A M-B: 5 - No chance with first but should have done better with 2nd... REG: 4.5 - Meh A.MITCHELL: 5 - Cracks starting to show each week GILLESPHEY: 4.5 - Brainless EDWARDS: 5.5 - Every throw in is a foul throw (but gets away with it) TAYLOR: 5.5 Buzzed about COVENTRY: 4.5 - Got in Taylor's way A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Lots of tackles but failed to use the ball at all GODDEN: 3 - Did very little and didn't seem bothered LEABURN: 3.5 - Has he been tapped up? AHADME: 5 - Tries hard but so ineffective (bar the assist) SMALL: 5.5 - Tried hard and brought desperately needed width KANU: 6 (MoM) - Gave his all and took goal well T.CAMPBELL: 4 - Didn't work for him whatever position (winger, wing back, striker) he played Referee: 3 - Failed to stamp on time wasting, and kept breaking any fluidity we had
A M-B: 6 A mistake for the second goal possibly, but should have been helped out more by his defenders. A great double save earlier. Kicking was awful, but so was everyone else's. REG: 5 Poor. No positive play at all. A.MITCHELL: 6 Can't deny his effort, but skill factor is low. GILLESPHEY: 6 Did mostly okay. It's not his fault Jones has told him to play it long all the time EDWARDS: 5 Started very brightly but faded badly and a few sloppy moments in second half. TAYLOR: 6 Did okay and some set pieces were good, but not at his best. COVENTRY: 6 Tried to keep us ticking over in midfield but largely failed. A.CAMPBELL: 5 One of his better games. Started well, winning lots of tackles, but faded badly and reverted to usual poor levels as game progressed. I can't understand how he was not subbed. GODDEN: 5 Not his best role and fed on scraps, but fairly anonymous. LEABURN: 5 He was clearly either ill or just not up for it. Rightly subbed at half time. AHADME: 6 Works really hard trying to make something happen. He is decent in the air, but he is not a target man. He can make nice little flick-ons, but he is not strong enough to hold the ball up. SMALL: 6 Livened things up a bit, but nothing special. KANU: 6 Well taken goal and he looked lively. T.CAMPBELL: 6 Livened things up a bit, but no huge impact.
Referee: 5 Very pedantic and seemed to give much more 50:50s to Crawley than us. Not as bad as some we have had though.
Laqeretabua: n/a No time to do much. Jones: n/a Good to have him back. I hope he hasn't lost the form he had before his injury. We desperately need him.
A M-B: 5 - a good double save but…….. 🤦🏻♀️ REG: 4 A.MITCHELL: 5 GILLESPHEY: 5 EDWARDS: 5 TAYLOR: 5 COVENTRY: 5 A.CAMPBELL: 6.5 - his best game, put himself about GODDEN: 5 LEABURN: 4 AHADME: 6 SMALL: 5 KANU: 6 - well taken goal 👏🏻 T.CAMPBELL: 5
A M-B: 4 thought he could do better for the first goal, then the double save he made he only had to make the second save because he pushed it right to their player, so we should have seen what was coming for the second goal. Also his decision making and distribution is fucking dogshit
REG: 5 isn't a right wing back so when we came out second half and played 5 ATB he was completely lost
A.MITCHELL: 5.5 such a 50p head
GILLESPHEY: 4.5 endless long balls
EDWARDS: 5 bustles about a lot but no end product and his defending is average
TAYLOR: 4.5 overran in the second half, barely involved in the first
COVENTRY: 5.5 best of a bad bunch in the middle, should have been the last to be subbed
A.CAMPBELL: 2 fuck off you useless cretin
GODDEN: 3.5 absolute drivel when in midfield, not much better up top
LEABURN: 2.5 sell him whilst we still can, he's not a team player in any sense of the word, just trying to do everything himself and when he doesn't have the ball looks completely disinterested
AHADME: 5.5 worked his nuts off but pointless winning headers when your strike partner is off sulking on the other side of the pitch
SMALL: 5.5 came on, was meant to look dangerous but ultimately wasn't
KANU: 6.5 scored the goal, should start over Miles
T.CAMPBELL: 4.5 came on and was shuffled out to right wing back so couldn't actually influence the game in any way, later on when Josh L came on he ended up just drifting about in the middle, completely lost at sea
Referee: 5 got more and more pedantic as the match went on, some fouls given were literally just 2 players jumping next to eachother for a header
