 some came off most didn't
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5
Referee: 5.5 thought he was OK, can't really complain about the bookings and he did try and stop the time wasting and niggly stuff from AS. I was surprised Gilbey wasn't booked, but then he hadn't fouled Pell so maybe it didn't count
Why was Washington not on sooner? I like him more than all the rest put together because he actually tries
Gunter: 4 Strewn with errors
Lavelle: 4.5
Famewo: 4 Gets increasingly worse: prone to basic errors
Souaré: 4.5
Clare: 4 Anonymous
Gilbey: 5 The only player with a modicum of intelligence
Morgan: 2 No, no, no! How many times have we watched those misplaced passes?
Leko: 4 Anonymous
Stockley: 4.5 Let down as usual by incompetent team-mates
B-T: 4 Utterly ineffective
Referee: 6 Had a better game than any one of our players
MacG: 5.5
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 5
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Leko: 5
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 5
Clare: 6
Gilbey: 7
Morgan: 5
Leko: 7
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 3 really regressed from last season
Souaré: 4
Clare: 4.5 a couple of nice runs, but too anonymous
Gilbey: 6 a couple of nice runs, but faded
Morgan: 5.5 flawed defensively, but didn't hide and unlike some players can actually play a full 90
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 4.5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5.5
Souaré: 5
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 7.5
Morgan: 4
Leko: 5.5
Stockley 6
Gunter: 2 Go and play golf with your mate Bale because you can't play football.
Lavelle: 6 Shown effort and determination in this freak show
Famewo: 2 Norwich please take him back in January. Thinks he is Beckenbauer, but plays like the 80 year old version
Souaré: 2 Sadly hasn't recovered from his accident. I think he is finished as a pro. Please play Purrington
Clare: 5.5 He tried his best
Gilbey: 7 Showed pride and gave his all
Morgan: 4 Not up to it don't think he ever will be
Leko: 6.5 Inconsistent but still our greatest danger up front
Stockley: 5 Slow and limited but tried
B-T: 5 a few cameo moments
Referee: 4 Never seemed in control
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 4.5
Souaré: 5
Clare: 6
Gilbey: 7.5
Morgan: 4.5
Leko: 7
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5
Referee: 3
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 4
Clare: 4.5
Gilbey: 6.5
Morgan:5.5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 4
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 5
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 4
Leko: 6
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5
Referee: 5
Washington: n/a
Davison: n/a
DJ: n/a1
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 4
Clare: 3
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 6
B-T: 4
Referee: 4
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 4.5
Clare: 5.5
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5.5
Referee: 6
Gunter: 4
Lavelle: 5
Famewo: 4
Souaré: 4
Clare: 5.5
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 4
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5
Referee: 4
Gunter: 3 Lost his winger and then let him get into the box and cross for the second goal. He does look like he’s trying but just can’t defend.
Lavelle: 6 Won his challenges and tries but can’t shoot like most of his fellow players.
Famewo: 5.5 Works hard & tries but distribution is poor but then there weren’t many options for him.
Souaré: 2 Second game running he has been total crap. Can’t control the ball, pass to a red shirt or make a tackle. Extra point for standing up to Pell.
Clare: 3 Majority of time the game passes him by
Gilbey: 7.5 Showed pride and gave his all
Morgan: 4.5 Worked his socks off, made challenges and some decent corners but bad free kicks. Looked devastated at the end.
Leko: 6.5 Inconsistent but still our greatest danger up front. Poor shooting.
Stockley: 5 Slow and limited but tried & took his goal well
B-T: 3 Not playing to his strengths but needs to be more involved.
Referee: 2 Fell for the AS tactics all night. Why did he let Pell walk the full width of the pitch after treatment when he was on the AC stand touch line. Gave AS a free kick every time one of them fell over.
Gunter: 5
Lavelle: 6
Famewo: 5
Souaré: 4.5
Clare: 5
Gilbey: 7.5
Morgan: 5.5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5
Referee: 5