MacG: 6 missed a corner but not much chance with worldie Egbo: 6 -1 for poor miss Lavelle: 5.5 -1 for mess up for 3rd goal O'Connell: 5 decent 1st half but at fault later. Clare: 5 Sean is not a LB. Dobson: 6 why did he come off ? Morgan: 4 terrible 2nd half Fraser: 5 faded. Raki S. 6.5 has talent Stockley: 5 started well with good passing but misses Conor big time. Can only play in a two up front. 20 goal striker to ? B-T: 5 can go past players with ease but no composure. Leaburn: 4.5 didn't get a kick Kirk: 6 put in some crosses from deep McGrandles: 6 play ok from bench Payne: 7 +1 for goal Sessegnon: 6 first game back and chaos around him. Referee: 7 i assume the lino was correct on Cafc being offside a dozen times ?
MacG: 6 - Didn’t have anything to do, maybe question going with wrong hand for the first? Egbo: 6.5 - came forward well but needs to learn to shoot from 12 yards Lavelle: 4 - better than O’Connell but not saying much. Not sure why he got lower score by some on here when two of the goals were down to his partner O'Connell: 3 - shocking defending, getting bounced off the ball for the third summed up our day Clare:4 - poorest I have seen him for long time Dobson: 5 - same as above Morgan: 3 - don’t know what he offers us Fraser: 4 - passenger today, didn’t want to know R-S: 6 - had moments but made wrong decisions in vital moments Stockley: 4 - didn’t have impact CBT: 5 - decision making crap yet again, learn to look across the line Leaburn: 5 - nothing from Him Kirk: 5 - needs to get out the way of people running past him McGrandles:4 - poor again Payne: 6 - got the goal and buzzed about Sessegnon: 6- had pace but wanted to keep coming inside
MacG: 4 poor positioning should have done better with two of the goals. Egbo: 7 good player there. Bet we don't keep him Lavelle: 3 along with O Connel the worst keystone cop centre back pairing I've seen O'Connell: 3 see above Clare: 3 Not a full back, no excuse now to play him there, slow to track back and often out of position. Dobson: 4 worst game for us. Let him play his own game Garner. Morgan:4 Has his moments but often trots around not even watching play Fraser: 5 ok but not great, the rest drag him down R-S: 6 a bright spark but too much responsibility for a young bloke Stockley: 3 reminds of the showboating arms out like wings players at junior level football, very little talent and I'm begining to despise his whinging and arm flapping.... mate you're a donkey. B-T: 4 flatters to deceive, luxury player that can't shoot... Leaburn: 5 didn't get into the game Kirk: 6 not a fan but his crossing is streets ahead of the rest McGrandles:5 huffed and puffed but no quality Payne: 7 tried hard to get things moving Sessegnon: 6 probably the best player at the club, so stay fit and no more Clare at fb. Referee: 6
MacG: 6 - don't think he could have done much about any of the goals. A relatively quiet afternoon against a Barnsley side who barely had to get out of second gear. He badly misjudged a corner in the first half, which O'Connell headed off the line Egbo: 6.5 - looked good, particularly going forward, although blotted his copybook by blazing our best chance of the game over towards the end of the first half Lavelle: 4.5 - very poor defending in the second half O'Connell: 4 - ok in the first half but diabolical defending in the second Clare: 5 - out of position but he has lost form in recent weeks Dobson: 5 - poor Morgan: 4.5 - a few good long passes in the first half but disappeared in the second Fraser: 5 - unable to impose himself on the game R-S: 7 - a real threat. I fear that Palace will find him a new home in January, particularly if the atmosphere at the club turns increasingly toxic over the next few months Stockley: 4 - a few decent passes early on but he was dominated by the Barnsley defenders, who were everything that ours weren't - competent, well-drilled (as you'd expect with Michael Duff) and quietly impressive. At present, Stockley is hardly winning anything in the air (previously his strongest suit) and he doesn't even remotely look like nicking a goal B-T: 5.5 - his pace is unplayable but he consistently flatters to deceive. The final ball is generally poor and his shooting and level of composure are fourth rate Leaburn: 5 - unable to get into the game and barely touched the ball, although it wasn't his fault. The game was over when he came at 2-0, the substitutions made the team more disjointed and most of the players' heads had gone down Kirk: 6 - he has composure and good crossing ability, but his lack of pace and unwillingness to go for the line make him very predictable McGrandles: 5 - looks nothing like the player we thought we were getting. Hopefully he'll find some form after an injury disrupted start Payne: 6.5 - looked lively and tried to make things happen Sessegnon: 6 - a decent cameo and it was good to get some minutes into him. We desperately need him back in the starting 11 Referee: 6.5 - a little bit whistle happy but pretty good. An easy game to referee, not least because Charlton barely troubled themselves to put a tackle in during the second half.
