Said it before saying it again.ness is not good enough as for Kirk should never get near the first team again one shit player no more excuses about this and that just funk you useless prick
Applescore: 5 WALKER: 4 ABANKWAH: 5 NESS: 3 THOMAS: 5 EDUN: 5 McGRANDLES: 5 ANDERSON: 3 FRASER: 6 (surprised to see him marked so low, though he looked composed and tidy and took his goal well) C.CAMPBELL: 6 TEDIĆ: 5 KIRK: 1 (Genuinely think we would have been better with ten men) ASIIMWE: 4 T.WATSON: 4 MAY: 4 Referee: 6 LEABURN: n/a L.WATSON: n/a
Applescore: 4 - I think he was probably surprised at how bad some of these professionals did, but ultimately he got it very wrong and not beating a side 4 divisions apart may even warrant a lower score.
WALKER: 4.5 - complete guff, another one who looks like a waste of wages early doors.
ABANKWAH: 4 - out of position but seems to be another dud loan signing, question marks from me when he first signed him
NESS: 3 - Experienced enough now to look comfortable in a game like this and he didn't, docked 1.5 for the poor own goal.
THOMAS: 5 - didn't have much to do but again looked like a player from the same division
EDUN: 5 - Benefit of the doubt as he's returning to match fitness but I am worried the left back bad luck streak continues and we have another player not quite ready.
McGRANDLES: 4.5 - couldn't boss a midfield against part-timers and was hooked for not being able to control the game. Poor run out.
ANDERSON: 4.5 - Expected way more from Anderson who has faced up against a much higher level of opposition this season already.
FRASER: 5 - now this may seem harsh as he scored, but for such a vastly experienced player, who was a captain on the night and knowing how high he regards himself, he didn't look a cut above at all. He should have coasted this game and wracked up goal contributions imo.
C.CAMPBELL: 4.5 - Didn't do enough to warrant a higher score.
TEDIĆ: 4 - Man City were scammed in this instance. He reminds me of a Roland Rat signing. Out of place and didn't even look a cut above well below non-league standard.
KIRK: 3.5 - I don't think he was much worse than any of the others but he has a target on his back and performances like that won't help him. He shirks challenges and looks completely incompetent with the ball at his feet with a lack of work rate. Severely disappointing for such a big money signing.
ASIIMWE: 4.5 - Tried to attack, lost his man a few times.
T.WATSON: 4.5 - short cameo, hardly noticed
MAY: 5- ill probably never rate him lower tbf, 5 for trying despite being surrounded by utter guff.
Referee: 4.5. Allowed players to stay down too long, didn't seem up to it
Applescore: 3 -shouldn’t have made 11 changes but players picked should have beaten a team of part timers WALKER: 3 -not impressed looked shaky ABANKWAH: 4 - okay NESS: 3 - has gone so far backwards THOMAS: 3 -not great EDUN: 4 -okay after being out for sometime McGRANDLES: 4 -same as Edun ANDERSON: 3 -lost the ball that lead to their goal FRASER: 5 -only thing he did was score missing for large parts C.CAMPBELL: 5 -not too bad TEDIĆ: 3 -don’t know what Man City see in this bloke KIRK: 1 -no comment ASIIMWE: 3.5 -takes the wrong option so many times T.WATSON: 3 -not impressed MAY: 4 -didn’t make any difference today Referee: 5 LEABURN: n/a L.WATSON: n/a
Applescore: 3 I get why he made so many changes, there was certainly enough on the pitch to get the job done comfortable. WALKER: 2 absolute nervous wreck, I think an outfield player could do a better job. I really hope AMB doesn't get injured, if he does, we are in big trouble on that showing. ABANKWAH: 4 actually thought he was the better of our defence, couple good blocks and tackles, but doesn't look comfortable at full back. NESS: 3 woeful, what has happened to him, looks slow, lacking confidence, decision making is poor THOMAS: 2 terrible, gave the ball away so often. EDUN: 4 Could tell he is rusty, but even on this performance, he would be an upgrade on Thomas. He does seem to run in to trouble a lot. McGRANDLES: 5 thought he was the best of our midfield, kept it fairly tidy, but didn't really take control of the game, how you would like a midfielder to. ANDERSON: 4 got around the pitch, but some very poor decision making. Not sure if that pass was for Fraser, or if it was for Tedic. FRASER: 4 took the goal well, and he should have gone on to have a bigger impact on the game. Bit of a disappointing performance C.CAMPBELL: 6 our best player by some distance, looked to try and make things happen. TEDIĆ: 4 so nice touches, but doesn't do enough for my liking, but to be fair, not a lot of service KIRK: 2 performance of someone who doesn't want to be at the club, feel for him a little as the club should have just done the right thing and release him in the summer. ASIIMWE: 3 gave us a little more attacking threat when he come in. T.WATSON: 2 didn't notice him MAY: 4 huffed and puffed Referee: 3 not the best was he.. But no excuse for our result LEABURN: 5 should have come on before May, started to look bit more dangerous once he come on. L.WATSON: 4 he was frustrated by the lack of movement.
