Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Players Marks: EFL Cup R4: Charlton v B.H.A. ( closes Thursday teatime)

2»

Comments

  • Options
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8 
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9 
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8 
    Payne: 7.5
    Leaburn: 7.5
    R-S: 7.5
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 6 he doesn't fit the way we play. I'm probably giving him too high a mark but it seems unreasonable given we kept a clean sheet and won the shootout
    F-C: 7.5
    Referee: 7.5 
  • Options
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 7
    Ness: 7
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 5
    F-C: 6
    Referee: 9
  • Options
    M-B: 8.5
    Inniss:  8
    Lavelle: 8.5 (+0.5 for the penalty)
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8 a really tough second half against Japan WC star Mitoma, but an impressive performance
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 7 faded after one of those typically up and down performances
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6.5 fairly ineffective really, in what was a tough gig
    R-S: 6.5 
    B-T: 6.5
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 6.5
    Referee: 6


  • Options
    edited December 2022
    M-B: 9 Very pleased for the lad
    Inniss: 8 Keep simple and he’s good
    Lavelle: 8 plus 1 for the great penalty 
    Ness: 8 Very calm all night. One for the future. 
    Chin: 8 Brilliant night for him. 
    Dobson: 8.5 what can you say!
    Fraser: 7 Worked hard
    Sessegnon: 8 plus 1 for the great penalty 
    Payne: 7 Love his energy
    Leaburn: 7 Reall worked hard, and caused them problems. 
    R-S: 7 Tricky, but we’ll marked
    B-T: 7 plus 1 for the great penalty 
    Stockley: 6 Actually won some headers
    F-C: 7 plus 1 for the great penalty 
    Referee: 6 
  • Options
    M-B: 10 - What more do you want from a keeper? Clean sheet, excellent saves, commanded his box, went right way for all the pens and saved one. Faultless.
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8.5
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8.5 - Amazing performance given his age/experience and opposition  
    Dobson: 9 - Everywhere
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6.5
    R-S: 7 - Awful pen tho! 
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 7.5
    Referee: 8
  • Options


    M-B:        8.5
    Inniss:     8.5
    Lavelle:    8.5
    Ness:        7.5
    Chin:          7.5
    Dobson:     9
    Fraser:        8
    Sessegnon:7.5
    Payne:          7.5
    Leaburn:      7.5 
    R-S:               7
    B-T:                7
    Stockley:       7.5
    F-C:                6.5
    Referee:         6

    Aneke: n/a

  • Options
    M-B: 10 some superb saves, went the right way for every pen and distribution was really good, against Prem opposition. Faultless. 
    Inniss: 8.5 after losing the game for us at the weekend, to put in a performance like that today… brilliant. 
    Lavelle: 8.5 best game for a long time. Solid and composed. 
    Ness: 9 solid again. Pressed hard and nothing got through him. He’s only young but has to be knocking on the managers door after that. 
    Chin: 9 nervy start but dealt with Enciso in the first half to the point where he was off at HT. Handled Mitomo in the second half. He’s has a few shockers of late, but today he showed why he’s around the first team. 
    Dobson: 10 was everywhere. Threw himself in front of everything. Done us no favours in terms of keeping hold of him though. 
    Fraser: 7 looked knackered before half time. Kept plugging away though. 
    Sessegnon: 8.5 see Fraser. Also looked knackered but dealt with March and Lamptey. 
    Payne: 7.5 for those saying he runs around a lot don’t get football. Really helped out Sess, and cut out the supply to their midfielders well. 
    Leaburn: 7 had a job to do and done it well. Was never going to win much against Dunk. Put one on the keeper who milked it… anyone who rolls 6 times after a tackle is milking it. 
    R-S: 7.5 protected Chin well first half. Was dead on his feet second. 
    B-T: 6.5 was a bit underwhelmed. Fresh legs coming on and defensively didn’t help out much. 
    Stockley: 7.5 had a job to do and done it well. Won a lot in the air which got us up the pitch. Few defensive headers too. You can criticise Stockley this season, but not his performance today. 
    F-C: 8 worked really hard when coming on
    Referee: 8 done well. So glad he didn’t buy that shocker of a dive. Only wish he booked the player. 