A M-B: 5 - Very much a lower league keeper. REG: 5.5 - He'd be ok with a wide man in front of him. But the diamond formation is asking him to perform an attacking role that he just can't do. A.MITCHELL: 6 - Cleared his lines pretty well. At least he appears to care. Ballsed a good chance but he's no striker. GILLESPHEY: 6 - Did ok for the most part. EDWARDS: 5.5 - Did produce one of only two decent balls into the box (for Mitchell) but was pretty limited overall. TAYLOR: 5 - Tried but turned into trouble a few times and generally looked a bit weak. His very audible squeel of "pain" on the halfway line was embarrassing. COVENTRY: 5 - Another one who turned into trouble. Got completely out-gunned in midfield. A.CAMPBELL: 6 - Did at least win a few tackles and tried hard but he's limited. GODDEN: 4.5 - Out of position in the first half and largely anonymous when he moved up front. LEABURN: 3 - Had one ok shot. Just got to hope he's not fit because if he is, then there is a serious attitude problem. AHADME: 6 - Tried his nuts off but was living on scraps. Get some ammunition into the box and we could have a player but until we find some effective width, the poor bloke is fucked. SMALL: 5 - One great run followed by a succession of mishaps. Not a winger. KANU: 7 - Looked fit, sharp and raring to go. Lovely striker's finish for his goal. T.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Played out of position on the right, which made us ineffective on both wings, despite having him and Small on the pitch! When he moved central, suddenly he created a decent moment. Referee: 7 - He was fine, apart from missing a few shirt pulls.
Laqeretabua: n/a - Physically looks like a player but the poor sod was petrified when he got forward....which wasn't what was needed. He should have taken the opportunity by the scruff of the neck and enjoyed the licence to drive forward. Jones: n/a
A M-B: 4 Got to be holding that shot for the second goal. Also has redeveloped Toblerone feet and can't kick for shit REG: 5 Boring. Just a big of a nothing player. No clear skillset. Meh A.MITCHELL: 5 Looks to be carrying a bit too much timber which affects mobility and fitness. Love his commitment. Don't love his passing. GILLESPHEY: 4 Manages to get shorter when he jumps. Shit in the ar for a relatively big lad. Bored of watching his diagonals to their full back EDWARDS: 5 Shadow of the confident lad that started the season TAYLOR: 5 decent free kick delivery but we need more. He's looked at as the creative spark but it's not happening COVENTRY: 5 Backwards and sideways. Needs to be fitter and faster imo A.CAMPBELL: 2 Just fuck off. Please. Yet to see anything that convinces me he's actually a footballer. Always a yard too late to the ball. No physical presence. Just dreadful. How he stayed on the field I will never know. GODDEN: 5 Can finish. Can't do much else LEABURN: 4 Was very poor and looked leggy. Hasn't looked sharp since his return. Ball gets stuck under his feet too often. AHADME: 4 Runs around a lot but barely won a header all game even though he had 45,780 long balls punted to him. Appears to play football in a pair of moccasins too given how much time he spends on his arse SMALL: 6 Brightest spark but it's a remarkably low bar. KANU: 6.5 MOM because he scored a goal T.CAMPBELL: 5 Most creative player so it makes no sense to keep him on the bench. That said he tried to beat his man immediately after coming on and DIDN'T beat him for pace so then didn't have the confidence to try again. Playing him regularly will help his confidence. Keeping him on the bench will affect him. It's not rocket science Referee: 4 His arm only appeared to go one way - in favour of Crawley
Laqeretabua: n/a Horrible to bring him on in that situation Jones: n/a Good to see him
oh dear - like the team I just don't care but unlike the team I'll kick myself up the rear and get on with the players marks and stats but it might all appear a little later than usual
A M-B: 4 - Annoying habit of keeping the ball alive in the box when he saves. Has to push it away from the goal. REG: 4.5 - Not a full/wing back. Not sure what he offers TBH. A.MITCHELL: 5 - Looked amateur at times. GILLESPHEY: 5 - He's played worse, but can't kick a ball straight down the touchline without it going out of play. EDWARDS: 5 - Not great TAYLOR: 5.5 - Tidy at times, but ineffective. One excellent free kick in 2nd half. COVENTRY: 5 - Meh A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Tried, but he simply isn't good enough. GODDEN: 5 - Is not a no.10, he's wasted there. Looked frustrated with our long ball rubbish. LEABURN: 3 - Wow, he was poor. Hope he's ok and not struggling with injury. AHADME: 5.5 - I don't particularly rate him, but he tried really hard. Put a shift in. SMALL: 6 - Looked lively, but his style of getting down the wing & crossing doesn't fit in with NJ's Hoofball. KANU: 6 - Took goal well and I was pleased to see him back. T.CAMPBELL: 3.5 - Totally uninterested and doesn't have the bottle or guts to fight. He's not a striker and should've been released in the summer, as he isn't a particularly good winger either. Referee: 5 - Gave us very little in the 1st half.
