Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
January 2024 Transfer Rumours (D/day starts pg.263)
Comments
-
With recent comments Andy Scott has set himself up to fail. At the moment he’s succeeding in doing just that.7
-
I’m wondering if the Club now have reservations about Appleton and instead of lumbering us with permanent signings who a new manager will not want are happy for Appleton to bolster the squad with loanees so that when he’s sacked in February/March he’s not done too much damage long term.
Just a thought and time will tell.9 -
Jesus. You do realise “view to permanent” means absolutely nothing if they are out of contract at the end of the loan. It means us, and any other club can make them a permanent player.RonnieMoore said:
Loan signings with view to permanent move .. completely diff from a loan of a young player or someone needing to get fit …. excellent signings for the club and big move to improving us as a team and allow MA to play 352Addick_8 said:Nothing screams longevity more than 2 loan signings 🤣Also, how many times have you seen either play to call them “excellent players”5 -
Andy Scott is technical director Ronnie, he is responsible for the recruitment of players to the club, and those who depart. Whatever resources or advice he takes or uses, he is ultimately responsible. You will find that is how it works and he is answerable to the board whilst holding that post.RonnieMoore said:
Scott only acting on the manager’s and recruitmentBailey said:
Wise words mate, Wise words.golfaddick said:Seeing as its been confirmed that Tedic has gone back, and we believe that Abankwa has too, and then added into the mix that both Watson & Campbell have hardly been played by Appleton, can it be justified to say that Andy Scott's loan deals have a lot to be desired.Data Analyst…..3 -
More bollocks! One hasn't played all season the other can't get in a team that's threatened with relegation!RonnieMoore said:
Loan signings with view to permanent move .. completely diff from a loan of a young player or someone needing to get fit …. excellent signings for the club and big move to improving us as a team and allow MA to play 352Addick_8 said:Nothing screams longevity more than 2 loan signings 🤣
Nowhere does it say they are signings with a view to permanent, in fact I'm sure I read that Florin (sp) signed a 5 Yr contract in 2021 hence he's under contract until 2026!
Please stop making shit up....you know fuck all about anything! Stop pretending or provide proof! You're really winding me up tonight! Give it a fucking rest!6 -
6 -
NoBigDiddy said:
What should we do after 15 years of bullshite and decline - rejoice at shit owners, shit manager, shit squad and shit loanees?swordfish said:
It frustrates me to see such negativity too, but I do get why the level of scepticism has never been higher. Until the day the sceptics are proved wrong, and they do want to be, I don't doubt that, then unfortunately we're in for more of the same.Callumcafc said:
Signing from league above = castoffs or injury prone, not willing to pay the going rate for a good oneNabySarr said:
We haven’t signed any of them yet so it means nothing, but I think all 4 look like they’d be good signings. Personally Coventry and Docherty would be the standouts so I hope we get at least 1 of them doneBraziliance said:None of the links so far have impressed me bar JCH who I suspect we won't shell out for and Docherty could be a coup but again I don't see it. JCH could be formidable with May and Docherty is your very box-to-box type. Would make a great partner with Dobbo assuming the captain stays.
Coventry I really am not sure about, don't know enough/haven't watched him enough. I've seen a lot of people mention his MK Dons performance, but we are pants and I've seen loads of players do well against us and not light the pitch up in other games. Especially towards the end of Jackos tenure where we genuinely looked useless.
One signing I definitely don't like the sound of is Gillesphey which is probably the one who is a goer out of the lot. We have made the mistake too many times of taking other clubs bit part players who are struggling with injuries in particular. This screams of that. I've seen Plymouth fans annoyed when he allegedly failed the medical and saying 'more bad luck' and seen some pretty in-depth reports on him.
Basically sounds like he has no pace (which we struggle with as is) isn't particularly strong or an aerial threat but his main strength is he can ping a ball and in a back 3 he is dependable. We don't play a back 3 and as much as I give him grief, we already have Hector who can ping a ball to all of our non-physical forwards.
Just sounds like an on the cheap window again, especially if we can't get JCH who is proven and does what he says on the tin and we now know is realistic.
