MacGillivray: 8 Some good saves Chin: 5 Bit lightweight Lavelle: 5 Still doesn't inspire confidence Inniss: 7 Great assist for the first. Won headers Sessegnon: 6.5 Pretty decent R-S: 6.5 took his goal really well Dobson: 5 Didn't get involved today Fraser: 5.5 Allowed their third Campbell: 6 Stockley: 5 Kirk: 7 Two good finishes, but quiet otherwise Aneke: 7 Great assist for the equaliser B-T: 7 Beat his man almost every time F-C: 6 Payne: 6 Referee: 7
MacGillivray: 7 not easy coming in last min Chin: 6 Lavelle: 7 Inniss: 6 not seen him bullied like that before Sessegnon: 7 R-S: 5 good goal but then really should pass to CBT who had a tap in Dobson: 5 worst performance in a Charlton shirt Fraser: 6 Campbell: 5 Stockley: 6 Kirk: 8 MOM two great goals Aneke: 6 B-T: 6 F-C: 6 Payne:6 Referee: 6
MacGillivray: 6 - Did well as a late replacement Chin: 5 - Showing his inexperience Lavelle: 4 - Showing his lack of ability Inniss: 6 - Decent game, got a nice assist Sessegnon: 6 - Solid Rak-Sakyi: 6 - Lovely finish, but needs to look up still Dobson: 6 - Solid as always Fraser: 5 - Very sloppy today, very sloppy Campbell: 6 - Improving Stockley: 5 - linked up play well, not a scoring threat though Kirk: 6 - Invisible apart from two lovely goals
Aneke: 6 - A nuisance for Burton as expected, lovely assist Blackett-Taylor: 6 - A constant threat, as expected, needs to work with JRS Forster-Caskey: 6 - Nice to have the calm experience of him back Payne: 5 - Didnt really notice him
Mac 7 - some good saves and couldn't do much for goals Chin 5 - beaten too often but left very isolated. Let too many crosses in Lavelle 4 - the centre point of weakness at the back. Barely won a header Inniss 6 inc. + 0.5 for assist. Credit for that assist, and the best defender, but that’s faint praise Sessegnon 5.5 - not strong enough on occasion, added nothing going forward JRS 6 Inc +1 for goal. Took his goal so well, but inexcusable lack of pass to CBT. Needs to learn how to cross. Dobson 5 worst I've seen him in ages 2nd half. Much stronger in the first, so maybe ran out of steam Fraser 6 lost some of his tracking back, but slick passing as always Campbell 5 frustrated me such, good positioning, nice running, dire final ball Stockley 6 Inc +.5 for assist. Beaten in the air too often. Most of these points are for 15 minutes in the first half. Kirk 8 MoM look, he's never going to be the strongest, but didn't waste possession, some very clever passes, and scored 2 fantastic goals. Aneke 7 immediate impact with ball of the season CBT 7 looked a real threat JFC 6.5 provided much needed energy across the pitch Payne 6 didn't make much impact
MacGillivray: 7 doesn't command his box, but a number of decent saves Chin: 5 decent running and control but weak against some powerful attackers Lavelle: 3 absolutely hopeless Inniss: 7.5 lumbered with a partner who hid he had a lot to do, so it was nice to see him adding being Beckenbauer to that list Sessegnon: 7 dominated his winger, attacked okay R-S: 7 lovely goal, so close to another Dobson: 4 not only is he merely human, but this was a frankly awful display Fraser: 6.5 not sure what he was doing for their 3rd, good and tidy otherwise Campbell: 6.5 a threat, final ball a letdown Stockley: 6 did some hold up play and got an assist technically. 6 represents the pinnacle of what he can be marked atm Kirk: 7.5 two very lovely goals, absolute class first half. Then, as he is apt to do, vanished completely Aneke: 7.5 what a beast, what a pass B-T: 7 absolute menace, final ball though! F-C: 7.5 looked v tidy Payne: 6.5 couldn't get into it much Referee: 5 a lot of guesswork, including for the fk for their 1st goal
