AMB: 5.5 made a couple of decent saves but did look a bit ropey at times Asiimwe: 6 struggled a bit going forward but has settled in reasonably well Jones: 6.5 thought he looked quite comfortable Ness: 6.5 great goal line clearance saved a certain goal, maybe could have done better for second Edun: 7.5 thought he was excellent shame he couldn’t last the 90 Dobson: 7 excellent first half looked knackered towards the end of second Anderson: 5.5 there’s promise but don’t think he’s quite ready Camará: 6 a few promising runs but have the ball away a bit too often Payne: 5 not a great game but not as disastrous as many are making out May: 6 unlucky not to score, offside a bit too often CBT: 6 looked dangerous but not his best game Kanu: 7 great goal and great closing down to set up May’s chance Referee: 4 got the red wrong ineligible but can be a marked Hector: Taylor: Thomas:
AMB: 7 Asiimwe: 7 Jones: 7 Ness: 7 Edun: 9 top quality Dobson: 7 great 65 mins Anderson: 5 Camará: 7 Payne: 1 nowhere near good enough his dumb arse foul cost us this game May: 7 CBT: 5 Kanu: 6 Referee: 4
AMB: 7 solid game and defenders needed to help after his save from free kick Asiimwe: 6.5 good potential Jones: 6.5 looked decent before cramping up. Ness: 6.5 good overall Edun: 7 LB at last. Again went off as cramping. Dobson: 8.5 no way should he have been on losing side. Anderson: 6 assist for Kanu and good prospect. Camará: 6 erratic performance and can't finish but great engine who needs games. Payne: 5 +1 for hard work but never looks good enough. May: 5.5 needs a partner but 3 chances and no goals. CBT: 7.5 dangerous but one cross in 1st half if he taken a bit off May had tap in. Kanu: 7.5 took his goal well and gave two good interceptions to Alfie including when the defender should have seen Red. Referee: 4 if red card shown we get a point if not more.
marks 0.5 - 10.0 AMB: 6.0 Should have done better with 2nd goal Asiimwe: 6.0 lost his man for 2nd goal Jones: 6.5 Just about ok Ness: 6.5 Just about ok Edun: 7.0 Good first start Dobson: 8.0 Best player on the pitch by far Anderson: 7.0 tried hard Camará: 7.0 flattered to deceive Payne: 4.0 Oh dear May: 7.0 Just lacks a bit of good fortune to go his way CBT: 6.5 Needs to look up Kanu: 7.0 Took his goal well Referee:4.0 would have been more but bottled the red card ineligible but can be a marked Hector: Taylor: Thomas:
AMB:5 couple of good saves but should never get beaten at his neat post Asiimwe: 6.5 a real player on ours hands Jones: 7 Ness:7 Edun: 7 really impressed with him today Dobson: 9.5 a proper captain, absolute spartan Anderson: 6 Camará: 6 sometimes good, sometimes shit Payne: 3 just fuck off to Swindon with garner May: 6.5 its going to come, just needs a partner CBT: 6 frustrating Kanu: 7 he can finish Referee: 6.5 barring not sending off the last man, he was actually pretty good
AMB: 8, Could have been worse if it wasn't for him Asiimwe: 7 Jones: 7 Ness: 6 Edun: 7 Dobson: 7 Anderson: 7 Camará: '6, Got overun by Rovers change of formation, not fit enough yet. Payne: 6, Hard to be harsh on him but he is simply not good enough May: 6, Should have scored but is feeling his hamstring as well, not good CBT: 8, Probably our biggest threat Kanu: 7, Composed for his goal but can't hold the ball up, yet. Referee:5, Bottled the sending off.
In Covered End, so view of both their goals not great.
AMB: 5
Asiimwe: 7 Jones: 6 Ness: 7 Great clearance off the line
Edun: 8.5 Brilliant performance. Some player. Dobson: 8 (9 first half, 7 second half) Anderson: 6.5 Camará: 6.5 Lost the ball too often, good otherwise Payne: 3 Love his effort, but he not quite at this level. May: 6.5. Wld have been 8 if he’d scored instead of hitting the post CBT: 7 Couple of shots blocked, one by Payne Kanu: 7 Very promising Referee: 4 it was a red
AMB: 6 Asiimwe: 6 Jones: 6.5 Ness: 6 Edun: 7.5 Dobson: 8 Anderson: 7 Camará: 6 Payne: 3 May: 5 CBT: 6.5 Kanu: 7.5 Referee: 5 (was fine but how was that not a last man red card?)