There are quality players in this league and below, why are we going for the ones who are out of favour at their current clubs or coming back from injuries? Same old Charlton for me
There is nothing wrong with signing players from leagues above, in fact it should be encouraged surely? Better than the likes of Jaiyesimi, Payne, Egbo, Kirk, Lavelle etc that we’ve signed from Leagues 1 & 2. The best L1/L2 players cost millions nowadays, we can’t afford that. Better players for better value exist in championship squads
Signings from this league = just because he played well against us doesn’t mean anything, probably wants more than we’re willing to pay
Signings from league below = never going to make the step up, won’t want a big wage
These are the conclusions you can draw when you have a pre-determined outcome in your head.0 -
That League 1 News account is ran by a teenager undoubtedly, they copy and paste a fuck ton of tweets.
They're probably just going by what is being said on the cafc hashtag and going with it for interactions. That's what that account does on a day to day basis, it's not an ITK account @Yann8970 -
Hearing strong rumours that both Dobson and Blackett-Taylor are so impressed by the quality of our 2 new signings that it is thought likely they will sign their new contracts as soon as tomorrow.26
-
Sponsored links:
-
I take it by your demeanour BigDiddy, that your Christmas wasn't quite the roaring success you were hoping for ! 😊swordfish said:
NoBigDiddy said:
What should we do after 15 years of bullshite and decline - rejoice at shit owners, shit manager, shit squad and shit loanees?swordfish said:
It frustrates me to see such negativity too, but I do get why the level of scepticism has never been higher. Until the day the sceptics are proved wrong, and they do want to be, I don't doubt that, then unfortunately we're in for more of the same.Callumcafc said:
Signing from league above = castoffs or injury prone, not willing to pay the going rate for a good oneNabySarr said:
We haven’t signed any of them yet so it means nothing, but I think all 4 look like they’d be good signings. Personally Coventry and Docherty would be the standouts so I hope we get at least 1 of them doneBraziliance said:None of the links so far have impressed me bar JCH who I suspect we won't shell out for and Docherty could be a coup but again I don't see it. JCH could be formidable with May and Docherty is your very box-to-box type. Would make a great partner with Dobbo assuming the captain stays.
Coventry I really am not sure about, don't know enough/haven't watched him enough. I've seen a lot of people mention his MK Dons performance, but we are pants and I've seen loads of players do well against us and not light the pitch up in other games. Especially towards the end of Jackos tenure where we genuinely looked useless.
One signing I definitely don't like the sound of is Gillesphey which is probably the one who is a goer out of the lot. We have made the mistake too many times of taking other clubs bit part players who are struggling with injuries in particular. This screams of that. I've seen Plymouth fans annoyed when he allegedly failed the medical and saying 'more bad luck' and seen some pretty in-depth reports on him.
Basically sounds like he has no pace (which we struggle with as is) isn't particularly strong or an aerial threat but his main strength is he can ping a ball and in a back 3 he is dependable. We don't play a back 3 and as much as I give him grief, we already have Hector who can ping a ball to all of our non-physical forwards.
Just sounds like an on the cheap window again, especially if we can't get JCH who is proven and does what he says on the tin and we now know is realistic.
There are quality players in this league and below, why are we going for the ones who are out of favour at their current clubs or coming back from injuries? Same old Charlton for me
There is nothing wrong with signing players from leagues above, in fact it should be encouraged surely? Better than the likes of Jaiyesimi, Payne, Egbo, Kirk, Lavelle etc that we’ve signed from Leagues 1 & 2. The best L1/L2 players cost millions nowadays, we can’t afford that. Better players for better value exist in championship squads
Signings from this league = just because he played well against us doesn’t mean anything, probably wants more than we’re willing to pay
Signings from league below = never going to make the step up, won’t want a big wage
These are the conclusions you can draw when you have a pre-determined outcome in your head.1 -
We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.24 -
Spot on unfortunately.ozaddick said:We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.1 -
How about wait and see how these two are before you jump the gun?ozaddick said:We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.16 -
Actually agree with this post, it seems like lessons haven't been learn't after the signings of Taylor and Camara. Both Camara and Taylor had limited minutes of football in the previous six months and were obviously a risk, Appleton needs to give the two new signings some game time in the reserves before blooding them in the first team.ozaddick said:We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.3 -
Scar tissuecafcsinger said:
How about wait and see how these two are before you jump the gun?ozaddick said:We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.