MacGillivray: 5.5 let three goals in but made some decent stops Chin: 4.5 plenty of effort but a lot of loose passes and poor crosses Lavelle: 4 disaster waiting to happen Inniss: 5 ditto and too many hospital balls extra half point for assist Sessegnon: 6.5 best of a shower at the back R-S: 6 extra point for the goal did very little for 75 minutes Dobson: 4.5 overrun today and shouldn’t have been marking Oshilaja for their 1st Fraser: 4 never broke sweat today poor Campbell: 4 little end product defensively naive Stockley: 4.5 extra half point for assist but the poor form continues Kirk: 7 two extra points for the goals Aneke: 6.5 extra half point for assist B-T: 6 had the full back on toast F-C: 6.5 added composure to the proceedings Payne: 6 tidy little cameo Referee: 6
MacGillivray: 7 did well considering thrust in last minute Chin: 5 started well but seemed to lose confidence as the game progressed Lavelle: 2 so slow and cumbersome. Scares the hell out of me Inniss: 5.5 one of his lackadaisical games Sessegnon: 7.5 only defender who stuck to the task for 90 mins. Some good challenges R-S: 5.5 drifted out the game too often Dobson: 4 bring back the real dobbo. Who was that imposter?? Fraser: 4 wake up son!!! You’re so much better than that Campbell: 5 tried but not much end product Stockley: 4 absolutely no threat up front. Also doesn’t win much in the air anymore Kirk: 6 an inflated score thanks to his two goals. Some shocking shirking of challenges Aneke: 6.5 not as domineering as usual but great assist. Oshilaja was as strong as an ox B-T: 7 very good. Can he not do at least a full 45 mins F-C: 5 calm and moved the ball ok Payne:5 didn’t really notice him but I’d looked to see him playing off Stockley upfront
MacGillivray: 7 - a good save in each half and did well overall Chin: 5 - a good young prospect but struggled at times in a shaky rearguard Lavelle: 4.5 - weak Inniss: 5.5 - a very good assist and some decent headed clearances but he continues to worry me Sessegnon: 7 - the pick of a poor back four R-S: 6 - a tepid game but a classy and composed finish for the equaliser. Threatened a winner on a couple of occasions late on Dobson: 5 - off his game Fraser: 5 - ditto. Lacked energy and, for all his quality on the ball, sometimes wants one touch too many Campbell: 6 - I like his direct style Stockley: 5 - a familiar story Kirk: 6.5 - two very good goals and a couple of other good moments but not involved for much of the game Aneke: 6.5 - really good work to set up the equaliser. We can’t realistically expect him to bale us out every week B-T: 7 - beat his full back every time F-C: 6 - quietly efficient Payne: 6 - ok Referee: 6 - gave a few soft free kicks but generally fine. A pretty clean game
MacGillivray: 5 needs to practice catching the ball Chin: 4 looked way out of his comfort zone Lavelle: 3 heard that Coalville need a cb Inniss: 4 seeing how poor he is without O Connell Sessegnon: 6.5 kept going despite the crap alongside him R-S: 6 was pretty anonymous until Kirk went off... lesson for Garner, play to the players strengths Dobson: 4.5 he was poor today Fraser: 4.5 drifting around and not getting involved enough... look at the third Campbell: 5 did ok for a kid, but not really ready Stockley: 4.5 nice lay off, maybe he can do a job at cb... couldn't score in a brothel currently Kirk: 6.5 took his goals well but got lost in the second half Aneke: 6.5 that lay off for our third, sublime B-T: 5 took a while to get going but that's down to our powderpuff midfield. F-C: 6 looked better than Fraser, and more up for the fight.