A M-B: - 4 A moment in the first half when he let the ball drop in the 6 yard box. Doesn't command, at all. Some wayward kicking. Responsible for their winner. A good hand to the ball, but couldn't put it around thd post, put it back into play.
REG: - 5.5 Bang average defensively, but offers nothing going forward.
A.MITCHELL: - 5.5 Bang average defensively, but doesn't command at all.
GILLESPHEY: - 5 Bang average, but didn't he used to captain Plymouth? Needs to command more.
EDWARDS: - 5 Even his long throws were poor.
TAYLOR: - 5 Besides his dead balls, what does he offer? Not as effective defensively as Coventry.
COVENTRY: - 5.5 Looked lost playing farther up the pitch. Put him back to where he's best. Should'nt have been substituted.
A.CAMPBELL: - 6.5 MotM Did his damndest in a poor overall performance. For most of the game, looked like our only midfielder. In fact, Crawley's first goal was mainly due to the fact he was the only player pressing the Crawley players. When they by passed him, there was a gaping hole through the middle that they exploited. Decent shot in the 1st half.
GODDEN: - 5 Didn't do much, but that's mainly due to him NOT being a midfielder!
LEABURN: - 3 Probably his worst ever Charlton performance. Looked tired, and seemed to spend his whole time on the pitch trying to compete for the same balls as Ahadme.
AHADME: - 5.5 Can at least say he worked hard. Got an assist to show for it.
SMALL: - 4 Looked lively when he first came on. Then deteriorated badly. Leading to him trying to trick a defender, and running off, leaving the ball behind. I suppose you could say it worked...
KANU: - 6 Like Gassan, at least he can say he worked. Lovely finish.
T.CAMPBELL: - 5 Is he a one trick pony? Came up against someone with pace, and was totally ineffective.
A M-B: 3.5 - Awful goalkeeping for their second and kicking was awful. REG: 4.5 - Consistently unconvincing. A.MITCHELL: 4.5 - Probably his worst game in a Charlton shirt. GILLESPHEY: 5 - Would be alright if he had the passing range of De Bruyne. Unfortunately he doesn't. EDWARDS: 5.5 - Looked shaky on the ball but dealt well with their width on his side TAYLOR: 5.5 - Not great. Still not sure he's a starter. Saying that, he certainly is in this squad. COVENTRY: 5.5 - Worked hard and tidied up play at times. A.CAMPBELL: 4 - His work rate is a 10. Football ability a 2. I'll meet somewhere in the middle (closer to 2). GODDEN: 5 - Not his fault. Instinctive strikers should not be at the top of the midfield. Birmingham are learning that with May. LEABURN: 3.5 - Poor. Worryingly poor all season as well AHADME: 6 - Got no service whatsoever. Worked hard and a good flick on for the goal. Decent shift. SMALL: 4.5 - Gets the ball, dicks around for a bit, puts a crap ball in. Repeat KANU: 6 - Well taken goal and looked a bit lively when he came on. Welcome back DK . T.CAMPBELL: 4 - His pace naturally causes issues but he's unfortunately not very good. Serious improvement needed if he wants to stay here long term. Referee: 6.5 - Seemed slightly generous to them first half. Nothing majorly wrong and added their timewasting on at the end of the game.
