Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: League Cup R1: Charlton v Birmingham (closes Wednesday teatime)

2

Comments

  • MANNION; 6 - could do nothing about the goal. Only one other serious save to make
    R.E.G: 5 - not convinced. Lacks a bit of physicality
    JONES: 7 - our best defender
    GILLESPHEY: 5 - a bit ponderous and does not fill me with confidence
    WATSON: 5 - didn't really offer much
    COVENTRY: 7 - played well, both in and out of possession. Encouraging
    BERRY: 5 - looked well off the pace. He probably didn't play many minutes last season but he needs to sharpen up
    ANDERSON:5 - not one of his better games
    SMALL: 3 - really poor on the night and showed how far he has to go to be a big player in this division. Maybe he and his agent need to sort his contractual position out
    KANU: 4 - barely had a touch
    CAMPBELL: 5 - one good effort early in the second half but was comfortably controlled, given the lack of service
    Referee: 5 - very fussy and whistle-happy

    Aneke: n/a - livened things up a little
    Edun: n/a - not up to it
    Docherty: n/a - looked lively and went close at the end
    Z.Mitchell: n/a - the most impressive of the subs. Looks to defend on the front foot and can carry the ball forward effectively
    Ramsay: n/a - tried to force the issue down the right when he came on
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 4
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 3
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 4
    SMALL: 3
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL:5
    Referee: 6

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a 
  • MANNION: 6.5 did fine, no-one would have kept that shot out 
    R.E.G: 5 really meh, defending was average, passing was crap
    JONES: 6.5 think he'll have a pretty big season in the heart of the back 3
    GILLESPHEY: 6 got done for pace a couple of times, booking was a proper *welcome to League 1* ordeal for the opponent, decent range of passing 
    WATSON: 5 pretty anonymous
    COVENTRY: 6.5 he's really good at reading play and stepping in to intercept the ball
    BERRY: 5 weak shooting ability and spends too long looking for the pass
    ANDERSON: 5 he can run for days, just don't ask him to do anything with the ball 
    SMALL: 3 everything went wrong for him today, really disappointing
    KANU: 4.5 didn't have much of a look-in tonight, but didn't really make anything happen either
    CAMPBELL: 4 they can say they're converting him into a striker, but based on tonight it'll be a long time before he plays like one
    Referee: 2 jumped up little so and so 
  • Marks please:

    MANNION;  7
    R.E.G:   6.5
    JONES:  7
    GILLESPHEY:  7
    WATSON:   6
    COVENTRY:  7
    BERRY:  7.5
    ANDERSON:  6.5
    SMALL:  6
    KANU:  6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a



  • MANNION;      6
    R.E.G:               5.5 
    JONES:            6
    GILLESPHEY:  5.5 
    WATSON:         5.5
    COVENTRY:     6
    BERRY:             5.5 
    ANDERSON:    4
    SMALL:            4.5 
    KANU:              5.5   closed down well
    CAMPBELL:    5.5   ditto but poor pen
    Referee:            6

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a

  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 3
    KANU: 5
    CAMPBELL: 5
  • MANNION; 5 
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 4.5 slow 
    WATSON: 3 not sure what he offers 
    COVENTRY: 6 actually good defensively 
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 5 great energy, no quality 
    SMALL: 5 some nice crosses in the first half , awful second 
    KANU: 5 worked hard but fed off scraps .  Zero creativity doesn’t help him 
    CAMPBELL:5.  One or two flashes of excellence 
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 6.5
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5
    WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 5.5
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 5
    CAMPBELL: 5
    Referee: 4.5
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 7 solid game
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 7
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 5 couldn't seem to control the ball
    KANU: 6 lots of running
    CAMPBELL: 6 poor penalty
    Referee: 6

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a looked composed most of the time
    Ramsay: n/a 
  • edited August 14
    MANNION; 6.5
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 6
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 5.5
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL:6
    Referee: 7

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Mannion 6
    REG 6
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 6
    Watson 6
    Coventry 6
    Berry 6
    Anderson 5.5
    Small 5
    Kanu 5.5
    Campbell 6

    Ref 5

  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 6
    GILLESPHEY: 4
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    BERRY: 5.5
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 4
    CAMPBELL: 5
    Referee: 4

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a 
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 7 MOM
    BERRY: 7
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 
    CAMPBELL:6
    Referee:4 
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 4
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 5
    KANU: 5
    CAMPBELL:6
    REF3
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES:6
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY:5.5
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL 5
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5.5
    JONES: 6.5
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5
    WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY:6.5 
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 4.5
    CAMPBELL:4.5
    Referee:6
  • MANNION: 6
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 6.5
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 5
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 3
    KANU: 5
    CAMPBELL: 5.5
    Referee: 8
  • MANNION; 6 - not a lot to do
    R.E.G: 6 did ok
    JONES: 7 Solid again
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5 not bad but lack of pace worries me a bit
    WATSON: 3 Gave their winger too much space and didn't press him enough.  He was the difference between the two teams as he was their outlet.
    COVENTRY: 6 Lots of possession and hustle and bustle but I felt he needed more forward action rather than backwards and sideways
    BERRY: 6 Good positions and could have scored a couple.  Not bad first viewing in fairness as the link man between midfield and forwards
    ANDERSON: 5  not one of his better games but didn't give up
    SMALL: 4 Worst game for us.  Desision making was poor, first touch was lacking and his crossing was absolutely dreadful.  Some positivity and his first game of the season so I'm sure he'll be fine but he played like a man who knows his position isn't assured and needed to impress.  He failed at that
    KANU: 6 Lots of running and harrying and got the guy sent off.  But needs a bigger boy up there with him
    CAMPBELL:5 Didn't look confident with the penno and it was a shocker.  In fairness he worked hard and his pace worried them massively.  A really useful player at this level.
    Referee: 4 Fell for it everytime they hit the floor.  So infuriaiting

    Aneke: n/a Ineffective
    Edun: n/a My mum told me if I have nothing nice to say I should say nothing.  "Nothing"
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a I thought he looked decent and assured apart from that cross
    Ramsay: n/a  lively.  Better than TWatson.