We have it due to the shit windows we've endured recently
Happy to be proven wrong
Hopefully0 -
Positives:
- our midfield is terrible at the moment, these 2 are better than what we have fit and available so have improved the team
- Bakinson offers height/physicality and a bit of defensive ability. Fiorini offers creativity. All things we are really lacking at the moment
Negatives:
- 2 loans, at least with Bakinson there looks to be a decent chance of a permanent deal. Hopefully the same is true for Fiorini and it’s not just him auditioning for a championship loan next season
- neither have played much football so I’m doubtful they will be able to go straight into the 11 and play every minute
3 -
Fiorini is under contract till the summer of 2026. I can’t see City letting him go on the cheap if he’s any good.NabySarr said:Positives:
- our midfield is terrible at the moment, these 2 are better than what we have fit and available so have improved the team
- Bakinson offers height/physicality and a bit of defensive ability. Fiorini offers creativity. All things we are really lacking at the moment
Negatives:
- 2 loans, at least with Bakinson there looks to be a decent chance of a permanent deal. Hopefully the same is true for Fiorini and it’s not just him auditioning for a championship loan next season
- neither have played much football so I’m doubtful they will be able to go straight into the 11 and play every minute2 -
We need players to come in and play now, not in a month's time. We are six points above the relegation zone with a tough run of fixtures coming up. Will this lot never learn for fucks sake!NabySarr said:Positives:
- our midfield is terrible at the moment, these 2 are better than what we have fit and available so have improved the team
- Bakinson offers height/physicality and a bit of defensive ability. Fiorini offers creativity. All things we are really lacking at the moment
Negatives:
- 2 loans, at least with Bakinson there looks to be a decent chance of a permanent deal. Hopefully the same is true for Fiorini and it’s not just him auditioning for a championship loan next season
- neither have played much football so I’m doubtful they will be able to go straight into the 11 and play every minute6 -
I think someone can be very good at this level and nothing like good enough for Man City. (Tedic it seems was simply not good enough for either) I would imagine if he does well then a season long loan next season would be the most likely outcome.LargeAddick said:
Fiorini is under contract till the summer of 2026. I can’t see City letting him go on the cheap if he’s any good.NabySarr said:Positives:
- our midfield is terrible at the moment, these 2 are better than what we have fit and available so have improved the team
- Bakinson offers height/physicality and a bit of defensive ability. Fiorini offers creativity. All things we are really lacking at the moment
Negatives:
- 2 loans, at least with Bakinson there looks to be a decent chance of a permanent deal. Hopefully the same is true for Fiorini and it’s not just him auditioning for a championship loan next season
- neither have played much football so I’m doubtful they will be able to go straight into the 11 and play every minute0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Two additions but far from match fitness by the sounds of it. They will probably need a month before they can play in the first team. Any earlier and there is a big chance they will end up in the treatment room until the end of the seson.
Just cannot see these loans improving our results in the short term - if at all.
Happy days.7 -
I agree but I was responding to someone suggesting Fiorini could become a permanent deal possibly.RC_CAFC said:
I think someone can be very good at this level and nothing like good enough for Man City. (Tedic it seems was simply not good enough for either) I would imagine if he does well then a season long loan next season would be the most likely outcome.LargeAddick said:
Fiorini is under contract till the summer of 2026. I can’t see City letting him go on the cheap if he’s any good.NabySarr said:Positives:
- our midfield is terrible at the moment, these 2 are better than what we have fit and available so have improved the team
- Bakinson offers height/physicality and a bit of defensive ability. Fiorini offers creativity. All things we are really lacking at the moment
Negatives:
- 2 loans, at least with Bakinson there looks to be a decent chance of a permanent deal. Hopefully the same is true for Fiorini and it’s not just him auditioning for a championship loan next season
- neither have played much football so I’m doubtful they will be able to go straight into the 11 and play every minute0 -
Somethings not right. The other possible addition (Plymouth defender) also has had recent injuries. Unless the start honouring their pledges I really think fans should be very wary of these owners motives11
-
Do we have time to wait and see? I think not mate. Their playing minutes, or lack of, tell the whole story here. Tell me how they will have an immediate positive impact? They haven't played any footy this season.cafcsinger said:
How about wait and see how these two are before you jump the gun?ozaddick said:We've just signed 2 players, one that has only completed 90 mins once, and the other hasn't played this season at all. What the actual feck are these owners playing at??? These are not signings that will improve our squad. Charlie Kirk has played more minutes than these 2.
