Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: F.A. Cup R2: Charlton v Stockport (closes Sunday teatime)

your marks from those at the Valley today:

M-B: 
Clare: 
Inniss: 
Lavelle: 
Sessegnon: 
Dobson: 
Morgan: 
Fraser: 
R-S: 
Aneke: 
Kirk:
Chin: 
B-T: 

Referee: 

DJ: n/a
Campbell: n/a

Comments

  • M-B: 6 a good save but how on earth did he concede that final corner? 
    Clare: 6.5 a few decent blocks and stuff 
    Inniss: 7 seemed to be on top 
    Lavelle: 5.5 didn't 
    Sessegnon: 7.5 fine work for the goal 
    Dobson: 7.5 great assist 
    Morgan: 8 everywhere, great goal 
    Fraser: 6.5 a bit subdued but some lovely work 
    R-S: 6.5 his final shot/pass aside, good 
    Aneke: 6.5 dominant first half, faded 
    Kirk: 6.5 ditto 
    Chin: 4 patently unsuited to the position 
    B-T: 6.5 terrified em 

    Referee: 5 didn't understand the advantage rule 

    DJ: n/a looked effective 
    Campbell: n/a didn't have enough time 
  • M-B: 7 at fault for first goal but made some good saves  good saves 
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 6
    Lavelle: 6
    Sessegnon: 8 taking him
    off was when we lost the game 
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 6
    R-S: 4 ..we have a real problem he gone so far backwards it’s a concern 
    Aneke: 5 people call for him to start but he nowhere near the same player 


    Kirk: 6 
    Chin: 4 needs to be pulled out of first team squad 
    B-T: 6 good things bad things and poor final ball 

    Referee:  5
  • M-B:  6 should have done better with goals
    Clare: 7 played well got in some good blocks
    Inniss: 6 Did ok
    Lavelle: 5 improvement on usual but …
    Sessegnon: 7.5 did well until he got a knock
    Dobson:  7 good
    Morgan: 6.5 better unlucky not to score a second
    Fraser: 6 fits and starts gave ball the ball away a few times
    R-S: 6 in and out of the game
    Aneke: 5.5 can’t last the pace
    Kirk: 6 again in and out of the game
    Chin: 4 not impressed today
    B-T: 6.5 scared them should have made it 3-1

    Referee: 4 poor

    DJ: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 7.5
    Inniss: 6.5
    Lavelle: 6
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson: 6.5
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 6
    R-S: 6.5
    Aneke: 6.5
    Kirk: 6.5
    Chin: 4
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 4  


  • M-B:       6
    Clare:     6 
    Inniss:     7
    Lavelle:   5.5
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson:      6.5 
    Morgan:      6.5 
    Fraser         5.5 
    R-S:              6
    Aneke:          5.5 
    Kirk:              5.5 
    Chin:              5
    B-T:                 6

    Referee: 6

    DJ: n/a
    Campbell: n/a

  • M-B: 7
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Lavelle: 5
    Sessegnon: 6
    Dobson: 8
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 5
    R-S: 6
    Aneke: 6
    Kirk: 5
    Chin: 6
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 5
  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 7
    Inniss:6 
    Lavelle5: 
    Sessegnon7: 
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 6
    Fraser:6 
    R-S: 6
    Aneke: 7
    Kirk:5 
    Chin:6 
    B-T: 7
  • MB 6
    Clare 7
    Inniss 6
    Lavelle 6
    Sessegnon 6.5
    Dobson 7
    Morgan 7
    Fraser 6.5
    RS 6.5
    Aneke 6.5
    Kirk 6
    Chin 5.5
    BT 6

    Ref 5
  • MB 6.5
    Clare 7
    Inniss 6
    Lavelle 6
    Sessegnon 6
    Dobson 7
    Morgan 7
    Fraser 7
    RS 5
    Aneke 6
    Kirk 6
    Chin 6
    BT 6
  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 5
    Lavelle: 4
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 6
    Fraser: 6
    R-S: 6
    Aneke: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Chin: 4
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 4

    DJ: n/a
    Campbell: n/a 
  • Sponsored links:


  • M-B:       5
    Clare:     7
    Inniss:    6.5
    Lavelle:   5
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 6
    R-S: 7
    Aneke:4 
    Kirk:  4
    Chin: 5
    B-T:  6
  • M-B: 5
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 6
    Lavelle: 5.5
    Sessegnon: 6.5
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 6
    Fraser: 6
    R-S: 6
    Aneke: 5
    Kirk: 5.5
    Chin: 4.5
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 4.5

  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 6
    Inniss: 6
    Lavelle: 6
    Sessegnon: 6
    Dobson: 6
    Morgan: 6.5
    Fraser: 6.5
    R-S: 5.5
    Aneke: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Chin: 5.5
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 5.5
  • M-B: 6 couple good saves but poss at fault for at least one of the goals 
    Clare: 7 decent enough 
    Inniss: 7 won a lot and our best cb currently 
    Lavelle: 5.5 not worst display but so slow 
    Sessegnon: 7 motm v good attacking threat until got knock let’s pray he is ok as one of our few consistently decent performers atm 
    Dobson: 6 kept getting his foot in as best as he could 
    Morgan: 7 may be he gives the ball away a bit and isn’t brilliant but took goal well never hides and was very unlucky with long range effort 
    Fraser: 6 anonymous first half a lot better 2nd 
    R-S: 5.5 such a threat but then just seems far to quiet most of the time not getting the ball enough 
    Aneke: 6 strong first 35 mins then tired (only used to 20-25 I guess) said I doubt he be out for second half he last 20 mins of it but tbf looked done in the 46th min still better than stockley but can see why stockley struggles in this system too 
    Kirk: 6.5 some good passing and play when involved 
    Chin: 5 definite potential like the kid but just too lightweight for today been thrown in too early due to lack of options 
    B-T: 7 scared them massively and a real threat needs to start next game and give that for 60-70 mins

