Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
PLAYERS MARKS: BIRMINGHAM v CHARLTON ( closed Sunday teatime)
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,626
Apologies that this is late
Your marks please:
Your marks please:
A M-B
RAMSAY;
JONES;
GILLESPHEY:
SMALL:
BERRY:
COVENTRY:
DOCHERTY:
EDWARDS:
GODDEN:
T.CAMPBELL:
MANNION:
ANDERSON:
KANU:
Referee:
Gilbert: n/a
Leaburn: n/a
0
Comments
-
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 6
JONES; 6
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 4
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 5.5
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5.5
T.CAMPBELL: 3.5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5.5
KANU: 5
Referee: 1
Gilbert: n/a
Leaburn: n/a
0 -
A M-B 6 very lucky
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 8
GILLESPHEY: 8
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 6 had nothing to do showed how much we were the better team second half
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 4 just don’t know what he brings
Referee 2 shocker helped Birmingham time waste in the last 15 mins kept stoppping the play for ridiculous free kicks
4 -
A M-B : 6 Nothing much to doRAMSAY : 8 Outstanding
JONES: 7 Dominant
GILLESPHEY: 6.5 decent, nearly gave them an early chance & sliced a few clearances
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 6 His error led to the goal
DOCHERTY: 7
EDWARDS: 7.5 Very strong
GODDEN: 5 Didn't see/hear him mentioned until he was subbed
T.CAMPBELL: 6 Out thought by experienced players
MANNION: 6 Nothing much to do
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
Referee: 4.50 -
lancashire lad said:Apologies that this is late
Your marks please:
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 6
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 5
BERRY 5:
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
EDWARDS: 6.5
GODDEN: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
Referee: 2
Gilbert: n/a
Leaburn: n/a
0 -
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 7.5
JONES; 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 7.5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 8 MOM
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 50 -
A M-B 5.5
RAMSAY 7
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5.5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 5
Referee: 20 -
A M-B 6 Not sure he could have done better with the goal.
RAMSAY; 7.5 excellent second half especially
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 8 Faultless. Won ever head.
SMALL: 5 They snuffed him out. Never had a run.
BERRY: 6 Quiet
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 7 Battled well
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 7 Looked confident
ANDERSON: 5.5
KANU: 5
0 -
A M-B, 7, Not at fault for the goal and a great save to keep us in it.
RAMSAY; 9, MOM Was struggling then fought back against Anderson and won the battle
JONES; 8, Didn't lose a anything in the air
GILLESPHEY: 8, Steady, gritty performance
SMALL: 5, But you were up against the best player on the pitch, should have been moved left.
BERRY: 5, Not in it
COVENTRY: 5, At fault for the goal and was given a chasing by Birmingham's midfield
DOCHERTY: 8, Once again a proper Captain's performance
EDWARDS: 8, One our best for sure
GODDEN: 6, Give him a partner and you might see more goals from him
T.CAMPBELL, 4, Awful performance, was like a rabbit in the headlights, how he stayed on for 90 is beyond me. :
MANNION: 6, Didn't have a lot to doANDERSON:6, Busy when he came onKANU: As above and at least had a shotReferee: 4, but his linesmen were worse0 -
A M-B 4
RAMSAY; 6
JONES; 6
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 4
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5.5
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5.
