M-B: 6 - Possibly at fault for first goal, and almost caught out at near post in second half too Clare: 5.5 - He flatters every game, and it might not be a good thing if he's now injured for a while... Inniss: 6 - Did OK and red was a little harsh IMO Ness: 7 - Did well under extenuating circumstances (having to introduce himself to new defenders alongside him every five minutes! Penney: 3.5 - He is very poor at nearly everything, and loses another point for the dive. Dobson: 6 - Not at his best but kept trying Kilkenny: 5 - Started OK but faded Fraser: 7 - Kept pushing and probing but messed up his one good chance R-S: 6-5 - Nice goal but faded badly toward the end of the match Bonne: 3 - Offered nothing but fouls B-T: 5.5 - Started brightly but didn't seem bothered later in the game Sessegnon: 6 - Did OK Aneke: 6.5 - Did hugely more than Bonne but fluffed his big chance Campbell: 6.5 - Did OK in a weird role Referee: 3.5 - Made too many mistakes (not helped but lino's or 4th) but at least he did add the extra time on to the game
M-B: 5 Perhaps he could have done better with both goals? Clare: 6 Had a couple of good moments going forward, but still not great defensively. Gets drawn out of position and switches off much too easily. Inniss: 6 Thought he had a decent game. Never a red card. First impressions were that it was a great tackle, but even if not, it was not worthy of a red. Ness: 6 Did well again. I hope he has big shoulders because a lot will be resting on them for the next few games. Penney: 4 Linked up well with CBT for the first 20 minutes, then had a nightmare of a game. Mind you, he gets no help defensively whatsoever from CBT. Dobson: 7 Lots of tidying up and tackles as usual Kilkenny: 5 Started well, but faded very quickly. Shows promise though and looks an upgrade on Morgan. Fraser: 6 Had a few good moments, but minus half a point for messing up the two-on-one. R-S: 7 Great goal and thought he did well throughout. We need to get the ball to him more often and quicker before he gets double-marked. Bonne: 5 Did very little, but I fee a bit sorry for him. He is so isolated. The system of play does not work leaving him so isolated. CBT and JRS play too wide to support him (they need to get closer to him) and the midfield always seem too far behind him. B-T: 5 Did nothing of note and as usual faded after the first 20 minutes. Offers no help at all to the full back. Lazy player with fragile confidence. Sessegnon: 7 Made such a difference when he came on, even though not fully fit. Such a class player. He knows how to defend too. Aneke: 6 Made a big impact for about the first 10 to 15 minutes, but then faded badly. Is that all he can manage? We really need a fitter Chuks who can contribute a bit more than that. Campbell: 6 Looked okay playing out of position. Time to give him a chance ahead of CBT. Referee: 5 Lost the plot a bit at times second half. Not sure what he saw to make that a red card. Needs to give himself a red card for that!
M-B: 5.5 not his best game Clare: 7 one of the few trying to get something going forward Inniss: 4 clumsy challenge that was worth a yellow but still reckless and killed our momentum Ness: 6.5 relatively solid Penney: 3 really poor game for him, wonder if he was suffering from concussion, I'm not gonna go to the extremities of labelling him the worst full back of all time as he's only a couple of games in. Sess definitely seems the better option though even if out of position Dobson: 6.5 his usual solid game, a few sloppy passes Kilkenny: 6 good first half but went missing second Fraser: 6.5 a few good moments but just lacking that final ball today R-S: 7 fantastic goal Bonne: 4 may have been a lack of service but nothing happened for him today B-T: 4.5 one of his worst games for us, everything he tried didn't come off Sessegnon: 5 Aneke: 6 a threat Campbell: 5 Referee: 5.5 ultimately got the red card wrong but it wasn't his fault we lost. Actually felt he did a good job in both halves of accounting for Fleetwood's time wasting in injury time which doesn't always happen
M-B: 5.5 - not watched the goals back but he could perhaps have done better for both (although where the hell were his defenders for the second ?) Clare: 6 - did ok. I hope he didn't overextend his knee when making that game ending tackle or he could be out for some time Inniss: 5.5 - it didn't look like the denial of a goalscoring opportunity or a tackle sufficiently violent to justify a red card, but Inniss was never going to get there in time and it was an ill-judged and unnecessary challenge. His judgment is consistently poor. Subject to the outcome of any appeal, a third red card will attract a long suspension Ness: 7 - our best defender. His good positioning was in evidence when he cleared what would have been a third goal off the line Penney: 4 - very poor and got worse as the game went on. Too lightweight and incapable of beating the first man with his crosses Dobson: 6 - not at his best but did his utmost to try and shore things up Kilkenny: 5 - a decent first half but faded badly. He'll hopefully get fitter and sharper with more game time, although I expect that Morgan will be rotated in on Tuesday Fraser: 6 - a good first half but, like his teammates, dipped in the second R-S: 6.5 - a lovely goal but we couldn't get him on the ball enough in the second half Bonne: 3 - absolutely nothing went right for him. Lacks physicality and the rudiments of centre-forward play B-T: 5 - a good first 20 minutes but very little thereafter Sessegnon: 6.5 - one of the few Charlton players who looked like a footballer Aneke: 6.5 - made a difference when he came on but clearly won't be ready to start on Tuesday Campbell: 6.5 - lively Referee: 4 - I think he got the sending off wrong. At least he added on 12 minutes of injury time, although we could, in all honesty, played until midnight without scoring again
M-B: 5 Clare: 5 Inniss: 5 Ness: 5 Penney: 3 ( I like that he doesn't hide but is well off the pace, the dive was embarrassing) Dobson: 5 Kilkenny: 5 Fraser: 5 R-S: 6 Bonne: 5 B-T: 5 Sessegnon: 4 (looks assured on the ball but was jogging back for the 2nd goal) Aneke: 5 Campbell: 5 Referee: 3
Hope the tactics board took a kicking, worst performance since Oxford.