AMB: 5 - Could have done better with both goals IMO Asiimwe: 6.5 - Did OK, but still very inexperienced Jones: 6.5 - Did OK Ness: 6.5 - Ditto Edun: 6.5 - Still trying to understand what works and what doesn't with these team-mates Dobson: 7 - Gosh, where would our midfield be without him Anderson: 5 - Game seemed to pass him by Camará: 6 - Some good stuff but they swarmed over him and he struggled to break free Payne: 4.5 - Slowed everything down and went round in circles May: 4 - Love-fest over; he hit post when should have scored, and that awful free kick...hmmm. CBT: 6 - Our best outlet but teams know what he is going to do.... Kanu: 6.5 - Provided balance (at last) and help for May; took his goal very well. Referee: 6 - He did OK but these new regs re yellows/reds are strange ineligible but can be a marked Hector: 6 Taylor: 6 Thomas: 6
marks 0.5 - 10.0 AMB: 5.5 Still questions marks over him for me, shouldn't really be trying to save that and trying to keep the ball in play, and he got a strong hand on the ball, worries me with the ball at his feet. Asiimwe: 7 I thought he was really good, got great energy, comfortable on the ball, happy to have the ball in tight spaces, needs to work on his final delivery, and maybe for the winner, I can't work out if it is his man or Ness yet, there was a big overload on that side. Jones: 6 defended well, but he looks long to quickly, needs to be more comfortable on the ball Ness: 6.5 as above, he is a little more comfortable, but does look like he will give the ball away easily Edun: 8 I thought he was excellent, ran himself in to the ground, very good going forward, good at defending, only thing that worries me, is that he will get caught out to high up the pitch. Dobson: 9 he was outstanding last night, in fact on of his best performances in a Charlton shirt, didn't deserve to be on the losing side, looks like he has upped his game now, very confident on the ball, happy to turn and look for forward passes. Anderson: 6 good moments, and nice pass for the goal, but goes missing and gets caught on the ball. Camará: 7 not fully fit, but he is a driving force with the ball, his control isn't the best, maybe that will get better with fitness. Needs to cut out silly mistakes, if he can, we have a very good player. Payne: 4 sorry, that was not good enough, always caught on the ball, knocked off easily, runs in to trouble. Feel sorry for him, as there is a player in him, but it isn't working. Maybe a move is required. May: 5 lacking confidence, it is only 3 games in, he shouldn't be lacking it. Missed couple of chances, he does try hard.. I hate the fact he is offside so much, doesn't allow us to win the 2nd balls. CBT: 6.5 if he had an end product, he wouldn't be with us, he would be top end premier league player, and that's the reason he is in League One.. We look so dangerous when he has the ball, but we don't score enough of the chances he creates for others and himself. Kanu: 8 looked total different player to what we have seen previously, he normally looks sluggish, and lacks control - not tonight, looked sharp, hungry, quick, great control and confident.. Maybe the penny has dropped and it is time for Kanu to shine. Referee: 7 not a lot to do, only one decision, was if to send the man off when May was through, I think he got it right, 3 players hot on his tail, and they was quicker, they was getting back. ineligible but can be a marked Hector: 4 what has happened to him, looks unfit, not bothered and looks like a mistake waiting to happen. Taylor: 6 looked tidy on the ball, I like the way he drills the balls in to players. He will get better with game time. Thomas: 5 didn't notice him when he come on!