MacG: - 6 - Didn’t really do too much wrong Egbo: - 6.5 Was comfortable but didn’t get forward too much Lavelle: - 5 - Slow, Wooden, laboured O'Connell: 4 - Slow Wooden, laboured and mechanical Clare: - 6.5 - Was always available for a pass and pushed on. Dobson: 5.5 - Was outfought in midfield. Didn’t impress Morgan: - 5.5 - Flatters to deceive. Looks half decent in space but no end product and was bullied. Fraser: - 5.5 - see Morgan R-S: - 7 - One of the few highlights. Great talent caused problems but decision making needs to improve. As does shooting. Stockley: 5 - Fish out of water. B-T: - 7 - See R-S Leaburn: - 6 - Boys v men stuff today. Ineffective. Should have been sent off. Kirk: - 5 - Little impact. Lightweight McGrandles: 6 - No real impact but tried to push us forward. Payne: 6.5 - Busy and wants the ball but easily outmuscled yesterday. Needs to start. Sessegnon: 7 - Made a difference straight away. Referee - 6.5 - Little bit of a homey but got most stuff right except when Miles punched one of theirs.
MacG: 5 not really at fault for the goals but average dragged down by the rest of them Egbo: 6.5 can't shoot but looked OK otherwise Lavelle: 4 O'Connell: 4 Clare: 5 Dobson: 5 Morgan: 3 he tries but he's not very good Fraser: 5 R-S: 6.5 scared them and can make something happen. Some lovely touches. Shame about the finishing Stockley: 3 not a leader on the pitch B-T: 5 should pass more often Leaburn: 4.5 not really in the game Kirk: 5.5 some nice crosses McGrandles: 5.5 some good play though he's already scapegoat Payne: 7 why isn't he starting? Sessegnon: 6.5 Referee: 7 didn't notice him, which is always a good sign
Comments
Egbo: 7
Lavelle: 4
O'Connell: 5
Clare: 5.5
Dobson: 5
Morgan: 4
Fraser: 7
R-S: 6
Stockley: 5.5
B-T: 6
Leaburn: 5.5
Kirk: 5.5
McGrandles: 5
Payne: 6.5
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
Egbo: 5
Lavelle: 3 Drop
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5
Dobson: 6
Morgan: 3 Drop
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6
Stockley: 4 Drop
B-T: 4 Rest
Leaburn: 4 Play
Kirk: 5 Play
McGrandles: 5
Payne: 6 Play
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
Egbo: 7
Lavelle: 6
O'Connell: 5
Clare: 6
Dobson: 6
Morgan: 6
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5.5
Leaburn: 6
Kirk: 6
McGrandles: 6
Payne: 7
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
MacG: 6
Egbo: 6.5
Lavelle: 5
O'Connell: 5
Clare: 5
Dobson: 5
Morgan: 4
Fraser: 4.5
R-S: 6
Stockley: 5
B-T: 5
Leaburn: 5
Kirk: 5
McGrandles: 4.5
Payne: 6
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 7
Egbo: 7
Lavelle: 5
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 4
Dobson: 6
Morgan: 5
Fraser: 6
R-S: 5
Stockley: 4
B-T: 5
Leaburn: 5
Kirk: 4
McGrandles:5
Payne: 6
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
Egbo: 6 -1 for poor miss
Lavelle: 5.5 -1 for mess up for 3rd goal
O'Connell: 5 decent 1st half but at fault later.
Clare: 5 Sean is not a LB.
Dobson: 6 why did he come off ?
Morgan: 4 terrible 2nd half
Fraser: 5 faded.
Raki S. 6.5 has talent
Stockley: 5 started well with good passing but misses Conor big time. Can only play in a two up front. 20 goal striker to ?