Comments
Clare: 6.5
Inniss: 5.5
Ness: 6
Penney: 4
Dobson: 6.5
Kilkenny: 6
Fraser: 6.5
R-S: 7
Bonne: 3
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 6
Aneke: 6
Campbell: 6
Referee: 2
Clare: 6
Inniss: 6
Ness: 6
Penney: 3
Dobson: 7
Kilkenny: 6
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Bonne: 4
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 6
Aneke: 7
Campbell: 6
Referee: 3
Clare: 5.5 - He flatters every game, and it might not be a good thing if he's now injured for a while...
Inniss: 6 - Did OK and red was a little harsh IMO
Ness: 7 - Did well under extenuating circumstances (having to introduce himself to new defenders alongside him every five minutes!
Penney: 3.5 - He is very poor at nearly everything, and loses another point for the dive.
Dobson: 6 - Not at his best but kept trying
Kilkenny: 5 - Started OK but faded
Fraser: 7 - Kept pushing and probing but messed up his one good chance
R-S: 6-5 - Nice goal but faded badly toward the end of the match
Bonne: 3 - Offered nothing but fouls
B-T: 5.5 - Started brightly but didn't seem bothered later in the game
Sessegnon: 6 - Did OK
Aneke: 6.5 - Did hugely more than Bonne but fluffed his big chance
Campbell: 6.5 - Did OK in a weird role
Referee: 3.5 - Made too many mistakes (not helped but lino's or 4th) but at least he did add the extra time on to the game
M-B: 5 Perhaps he could have done better with both goals?
Clare: 6 Had a couple of good moments going forward, but still not great defensively. Gets drawn out of position and switches off much too easily.
Inniss: 6 Thought he had a decent game. Never a red card. First impressions were that it was a great tackle, but even if not, it was not worthy of a red.
Ness: 6 Did well again. I hope he has big shoulders because a lot will be resting on them for the next few games.
Penney: 4 Linked up well with CBT for the first 20 minutes, then had a nightmare of a game. Mind you, he gets no help defensively whatsoever from CBT.
Dobson: 7 Lots of tidying up and tackles as usual
Kilkenny: 5 Started well, but faded very quickly. Shows promise though and looks an upgrade on Morgan.
Fraser: 6 Had a few good moments, but minus half a point for messing up the two-on-one.
R-S: 7 Great goal and thought he did well throughout. We need to get the ball to him more often and quicker before he gets double-marked.
Bonne: 5 Did very little, but I fee a bit sorry for him. He is so isolated. The system of play does not work leaving him so isolated. CBT and JRS play too wide to support him (they need to get closer to him) and the midfield always seem too far behind him.
B-T: 5 Did nothing of note and as usual faded after the first 20 minutes. Offers no help at all to the full back. Lazy player with fragile confidence.
Sessegnon: 7 Made such a difference when he came on, even though not fully fit. Such a class player. He knows how to defend too.
Aneke: 6 Made a big impact for about the first 10 to 15 minutes, but then faded badly. Is that all he can manage? We really need a fitter Chuks who can contribute a bit more than that.
Campbell: 6 Looked okay playing out of position. Time to give him a chance ahead of CBT.
Referee: 5 Lost the plot a bit at times second half. Not sure what he saw to make that a red card. Needs to give himself a red card for that!