    Aneke: n/a really feel for him. I hope for his sake it’s not bad. 
  • Options
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 9
    Lavelle: 9
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Options
    here we go

    M-B:    8
    Inniss:   8
    Lavelle:  8
    Ness:   7.5
    Chin:    7.5
    Dobson:   8.5
    Fraser:    8.5
    Sessegnon:  8
    Payne:  7.5
    Leaburn:  7
    R-S:   7
    B-T:   7.5
    Stockley:  7
    F-C:  7
    Referee: 

    Aneke: n/a

  • Options
    M-B: 9.5
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 7
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 6.5
    Sessegnon: 6.5
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 5
    F-C: 6
    Referee: 6

    Aneke: n/a 
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    edited December 2022
    M-B: 10 - I thought he was outstanding, commanded box, good saves, looks comfortable and confident. Best keeper in the club on that performance. Make him number 1 
    Inniss: 9 - huge performance following the disappointment on the Bristol game, takes a strong character to bounce back like that. But all he had to do was defend, and he is actually pretty good at that 
    Lavelle: 8.5 as above, apart from mistakes against Bristol.. And that pen at the end, nerves of still for someone confidence that has been so low. 
    Ness: 8.5 - didn't actually notice him that much, but that is a good think I suppose, no real mistakes and defended well.
    Chin: 8 - he has been getting a lot of stick, but he stood up strong today, against tricky and quick players 
    Dobson: 10 - outstanding tonight, lead the team, some huge blocks and breaking up the play, and reads the game so well! Well played sir
    Fraser: 8 - very good, bit wasteful with the ball, but worked very hard - that turn out of trouble was outrageous! 
    Sessegnon: 10 - outstanding best game in a Charlton shirt by a mile. Only player I thought in Charlton colours that wouldn't have looked out of place in a premier league team
    Payne: 9 - also thought was his best game in a Charlton shirt, battled very hard, worked back, and was our only threat going forward.
    Leaburn: 7 - needs minutes to get up to speed again, 1 minute he looks class, the next clumsy and like he has never played football before.
    R-S: 8 - worked hard, wrong decision making from time to time. But they was doubling up on him
    B-T: 6 - no real impact, wrong decision when he broke in to the box
    Stockley: 7.5 - put himself about, made it hard work for the defenders at the end. But for whatever reason, he just looks like he is running on water now. Maybe this back injure has had a big effect on him
    JFC 6 - struggle when he come on, looked very slow. but was giving his all considering the way he has been treated
  • Options
    M-B: 8
    Inniss:  8.5
    Lavelle:  8
    Ness:  8
    Chin:  8
    Dobson:  9
    Fraser:  8
    Sessegnon:  8
    Payne:  8
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 5
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 5
    F-C: 6
    Referee:  7
  • Options
    I'm not going to give marks, it was such a glorious result I don't want to sully their achievement with something so divisive.
  • Options
    M-B: 9.5
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8.5
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9.5
    Fraser: 8.5
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 7.5
    B-T: 7.5
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 7.5
    Referee: 8
  • Options
    M-B: 8
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Payne: 8
    Leaburn: 7
    R-S: 7
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 7
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 7
  • Options
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 7
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 7
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 7
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 7
  • Options
    M-B: 9 A very commanding performance with some really good saves, including the all important penalty save
    Inniss: 9 Shame he can't always be this composed as he's such a solid defender on his day
    Lavelle: 8.5 similar to Innis, great penalty under pressure
    Ness: 8.5 Looked solid, has come into this side nicely
    Chin: 8.5 thought he really stepped up to the challenge against a very tricky Mitoma
    Dobson: 10 you won't see a better performance from anyone all season
    Fraser: 7.5 tired early into the second half but put in a real shift alongside Dobson
    Sessegnon: 8 was solid at the back and effective on the counter
    Payne: 8 ran tirelessly the whole game and was all over the pitch
    Leaburn: 7.5 again not too much service as Brighton dominated but looked a threat when we could get the ball in behind
    R-S: 7 struggled to get on the ball much but tracked back and played his part
    B-T: 7.5 should have made more of the chance that came his way but tracked back well and took a great pen
    Stockley: 6.5struggled to get involved in the game
    F-C: 7 slotted into the midfield well when a fresh set of legs were needed
    Referee: 7 thought he did ok but Brighton should have had a penalty for a clumsy challenge from Lavelle