A M-B: 4 - his error cost us the second goal and his kicking was poor. A shame, because he's done alright since he came into the side REG: 4 - he really is a very limited player - another dud (like Gillesphey) signed by Andy Scott in the January 2024 window. Offers nothing offensively A.MITCHELL: 4.5 - a determined and committed player but his distribution is terrible. Missed another good chance GILLESPHEY: 4 - their first goal was an excellent strike but it looked as if Gillesphey was running in treacle, as he was easily turned by their player and was then unable to get near him EDWARDS: 4.5 - not one of his better games, save for one excellent cross which Mitchell squandered. I do, however, like his robust and spirited approach TAYLOR: 4 - a couple of good free-kicks but that was about it, as Crawley totally dominated the midfield COVENTRY: 4 - poor, although quite was Jones hooked him when we were being overrun on midfield, only he knows A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - started the game well but faded in the second half and looked out on his feet towards the end GODDEN: 4 - played out of position and made no impact. Jones must know that Godden is almost exclusively a penalty box player LEABURN: 3 - I'm guessing he wasn't fully fit, in which case he should not have started. His demeanour looked very hangdog and I doubt that he (or any of the players) can enjoy trying to implement Jones' primordial style of football AHADME: 5 - tried hard but got no service SMALL: 5 - tried to liven things up but not much came off KANU: 6.5: MoTM - his pace injected a little urgency and he took his goal well T.CAMPBELL: 5 - he is not a right wing back. In a team lacking in pace and creativity, it can only be Jones' stubbornness which prevents Campbell starting in his natural position, wide on the left Referee: 5 - very fussy and seemed determined to show that he wasn't a 'homer'
A M-B: 3 Not a top League 1 keeper REG: 3 not good enough A.MITCHELL: 5 did a lot GILLESPHEY: 3 not good enough EDWARDS: 5 was ok TAYLOR: 5 was ok COVENTRY: 4 poor game from him A.CAMPBELL: 6 better than previous, but not hard tbf GODDEN: 5 needs service LEABURN: 3 poor/injured? AHADME: 5 was ok SMALL: 5 was ok KANU: 7 looked good T.CAMPBELL: 6 lively
Comments
REG: 4.5 - Meh
A.MITCHELL: 5 - Cracks starting to show each week
GILLESPHEY: 4.5 - Brainless
EDWARDS: 5.5 - Every throw in is a foul throw (but gets away with it)
TAYLOR: 5.5 Buzzed about
COVENTRY: 4.5 - Got in Taylor's way
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Lots of tackles but failed to use the ball at all
GODDEN: 3 - Did very little and didn't seem bothered
LEABURN: 3.5 - Has he been tapped up?
AHADME: 5 - Tries hard but so ineffective (bar the assist)
SMALL: 5.5 - Tried hard and brought desperately needed width
KANU: 6 (MoM) - Gave his all and took goal well
T.CAMPBELL: 4 - Didn't work for him whatever position (winger, wing back, striker) he played
Referee: 3 - Failed to stamp on time wasting, and kept breaking any fluidity we had
REG: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 6
COVENTRY: 5.5
A.CAMPBELL: 6
GODDEN: 4
LEABURN: 3
AHADME: 4.5
SMALL: 4.5
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 4
REG: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 4
TAYLOR: 6
COVENTRY: 6
A.CAMPBELL: 3
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 3
AHADME:3
SMALL: 6
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 7
A M-B: 6 A mistake for the second goal possibly, but should have been helped out more by his defenders. A great double save earlier. Kicking was awful, but so was everyone else's.
REG: 5 Poor. No positive play at all.
A.MITCHELL: 6 Can't deny his effort, but skill factor is low.
GILLESPHEY: 6 Did mostly okay. It's not his fault Jones has told him to play it long all the time
EDWARDS: 5 Started very brightly but faded badly and a few sloppy moments in second half.
TAYLOR: 6 Did okay and some set pieces were good, but not at his best.
COVENTRY: 6 Tried to keep us ticking over in midfield but largely failed.
A.CAMPBELL: 5 One of his better games. Started well, winning lots of tackles, but faded badly and reverted to usual poor levels as game progressed. I can't understand how he was not subbed.
GODDEN: 5 Not his best role and fed on scraps, but fairly anonymous.
LEABURN: 5 He was clearly either ill or just not up for it. Rightly subbed at half time.
AHADME: 6 Works really hard trying to make something happen. He is decent in the air, but he is not a target man. He can make nice little flick-ons, but he is not strong enough to hold the ball up.
SMALL: 6 Livened things up a bit, but nothing special.
KANU: 6 Well taken goal and he looked lively.