Applescore: 5 I would probably have played the same 11, there should have been enough quality about the squad, but the players let him down big time. WALKER: 3 - let's hope we can keep AMB fit ABANKWAH: 2 - not a full back or wing back NESS: 2 - shows we have no depth in central defenders area THOMAS: 2 - so poor for such an experienced player EDUN: 3 - very rusty McGRANDLES: 4 - thought he was one of the 'better' ones ANDERSON: 4 - at least showed some desire FRASER: 2 - lost his place in starting line up and on this performance is way off getting it back, fourth choiche behind Watson and Karoy now C.CAMPBELL: 4 - see Anderson TEDIĆ: 2 - struggling to see what he brings to the team KIRK: 1 - couldn't believe my eyes ASIIMWE: 3 T.WATSON: 2 MAY: 3 Referee: 5 LEABURN: n/a L.WATSON: n/a
Applescore: 3 WALKER: 5 not much to do so difficult to judge ABANKWAH: 4 NESS: 4 don't blame him for own goal but poor otherwise THOMAS: 4.5 EDUN: 5 think he will be OK when fully fit McGRANDLES: 4.5 benefit of doubt as 1st game back ANDERSON: 4 FRASER: 5 started well C.CAMPBELL: 6 looked ok, at least he tried to be positive TEDIĆ: 3 KIRK: 2 +1 for getting in position to score ASIIMWE: 4 lots of energy but no end priduct T.WATSON: 4 meh MAY: 4.5 no impact Referee: 5.5 LEABURN: n/a L.WATSON: n/a
Applescore: 3 WALKER: 4.5 ABANKWAH: 4.5 NESS: 3.5 THOMAS: 4 EDUN: 5 McGRANDLES: 5 ANDERSON: 4 FRASER: 5.5 C.CAMPBELL: 6 TEDIĆ: 3 KIRK: 0.5 ASIIMWE: 3 T.WATSON: 3.5 MAY: 5.5 Referee: 3 - Really biased towards us in the first half, then seemed to switch up entirely for the second half. No real control over timewasting.
Comments
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 3
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 5
Referee: 6
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 5
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 6
FRASER: 6
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 4
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5
Referee: 7
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 2
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 2
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 2
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 4
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 2
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 2
MAY: 5
Referee: 7
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 5
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 6
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 3
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 6
MAY: 6
Referee: 6
WALKER: 3
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 3
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 0
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 3
I am not a betting man, but Kirk will surely break the record for lowest ever Charlton Life score here.
WALKER: 6
ABANKWAH: 6.5
NESS: 5
THOMAS: 6
EDUN: 5.5
McGRANDLES: 5.5
ANDERSON: 6
FRASER: 6.5
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 6
KIRK: 5.5
ASIIMWE: 6
T.WATSON: 5.5
MAY: 5.5
Referee: 7
ANDERSON: 4.5 - Expected way more from Anderson who has faced up against a much higher level of opposition this season already.
C.CAMPBELL: 4.5 - Didn't do enough to warrant a higher score.