    Aneke: n/a
  • Options
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8.5
    Lavelle: 9
    Ness: 8.5
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 7
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7.5
    Leaburn: 5
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 6.5
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 5
  • Options
    M-B: 8
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8.5
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Payne: 8.5
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 7
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 7 
    F-C: 7
  • Options
    edited December 2022
    M-B: 9 - Caught and punched really well. Made several good saves and didn't muck about with the ball.
    Inniss: 8.5 - Extra half mark for showing a lot of nuts after Saturday. Took the battle to Brighton and refused to be beaten. 
    Lavelle: 8 - Much more aggresive and cleared his lines properly. 
    Ness: 7.5 - Actually didn't notice him too much but that probably says a lot for his positioning. Looks a strong player. 
    Chin: 8 - Held his position well and concentrated for the whole match. 
    Dobson: 8.5 - Took the battle to Brighton with a hefty early foul and produced the aggression needed for us to stay in the game.
    Fraser: 7.5 - Had some classy moments. If only he could get fitter, he'd be a terrific player at League One level. 
    Sessegnon: 8 - I keep saying it but looks ready for the next level up. Played with a lot of confidence.
    Payne: 7.5 - Offered a decent attacking threat and worked really hard to cover for Sess when he went forward. Thought we lost a bit when he went off. 
    Leaburn: 6.5 - Tried but was possibly lucky to only see yellow for his lunge on the keeper. Did a decent job trying to occupy their CBs but still very raw.
    R-S: 7 - Showed moments of true class when turning their players. Once he adds pace and power to his game, he's going to be a VERY good player. His attitude is spot-on. Shit penalty but showed balls taking it (as a Palace player in front of their fans). The boy was absolutely shattered!
    B-T: 6 - Lovely penalty but as on Saturday, we seemed to lose a bit when he came on, whereas previously we've gained a lot when he has come on. Slightly worrying. 
    Stockley: 6 - Dished out some stuff to the Brighton CBs which helped keep us in the fight. Good to have him on towards the end to help with the defending.
    F-C: 6 - Nice penalty. Disappointing free-kick and corner. 
    Referee: 8 - Allowed plenty of physical stuff which made the game better. Didn't fall for cheating matey (RS incident) which had me fooled. 

    Aneke: n/a - When a player just goes down without a challenge it's a bad sign. Very worrying for him and we will need a striker, maybe two in January. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    M-B: 9 - Strong saves in game and pen, commanded box when needed
    Inniss: 8 - Didn't get much wrong
    Lavelle: 6 - Always yards behind Ness and Inniss, pen was good, but just not good enough at his job
    Ness: 8.5 - Best of the three, should be in the first 11.
    Chin: 8 - Very accomplished performance
    Dobson: 10 - MOTM, he would have got 11, but I rounded him down for the pen miss
    Fraser: 7.5 - Struggled to have much impact, but worked hard
    Sessegnon: 8 - Another accomplished performance
    Payne: 5 - Woeful defensively, let players run off him all night and we should have been punished for it
    Leaburn: 7 - Worked hard 
    R-S: 8 - Worked really hard in both directions
    B-T: 7 - Not much impact, but good pen
    Stockley: 3 - Has to go, offered nothing in the match, No pressing, poor positional awareness in defensive situations, was a shadow of Leaburn. Get him sold.
    F-C: 6 - Didn't offer alot
    Referee: 7 - Was ok, but refused to book Brighton for 3 blatant dives.