I honestly believe that we are yet to hit rock bottom, and, considering how far we have fallen, I fear for the future of the club. I'm bloody gob smacked right now.
They may be good players, but they won't be turning our season around within the next few weeks until they're up to speed. And we do not have the comfort of affording 'new' players weeks of training to be match fit.There is an even greater risk of these 2 joining the injury list, than becoming game changers.
We need starters who are clearly an improvement on what we've got. These are the sound bites coming from our SMT, and yet they serve up 2 unfit players, who may or may not be better than the injured players we already have on the books.9 -
Is what it is! They’ll either be good or shite.
most on here know absolutely nothing about these players!7 -
Well none of us have been proved wrong about what we all thought would happen this window.
Today's unfit duo is another insult. You want to believe that maybe just maybe the Board of chancers would actually break open a piggy bank or two.... Yes there still time to buy JCH and Coventry but I'm not convinced.
I fail to see how these loans can make any difference when they can't even get into the squad for probably at least 3 weeks.
Lost for words.
12 -
Because this is the only signings we'll make this window right?
Fucking hell there's so much bed wetting on here no wonder there's floods across the country14 -
I’ve lost any expectations about our club years ago!Dazzler21 said:
Acclimatise your expectations to our current level.BigDiddy said:
What should we do after 15 years of bullshite and decline - rejoice at shit owners, shit manager, shit squad and shit loanees?swordfish said:
It frustrates me to see such negativity too, but I do get why the level of scepticism has never been higher. Until the day the sceptics are proved wrong, and they do want to be, I don't doubt that, then unfortunately we're in for more of the same.Callumcafc said:
Signing from league above = castoffs or injury prone, not willing to pay the going rate for a good oneNabySarr said:
We haven’t signed any of them yet so it means nothing, but I think all 4 look like they’d be good signings. Personally Coventry and Docherty would be the standouts so I hope we get at least 1 of them doneBraziliance said:None of the links so far have impressed me bar JCH who I suspect we won't shell out for and Docherty could be a coup but again I don't see it. JCH could be formidable with May and Docherty is your very box-to-box type. Would make a great partner with Dobbo assuming the captain stays.
Coventry I really am not sure about, don't know enough/haven't watched him enough. I've seen a lot of people mention his MK Dons performance, but we are pants and I've seen loads of players do well against us and not light the pitch up in other games. Especially towards the end of Jackos tenure where we genuinely looked useless.
One signing I definitely don't like the sound of is Gillesphey which is probably the one who is a goer out of the lot. We have made the mistake too many times of taking other clubs bit part players who are struggling with injuries in particular. This screams of that. I've seen Plymouth fans annoyed when he allegedly failed the medical and saying 'more bad luck' and seen some pretty in-depth reports on him.
Basically sounds like he has no pace (which we struggle with as is) isn't particularly strong or an aerial threat but his main strength is he can ping a ball and in a back 3 he is dependable. We don't play a back 3 and as much as I give him grief, we already have Hector who can ping a ball to all of our non-physical forwards.
Just sounds like an on the cheap window again, especially if we can't get JCH who is proven and does what he says on the tin and we now know is realistic.
There are quality players in this league and below, why are we going for the ones who are out of favour at their current clubs or coming back from injuries? Same old Charlton for me
There is nothing wrong with signing players from leagues above, in fact it should be encouraged surely? Better than the likes of Jaiyesimi, Payne, Egbo, Kirk, Lavelle etc that we’ve signed from Leagues 1 & 2. The best L1/L2 players cost millions nowadays, we can’t afford that. Better players for better value exist in championship squads
Signings from this league = just because he played well against us doesn’t mean anything, probably wants more than we’re willing to pay
Signings from league below = never going to make the step up, won’t want a big wage
These are the conclusions you can draw when you have a pre-determined outcome in your head.
We are a league 1 side with a championship stadium and a fan base with wildly high expectations.
The club will flirt with the dream of returning to the promised land every few years after a rare promotion, but realistically it is out of reach and we will be relegated again after a brief stay in the championship
This cycle will continue until we get unrealistic owners that match the unrealistic expectations.0