AMB: 6 - unconvincing. Might be being a bit harsh, but thought he could have done better woth the 2nd goal. Asiimwe: 6 - stuck to his job, still only young and will learn by playing games. Jones: 6 - did ok, but getting fed up with having to make defensive substitutions because he hasn’t got 90 mins in the tank. Ness: 7 - not his biggest fan, but did well last night, great recovery block on the line. Edun: 7 - very good first half, tired in the 2nd Dobson: 7.5 - excellent again. Has added anew dimension to his game. Anderson: 6 - did ok. Camará:5.5 - one excellent burst down the pitch, but looked off the pace for large parts of the game. Payne: 3 - Needless foul cost us. I’m not really sure what he offers and, ultimately not good enough. May: 5 - should have scored, desperately need a strike partner. Stay onside FFS. CBT: 7 - Always a threat, but needs an end product. Kanu: 6.5 - pleased he got a goal, we looked more likely with him on the pitch, long term I’m not so sure. Referee: 5 - needs to revisit the rule book.
Comments
Asiimwe: 6 struggled a bit going forward but has settled in reasonably well
Jones: 6.5 thought he looked quite comfortable
Ness: 6.5 great goal line clearance saved a certain goal, maybe could have done better for second
Edun: 7.5 thought he was excellent shame he couldn’t last the 90
Dobson: 7 excellent first half looked knackered towards the end of second
Anderson: 5.5 there’s promise but don’t think he’s quite ready
Camará: 6 a few promising runs but have the ball away a bit too often
Payne: 5 not a great game but not as disastrous as many are making out
May: 6 unlucky not to score, offside a bit too often
CBT: 6 looked dangerous but not his best game
Kanu: 7 great goal and great closing down to set up May’s chance
Referee: 4 got the red wrong
ineligible but can be a marked
Hector:
Taylor:
Thomas:
Asiimwe: 5
Jones: 5
Ness: 5
Edun: 6
Dobson: 6
Anderson: 5
Camará: 6
Payne: 2
May: 5
CBT: 5
Kanu: 7
Referee:2
Asiimwe: 7
Jones: 7
Ness: 7
Edun: 9 top quality
Dobson: 7 great 65 mins
Anderson: 5
Camará: 7
Payne: 1 nowhere near good enough his dumb arse foul cost us this game
May: 7
CBT: 5
Kanu: 6
Referee: 4
not bad for a ten man team
Asiimwe: 6.5 good potential
Jones: 6.5 looked decent before cramping up.
Ness: 6.5 good overall
Edun: 7 LB at last. Again went off as cramping.
Dobson: 8.5 no way should he have been on losing side.
Anderson: 6 assist for Kanu and good prospect.
Camará: 6 erratic performance and can't finish but great engine who needs games.
Payne: 5 +1 for hard work but never looks good enough.
May: 5.5 needs a partner but 3 chances and no goals.
CBT: 7.5 dangerous but one cross in 1st half if he taken a bit off May had tap in.
Kanu: 7.5 took his goal well and gave two good interceptions to Alfie including when the defender should have seen Red.
Referee: 4 if red card shown we get a point if not more.
AMB: 6.0 Should have done better with 2nd goal
Asiimwe: 6.0 lost his man for 2nd goal
Jones: 6.5 Just about ok
Ness: 6.5 Just about ok
Edun: 7.0 Good first start
Dobson: 8.0 Best player on the pitch by far
Anderson: 7.0 tried hard
Camará: 7.0 flattered to deceive
Payne: 4.0 Oh dear
May: 7.0 Just lacks a bit of good fortune to go his way
CBT: 6.5 Needs to look up
Kanu: 7.0 Took his goal well
Referee:4.0 would have been more but bottled the red card
ineligible but can be a marked
Hector:
Taylor:
Thomas:
Asiimwe: 6.5 a real player on ours hands
Jones: 7
Ness:7
Edun: 7 really impressed with him today
Dobson: 9.5 a proper captain, absolute spartan
Anderson: 6
Camará: 6 sometimes good, sometimes shit
Payne: 3 just fuck off to Swindon with garner
May: 6.5 its going to come, just needs a partner
CBT: 6 frustrating
Kanu: 7 he can finish
Referee: 6.5 barring not sending off the last man, he was actually pretty good
Asiimwe 6
Jones 6.5
Ness 6.5
Edun 7
Dobson 7.5
Anderson 6.5
Camara 7
Payne 6
May 6.5
Cbt 6.5
Kanu 7
Ref 5
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6.5
Ness: 6.5
Edun: 7
Dobson: 7.5
Anderson: 6.5
Camará: 6
Payne: 3
May: 6
CBT: 7
Kanu: 7
Referee: 5
Asiimwe: 5.5
Jones: 5
Ness: 5.5
Edun: 6
Dobson: 7.5
Anderson: 5.5
Camara: 6
Payne: 3
May: 5.5
CBT: 5.5
Kanu: 6
Referee: 3
Asiimwe: 7
Jones: 7
Ness: 7
Edun: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 5.5
Camará: 7
Payne: 3
May: 5
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 7
Referee: 4
ineligible but can be a marked
Hector: 6
Taylor: 5
Thomas: 4.5
Asiimwe: 7
Jones: 7
Ness: 6
Edun: 7
Dobson: 7
Anderson: 7
Camará: '6, Got overun by Rovers change of formation, not fit enough yet.