T.CAMPBELL: 6 Livened things up a bit, but no huge impact.
Referee: 5 Very pedantic and seemed to give much more 50:50s to Crawley than us. Not as bad as some we have had though.
Laqeretabua: n/a No time to do much.
Jones: n/a Good to have him back. I hope he hasn't lost the form he had before his injury. We desperately need him.
REG: 4
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5
COVENTRY: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 6.5 - his best game, put himself about
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 6
SMALL: 5
KANU: 6 - well taken goal 👏🏻
T.CAMPBELL: 5
REG: 4
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 3
TAYLOR: 5
COVENTRY: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 5
GODDEN: 4
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 5.5
SMALL: 6
KANU: 7
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 7
REG: 5.5 - He'd be ok with a wide man in front of him. But the diamond formation is asking him to perform an attacking role that he just can't do.
A.MITCHELL: 6 - Cleared his lines pretty well. At least he appears to care. Ballsed a good chance but he's no striker.
GILLESPHEY: 6 - Did ok for the most part.
EDWARDS: 5.5 - Did produce one of only two decent balls into the box (for Mitchell) but was pretty limited overall.
TAYLOR: 5 - Tried but turned into trouble a few times and generally looked a bit weak. His very audible squeel of "pain" on the halfway line was embarrassing.
COVENTRY: 5 - Another one who turned into trouble. Got completely out-gunned in midfield.
A.CAMPBELL: 6 - Did at least win a few tackles and tried hard but he's limited.
GODDEN: 4.5 - Out of position in the first half and largely anonymous when he moved up front.
LEABURN: 3 - Had one ok shot. Just got to hope he's not fit because if he is, then there is a serious attitude problem.
AHADME: 6 - Tried his nuts off but was living on scraps. Get some ammunition into the box and we could have a player but until we find some effective width, the poor bloke is fucked.
SMALL: 5 - One great run followed by a succession of mishaps. Not a winger.
KANU: 7 - Looked fit, sharp and raring to go. Lovely striker's finish for his goal.
T.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Played out of position on the right, which made us ineffective on both wings, despite having him and Small on the pitch! When he moved central, suddenly he created a decent moment.
Referee: 7 - He was fine, apart from missing a few shirt pulls.
Laqeretabua: n/a - Physically looks like a player but the poor sod was petrified when he got forward....which wasn't what was needed. He should have taken the opportunity by the scruff of the neck and enjoyed the licence to drive forward.
Jones: n/a
REG: 5 Boring. Just a big of a nothing player. No clear skillset. Meh
A.MITCHELL: 5 Looks to be carrying a bit too much timber which affects mobility and fitness. Love his commitment. Don't love his passing.
GILLESPHEY: 4 Manages to get shorter when he jumps. Shit in the ar for a relatively big lad. Bored of watching his diagonals to their full back
EDWARDS: 5 Shadow of the confident lad that started the season
TAYLOR: 5 decent free kick delivery but we need more. He's looked at as the creative spark but it's not happening
COVENTRY: 5 Backwards and sideways. Needs to be fitter and faster imo
A.CAMPBELL: 2 Just fuck off. Please. Yet to see anything that convinces me he's actually a footballer. Always a yard too late to the ball. No physical presence. Just dreadful. How he stayed on the field I will never know.
GODDEN: 5 Can finish. Can't do much else
LEABURN: 4 Was very poor and looked leggy. Hasn't looked sharp since his return. Ball gets stuck under his feet too often.
AHADME: 4 Runs around a lot but barely won a header all game even though he had 45,780 long balls punted to him. Appears to play football in a pair of moccasins too given how much time he spends on his arse
SMALL: 6 Brightest spark but it's a remarkably low bar.