Payne 5 not the cup campaigner we've seen Referee 6
MacGillivray: 7 Made a number of excellent saves that kept us in the game Chin: 5 Promising youngster but not ready for the first team Lavelle: 4 Poor. It looked like they could score at any time with him in defence Inniss: 5 Same as Lavelle. Works much better with O'Connell next to him. Extra mark for the assist for our first Sessegnon: 6 Best of the back four by far. R-S: 6 Some good some average. Was better second half when Chucks and CBT came on. Well taken goal. Dobson: 4 Very poor. Passing was mostly bad and didn't support the back four enough Fraser: 4 Also very poor. When these two have a bad game we lose the midfield. Lost the ball that led to their third (I think!) Campbell: 5 Again, another promising talent but thrown into the first team too soon. Stockley: 4 What can I say! TBF had zero support from those around him. Kirk: 6 Gets extra marks for the well taken goals. Not involved enough in second half. Needed to work with Stockley more instead of getting in Cambells way. Aneke: 7 Great pass for the goal. He scares defenders. I wish he could play for 90 minutes! B-T: 6 Had the defender on toast every time. Fluffed his lines on one occasion when all the hard work was done. It is not often you see a shot end up behind the player! F-C: 6 Didn't really notice him but was part of the resurgence when the subs were made so must have been okay. Payne: 6 Beavered a lot and tried hard. Another one who messed up with the goal at his mercy Referee: 8 A bit biased toward them but otherwise a good performance. Extra point for missing the clear handball in the first half
Comments
Chin: 4
Lavelle: 4
Inniss: 4
Sessegnon: 7
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Referee: 6
Chin: 5 Bit lightweight
Lavelle: 5 Still doesn't inspire confidence
Inniss: 7 Great assist for the first. Won headers
Sessegnon: 6.5 Pretty decent
R-S: 6.5 took his goal really well
Dobson: 5 Didn't get involved today
Fraser: 5.5 Allowed their third
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 7 Two good finishes, but quiet otherwise
Aneke: 7 Great assist for the equaliser
B-T: 7 Beat his man almost every time
F-C: 6
Payne: 6
Referee: 7
Chin: 6
Lavelle: 7
Inniss: 6 not seen him
bullied like that before
Sessegnon: 7
R-S: 5 good goal but then really should pass to CBT who had a tap in
Dobson: 5 worst performance in a Charlton shirt
Fraser: 6
Campbell: 5
Stockley: 6
Kirk: 8 MOM two great goals
Aneke: 6
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Referee: 6
Chin: 5
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 6
Campbell: 5
Stockley: 4
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 7
B-T: 7.5
F-C: 6
Payne: 6
Chin: 5 - Showing his inexperience
Lavelle: 4 - Showing his lack of ability
Inniss: 6 - Decent game, got a nice assist
Sessegnon: 6 - Solid
Rak-Sakyi: 6 - Lovely finish, but needs to look up still
Dobson: 6 - Solid as always
Fraser: 5 - Very sloppy today, very sloppy
Campbell: 6 - Improving
Stockley: 5 - linked up play well, not a scoring threat though
Kirk: 6 - Invisible apart from two lovely goals
Aneke: 6 - A nuisance for Burton as expected, lovely assist
Blackett-Taylor: 6 - A constant threat, as expected, needs to work with JRS
Forster-Caskey: 6 - Nice to have the calm experience of him back
Payne: 5 - Didnt really notice him
Referee: 7 - Didnt have much to do to be fair
Chin: 5.5
Lavelle: 6
Inniss: 6.5
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 5.5
Dobson: 5.5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 5.5
Stockley: 6
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 7.5
B-T: 7.5
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Chin 5 - beaten too often but left very isolated. Let too many crosses in
Lavelle 4 - the centre point of weakness at the back. Barely won a header
Inniss 6 inc. + 0.5 for assist. Credit for that assist, and the best defender, but that’s faint praise
Sessegnon 5.5 - not strong enough on occasion, added nothing going forward
JRS 6 Inc +1 for goal. Took his goal so well, but inexcusable lack of pass to CBT. Needs to learn how to cross.
Dobson 5 worst I've seen him in ages 2nd half. Much stronger in the first, so maybe ran out of steam
Fraser 6 lost some of his tracking back, but slick passing as always
Campbell 5 frustrated me such, good positioning, nice running, dire final ball
Stockley 6 Inc +.5 for assist. Beaten in the air too often. Most of these points are for 15 minutes in the first half.
Kirk 8 MoM look, he's never going to be the strongest, but didn't waste possession, some very clever passes, and scored 2 fantastic goals.
Aneke 7 immediate impact with ball of the season
CBT 7 looked a real threat
JFC 6.5 provided much needed energy across the pitch
Payne 6 didn't make much impact
Ref 7
Chin: 4
Lavelle: 4
Inniss: 5.5
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 6.5
Dobson: 4.5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 6
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 7
B-T: 6.5
F-C: 6
Payne:5
Chin: 5 decent running and control but weak against some powerful attackers
Lavelle: 3 absolutely hopeless
Inniss: 7.5 lumbered with a partner who hid he had a lot to do, so it was nice to see him adding being Beckenbauer to that list
Sessegnon: 7 dominated his winger, attacked okay
R-S: 7 lovely goal, so close to another
Dobson: 4 not only is he merely human, but this was a frankly awful display
Fraser: 6.5 not sure what he was doing for their 3rd, good and tidy otherwise
Campbell: 6.5 a threat, final ball a letdown
Stockley: 6 did some hold up play and got an assist technically. 6 represents the pinnacle of what he can be marked atm
Kirk: 7.5 two very lovely goals, absolute class first half. Then, as he is apt to do, vanished completely
Aneke: 7.5 what a beast, what a pass
B-T: 7 absolute menace, final ball though!