    Aneke: n/a
  • Options
    At the game.

    M-B: 9 Well done Ash. Another fantastic performance. I feel confident with him in goal and I think the defence must do too. Some great saves, good handling and good distribution (mostly). Oh, and the small matter of a penalty save too.
    Inniss: 8 What a difference from Saturday! Well done Ryan.
    Lavelle: 8 Very decent. Great winning penalty kick.
    Ness: 8 For a young man he shows great maturity. Could be something special.
    Chin: 8 Had a very tough job marking some top players, but did amazingly well.
    Dobson: 9 Another storming captain's performance. I don't know where he gets his energy. Shame he can't bottle it and spread it around the team a bit more!
    Fraser: 6 I thought he tried hard, but that it didn't really come off for him. Seemed a bit light-weight. Ran out of steam as usual.
    Sessegnon: 8 Good solid game. Looks class.
    Payne: 8 Tons of energy. Really worked hard and our best threat going forward.
    Leaburn: 6 Tough job asked of him and didn't really do much.
    R-S: 7 Decent, but lacking end product again.
    B-T: 6 Did okay, but no real threat.
    Stockley: 7 I thought he did well. Based on the long ball style we played, I think he should have started ahead of Leaburn. We might have won a few more headers if he had been playing first half.
    F-C: 6 Did okay. Nothing great, nothing bad.
    Referee: 6

    Aneke: n/a Oh dear. Hope it's not too bad.
  • Options
    M-B: 9 MOM 
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 7
    Chin: 7
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 7 hope his injury not to bad 
    Sessegnon: 7
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 5
    Referee:  7
  • Options
    It would be very easy to give them all ten, but I won't...

    M-B: 9.5 (MoM) - Fabulous; has to be our Number 1 from now on.
    Inniss: 7.5 - Solid as a rock (which he can be when he doesn't get asked to play tippy-tappy at the back!)
    Lavelle: 8 - Ditto
    Ness: 8 - He was very cool and calm throughout and stuck to his task
    Chin: 6 - Got turned and beaten a lot but never gave up
    Dobson: 8.5 - Excellent game and made so many tackles
    Fraser: 7 - Very little space in midfield but tried to create when he could
    Sessegnon: 8 - Did very well until he ran out of steam
    Payne: 6.5 - Some good flashes
    Leaburn: 6 - Worked hard, unlucky to be booked as he had to go for that loose ball
    R-S: 5.5 - Show-pony showed he's not ready for EPL yet (if ever!)
    B-T: 6 - After an early bollocking, stuck to his task well
    Stockley: 5.5 - Got nothing from the ref
    F-C:  5 - A corner and free-kick was about all we got
    Referee: 5 - Did neither side any favours
  • Options
    M-B: 9.5 what a performance
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8.5
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 7.5
    Dobson: 9 what a performance (shame about the pen!)
    Fraser: 6
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Payne: 7.5
    Leaburn: 7.5
    R-S: 7.5
    B-T: 7.5
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 4
  • Options
    M-B: 8
    Inniss: 8 
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9 
    Fraser: 7.5
    Sessegnon: 8 
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6 
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 6 
    F-C: 7
  • Options
    M-B: 8.5
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 7
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 7
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 6.5
    F-C: 7
    Referee: 7

    Aneke: n/a 

    What an effort 👍
  • Options
    M-B: 8.5
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 7.5
    Sessegnon: 7.5 
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6.5
    R-S: 6
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 6 
    F-C: 6.5
  • Options
    edited December 2022
    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 8
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Payne: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    R-S: 7
    B-T: 7
    Stockley: 6
    F-C: 6.5
    Referee: 6

  • Options
    here we go

    M-B: 9
    Inniss: 8
    Lavelle: 7.5
    Ness: 8
    Chin: 8
    Dobson: 9
    Fraser: 7
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Payne: 6.5
    Leaburn: 6.5
    R-S: 6.5
    B-T: 6
    Stockley: 2.5
    F-C: 5
    Referee: 6

    Aneke: n/a

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!