Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Peterborough (closes Sunday teatime)

13»

Comments

  • Apples 4 - poor starting line up - and did not see him shout at T Campbell once - even though he was walking around. 
    AMB 7
    Jones 6.5
    Ness 6
    Thomas 8 best game I have seen him play. Our best player - we need to keep him . 
    T Watson 6
    Dobson 6.5
    Bakinson 7
    Edun 6
    T Campbell 1 Did not seem bothered at all
    May 7
    C Campbell 4 rarely touched the ball
    Kanu 6.5
    L Watson 6.5
    Ref 6.5
  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 6.5
    JONES: 6 Not at his best
    NESS: 7 very good considering he hasn't played for a while
    THOMAS: 8 this looks like his best position, hardly put a foot wrong
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    DOBSON: 5.5 not great today 
    BAKINSON: 7 looks good
    EDUN: 6 some good, some bad, plenty of energy
    T.CAMPBELL: 3 poor
    MAY: 7 did what he does
    C.CAMPBELL: 3.5 poor but at least looked like he was trying
    KANU: 7 tried hard
    L.WATSON: 6.5 ok
    Referee: 5.5
    COVENTRY:n/a looks a class player
    FIORINI: n/a couple of nice touches
  • edited January 14
    Ascore: 6 changed things about
    AMB: 6 some good saves
    JONES: 5.5 looked less confident today
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 6.5 our best defender yesterday, played like he's got a point to make 
    T.WATSON: 6
    DOBSON:  6
    BAKINSON:  7 like him, he faded a bit but had some urgency about him
    EDUN:  6 I was not sure what he was meant to be doing and not sure he was either
    T.CAMPBELL: 4 being generous, lost the ball almost every time he got it
    MAY: 7.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 4.5
    KANU: 7 battled well
    L.WATSON: 6.5 not as effective as we all think he is
    Referee: 5 meh
    COVENTRY:n/a
    FIORINI: n/a
  • Watched on CharltonTV

    A-score: 5 

    AMB: 6 
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 7
    T.WATSON: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 3
    MAY: 7.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 3
    KANU: 7
    L.WATSON: 6.5

    Referee: 4 

  • AMB: 6.5
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 7
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 6.5
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 5
    MAY: 6.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 5
    KANU: 7
    L.WATSON: 6
  • Ascore: 1 - Mr Boring got it very wrong again in the first half, despite 2.5 days work on the training ground
    AMB: 7 - Didn't look comfortable but some good saves
    JONES: 5.5 - Struggled with their movement 
    NESS: 5.5 - Better second half
    THOMAS: 6 - So limited but gives 100% every game
    T.WATSON: 4 - Both goals came from his man; nuff said
    DOBSON: 6 - Not his best game
    BAKINSON: 5.5 - Better second half when he moved
    EDUN: 4 - Loses the ball so many times...
    T.CAMPBELL: 3 - Played out of position and being ruined by the manager
    MAY: 6 - Came alive when he had a partner
    C.CAMPBELL: 5 - Worked hard but little impact
    KANU:  6.5 - Did OK
    L.WATSON: 6 - Got involved and did OK
    Referee:  8 - Did well though little to blow for
  • edited January 14
    AMB: 5.5 
    JONES: 6.5
    NESS: 6.5
    THOMAS: 7.5 thought he played well
    T.WATSON: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7 good debut
    EDUN: 7.5 always positive
    T.CAMPBELL: 5
    MAY: 6.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 6
    KANU: 6.5
    L.WATSON: 6
    Referee: 6
  • Ascore: 3
    AMB: 6
    JONES: 5 lost a mark for the 50p head effort
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 6
    T.WATSON: 4
    DOBSON: 5
    BAKINSON: 7 one of the few to actually put a shift in for both halves
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 1 like playing with 10 men. Body language is atrocious 
    MAY: 7
    C.CAMPBELL: 4
    KANU: 6
    L.WATSON: 6
    Referee: 7
  • At the Valley

    Ascore: 5 Tried something different first half but it didn't work. Tried something different second half and it was much better. It has been glaringly obvious to many that we should be playing two up front.