Payne: 6, Hard to be harsh on him but he is simply not good enough
May: 6, Should have scored but is feeling his hamstring as well, not good
CBT: 8, Probably our biggest threat
Kanu: 7, Composed for his goal but can't hold the ball up, yet.
Referee:5, Bottled the sending off.
AMB: 6
Asiimwe: 6.5
Jones: 6
Ness: 6
Edun: 8
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 6
Camará: 6.5
Payne: 5
May: 6
CBT: 7
Kanu: 7
Referee: 3
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 6.5
Edun: 6.5
Dobson: 7
Anderson: 5.5
Camará: 6.5
Payne: 6
May: 6
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 6.5
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 6
Edun: 6.5
Dobson: 7
Anderson: 6
Camará: 6
Payne: 5
May: 6
CBT: 6
Kanu: 7
Referee: 5
Asiimwe: 6.5
Jones: 6.5
Ness: 6
Edun: 7
Dobson: 7.5
Anderson: 6
Camará: 7
Payne: 4
May: 5.5
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 6.5
Referee: 6
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 6
Edun: 6
Dobson: 7.5
Anderson: 6
Camará: 6
Payne: 4
May: 6
CBT: 6
Kanu: 7
Referee: 5
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 7
Edun: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 5.5
Camará: 6
Payne: 3
May: 5.5
CBT: 6
Kanu: 7
Referee:4
Jones: 6
Ness: 7 Great clearance off the line
Dobson: 8 (9 first half, 7 second half)
Anderson: 6.5
Camará: 6.5 Lost the ball too often, good otherwise
Payne: 3 Love his effort, but he not quite at this level.
May: 6.5. Wld have been 8 if he’d scored instead of hitting the post
CBT: 7 Couple of shots blocked, one by Payne
Kanu: 7 Very promising
Referee: 4 it was a red
AMB: 5.5
Asiimwe: 6.5
Jones: 6
Ness: 6
Edun: 7
Dobson: 6
Anderson: 6
Camará: 6
Payne: 6
May: 6
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 6
Referee:
Asiimwe: 5
Jones: 5
Ness: 5
Edun: 5
Dobson: 7
Anderson: 5
Camará: 6
Payne: 4.5
May: 5
CBT: 6
Kanu: 5.5
Referee: 7
Asiimwe: 7
Jones: 6.5
Ness: 7
Edun: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 6.5
Camará: 7
Payne: 4
May: 6
CBT: 7
Kanu:6.5
Referee:6
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 6.5
Edun: 7
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 6
Camará: 4
Payne: 4
May: 4
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 7
Referee: 7
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6
Ness: 7
Edun: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 6
Camará:5.5
Payne: 3
May: 5.5
CBT: 6
Kanu: 7
Referee:6
Asiimwe: 6
Jones: 6.5
Ness: 6
Edun: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Anderson: 7
Camará: 6
Payne: 3
May: 5
CBT: 6.5
Kanu: 7.5
Referee: 5 (was fine but how was that not a last man red card?)