    Garner - far too much sideways backwards stuff subs too late May be unlucky (again) with injuries but very poor of late 

    Referee: 4 very poor, didn’t play advantage too much interrupting an already poor game  
  • edited November 2022
    M-B: 7
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 6
    Lavelle: 6
    Sessegnon: 6.5
    Dobson: 6.5
    Morgan: 6.5
    Fraser: 6.5
    R-S: 6.5
    Aneke: 5.5
    Kirk: 6
    Chin: 6
    B-T: 6

    Referee: 6

    Overall game- 7 quite alright.
  • M-B:  6 
    Clare:  5 
    Inniss:  5 
    Lavelle:  5 
    Sessegnon:  5 
    Dobson:  5 
    Morgan:  5 
    Fraser:  5.5 
    R-S:  5.5 
    Aneke:  4.5 
    Kirk:  5 
    Chin:  4 
    B-T:  6 

    Referee:  5.5 
  • M-B: 6 A couple of decent saves but not convinced by his positioning. He'll have to do for now but looks like he needs a lot more football.
    Clare: 6.5 Started badly but ended up one of the better players.
    Inniss: 6 Wasn't as strong in the air as usual. 
    Lavelle: 6 Doesn't look like he'll improve and has reached his level.
    Sessegnon: 7 I like his positioning. Every chance he'll be a Championship defender next season...or before...providing he stays fit!
    Dobson: 6.5 Not his best game but did tons of covering work.
    Morgan: 7 Mixed bag. In it a lot 1st half, always moving and scored a great goal. 2nd half was weird...nearly scored an exceptional goal and had another half chance late on but in general play couldn't get into it.
    Fraser: 6 Did some very good things but faded very badly fitness-wise late on.
    R-S: 6 Was quite bright but needed to be subbed 15 mins earlier.
    Aneke: 5.5 Starting him didn't work. He played within himself so he could last the 65 and that was counter-productive.
    Kirk: 5 Classic modern sideways and back wide-player. Technically sound but he's not for me. Awful challenge on their keeper.
    Chin: 4.5 Being right footed meant he couldn't clear his lines late on. Can obviously play a bit but physically he struggled.
    B-T: 8 The one player with pace and power. Different game when he is playing. 

    Referee: 5.5 Too fussy. 

    DJ: n/a Thought he looked strong and effective up front. Been out for a long while but will need to play in the replay.
    Campbell: n/a I like this one. Think he'll be a good 'un. 

  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 6
    Inniss: 5
    Lavelle: 5
    Sessegnon: 6
    Dobson: 7
    Morgan: 6.5
    Fraser: 5
    R-S: 5.5
    Aneke: 5
    Kirk: 5
    Chin: 6
    B-T: 5

    Referee: 4
  • M-B 6
    Clare: 6
    Inniss: 6.5
    Lavelle: 6
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 7
    R-S: 7
    Aneke: 6.5
    Kirk: 5.5
    Chin: 4
    B-T: 6.5

    Referee: 4
  • M-B: 7 - Did OK with little in front to protect him
    Clare: 5 - Mr Negative
    Inniss: 5.5 - Tried I suppose...
    Lavelle: 3 - He lost every single battle on the pitch and is awful!
    Sessegnon: 6.5 - Good going forwards
    Dobson:  5.5 - Not at his best 
    Morgan: 5 - Strolled through but took his goal well
    Fraser: 6 - Some good work
    R-S:  4 - Show pony who messed up his big chance
    Aneke: 5.5 - Tried hard
    Kirk: 5 - Mr Nearly man again...
    Chin: 3.5 - Sorry, but not good enough.
    B-T: 4.5 - Wasted his best chance and then couldn't be bothered

    Referee: 5 - Fussy 
  • Sponsored links:


  • M-B: 6 - looks comfortable but should perhaps have done better for the first goal
    Clare: 6 - good going forward in the first half
    Inniss: 6.5 - did reasonably well and only nearly got caught on the ball once in a dangerous position (an improvement on recent weeks)
    Lavelle: 4.5 - struggled badly and, at times, looked like he was running through treacle
    Sessegnon: 7 - offered an offensive threat prior to his injury (essential with Kirk in front of him)
    Dobson: 7.5 - held things together and we'd be in big trouble without his ability to see and snuff out danger 
    Morgan: 7 - made some good late runs into the box and scored a lovely goal from Dobbo's exquisite chipped through ball
    Fraser: 5.5 - some good moments but a bit uneven and tired badly towards the end
    R-S: 5 - an off-day
    Aneke: 6 - a good first half but predictably faded in the second before he was withdrawn
    Kirk: 5 - a couple of good passes but offers little offensively and nothing when the opposition is in possession. He is far too keen to pass responsibility onto other players. 
    Chin: 4 - a promising youngster but he needs to be taken out of the firing line
    B-T: 6.5 - electric pace and offered his usual threat

    Referee: 5 - annoying at times and failed to play the advantage on more than one occasion.
  • M-B: 6
    Clare: 5.5
    Inniss: 6
    Lavelle: 5
    Sessegnon: 7
    Dobson: 6.5
    Morgan: 7
    Fraser: 5.5
    R-S: 6
    Aneke: 5.5
    Kirk:6
    Chin: 4
    B-T: 5.5

    Referee: 4.5 poor, fussy, all about him but still only average in terms of quality this season 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!