Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Michael Appleton - Sacked 23/1/2024 (p105)

194959799100124

Comments

  • seth plum said:
    JohnnyH2 said:
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    We have had loads of owners and high profile supporters who have previously supported other clubs, did you have an issue with all of them?
    My issue would be around understanding why they switched from other clubs.
    I call it the David Mellor curiosity.
    Anyway I don't believe Methven has switched from Oxford United to Charlton Athletic, do you believe that?
    No I don't believe Methven has switched his allegiance. Just wanted to check your consistency 
  • edited January 2024
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    No it's not.

    He's getting a wage, and then hoping he'll get a share of a sale.

    Obvious why he's here, just less clear whether any of them have any idea how to achieve that.
     I agree. But he wouldn't say that to your face as a fan. He would tell you something completely different.
    so I guess you could call that a little fuzzy.

    For me, he's not a lot different to Southall. He just managed to dupe people with actual wealth into getting involved.
    Looks like he's getting the same results though!
  • thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
  • seth plum said:
    JohnnyH2 said:
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    We have had loads of owners and high profile supporters who have previously supported other clubs, did you have an issue with all of them?
    My issue would be around understanding why they switched from other clubs.
    I call it the David Mellor curiosity.
    Anyway I don't believe Methven has switched from Oxford United to Charlton Athletic, do you believe that?
    Really don't get why if your a part owner of a football club you have to support that club. Were the Saudis massive newscastle or man city fans? Was John Berylson a massive Millwall fan ? I could go on. Really can't see the logic of the argument football is a buisness. 
  • seth plum said:
    thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
     I do actually think he's got some skin in the game Seth. Not a lot in the grand scheme of things but probably a lot for him.
  • seth plum said:
    thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
     I do actually think he's got some skin in the game Seth. Not a lot in the grand scheme of things but probably a lot for him.
    Hes a very small part in all of this imo and recent events have proven he hasn't got as much clout as people think.
  • Common sense will tell us that those running the club would definitely have had a meeting to discuss Appleton's future. It will also tell us that this would have been a dangerous meeting for Appleton. Then I imagine I was part of that meeting. I would probably say that Appleton now has the opportunity to change the defence, midfield and attack and whilst Burton wasn't great, because players were too new to the club he probably had less ability to fix the defence. So I would be for giving him the next two games but only one if the performance was dire against Northampton. Appleton seems to know he has to turn it round fast. I think he didn't refer to very quickly in his press conference, but very, VERY, quickly! I think that is reasonable and I would hope that fans give the club full support to help him achieve that even if they think it is unlikely.
  • Do love an ownership conspiracy theory 
  • jondon76 said:
    seth plum said:
    JohnnyH2 said:
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    We have had loads of owners and high profile supporters who have previously supported other clubs, did you have an issue with all of them?
    My issue would be around understanding why they switched from other clubs.
    I call it the David Mellor curiosity.
    Anyway I don't believe Methven has switched from Oxford United to Charlton Athletic, do you believe that?
    Really don't get why if your a part owner of a football club you have to support that club. Were the Saudis massive newscastle or man city fans? Was John Berylson a massive Millwall fan ? I could go on. Really can't see the logic of the argument football is a buisness. 
    I get that too.
    But our present misery hurts more for the Charlton supporters than the Oxford Supporters, and if it is hurting, Charlton supporters are much more likely to go that extra mile to put things right, they can't walk away.
  • Sponsored links:


  • seth plum said:
    thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
     I do actually think he's got some skin in the game Seth. Not a lot in the grand scheme of things but probably a lot for him.
    Do you remember the excellent Airman quote where he said we are a club where the management has chosen the ownership?
    Maybe that is all wrong, but the buck stops somewhere.
  • jondon76 said:
    seth plum said:
    thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
     I do actually think he's got some skin in the game Seth. Not a lot in the grand scheme of things but probably a lot for him.
    Hes a very small part in all of this imo and recent events have proven he hasn't got as much clout as people think.
    Do we know who has the most or the actual clout at Charlton Athletic?
  • On the pre match interview on Charlton TV Appleton said he took training yesterday morning.
  • Common sense will tell us that those running the club would definitely have had a meeting to discuss Appleton's future. It will also tell us that this would have been a dangerous meeting for Appleton. Then I imagine I was part of that meeting. I would probably say that Appleton now has the opportunity to change the defence, midfield and attack and whilst Burton wasn't great, because players were too new to the club he probably had less ability to fix the defence. So I would be for giving him the next two games but only one if the performance was dire against Northampton. Appleton seems to know he has to turn it round fast. I think he didn't refer to very quickly in his press conference, but very, VERY, quickly! I think that is reasonable and I would hope that fans give the club full support to help him achieve that even if they think it is unlikely.
    I agree with all of this. I think we might have hit a point where some people have such a personal dislike of MA that they would rather he didn’t turn it around so that he can be sacked. 

