Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Newport County v Charlton Athletic (closes Thursday breakfast)

marks 0.5 to 10.0

ISTED:
MITCHELL; 
NESS: 
HECTOR: 
CAMPBELL (sub): 
McGRANDLES: 
PAYNE: 
CAMARÁ: 
EDUN: 
KANU: 
KIRK:
ANDERSON: 
TAYLOR: 
THOMAS: 

REFEREE:

Ineligible but can be marked
CHIN (injured):
MAY: 

Comments


  • ISTED: 6
    MITCHELL; 5.5
    NESS: 6
    HECTOR: 5.5
    CAMPBELL (sub): 6
    McGRANDLES: 4.5
    PAYNE: 6.5 at least he tried!
    CAMARÁ: 5
    EDUN: 6
    KANU: 5
    KIRK: 4
    ANDERSON: 6
    TAYLOR: 5.5
    THOMAS: 6

    REFEREE: 6
  • marks 0.5 to 10.0

    ISTED: 5
    MITCHELL; 5
    NESS: 5
    HECTOR: 5
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    PAYNE: 6
    CAMARÁ: 6
    EDUN: 6
    KANU: 6
    KIRK: 4
    ANDERSON: 6
    TAYLOR: 5
    THOMAS: 6

    REFEREE: 7

    Ineligible but can be marked
    CHIN (injured):
    MAY: 

  • ISTED: 6
    MITCHELL; 5.5
    NESS: 5.5
    HECTOR: 5
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5.5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    PAYNE: 5.5
    CAMARÁ: 6
    EDUN: 5
    KANU: 5
    KIRK:4
    ANDERSON: 5
    TAYLOR: 5
    THOMAS: 6

    REFEREE:6
  • ISTED: 3 shocking trying to play it from the back 
    MITCHELL;  4 Not good enough yet
    NESS: 4
    HECTOR: 3 awful
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    PAYNE: 1 really thought he may look ok against a lower league team but he is absolute shit. To everyone saying he is a decent back up to Fraser he is not he is shit
    CAMARÁ 5: 
    EDUN: 5
    KANU: 2 dreadful needs to go out on loan to a non league team 
    KIRK: 1 sack of shit player I pray we get rid of by the end of the month 
    ANDERSON: 5
    TAYLOR:5 
    THOMAS: 5
  • At the game

    ISTED: 6
    MITCHELL; 6
    NESS: 6
    HECTOR: 6
    CAMPBELL (sub): 6
    McGRANDLES: 5
    PAYNE: 6
    CAMARÁ: 6
    EDUN: 6
    KANU: 6
    KIRK: 5
    ANDERSON: 5
    TAYLOR: 5
    THOMAS: 6
  • Defence getting 6's and we lose 3-1? really
  • edited August 2023
    TEL said:
    Defence getting 6's and we lose 3-1? really
    On the highlights it looked like two of the goals were caused by our midfielders
  • ISTED: 5
    MITCHELL: 5
    NESS: 5.5
    HECTOR: 5.6
    CAMPBELL (sub): 6
    McGRANDLES: 6
    PAYNE: 6
    CAMARÁ: 5.5
    EDUN: 6.5
    KANU: 5
    KIRK: 5
    ANDERSON: 6
    TAYLOR: 4
    THOMAS: 6

    REFEREE: 7
  • Camara seems to have performed poorly, yet he had a fantastic  cameo on Saturday. Is that really the case? Fitness? or really that inconsistent
  • Sponsored links:


  • Sign up the ref!
  • ISTED: 5
    MITCHELL: 5
    NESS: 4
    HECTOR: 5
    CAMPBELL (sub): 6
    McGRANDLES: 4
    PAYNE: 6
    CAMARÁ: 5
    EDUN: 6
    KANU: 6
    KIRK: 3
    ANDERSON: 6
    TAYLOR: 4
    THOMAS: 6

    REFEREE: 6
  • ISTED: 5 - he worries me when he tries to play out from the back
    MITCHELL; 5 - still learning
    NESS: 5.5 - a bit more solid than his colleagues, although that is damning with faint praise
    HECTOR: 5 - not as good as he thinks he is
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5 - he is not a wing back. I hope the injury’s not a bad one
    McGRANDLES: 4 - his basic error handed them an equaliser and was a pivotal moment. Poor throughout 
    PAYNE: 5 -  a very limited and frustrating player
    CAMARÁ: 5 - unable to affect the game but hopefully the minutes will help him
    EDUN: 5 - didn’t see much of him in an attacking sense
    KANU: 5 - left very isolated up top and found it difficult to hold the ball up and bring others into play
    KIRK: 3 - a full-back’s dream. He never takes his man on and is one of the most predictable players I’ve ever seen. His peevish whinging at his team mates is a further irritation. We need him out, although inevitably it will be another loan with us picking up most of his wages
    ANDERSON: 6 - tried to inject a bit of urgency when he came on
    TAYLOR: 5 - an unfortunate slip for the third goal but hopefully his time on the pitch will help him towards full fitness
    THOMAS: 5.5 - a bit shaky defensively but one good attacking foray towards the end

    REFEREE: 6 - didn’t notice him much, which is always a good sign
  • Chunes said:
    TEL said:
    Defence getting 6's and we lose 3-1? really
    On the highlights it looked like two of the goals were caused by our midfielders
    Hector was nowhere near close enough to his man. 
  • ISTED: 5
    MITCHELL; 5
    NESS: 5
    HECTOR: 5
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5
    McGRANDLES: 4 Lost the ball & then got beaten again for their 1st goal - twice at fault - I'm convinced get rid
    PAYNE: 5 Happy if he goes
    CAMARÁ: 5
    EDUN: 5
    KANU: 5
    KIRK: 3 Contributes next to nothing other than passing the ball backwards - get rid 
    ANDERSON: 5
    TAYLOR: 5 Some nice passes but slipped over to gift them their 3rd goal 
    THOMAS: 5

    REFEREE: 7

    Ineligible but can be marked
    CHIN (injured): 5
    MAY: 7 The only player who put in a decent shift & looked like they cared
  • I don't mark players.  But a big fat zero to whoever choose to play in the black away kit for a wet, night time game at a ground with second-rate lighting. God knows how the players saw each other because I couldn't see them half the time. Should have been the white kit or maybe, heaven forbid, even the actual main red kit.
  • edited August 2023
    I wonder if some players are playing to get out of the club as an example Kirk Mcgrandles and Payne they know they are on their way out perhaps .The new players Taylor , Camera and Edun are still not up to speed nor is Ness after his injury that’s 7 players …
  • edited August 2023

    ISTED: 3
    MITCHELL; 3.5
    NESS: 4.5
    HECTOR: 4
    CAMPBELL (sub): 5
    McGRANDLES: 5.5
    PAYNE: 5.5
    CAMARÁ: 5
    EDUN: 5
    KANU: 6
    KIRK: 3.5
    ANDERSON: 4.5
    TAYLOR: 4
    THOMAS: 5.5

    I just can't find myself giving higher ratings losing to a team in the division below, otherwise I'd be handing out tens to our team Vs Leyton Orient as they were substantially better 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!