STATBANK: Peterborough 1-0 Charlton

lancashire lad

many thanks to the 46 Lifers who gave marks
I have included an injury table, this is very much a guesstimate and as usual I happy to be corrected.

Bedsaddick

That's harsh that Jack Payne got the lowest average . There were worse players than him yesterday. I thought he had a really good second half. It looks like he's our new player to slag off regardless of how he plays. It's what we do. 

killerandflash

The ref on Tuesday was deservedly ahead of the players. The ref yesterday was deservedly below them...

Covered End

Bedsaddick said:

That's harsh that Jack Payne got the lowest average . There were worse players than him yesterday. I thought he had a really good second half. It looks like he's our new player to slag off regardless of how he plays. It's what we do. 

I'm not a fan and would be quite happy if he left (sorry Jack), but I thought he was one of our better players yesterday.

Callumcafc

Funny because I feel like I’m one of Payne’s biggest defenders on here but yesterday I thought he was naff - couple of attacks broke down when he ran down a blind alley when he could’ve passed it and then second half, taking that free kick off Alfie May & skying it didn’t impress me. 

Probably not the worst player on the pitch though.

JamesSeed

Bedsaddick said:

That's harsh that Jack Payne got the lowest average . There were worse players than him yesterday. I thought he had a really good second half. It looks like he's our new player to slag off regardless of how he plays. It's what we do. 

Totally agree. Someone gave him a score of 3. Would love to see the evidence for such a low score. Having said that 5.60 isn’t a shocker of a score, and no one had a terrible game. 

Perhaps it should be like in the Olympics when they score gymnastics. The highest and lowest scores are removed, I think to stop manipulation of the results.
I sometimes think Dobbo is scored too highly, but  he’s deserved his two MotMs so far, for sure.

Dazzler21

Callumcafc said:

Funny because I feel like I’m one of Payne’s biggest defenders on here but yesterday I thought he was naff - couple of attacks broke down when he ran down a blind alley when he could’ve passed it and then second half, taking that free kick off Alfie May & skying it didn’t impress me. 

Probably not the worst player on the pitch though.

He's like a worse Johnny Williams, but is a bit more reliable in front of goal. 

redman

Bit surprised Camara ended up so high in the rankings. His mistake effectively cost us the game. 

Also think the ref has been harshly scored. Few decisions but nothing crucial. There again we lost so many people immediately mark the ref down. I wonder what the average is when we win compared to when we lose! 

Dazzler21

redman said:

Bit surprised Camara ended up so high in the rankings. His mistake effectively cost us the game. 

Also think the ref has been harshly scored. Few decisions but nothing crucial. There again we lost so many people immediately mark the ref down. I wonder what the average is when we win compared to when we lose! 

In fairness to him, that was a single mistake (a horrendous touch) in an otherwise relatively decent game. He had at least 4 players in behind him and he tried to get back to defend too as he should have - we should have been able to deal with it. 

redman

I wonder if you or others would have judged the same way had Albie Morgan done exactly the same. (I'm not saying Camara isn't a better long term upgrade on Morgan btw)

Dazzler21

redman said:

I wonder if you or others would have judged the same way had Albie Morgan done exactly the same. (I'm not saying Camara isn't a better long term upgrade on Morgan btw)

 I'd have defended Morgan in the same way. (I often defended him for minor mistakes when the whole team failed to do something)

killerandflash

redman said:

Bit surprised Camara ended up so high in the rankings. His mistake effectively cost us the game. 

Also think the ref has been harshly scored. Few decisions but nothing crucial. There again we lost so many people immediately mark the ref down. I wonder what the average is when we win compared to when we lose! 

The ref lost control of the game, and seemed very card happy. The ref on Tuesday was very good and got a good score, despite us losing badly.

killerandflash

redman said:

I wonder if you or others would have judged the same way had Albie Morgan done exactly the same. (I'm not saying Camara isn't a better long term upgrade on Morgan btw)

Or Inniss, who got slaughtered for that cock up on the touchline which led to a goal.

eastterrace6168

redman said:

Bit surprised Camara ended up so high in the rankings. His mistake effectively cost us the game. 

Also think the ref has been harshly scored. Few decisions but nothing crucial. There again we lost so many people immediately mark the ref down. I wonder what the average is when we win compared to when we lose! 

It was Camara's lack of control agreed, but I thought it was a well taken goal, something we would have probably cocked up if it was the other way round...

Addictedoldgit

My opinion, Camara’s first touch mistake should not have led to a goal. Unfortunately Thomas had gone walk about from left CB position over to rhs. 

So for me Thomas was primarily at fault for the goal.
Having said that I’ve noticed Camara will sometimes lose possession- happens with young/inexperienced players.
Anderson has done same, it’s part of the learning process’s and why the youngsters should be gradually dipped in/out of first team games.