    18 managers in 17 years (or whatever it is) suggests maybe we aren’t giving people enough time - I don’t think he’s a world-beater but with the right tools he could probably get us out of this league. Saying that if he’s lost the dressing room then it may be time to go but I think he deserves two more games to see if he can work something out with the new arrivals. 

    Generally I cringe when it all gets a bit ‘man who’s managed over 500 football league matches is clueless and tactically inept’ says ex U11 school captain Steve in Eltham, 36.
  • Property play

    Methven moving Oxford to the Valley and building a 2 up 2 down on the Kassam stadium or whatever its called. The £1m+ net spent on players is just a red herring to cover his dastardly plan


  • Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    I make Seth right regards Methven, I cannot see how people can disagree with him.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Owners are owners, boards are boards and management are management. The latter answerable to the two layers above (i.e., through the Board).

    I believe those that passed the information they had received on did it in good faith and from a certain point of view - that view being UK management’s which was likely prematurely leaked. If the latter is true, it is utterly naive but of course may not be true, who really knows other than the mouth pieces themselves? 

    If I were the main investors I think about how would I likely respond to the proposal that the first team coach be sacked? Firstly, I would be asking the UK SMT what they have been doing to deal with the issues and results run that has unfolded of late (day to day)? I would also be asking AS specifically why he so convincingly put forward this coach if his character traits and style, let alone record overall was not befitting of the promotion push they were funding, nor a rapport with fans being built? 

    Point being, if I was an investor I would be scrutinising the actions, motivations and results of the SMT as a whole, more than simply looking at an individual that reports to them, no matter how important results on the pitch may be in this business. That individual may be the biggest problem at the moment, but it could also be as a result of the sum of many background parts…?

    Who knows what has been said since the leak, it is feasible that the SMT and MA have been collectively told to get us into position x by y timeframe or you are all out of the door…
  • seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    Quite how you navigate life when you suspect there is a conspiracy against your interests under every leaf I can’t imagine. 
    How do you come to the conclusion that I suspect there is a conspiracy against my interests under every leaf?
    If I am guilty of repetition, I suggest in this matter you are guilty of exaggeration.
  • seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    thenewbie said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    No. I have a problem with the theory that Methven is deliberately doing badly because he's an Oxford fan, which 1.) is nonsensical - he's just incompetent, it's not a conspiracy and 2.) Gets repeatedly bought up over and over and over again.

    I've got problems with Methven. I certainly don't like him or think he's much use. But this Oxford stuff is just boring now.
    I have not said that it is deliberate, but emphasised the point that in my view for Methven failure at Charlton is no biggie because he can escape into the arms of Oxford United to forget his troubles.
    I focus on Methven because he seems to be the person in charge.
     I do actually think he's got some skin in the game Seth. Not a lot in the grand scheme of things but probably a lot for him.
    Do you remember the excellent Airman quote where he said we are a club where the management has chosen the ownership?
    Maybe that is all wrong, but the buck stops somewhere.
    But presumably can't sack them. The management are the owners facilitators and expendable at their whim.

    Not sure I'm actually disagreeing with you here as my brain is so befuddled after yesterday's shenanigans. 🤔
  • edited January 2024
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    seth plum said:
    I think it may be the case that the real boss, Methven, is more occupied with thinking about his beloved Oxford United (where Appleton used to work) than being concerned with our progress as a football club.
    I wish you’d give it a rest Seth. 
    OK.
    Can you compare your personal interest in Charlton Athletic with Charlie Methven's?
    I know which one of the two of you is most likely to get a Charlton crest tattooed on your forearm.
    The reason why Methven is here is obscure and foggy to say the least, and if it all goes wrong who do you believe will feel the most pain, you or Methven?
    He will be able to schlepp off to the Kassam to take his mind off things.
    Maybe what Methven brings to the table which you and I lack is cool intelligent objectivity, coupled with the present miserable failure that is accompanying him at the moment.
    Plenty of posters are repetitive around certain things, Methven being a 'U' is one of mine, is that so bad.

    P.S. I don't trust him.

    Quite how you navigate life when you suspect there is a conspiracy against your interests under every leaf I can’t imagine. 
    How do you come to the conclusion that I suspect there is a conspiracy against my interests under every leaf?
    If I am guilty of repetition, I suggest in this matter you are guilty of exaggeration.
    Who, Shooters "7 inch soft" Guru?
  • Gribbo said:
    Forgive me.
    Have people got a problem with Seth because he's got a problem with Methven?
    Really?
    I make Seth right regards Methven, I cannot see how people can disagree with him.
    Think what some people are saying is that, whether Methven and his investors are proper Charlton or not, its most probably still in their best interest that the Club is moving upwards rather than downwards. If that is the case, why lose sleep over their motivation as long as we get to the shared common goal?
    Perhaps Seth's angle is wtf does Methven not go and work for Oxford and f*** it up there?
    PS, I am not related to Seth.
  • Charlton Athletic...Casey's Court more like...🤡🤡
  • Is there a Methven thread?
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!