KANU: 6.5 MOM because he scored a goal
T.CAMPBELL: 5 Most creative player so it makes no sense to keep him on the bench. That said he tried to beat his man immediately after coming on and DIDN'T beat him for pace so then didn't have the confidence to try again. Playing him regularly will help his confidence. Keeping him on the bench will affect him. It's not rocket science
Referee: 4 His arm only appeared to go one way - in favour of Crawley
Laqeretabua: n/a Horrible to bring him on in that situation
Jones: n/a Good to see him
REG 4.5
Mitchell 5.5
Gillesphey 5
A Campbell 4.5
Godden 4.5
Leaburn 4.5
Ahadme 5.5
Small 6
Kanu 6
T Campbell 5
Ref 5
REG: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 6
EDWARDS: 6
TAYLOR: 5.5
COVENTRY: 5.5
A.CAMPBELL: 6
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 5.5
SMALL: 5.5
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 5.5
REG: 5.5
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5.5
TAYLOR: 6
COVENTRY: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 5
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 2
AHADME: 5
SMALL: 6
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 6.5
REG: 4
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6.5
A.CAMPBELL: 2
GODDEN: 4.5
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 6
SMALL: 6
KANU: 7
T.CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 5
REG: 4.5
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 4.5
EDWARDS: 4.5
TAYLOR: 5
COVENTRY: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5
GODDEN: 4.5
LEABURN: 4.5
AHADME:5.5
SMALL: 5
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 7
REG: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6
A.CAMPBELL: 2 (and that is generous)
GODDEN: 6
LEABURN: 4
AHADME:6
SMALL: 6
KANU: 7
T.CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 7
REG: 4.5 - Not a full/wing back. Not sure what he offers TBH.
A.MITCHELL: 5 - Looked amateur at times.
GILLESPHEY: 5 - He's played worse, but can't kick a ball straight down the touchline without it going out of play.
EDWARDS: 5 - Not great
TAYLOR: 5.5 - Tidy at times, but ineffective. One excellent free kick in 2nd half.
COVENTRY: 5 - Meh
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - Tried, but he simply isn't good enough.
GODDEN: 5 - Is not a no.10, he's wasted there. Looked frustrated with our long ball rubbish.
LEABURN: 3 - Wow, he was poor. Hope he's ok and not struggling with injury.
AHADME: 5.5 - I don't particularly rate him, but he tried really hard. Put a shift in.
SMALL: 6 - Looked lively, but his style of getting down the wing & crossing doesn't fit in with NJ's Hoofball.
KANU: 6 - Took goal well and I was pleased to see him back.
T.CAMPBELL: 3.5 - Totally uninterested and doesn't have the bottle or guts to fight. He's not a striker and should've been released in the summer, as he isn't a particularly good winger either.
Referee: 5 - Gave us very little in the 1st half.
Laqeretabua: n/a
Jones: n/a
REG: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5.5
TAYLOR: 6
COVENTRY: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 6
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 6
SMALL: 6
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 5
REG: - 5.5 Bang average defensively, but offers nothing going forward.
A.MITCHELL: - 5.5 Bang average defensively, but doesn't command at all.
GILLESPHEY: - 5 Bang average, but didn't he used to captain Plymouth? Needs to command more.
EDWARDS: - 5 Even his long throws were poor.
TAYLOR: - 5 Besides his dead balls, what does he offer? Not as effective defensively as Coventry.
COVENTRY: - 5.5 Looked lost playing farther up the pitch. Put him back to where he's best. Should'nt have been substituted.
A.CAMPBELL: - 6.5 MotM Did his damndest in a poor overall performance. For most of the game, looked like our only midfielder. In fact, Crawley's first goal was mainly due to the fact he was the only player pressing the Crawley players. When they by passed him, there was a gaping hole through the middle that they exploited. Decent shot in the 1st half.
GODDEN: - 5 Didn't do much, but that's mainly due to him NOT being a midfielder!
LEABURN: - 3 Probably his worst ever Charlton performance. Looked tired, and seemed to spend his whole time on the pitch trying to compete for the same balls as Ahadme.
AHADME: - 5.5 Can at least say he worked hard. Got an assist to show for it.
SMALL: - 4 Looked lively when he first came on. Then deteriorated badly. Leading to him trying to trick a defender, and running off, leaving the ball behind. I suppose you could say it worked...
KANU: - 6 Like Gassan, at least he can say he worked. Lovely finish.
T.CAMPBELL: - 5 Is he a one trick pony? Came up against someone with pace, and was totally ineffective.
REG: 4.5 - Consistently unconvincing.
A.MITCHELL: 4.5 - Probably his worst game in a Charlton shirt.
GILLESPHEY: 5 - Would be alright if he had the passing range of De Bruyne. Unfortunately he doesn't.
EDWARDS: 5.5 - Looked shaky on the ball but dealt well with their width on his side
TAYLOR: 5.5 - Not great. Still not sure he's a starter. Saying that, he certainly is in this squad.