B-T: 5 can go past players with ease but no composure.
Leaburn: 4.5 didn't get a kick
Kirk: 6 put in some crosses from deep
McGrandles: 6 play ok from bench
Payne: 7 +1 for goal
Sessegnon: 6 first game back and chaos around him.
Referee: 7 i assume the lino was correct on Cafc being offside a dozen times ?
Egbo: 6.5 - came forward well but needs to learn to shoot from 12 yards
Lavelle: 4 - better than O’Connell but not saying much. Not sure why he got lower score by some on here when two of the goals were down to his partner
O'Connell: 3 - shocking defending, getting bounced off the ball for the third summed up our day
Clare:4 - poorest I have seen him for long time
Dobson: 5 - same as above
Morgan: 3 - don’t know what he offers us
Fraser: 4 - passenger today, didn’t want to know
R-S: 6 - had moments but made wrong decisions in vital moments
Stockley: 4 - didn’t have impact
CBT: 5 - decision making crap yet again, learn to look across the line
Leaburn: 5 - nothing from Him
Kirk: 5 - needs to get out the way of people running past him
McGrandles:4 - poor again
Payne: 6 - got the goal and buzzed about
Sessegnon: 6- had pace but wanted to keep coming inside
Egbo: 6
Lavelle: 3
O'Connell: 3
Clare: 4
Dobson: 4
Morgan: 2
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6
Stockley: 3
B-T: 5
Leaburn: 5
Kirk: 6
McGrandles:6
Payne: 6.5
Sessegnon: 5
Referee: 6
Egbo: 6
Lavelle: 5
O'Connell: 5
Clare: 6
Dobson: 6.5
Morgan: 5
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6
Stockley: 6
B-T: 6
Leaburn: 5.5
Kirk: 6
McGrandles: 5.5
Payne: 6.5
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 7
Egbo: 7 good player there. Bet we don't keep him
Lavelle: 3 along with O Connel the worst keystone cop centre back pairing I've seen
O'Connell: 3 see above
Clare: 3 Not a full back, no excuse now to play him there, slow to track back and often out of position.
Dobson: 4 worst game for us. Let him play his own game Garner.
Morgan:4 Has his moments but often trots around not even watching play
Fraser: 5 ok but not great, the rest drag him down
R-S: 6 a bright spark but too much responsibility for a young bloke
Stockley: 3 reminds of the showboating arms out like wings players at junior level football, very little talent and I'm begining to despise his whinging and arm flapping.... mate you're a donkey.
B-T: 4 flatters to deceive, luxury player that can't shoot...
Leaburn: 5 didn't get into the game
Kirk: 6 not a fan but his crossing is streets ahead of the rest
McGrandles:5 huffed and puffed but no quality
Payne: 7 tried hard to get things moving
Sessegnon: 6 probably the best player at the club, so stay fit and no more Clare at fb.
Referee: 6
and Morgan a 1.... they were both poor.