Clare 6.5
Inniss 6
Ness 6.5
Penny 5
Dobson 6.5
Kilkenny 6
Fraser 6.5
RS 7
Bonne 5.5
BT 6
Sess 6
Aneke 6
Campbell 6
Ref 2.5
Clare: 4
Inniss:5
Ness: 5.5
Penney: 3
Dobson: 5.5
Kilkenny: 5.5
Fraser: 5
R-S: 5
Bonne: 4.5
B-T: 4
Sessegnon: 4
Aneke: 6
Campbell: 6
Referee: 4
Clare: 7 one of the few trying to get something going forward
Inniss: 4 clumsy challenge that was worth a yellow but still reckless and killed our momentum
Ness: 6.5 relatively solid
Penney: 3 really poor game for him, wonder if he was suffering from concussion, I'm not gonna go to the extremities of labelling him the worst full back of all time as he's only a couple of games in. Sess definitely seems the better option though even if out of position
Dobson: 6.5 his usual solid game, a few sloppy passes
Kilkenny: 6 good first half but went missing second
Fraser: 6.5 a few good moments but just lacking that final ball today
R-S: 7 fantastic goal
Bonne: 4 may have been a lack of service but nothing happened for him today
B-T: 4.5 one of his worst games for us, everything he tried didn't come off
Sessegnon: 5
Aneke: 6 a threat
Campbell: 5
Referee: 5.5 ultimately got the red card wrong but it wasn't his fault we lost. Actually felt he did a good job in both halves of accounting for Fleetwood's time wasting in injury time which doesn't always happen
Clare: 7
Inniss: 7
Ness: 7
Penney: 3
Dobson: 7
Kilkenny: 7
Fraser: 6
R-S: 7
Bonne: 4
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 6
Aneke: 7
Campbell: 6
Referee: 5
Clare: 5
Inniss:5
Ness: 6
Penney: 4
Dobson: 5
Kilkenny: 4
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6
Bonne: 4
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 5
Aneke: 5
Campbell: 6
Clare: 6
Inniss: 5
Ness: 7
Penney: 5
Dobson: 6
Kilkenny: 5
Fraser: 5
R-S: 7.5
Bonne: 6
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 6
Aneke: 6.5
Campbell: 7
Referee: 4
Clare: 6 - did ok. I hope he didn't overextend his knee when making that game ending tackle or he could be out for some time
Inniss: 5.5 - it didn't look like the denial of a goalscoring opportunity or a tackle sufficiently violent to justify a red card, but Inniss was never going to get there in time and it was an ill-judged and unnecessary challenge. His judgment is consistently poor. Subject to the outcome of any appeal, a third red card will attract a long suspension
Ness: 7 - our best defender. His good positioning was in evidence when he cleared what would have been a third goal off the line
Penney: 4 - very poor and got worse as the game went on. Too lightweight and incapable of beating the first man with his crosses
Dobson: 6 - not at his best but did his utmost to try and shore things up
Kilkenny: 5 - a decent first half but faded badly. He'll hopefully get fitter and sharper with more game time, although I expect that Morgan will be rotated in on Tuesday
Fraser: 6 - a good first half but, like his teammates, dipped in the second
R-S: 6.5 - a lovely goal but we couldn't get him on the ball enough in the second half
Bonne: 3 - absolutely nothing went right for him. Lacks physicality and the rudiments of centre-forward play
B-T: 5 - a good first 20 minutes but very little thereafter
Sessegnon: 6.5 - one of the few Charlton players who looked like a footballer
Aneke: 6.5 - made a difference when he came on but clearly won't be ready to start on Tuesday
Campbell: 6.5 - lively
Referee: 4 - I think he got the sending off wrong. At least he added on 12 minutes of injury time, although we could, in all honesty, played until midnight without scoring again
Clare: 6
Inniss: 5
Ness: 7
Penney: 5
Dobson: 7
Kilkenny: 6
Fraser: 6
R-S: 7
Bonne: 4
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 7
Aneke: 6
Campbell: 7
Referee: 5
Clare: 6
Inniss: 6
Ness: 6.5
Penney: 4
Dobson: 6
Kilkenny: 5
Fraser: 6
R-S: 6
Bonne: 4
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 6
Aneke: 6
Campbell: 5
Referee: 4
Clare: 5
Inniss: 5
Ness: 5
Penney: 3 ( I like that he doesn't hide but is well off the pace, the dive was embarrassing)
Dobson: 5
Kilkenny: 5
Fraser: 5
R-S: 6
Bonne: 5
B-T: 5
Sessegnon: 4 (looks assured on the ball but was jogging back for the 2nd goal)
Aneke: 5
Campbell: 5
Referee: 3
Hope the tactics board took a kicking, worst performance since Oxford.