Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best & Worst

stoneroses19stoneroses19
in General Charlton
Nice article with @PaddyP17 in this month's FourFourTwo. 


Comments

  • GribboGribbo
    Didn't realise this mag was still going. Pretty sure I remember when it first come out
  • ChizzChizz
    Some terrific answers there! I love "like a crisp packet on a warm summer breeze". 

    But, did you really mean lecherous, as opposed to leech-like? 
  • JohnnyH2JohnnyH2
    Wasn't Frayeye in a laundry basket at Colchester rather than Huddersfield?
  • se9addickse9addick
    Great answers Paddy, poor Simon Francis though! 
  • PaddyP17PaddyP17
    Editing mistakes lie with them lot. @JohnnyH2 thought it was a combination of both results?
  • SporadicAddickSporadicAddick
    Just watched the Sanogo hattrick on museum web site. Not as bad as all that but the one thing that stands out from that match was Yann. 

    I hope on that day Meire realised what an absolute out of depth cretin she was.  
  • SolidgoneSolidgone
    Great article Paddy.

    Interesting to hear of other’s responses to the best and worst?
  • cafcnick1992cafcnick1992
    That Worst Charlton XI is pretty spot on. I'm glad McLeod got a look in - he really was absolutely absymal. 
  • sam3110sam3110
    XI
    B:
    W:
    PLAYER
    B:
    W:
    MOMENT
    B:
    W:
    GAME
    B:
    W:
    SEASON
    B:
    W:
    GOAL
    B:
    W:
    MANAGER
    B:
    W:
    OWNER
    B:
    W:
    NICKNAME
    B:
    W:
    CHANT
    B:
    W:
    AWAY TRIP
    B:
    W:
  • Sponsored links:


  • sam3110sam3110
    XI
    B: Kiely, Young, Gomez, Costa, Powell, Berg Gudmundsson, Parker, Jensen, Jackson, Bent, Mendonca 
    W: Weaver, Foley, Williams, Cranie, Seaborne, Alonso, Crofts, Pouso, Ba, Gillespie, McLeod
    PLAYER
    B: Darren Bent, should have been an England regular and scoring goals in the Euros representing Charlton
    W: Seaborne, came on loan to us and genuinely didn't do a single thing well
    MOMENT
    B: Last minute winner at Wembley 
    W: watching us get relegated during COVID
    GAME
    B: A 4 nil demolition of West Ham, probably stands out more because we were rubbish that season and got relegated, but we were on fire that day
    W: most of the last few seasons tbh, one that particularly stands out is getting turned over by a dire Gillingham in the FA Cup
    SEASON
    B: 101 points, nuff said
    W: last season statistically was the worst, so that one
    GOAL
    B: JBG slide tackling his man 40 yards out, used his momentum to carry the ball forward and blasted it in from well outside the box, fantastic 
    W: Ahadme at the start of the season scored from about 6 inches out and still made it look hard work
    MANAGER
    B: Curbs
    W: Appleton
    OWNER
    B: Murray in the PL era
    W: Does Southall count?
    NICKNAME
    B: Simon "Spongefoot" Church, hilarious if he's not playing for you
    W: "Dench" Frimpong
    CHANT
    B:Valley Floyd Road but not at 3x speed
    W: the incest song to the Addams Family theme
    AWAY TRIP
    B: always love a trip to Portsmouth 
    W: Gillingham, shit stand, shit place, usually shit football 
  • killerandflashkillerandflash
    For the best season, it would have to be the "Championship" title of 1999/2000, as a bigger achievement than winning L1, however great that was.

    We got 91 points that season.
  • PaddyP17PaddyP17
    killerandflash said:
    For the best season, it would have to be the "Championship" title of 1999/2000, as a bigger achievement than winning L1, however great that was.

    We got 91 points that season.
    In fairness I was 5/6 at the time, so the later one - as seasons go, rather than individual players and the like - has stuck in my memory a bit more!
  • killerandflashkillerandflash
    PaddyP17 said:
    killerandflash said:
    For the best season, it would have to be the "Championship" title of 1999/2000, as a bigger achievement than winning L1, however great that was.

    We got 91 points that season.
    In fairness I was 5/6 at the time, so the later one - as seasons go, rather than individual players and the like - has stuck in my memory a bit more!
    I'm waiting for someone to reprimand me for not choosing 46/47 as the best season  :D
  • Hal1xHal1x
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

  • StigStig
    Hal1x said:
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

    Humphrey?
  • SteveACSSteveACS
    IHal1x said:
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

    I don't mind Mendonca, and Yann is a legend, but surely the best striker HAS to be Darren Bent?
  • Hal1xHal1x
    Stig said:
    Hal1x said:
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

    Humphrey?
    both of them
  • Hal1xHal1x
    edited April 4
    SteveACS said:
    IHal1x said:
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

    I don't mind Mendonca, and Yann is a legend, but surely the best striker HAS to be Darren Bent?
    Darren Bent's not visiting us tomorrow! I could drop Parker, bring in Bent and put Kermogant just behind the front two.

    You don't MIND Mendonca??? thats very generous of you! 

  • SteveACSSteveACS
    edited April 4
    Hal1x said:
    SteveACS said:
    IHal1x said:
    sam3110 said:
    XI https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/49244/worst-strikers-to-ever-wear-the-charlton-shirt/p2
    B: Kiely, Humphries, Reid, Rufus, Costa, Robinson, Kinsella, Parker, Jensen, Mendonca, Kermogant.
    W:Thuram, Bacon, E Khalej, Chappell, Pitcher, Blomqvist, K Smith, G Lapslie, Gillespie, Small, Clarke.
    PLAYER
    B: Kinsella
    W: Thuram
    MOMENT
    B: Shirtliff Play Off goal
    W: Leaving Valley.
    GAME
    B: Play Off Final at old Wembley
    W: 3-0 v Colchester
    SEASON
    B: 2011-12
    W: Last year
    GOAL
    B: Rufas goal at Wembley
    W: Alan Smith for Leeds
    MANAGER
    B:Curbishley
    W: any of Duchalets many.
    OWNER
    B: Murray/Simons
    W: The Spivs
    NICKNAME
    B: Addicks
    W: none
    CHANT
    B: Valley Floyd Rd
    W: Your Sister....
    AWAY TRIP
    B: Portsmouth or Southend
    W: Millwall Old Den

    I don't mind Mendonca, and Yann is a legend, but surely the best striker HAS to be Darren Bent?
    Darren Bent's not visiting us tomorrow! I could drop Parker, bring in Bent and put Kermogant just behind the front two.

    You don't MIND Mendonca??? thats very generous of you! 

    Yes, it was more in answer to someone saying our best two strikers were Mendoncs and Kermogant.

    Picking Mendonca is fine. He was one of our best strikers ever, and did it in the top tier.

    But Darren Bent, at one time, was the top scoring English striker in the Premier League, and MUST be in our best ever team...
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!