    All in all I wasn't disappointed at all.  Brum are arrogant as are their fans but they look like they will walk this division.  We were decent and solid without threatening much going forwards.  I really enjoyed the game
  • MANNION; 7.5
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 4
    BERRY: 4
    ANDERSON: 7
    SMALL: 6
    KANU: 2
    CAMPBELL:6
    Referee: 7

  • Mannion 7 did all that could be reasonably expected 
    REG 6.5 fairly solid yeah
    Jones 7 very good
    Gillesphey 6.5 skinned once or twice but good 
    Watson 6 decent until the cross
    Coventry 8 played brilliantly tbh, at the heart of everything good we did 
    Berry 6.5 looked a threat, poor finishing 
    Anderson 5 hmm. 
    Small 5 started well then went off a cliff, didn't hide though 
    Kanu 5.5 busy 
    Campbell 5 busy but what was that lol
  • Sponsored links:


  • Mannion - 6.5
    REG - 6
    Jones - 7
    Gillesphey - 6
    Watson - 5
    Coventry - 7
    Berry - 6.5
    Anderson - 5.5
    Small - 4
    Kanu - 6
    Campbell - 5
  • MANNION; 6 - Didn't really do much
    R.E.G: 6 - OK
    JONES: 6.5 - Led well
    GILLESPHEY: 6 - OK
    WATSON: 5 - All the negativity came back again....play forwards!!!
    COVENTRY: 6.5 - Tried hard in a tough midfield
    BERRY: 5.5 - Got stuck in but it would have been nice for him to have "Berry-ied" one of his 3 shooting chances
    ANDERSON: 5 - No space for him to get going
    SMALL: 5 - Shadow of last season's player
    KANU: 5 - Struggled against big centre backs but kept trying
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 (MoM) - Had a great start, won the penalty, but it shouldn't be him taking them (not that it will be again soon...)
    Referee: 4 - Gave us the pen and then nothing all night....
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5.5 - one excellent block but distribution was very poor
    JONES: 6.5
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    BERRY: 6
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 5.5
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 7
  • edited August 14
    MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    GILLESPHEY: 7
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 5
    BERRY: 4
    ANDERSON: 5 
    SMALL: 3
    KANU: 4 
    CAMPBELL: 4 
  • MANNION: 6.5 - some good saves later on but that shot was not top corner
    R.E.G: 6 - strong tackles, limited distribution
    JONES: 7 - Defended well, kept May quiet, looked comfortable on the ball
    GILLESPHEY: 6 - Made some strong tackles but not quite it
    WATSON: 6 - Sat so Small could go
    COVENTRY: 7 - Looked very comfortable on the ball and held his position well
    BERRY: 6.5 - Bright at the start and showed he can be on the end of chances but didn't close for their goal. Tired quickly.
    ANDERSON: 6 - Gets about but doesn't take enough care of the ball when he should be linking play. Good ideas on flicks and passes round the corner but they're not quite coming off
    SMALL: 5 - Should have dominated and been our creative centrepiece but couldn't get the ball out from under his feet
    KANU: 5.5 - Very quiet. Did force the red
    CAMPBELL: 6 - Won the penalty well but a really poor effort.
    Referee: 7 - A bit finicky but gave the pen and didn't bottle the red

    Aneke: n/a - Quiet
    Edun: n/a - Looked like he wanted to impress
    Docherty: n/a - Created danger, has good feet and he'll be a goal threat
    Z.Mitchell: n/a - So composed, very exciting
    Ramsay: n/a - Needs a better final ball
  • At the game.

    MANNION: 6 - Not much to do. Couldn't help the goal from my view in the NSL.
    R.E.G: 5 - Lets hope we don't have to rely for him in the league.
    JONES: 6 - Done nothing wrong in my eyes.
    GILLESPHEY: 6 -As above.
    WATSON: 5 - Not as strong defensively and crosses was not something to write home about.
    COVENTRY: 8 - Improvement on last season. Collects the balls in the dangerous areas and calmly pushes it back up the pitch without just hoofing it. MOTM
    BERRY: 7 - Unfortunate to not get a goal. Appeared in the right positions and was great in the first half.
    ANDERSON: 6 - There's a good player in there but with his age it's hit and miss what you're gonna get.
    SMALL: 5 - Looked so disinterested for the first 20 minutes. Like he doesn't want to be here. Worst game in our shirt. 
    KANU: 5 - Not effective enough.
    CAMPBELL: 7 - Our most attacking threat. Was barging players of the ball with confidence. Collecting the ball and taking on players. Making the right runs.
    Referee: 4 - Seemed to give a foul anytime someone fell over whether there was contact or not.
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 6
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY: 6.5
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 5
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL:6
    Referee: 7.5
  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 4.5
    JONES: 6
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 6
    BERRY: 5.5
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 5.5
    CAMPBELL: 5.5
    Referee: 5

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a


  • MANNION; 7
    R.E.G: 6
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 7
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 5
    SMALL: 4
    KANU: 5
    CAMPBELL: 5
    Referee: 

    Aneke: n/a
    Edun: n/a
    Docherty: n/a
    Z.Mitchell: n/a
    Ramsay: n/a

  • MANNION; 6
    R.E.G: 5
    JONES: 4
    GILLESPHEY: 4 
    WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 5 
    BERRY: 5
    ANDERSON: 6
    SMALL: 6
    KANU: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 4

    Aneke: n/a!!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!