Egbo: 6
Lavelle: 5.5
O'Connell: 5.5
Clare: 6
Dobson: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6.5
Stockley: 6
B-T: 5.5
Leaburn: 6
Kirk: 5.5
McGrandles: 4.5
Payne: 6.5
Sessegnon: 5
Referee: 6
Egbo: 6.5
Lavelle: 3
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5.5 (extra point for having to play out of position - again)
Dobson: 4
Morgan: 1
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6
Stockley: 3
B-T: 5.5
Leaburn: 5
Kirk: 6
McGrandles:6
Payne: 6.5
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 5.5
Egbo: 6
Lavelle:3
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 4
Dobson: 6
Morgan: 2
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6
Stockley: 3
B-T: 5
Leaburn: 4
Kirk: 4
McGrandles:5
Payne: 6
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
Egbo: 6
Lavelle: 4
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5
Dobson: 6
Morgan: 6
Fraser: 5.5
R-S: 7.5
Stockley: 6
B-T: 6.5
Leaburn: 6
Kirk: 6.5
McGrandles: 6
Payne: 7
Sessegnon: 6.5
Referee: 7
Egbo: 7
Lavelle: 4
O'Connell: 5
Clare: 5
Dobson: 5.5
Morgan: 4
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6.5
Stockley: 4
B-T: 6
Leaburn: 4.5
Kirk: 5
McGrandles:6
Payne: 6
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6.5
Egbo: 6.5 - looked good, particularly going forward, although blotted his copybook by blazing our best chance of the game over towards the end of the first half
Lavelle: 4.5 - very poor defending in the second half
O'Connell: 4 - ok in the first half but diabolical defending in the second
Clare: 5 - out of position but he has lost form in recent weeks
Dobson: 5 - poor
Morgan: 4.5 - a few good long passes in the first half but disappeared in the second
Fraser: 5 - unable to impose himself on the game
R-S: 7 - a real threat. I fear that Palace will find him a new home in January, particularly if the atmosphere at the club turns increasingly toxic over the next few months
Stockley: 4 - a few decent passes early on but he was dominated by the Barnsley defenders, who were everything that ours weren't - competent, well-drilled (as you'd expect with Michael Duff) and quietly impressive. At present, Stockley is hardly winning anything in the air (previously his strongest suit) and he doesn't even remotely look like nicking a goal
B-T: 5.5 - his pace is unplayable but he consistently flatters to deceive. The final ball is generally poor and his shooting and level of composure are fourth rate
Leaburn: 5 - unable to get into the game and barely touched the ball, although it wasn't his fault. The game was over when he came at 2-0, the substitutions made the team more disjointed and most of the players' heads had gone down
Kirk: 6 - he has composure and good crossing ability, but his lack of pace and unwillingness to go for the line make him very predictable
McGrandles: 5 - looks nothing like the player we thought we were getting. Hopefully he'll find some form after an injury disrupted start
Payne: 6.5 - looked lively and tried to make things happen
Sessegnon: 6 - a decent cameo and it was good to get some minutes into him. We desperately need him back in the starting 11
Referee: 6.5 - a little bit whistle happy but pretty good. An easy game to referee, not least because Charlton barely troubled themselves to put a tackle in during the second half.
Egbo: - 6.5 Was comfortable but didn’t get forward too much
Lavelle: - 5 - Slow, Wooden, laboured
O'Connell: 4 - Slow Wooden, laboured and mechanical
Clare: - 6.5 - Was always available for a pass and pushed on.
Dobson: 5.5 - Was outfought in midfield. Didn’t impress
Morgan: - 5.5 - Flatters to deceive. Looks half decent in space but no end product and was bullied.
Fraser: - 5.5 - see Morgan
R-S: - 7 - One of the few highlights. Great talent caused problems but decision making needs to improve. As does shooting.
Stockley: 5 - Fish out of water.
B-T: - 7 - See R-S
Leaburn: - 6 - Boys v men stuff today. Ineffective. Should have been sent off.
Kirk: - 5 - Little impact. Lightweight
McGrandles: 6 - No real impact but tried to push us forward.
Payne: 6.5 - Busy and wants the ball but easily outmuscled yesterday. Needs to start.
Sessegnon: 7 - Made a difference straight away.
Referee - 6.5 - Little bit of a homey but got most stuff right except when Miles punched one of theirs.
Egbo: 6.5 can't shoot but looked OK otherwise
Lavelle: 4
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5
Dobson: 5
Morgan: 3 he tries but he's not very good
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6.5 scared them and can make something happen. Some lovely touches. Shame about the finishing
Stockley: 3 not a leader on the pitch
B-T: 5 should pass more often
Leaburn: 4.5 not really in the game
Kirk: 5.5 some nice crosses
McGrandles: 5.5 some good play though he's already scapegoat
Payne: 7 why isn't he starting?
Sessegnon: 6.5
Referee: 7 didn't notice him, which is always a good sign
Egbo: 6.5
Lavelle: 4
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5.5
Dobson: 5
Morgan: 2
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6.5
Stockley: 2
B-T: 3
Leaburn: 4
Kirk: 6
McGrandles: 5.5
Payne: 7
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 6
everything about us yesterday was poor
Egbo: 7
Lavelle: 5
O'Connell: 4
Clare: 5
Dobson: 5
Morgan: 6
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Stockley: 4
B-T: 5
Leaburn: 6
Kirk: 5
McGrandles: 5
Payne: 6
Sessegnon: 6
Referee: 5