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 3
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3.5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 4.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 5
Referee: 7
WALKER: 3 -not impressed looked shaky
ABANKWAH: 4 - okay
NESS: 3 - has gone so far backwards
THOMAS: 3 -not great
EDUN: 4 -okay after being out for sometime
McGRANDLES: 4 -same as Edun
ANDERSON: 3 -lost the ball that lead to their goal
FRASER: 5 -only thing he did was score missing for large parts
C.CAMPBELL: 5 -not too bad
TEDIĆ: 3 -don’t know what Man City see in this bloke
KIRK: 1 -no comment
ASIIMWE: 3.5 -takes the wrong option so many times
T.WATSON: 3 -not impressed
MAY: 4 -didn’t make any difference today
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6 Thought he was decent.
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 3
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5
WALKER: 3.5
ABANKWAH: 3
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 3
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 3
C.CAMPBELL: 3
TEDIĆ: 2
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 2.5
MAY: 4
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 4
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 4
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
Referee:
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 2 absolute nervous wreck, I think an outfield player could do a better job. I really hope AMB doesn't get injured, if he does, we are in big trouble on that showing.
ABANKWAH: 4 actually thought he was the better of our defence, couple good blocks and tackles, but doesn't look comfortable at full back.
NESS: 3 woeful, what has happened to him, looks slow, lacking confidence, decision making is poor
THOMAS: 2 terrible, gave the ball away so often.
EDUN: 4 Could tell he is rusty, but even on this performance, he would be an upgrade on Thomas. He does seem to run in to trouble a lot.
McGRANDLES: 5 thought he was the best of our midfield, kept it fairly tidy, but didn't really take control of the game, how you would like a midfielder to.
ANDERSON: 4 got around the pitch, but some very poor decision making. Not sure if that pass was for Fraser, or if it was for Tedic.
FRASER: 4 took the goal well, and he should have gone on to have a bigger impact on the game. Bit of a disappointing performance
C.CAMPBELL: 6 our best player by some distance, looked to try and make things happen.
TEDIĆ: 4 so nice touches, but doesn't do enough for my liking, but to be fair, not a lot of service
KIRK: 2 performance of someone who doesn't want to be at the club, feel for him a little as the club should have just done the right thing and release him in the summer.
ASIIMWE: 3 gave us a little more attacking threat when he come in.
T.WATSON: 2 didn't notice him
MAY: 4 huffed and puffed
Referee: 3 not the best was he.. But no excuse for our result
LEABURN: 5 should have come on before May, started to look bit more dangerous once he come on.
L.WATSON: 4 he was frustrated by the lack of movement.
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 2.5
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 4
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 5.5
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 5
Referee: 6
WALKER: 3 - let's hope we can keep AMB fit
ABANKWAH: 2 - not a full back or wing back
NESS: 2 - shows we have no depth in central defenders area
THOMAS: 2 - so poor for such an experienced player
EDUN: 3 - very rusty
McGRANDLES: 4 - thought he was one of the 'better' ones
ANDERSON: 4 - at least showed some desire
FRASER: 2 - lost his place in starting line up and on this performance is way off getting it back, fourth choiche behind Watson and Karoy now
C.CAMPBELL: 4 - see Anderson
TEDIĆ: 2 - struggling to see what he brings to the team
KIRK: 1 - couldn't believe my eyes
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 2
MAY: 3
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 5 not much to do so difficult to judge
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 4 don't blame him for own goal but poor otherwise
THOMAS: 4.5
EDUN: 5 think he will be OK when fully fit
McGRANDLES: 4.5 benefit of doubt as 1st game back
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5 started well
C.CAMPBELL: 6 looked ok, at least he tried to be positive
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 2 +1 for getting in position to score
ASIIMWE: 4 lots of energy but no end priduct
T.WATSON: 4 meh
MAY: 4.5 no impact
Referee: 5.5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 3
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 4
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 4.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 2
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
my lowest ever marks
ABANKWAH: 3.5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 5.5
McGRANDLES: 5.5
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 5.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 2
ASIIMWE: 5.5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5.5
WALKER: 4.5
ABANKWAH: 4.5
NESS: 3.5
THOMAS: 4
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 0.5
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3.5
MAY: 5.5
Referee: 3 - Really biased towards us in the first half, then seemed to switch up entirely for the second half. No real control over timewasting.
WALKER: -5
ABANKWAH: 5.5
NESS: 5
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 6.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 4
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5
Referee: 6
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a