T.CAMPBELL: 3
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5
KANU: 5
Referee: 30 -
A M-B 5.5 Lucky boy
RAMSAY 7.5 Very good second half
JONES; 7 Good headers
GILLESPHEY: 7 Pretty solid, some good passes
SMALL: 5 Cochrane had the better of him
BERRY: 5 A bit anonymous
COVENTRY: 5 Not up to usual standard plus a bad error for their goal
DOCHERTY: 6.5 Good captain's performance
EDWARDS: 7.5 Good game. Edged MOM for me
GODDEN: 5.5 Didn't get a look in
T.CAMPBELL: 5 Should have done better on so many occasions
MANNION: 6 Little to do
ANDERSON: 6 Aggressive performance. Was always going to get booked with that ref
KANU: 4.5 Disappointing
Referee: 3 Too many poor decisions and too card happy
Gilbert: n/a I think he could be very useful to us
Leaburn: n/a DId OK but not exactly threatening0 - Sponsored links:
-
A M-B 6
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 8
GILLESPHEY: 8
SMALL: 4
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 8
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 2
MANNION: 7
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 4
Referee: 2 fecking awful0 -
A M-B 6 Was lucky to get away with the handball, made one good save & maybe could have done better with their goal
RAMSAY; 7 poor. Start but string second half
JONES; 7.5 Consistently good
GILLESPHEY: 7 Done ok, won his headers
SMALL: 2 Couldn’t do a thing right today
BERRY: 3.5 Struggled to make an impact
COVENTRY: 4.5 Done ok but -2 for losing the ball for their goal
DOCHERTY: 6 Busy but couldn’t make an impact
EDWARDS: 7 Defended well & was strong throughout
GODDEN: 5 Worked his socks off but got no support
T.CAMPBELL: 1.5 Awful performance, couldn’t control the ball all game apart from one dribble just before half time
MANNION: 6.5 Looked solid, caught one good cross and should have caught a second but went for a dodgy punch
ANDERSON: 2 Runs round like a headless chicken with little footballing ability unfortunately
KANU 2 Same as Anderson
Referee: 3
0 -
A M-B - 6 - not close to goal, or 2 close shots first half, saved one & injured
RAMSAY; 7.5 - looked quality 2nd half
JONES; 7 - solid and calm
GILLESPHEY: 7 - solid
SMALL: 6 - marked out of game -occassionaly he got past marker, 2nd Birmingham marker was ready
BERRY: 6- didn't really notice him,
COVENTRY: 6 - mistake lead to goal, not a good first half, but battled on
DOCHERTY: 7 - played well and showed leadership
EDWARDS: 7 - steady
GODDEN: 6 - isolated but battled on
T.CAMPBELL: 6- looked tired
MANNION: 6 - not much to do, but steady enough
ANDERSON: 6 - showed energy
KANU: 6 - didn't really influence events
Referee / linos: 4 - lots of poor decisions & too many cards, surprised no one get sent off
Gilbert: n/a - looked promising in brief stint he was on the pitch
Leaburn: n/a - made a difference when he came on0 -
A M-B: 6
RAMSAY; 6.5
JONES; 6
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 4.5
DOCHERTY: 5.5
EDWARDS: 6
GODDEN: 5.5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5
KANU: 6
Referee: 2
0 -
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 5
JONES; 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
SMALL: 4
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5
EDWARDS: 4
GODDEN: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 5
ANDERSON: 5
KANU: 5
1 -
A M-B 6
RAMSAY; 6.5
JONES; 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
Referee: 4
0 -
A M-B: 6
RAMSAY: 6.5
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5.5
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5.5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5.5
KANU: 5
Referee: 40 -
A M-B 6
RAMSAY; 6.5
JONES; 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 5
GODDEN: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 4.5
MANNION: 6.5
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
0 -
A M-B; 6.5
RAMSAY; 8
JONES; 8
GILLESPHEY: 7.5
SMALL: 6.5
BERRY: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6.5
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
Referee: 6.5
0 -
A M-B 6
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 8
GILLESPHEY: 8
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 8
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 7
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 4
Referee: 2
0 - Sponsored links:
-
A M-B: 5.5
RAMSAY: 7.5
JONES; 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 7
EDWARDS: 7.5
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 6
Referee: 20 -
A M-B 5.5 lucky boy
RAMSAY; 6.5
JONES; 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
EDWARDS: 6.5
GODDEN: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 4 looked disinterested
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 5.5
Referee: 1 possibly the worse I’ve ever seen, but for both teams…..complete clown
0 -
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 4.5
COVENTRY: 4.5
DOCHERTY:6.5
EDWARDS:7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL:4
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5
KANU: 4
Referee: 31 -
AMB: 4RAMSAY: 7.5JONES: 6GILLESPHEY: 7SMALL: 4BERRY: 4COVENTRY: 4DOCHERTY: 5EDWARDS: 5GODDEN: 5T.CAMPBELL: 3MANNION: 6ANDERSON: 5KANU: 5Referee: 30
-
Via the cafc stream.
A M-B. 5
RAMSAY; 6
JONES; 6
GILLESPHEY: 5.5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 6
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 5..5
Referee: 3.5. Awfull
Gilbert: n/a
Leaburn: n/a
0 -
A M-B 5
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 4
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 4
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 4
KANU: 4
Referee 30 -
At the game
A M-B 6
RAMSAY; 7
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 7
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 6.5
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 5
KANU: 5
Referee: 61 -
A M-B; 6
RAMSAY; 6.5
JONES; 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
EDWARDS: 7
GODDEN: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
MANNION: 6
ANDERSON: 6
KANU: 5
Referee: 4
0 -
A M-B 6RAMSAY; 6JONES; 6.5GILLESPHEY: 6SMALL: 6BERRY: 6COVENTRY: 6DOCHERTY: 6EDWARDS: 6GODDEN: 6T.CAMPBELL: 6MANNION: 6ANDERSON: 6KANU: 6Referee: 2 Killed the game second half.Gilbert: n/aLeaburn: n/a0