Asiimwe: 6.5 - Did OK, but still very inexperienced
Jones: 6.5 - Did OK
Ness: 6.5 - Ditto
Edun: 6.5 - Still trying to understand what works and what doesn't with these team-mates
Dobson: 7 - Gosh, where would our midfield be without him
Anderson: 5 - Game seemed to pass him by
Camará: 6 - Some good stuff but they swarmed over him and he struggled to break free
Payne: 4.5 - Slowed everything down and went round in circles
May: 4 - Love-fest over; he hit post when should have scored, and that awful free kick...hmmm.
CBT: 6 - Our best outlet but teams know what he is going to do....
Kanu: 6.5 - Provided balance (at last) and help for May; took his goal very well.
Referee: 6 - He did OK but these new regs re yellows/reds are strange
ineligible but can be a marked
Hector: 6
Taylor: 6
Thomas: 6
AMB: 5.5 Still questions marks over him for me, shouldn't really be trying to save that and trying to keep the ball in play, and he got a strong hand on the ball, worries me with the ball at his feet.
Asiimwe: 7 I thought he was really good, got great energy, comfortable on the ball, happy to have the ball in tight spaces, needs to work on his final delivery, and maybe for the winner, I can't work out if it is his man or Ness yet, there was a big overload on that side.
Jones: 6 defended well, but he looks long to quickly, needs to be more comfortable on the ball
Ness: 6.5 as above, he is a little more comfortable, but does look like he will give the ball away easily
Edun: 8 I thought he was excellent, ran himself in to the ground, very good going forward, good at defending, only thing that worries me, is that he will get caught out to high up the pitch.
Dobson: 9 he was outstanding last night, in fact on of his best performances in a Charlton shirt, didn't deserve to be on the losing side, looks like he has upped his game now, very confident on the ball, happy to turn and look for forward passes.
Anderson: 6 good moments, and nice pass for the goal, but goes missing and gets caught on the ball.
Camará: 7 not fully fit, but he is a driving force with the ball, his control isn't the best, maybe that will get better with fitness. Needs to cut out silly mistakes, if he can, we have a very good player.
Payne: 4 sorry, that was not good enough, always caught on the ball, knocked off easily, runs in to trouble. Feel sorry for him, as there is a player in him, but it isn't working. Maybe a move is required.
May: 5 lacking confidence, it is only 3 games in, he shouldn't be lacking it. Missed couple of chances, he does try hard.. I hate the fact he is offside so much, doesn't allow us to win the 2nd balls.
CBT: 6.5 if he had an end product, he wouldn't be with us, he would be top end premier league player, and that's the reason he is in League One.. We look so dangerous when he has the ball, but we don't score enough of the chances he creates for others and himself.
Kanu: 8 looked total different player to what we have seen previously, he normally looks sluggish, and lacks control - not tonight, looked sharp, hungry, quick, great control and confident.. Maybe the penny has dropped and it is time for Kanu to shine.
Referee: 7 not a lot to do, only one decision, was if to send the man off when May was through, I think he got it right, 3 players hot on his tail, and they was quicker, they was getting back.
ineligible but can be a marked
Hector: 4 what has happened to him, looks unfit, not bothered and looks like a mistake waiting to happen.
Taylor: 6 looked tidy on the ball, I like the way he drills the balls in to players. He will get better with game time.
Thomas: 5 didn't notice him when he come on!
Asiimwe: 6 - stuck to his job, still only young and will learn by playing games.
Jones: 6 - did ok, but getting fed up with having to make defensive substitutions because he hasn’t got 90 mins in the tank.
Ness: 7 - not his biggest fan, but did well last night, great recovery block on the line.
Edun: 7 - very good first half, tired in the 2nd
Dobson: 7.5 - excellent again. Has added anew dimension to his game.
Anderson: 6 - did ok.
Camará:5.5 - one excellent burst down the pitch, but looked off the pace for large parts of the game.
Payne: 3 - Needless foul cost us. I’m not really sure what he offers and, ultimately not good enough.
May: 5 - should have scored, desperately need a strike partner. Stay onside FFS.
CBT: 7 - Always a threat, but needs an end product.
Kanu: 6.5 - pleased he got a goal, we looked more likely with him on the pitch, long term I’m not so sure.
Referee: 5 - needs to revisit the rule book.