    AMB: 7 The double save in the second half was great. Distribution still needs to be quicker and better. Had no chance with the goals.
    JONES: 5 Poor game by his standards
    NESS: 6 Decent game and back to form of last season
    THOMAS: 7 Best game for a long time, but playing in natural position helps.
    T.WATSON: 4 Tries hard but not good. He always seems to slow down our progress. He was at fault for second goal, but can't really blame him too much for struggling to get back after a rare burst forward. Someone should have been covering.
    DOBSON: 6 Very average by his standards, but still puts in a huge workload.
    BAKINSON: 6 Looks very promising. Surprisingly mobile for a big guy.
    EDUN: 5 Marginally better than T Watson, but by a small margin.
    T.CAMPBELL: 4 Out-muscled and never got into the game. His confidence needs rebuilding. I still think he has huge potential.
    MAY: 7 Another well taken goal and as usual, loads of effort. Good to have him back.
    C.CAMPBELL: 5 Never really got going.
    KANU: 7 A huge improvement when he came on. Worked really hard and unlucky not to score - great save by keeper.
    L.WATSON: 6 Improved things, but wasn't great.

    Referee: 6 Seemed to give an awful lot to them, but generally I thought he did okay.
     
    COVENTRY:n/a based on this cameo he looks the real deal. Very excited to see the impact he will have. 
    FIORINI: n/a Clearly rusty but some good touches. I hope he can get match fit quickly.
  • Ascore: 6
    AMB: 6
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 4
    MAY: 6.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 4.5
    KANU: 6.5
    L.WATSON: 6
    Referee: 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 6
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 6
    T.WATSON: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6.5
    T.CAMPBELL: 4.5
    MAY: 6.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 4.5
    KANU: 6.5
    L.WATSON: 6
    Referee: 5.5
  • AMB: 6.5
    JONES: 5
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 7
    T.WATSON: 2
    DOBSON: 5.5
    BAKINSON: 7.5
    EDUN: 6 
    T.CAMPBELL: 3
    MAY: 7
    C.CAMPBELL: 3
    KANU: 7
    L.WATSON: 6

  • Ascore: 4
    AMB: 5
    JONES: 4
    NESS: 5
    THOMAS: 4
    T.WATSON: 4
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 6
    EDUN: 6.5
    T.CAMPBELL: 4
    MAY: 6
    C.CAMPBELL: 4
    KANU: 6
    L.WATSON: 5
    The marks a little higher than I would normally give for such a poor performance based on  how good Peterborough are.
  • Ascore:
    AMB: 6.5
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 6
    THOMAS: 6.5
    T.WATSON: 6
    DOBSON: 6.5
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 4
    MAY: 6.5
    C.CAMPBELL: 5
    KANU: 6.5
    L.WATSON: 6.5
    Referee: 7
    COVENTRY:n/a
    FIORINI: n/a


  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 7
    JONES: 6
    NESS: 7
    THOMAS: 7.5
    T.WATSON: 5
    DOBSON: 5
    BAKINSON: 6
    EDUN: 5
    T.CAMPBELL: 4
    MAY: 7
    C.CAMPBELL: 5
    KANU: 6
    L.WATSON: 6
    Referee: 3
    COVENTRY:n/a
    FIORINI: n/a
  • Ascore: 2 There’s no plan A or B

    AMB: 6 could have got closer to the first goal

    JONES:  7 Captain material 

    NESS:  7  not bad 

    THOMAS: MOM 9 our best defender

    T.WATSON:  6 bit patchy

    DOBSON: 5 has started playing alongside his replacements. It showed 

    BAKINSON:  7 liked what he did 

    EDUN:  6 there is the making of a good player in him - needs time. 