COVENTRY: 5.5 - Worked hard and tidied up play at times.
A.CAMPBELL: 4 - His work rate is a 10. Football ability a 2. I'll meet somewhere in the middle (closer to 2).
GODDEN: 5 - Not his fault. Instinctive strikers should not be at the top of the midfield. Birmingham are learning that with May.
LEABURN: 3.5 - Poor. Worryingly poor all season as well
AHADME: 6 - Got no service whatsoever. Worked hard and a good flick on for the goal. Decent shift.
SMALL: 4.5 - Gets the ball, dicks around for a bit, puts a crap ball in. Repeat
KANU: 6 - Well taken goal and looked a bit lively when he came on. Welcome back DK .
T.CAMPBELL: 4 - His pace naturally causes issues but he's unfortunately not very good. Serious improvement needed if he wants to stay here long term.
Referee: 6.5 - Seemed slightly generous to them first half. Nothing majorly wrong and added their timewasting on at the end of the game.
Laqeretabua: n/a
Jones: n/a
REG: 2
A.MITCHELL: 3
GILLESPHEY: 2
EDWARDS: 3
TAYLOR: 4
COVENTRY: 3
A.CAMPBELL: 4
GODDEN: 3
LEABURN: 2
AHADME:3
SMALL: 3
KANU: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 3
Referee: 0...total dick'ead...
REG: 4 - he really is a very limited player - another dud (like Gillesphey) signed by Andy Scott in the January 2024 window. Offers nothing offensively
A.MITCHELL: 4.5 - a determined and committed player but his distribution is terrible. Missed another good chance
GILLESPHEY: 4 - their first goal was an excellent strike but it looked as if Gillesphey was running in treacle, as he was easily turned by their player and was then unable to get near him
EDWARDS: 4.5 - not one of his better games, save for one excellent cross which Mitchell squandered. I do, however, like his robust and spirited approach
TAYLOR: 4 - a couple of good free-kicks but that was about it, as Crawley totally dominated the midfield
COVENTRY: 4 - poor, although quite was Jones hooked him when we were being overrun on midfield, only he knows
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 - started the game well but faded in the second half and looked out on his feet towards the end
GODDEN: 4 - played out of position and made no impact. Jones must know that Godden is almost exclusively a penalty box player
LEABURN: 3 - I'm guessing he wasn't fully fit, in which case he should not have started. His demeanour looked very hangdog and I doubt that he (or any of the players) can enjoy trying to implement Jones' primordial style of football
AHADME: 5 - tried hard but got no service
SMALL: 5 - tried to liven things up but not much came off
KANU: 6.5: MoTM - his pace injected a little urgency and he took his goal well
T.CAMPBELL: 5 - he is not a right wing back. In a team lacking in pace and creativity, it can only be Jones' stubbornness which prevents Campbell starting in his natural position, wide on the left
Referee: 5 - very fussy and seemed determined to show that he wasn't a 'homer'
REG: 3 not good enough
A.MITCHELL: 5 did a lot
GILLESPHEY: 3 not good enough
EDWARDS: 5 was ok
TAYLOR: 5 was ok
COVENTRY: 4 poor game from him
A.CAMPBELL: 6 better than previous, but not hard tbf
GODDEN: 5 needs service
LEABURN: 3 poor/injured?
AHADME: 5 was ok
SMALL: 5 was ok
KANU: 7 looked good
T.CAMPBELL: 6 lively
REG: 3
A.MITCHELL: 4
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5
COVENTRY: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
GODDEN: 4
LEABURN: 3
AHADME: 4
SMALL: 5
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 7
REG: 3
A.MITCHELL: 3
GILLESPHEY: 3
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5
COVENTRY: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
GODDEN: 4
LEABURN: 2
AHADME: 5
SMALL: 4
KANU: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 4
REG: 4
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 7
COVENTRY: 6
A.CAMPBELL: 3 all those subs and he still finishes the match!
GODDEN: 5
LEABURN: 4
AHADME: 6
SMALL: 6
KANU: 7
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 5
Laqeretabua: n/a
Jones: n/a
REG: 3.5
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
TAYLOR: 5.5
COVENTRY: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 6
GODDEN: 4
LEABURN: 3
AHADME: 5
SMALL: 5
KANU: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
Referee: 6