F-C: 7.5 looked v tidy
Payne: 6.5 couldn't get into it much
Referee: 5 a lot of guesswork, including for the fk for their 1st goal
Morgan: n/a
Chin: 4.5 plenty of effort but a lot of loose passes and poor crosses
Lavelle: 4 disaster waiting to happen
Inniss: 5 ditto and too many hospital balls extra half point for assist
Sessegnon: 6.5 best of a shower at the back
R-S: 6 extra point for the goal did very little for 75 minutes
Dobson: 4.5 overrun today and shouldn’t have been marking Oshilaja for their 1st
Fraser: 4 never broke sweat today poor
Campbell: 4 little end product defensively naive
Stockley: 4.5 extra half point for assist but the poor form continues
Kirk: 7 two extra points for the goals
Aneke: 6.5 extra half point for assist
B-T: 6 had the full back on toast
F-C: 6.5 added composure to the proceedings
Payne: 6 tidy little cameo
Referee: 6
Chin: 6
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 5.5
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 7
F-C: 7
Payne: 6
Referee: 6
Chin: 5
Lavelle:4
Inniss: 4
Sessegnon:6.5
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5
Campbell:6
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 7
Aneke:6.5
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Chin: 5.5
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5.5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5.5
Kirk: 7.5
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 6.5
F-C: 6
Payne: 6
Referee 6
Chin: 4
Lavelle: 4
Inniss: 5
Sessegnon: 6
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5
Campbell: 5
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 8
Aneke: 7
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne: 6
Referee: 7
MacGillivray: 7
Chin: 5
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6.5
Sessegnon: 6.5
R-S: 7
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 6
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 6
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 7
B-T: 7
F-C: 7
Payne:6
Referee: 6
Chin: 5
Lavelle: 4
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6.5
R-S: 6
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5
Campbell: 5.5
Stockley: 6.5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne: 6
Referee: 5
Chin: 5 started well but seemed to lose confidence as the game progressed
Lavelle: 2 so slow and cumbersome. Scares the hell out of me
Inniss: 5.5 one of his lackadaisical games
Sessegnon: 7.5 only defender who stuck to the task for 90 mins. Some good challenges
R-S: 5.5 drifted out the game too often
Dobson: 4 bring back the real dobbo. Who was that imposter??
Fraser: 4 wake up son!!! You’re so much better than that
Campbell: 5 tried but not much end product
Stockley: 4 absolutely no threat up front. Also doesn’t win much in the air anymore
Kirk: 6 an inflated score thanks to his two goals. Some shocking shirking of challenges
Aneke: 6.5 not as domineering as usual but great assist. Oshilaja was as strong as an ox
B-T: 7 very good. Can he not do at least a full 45 mins
F-C: 5 calm and moved the ball ok
Payne:5 didn’t really notice him but I’d looked to see him playing off Stockley upfront
MacGillivray: 8
Chin: 6
Lavelle:6
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6.5
R-S: 7
Dobson: 6
Fraser: 6
Campbell: 5
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6
B-T: 6.5
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Referee: 6
Chin: 5
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6.5
R-S: 5.5
Dobson: 5.5
Fraser: 6
Campbell: 5.5
Stockley: 5
Kirk: 6.5
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne: 5.5
Referee: 6
Chin 6
Lavelle 6
Inniss 6.5
Sessegnon 6
Rs 6.5
Dobson 6
Fraser 6
Campbell 6
Stockley 6
Kirk7
Aneke 6
Bt 6
Fc 6
Payne 6
Ref 6
Chin: 5 - a good young prospect but struggled at times in a shaky rearguard
Lavelle: 4.5 - weak
Inniss: 5.5 - a very good assist and some decent headed clearances but he continues to worry me
Sessegnon: 7 - the pick of a poor back four