    T.CAMPBELL:  2 has had enough time. 

    MAY:  8 right on the money when it mattered 

    C.CAMPBELL: 4 invisible 

    KANU:  6 played better than lately 

    L.WATSON:  3 Woeful passing, never finds a team mate. 

    Referee:  7 some inconsistency awarding free kicks, but better than the usual. 

    COVENTRY: He will be a good signing 

    FIORINI:  too early to tell. 
  • Ascore: 3
    AMB: 6
    JONES: 4 
    NESS: 5
    THOMAS: 6 
    T.WATSON: 6 
    DOBSON: 8
    BAKINSON: 5 
    EDUN: 6
    T.CAMPBELL: 5 
    MAY: 8
    C.CAMPBELL: 3
    KANU: 6
    L.WATSON: 7 
    Referee: 5
  • Applescore 2. Terrible team selection/set up. Useless manager. Needs to go.
    Amb 6. Didn't make any real clangers, but not convinced. Not a QUALITY keeper
    Jones 5.5. Not playing so well the last 2 or three games. Not sure why.
    Ness 5.5. Not awful, but needs to progress
    Thomas 5.5. No too bad
    T Watson 6.5. Had the most difficult task in having to mark Mason Clarke ( to me their best player). Actually thought he did a reasonable job.
    Dobson 6. Think all the uncertainty is affecting his game
    Bakinson 6.5. Looked promising. Looked pretty tired from about 65 mins on. We all saw it. Should have come off before he did. Ring any bells Appleton
    Edun 4.5. People around me thought he played well. I didn't. Far too easily pushed off the ball. Has skill, but has he got the physicality?
    T Campbell 4. Poor. Totally devoid of confidence. Appleton should have had him on the bench to bring on when Boros legs were tiring
    May 7. Runs his socks off. Where would we be without him, and this bunch of clowns nearly didn't sign him!
    C Campbell 4. Similar to T. Campbell. Not strong enough.  Would send back
    Kanu 6.5. Played well. Boro had much more to do when he came on
    L Watson 6. Has a footballing brain, but is a little bit lightweight. For me rather him than C. Campbell as one of the loan spaces
    Coventry 7. Looks a player
    Fiorini 5.5. Not much time, difficult to judge
    Ref 6. Not great, but far from the worst this season.
  • Ascore: 4 - set us very badly. Mitigated his negligence by making the changes at half time but, by then, we were chasing the game. How on earth did Appleton think that Alfie on his tod up front with two lightweight wingers would work ?
    AMB: 6.5 - couldn't do anything about the goals and made a fine double save in the second half
    JONES: 5.5 - not at his best and missed our best chance
    NESS: 6.5 - good to see him turning in a decent performance after looking so shaky earlier this season. Timely, too, given that Hector is out for 10 weeks
    THOMAS: 7 - our best defender on the day and did well against their right winger, Poku, who is a very tricky customer
    T.WATSON: 5 - anaemic. Neither he or Edun are good enough defensively
    DOBSON: 5.5 - not his best game but an excellent ball to Kanu in the build up to our goal
    BAKINSON: 7 - a pretty impressive debut. Good physicality and actually talks to his teammates during the game - a rare thing in this side
    EDUN: 6 - like the rest of the team, very poor in the first half, when he didn't even attempt to get to the byline. Better in the second but his lack of physicality means he is too easily eased off the ball
    T.CAMPBELL: 3.5 - the lad needs to be taken out of the firing line
    MAY: 7 - came to life when he was given a partner in the second half and turned in a typically industrious performance.
    C.CAMPBELL: 3.5 - not good enough
    KANU: 6.5 - made a big difference with his speed and movement
    L.WATSON: 6 - blows hot and cold but a big improvement on what went before
    Referee: 7 - not bad
    COVENTRY:n/a - he looks like a player
    FIORINI: n/a
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!