R-S: 6 - a tepid game but a classy and composed finish for the equaliser. Threatened a winner on a couple of occasions late on
Dobson: 5 - off his game
Fraser: 5 - ditto. Lacked energy and, for all his quality on the ball, sometimes wants one touch too many
Campbell: 6 - I like his direct style
Stockley: 5 - a familiar story
Kirk: 6.5 - two very good goals and a couple of other good moments but not involved for much of the game
Aneke: 6.5 - really good work to set up the equaliser. We can’t realistically expect him to bale us out every week
B-T: 7 - beat his full back every time
F-C: 6 - quietly efficient
Payne: 6 - ok
Referee: 6 - gave a few soft free kicks but generally fine. A pretty clean game
Chin: 4 looked way out of his comfort zone
Lavelle: 3 heard that Coalville need a cb
Inniss: 4 seeing how poor he is without O Connell
Sessegnon: 6.5 kept going despite the crap alongside him
R-S: 6 was pretty anonymous until Kirk went off... lesson for Garner, play to the players strengths
Dobson: 4.5 he was poor today
Fraser: 4.5 drifting around and not getting involved enough... look at the third
Campbell: 5 did ok for a kid, but not really ready
Stockley: 4.5 nice lay off, maybe he can do a job at cb... couldn't score in a brothel currently
Kirk: 6.5 took his goals well but got lost in the second half
Aneke: 6.5 that lay off for our third, sublime
B-T: 5 took a while to get going but that's down to our powderpuff midfield.
F-C: 6 looked better than Fraser, and more up for the fight.
Referee 6
Chin: 5.5
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6.5
Sessegnon: 7.5
R-S: 7
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 5
Stockley: 5.5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 6.5
F-C: 6
Payne: 5.5
Referee: 7
Chin: 6
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 5
Sessegnon: 7
R-S: 7
Dobson: 5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5.5
Kirk: 7
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 7
F-C: 6
Payne: 5
Referee: 7
Chin: 6
Lavelle: 5.5
Inniss: 5.5
Sessegnon: 7
R-S: 7
Dobson: 5.5
Fraser: 5.5
Campbell: 6.5
Stockley: 5.5
Kirk: 7.5
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 7
F-C: 6
Payne: 5
Referee: 6.5
Chin: 5 Promising youngster but not ready for the first team
Lavelle: 4 Poor. It looked like they could score at any time with him in defence
Inniss: 5 Same as Lavelle. Works much better with O'Connell next to him. Extra mark for the assist for our first
Sessegnon: 6 Best of the back four by far.
R-S: 6 Some good some average. Was better second half when Chucks and CBT came on. Well taken goal.
Dobson: 4 Very poor. Passing was mostly bad and didn't support the back four enough
Fraser: 4 Also very poor. When these two have a bad game we lose the midfield. Lost the ball that led to their third (I think!)
Campbell: 5 Again, another promising talent but thrown into the first team too soon.
Stockley: 4 What can I say! TBF had zero support from those around him.
Kirk: 6 Gets extra marks for the well taken goals. Not involved enough in second half. Needed to work with Stockley more instead of getting in Cambells way.
Aneke: 7 Great pass for the goal. He scares defenders. I wish he could play for 90 minutes!
B-T: 6 Had the defender on toast every time. Fluffed his lines on one occasion when all the hard work was done. It is not often you see a shot end up behind the player!
F-C: 6 Didn't really notice him but was part of the resurgence when the subs were made so must have been okay.
Payne: 6 Beavered a lot and tried hard. Another one who messed up with the goal at his mercy
Referee: 8 A bit biased toward them but otherwise a good performance. Extra point for missing the clear handball in the first half
Chin: 6
Lavelle: 5
Inniss: 6
Sessegnon: 6.5
R-S: 7
Dobson: 6
Fraser: 6.5
Campbell: 6
Stockley: 5.5
Kirk: 6.5
Aneke: 6.5
B-T: 6
F-C: 6
Payne:6
Referee: 5
MacGillivray: 8.0
Chin: 6.0
Lavelle: 5.0
Inniss: 5.0
Sessegnon: 7.0
R-S: 6.0
Dobson: 5.0
Fraser: 6.0
Campbell: 5.0
Stockley: 5.0
Kirk: 7.0
Aneke: 7.0
B-T: 6.0
F-C: 6.0
Payne: 6.0
Referee: 7.0
Morgan: n/a