Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best / Worst Loan Players ?

SwingForward
SwingForward Posts: 146
edited November 2011 in General Charlton

As we are in the modern era of Loan players ( although not so much this time ) !! - who have been the 3 best / worst loan players we have seen at CAFC ?

Best - Alex Song, Graeme Murty and Scott Carson

Worst - Scott Sinclair, Lee Cook and Tom Soares.

«13

Comments

  • CAFC, We hate Palace
    CAFC, We hate Palace Posts: 116
    Jorge Costa - Best
  • peteshep1905
    peteshep1905 Posts: 491

    best - song, carson, martin

    worst - gillespie, crainie, ikeme

  • I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY
    I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY Posts: 4,619
    Best: Jorge Costa, Alex Song, Chris Perry

    Worst: Gillespie, Butterfield, Lee Cook

    Used badly: Scott Sinclair & OMAR POUSO


  • Crispy
    Crispy Posts: 594

    Best - Song, Costa, Carson

    Worst - Gillespie, Cranie, Nouble

  • Rizzo
    Rizzo Posts: 6,468
    Alex Song has turned into a pretty decent player but when we had him I was really unimpressed. He seemed lazy and uninterested. Surprised to see him in people's lists to be honest.
  • SoundAsa£
    SoundAsa£ Posts: 22,576
    Have to say Costa.
  • Mortimerician
    Mortimerician Posts: 5,222
    Best: Smertin, Song, Costa
    Worst: Sinclair Cook Soares Ikeme Craine
  • Saga Lout
    Saga Lout Posts: 6,845
    I thought Smertin was ours?
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,978
    Costa has to be the best hands down. Wasnt Bothroyd on loan also?
  • thai malaysia addick
    thai malaysia addick Posts: 18,532
    edited November 2011
    Mike Small from West Ham
    Tom Hovi from HamKam(?) FC

    I'll leave everyone to decide if they come under 'best' or 'worst'

  • Sponsored links:



  • Ormiston_Addick
    Ormiston_Addick Posts: 8,818

    Alan Kernaghan was class but I don't see how you can go past Jorge "The Tank" Costa.

    Don't forget, the bloke went on to captain a Champions League winning team (Porto) after he left us - will that ever happen again?

  • peteshep1905
    peteshep1905 Posts: 491

    carlton cole was ok wen with us

  • davedave
    davedave Posts: 101
    George Costa
    Mike Small/Tom Hovi
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,978

    carlton cole was ok wen with us

    I thought he was pony.
  • Talal
    Talal Posts: 11,571

    Remember thinking Kevin Scott was dreadful, for a centre back who was about 6ft3 he barely won a header.

    Will always think fondly of Neil Heaney

  • McBobbin
    McBobbin Posts: 12,090
    El khalej was on loan, and the worst player I have ever seen.  Excluding those who signed afterwards, Costa has to be the best.  I also have fond memories of Neil Heaney, not least because of the Playoff finals.
  • Its_Hamer_Time
    Its_Hamer_Time Posts: 1,565
    Carlton Cole was poo! Terrible at us.
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,040

     

    Best either Carson or Costa

    Worst probably Lee Cook not that he is a bad player but he was injured and never match fit.

  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,426
    Alan McDonald, Jorge Costa
  • adamtheaddick
    adamtheaddick Posts: 8,664
    neil heaney is in with a shout with the part he played leading up to sunderland.

  • Sponsored links:



  • adamtheaddick
    adamtheaddick Posts: 8,664
    sasa loan spell with the hammers was epic..
  • Big William
    Big William Posts: 3,868
    sasa loan spell with the hammers was epic..
    Someone showed me a West Ham news site with the headline "Coco goes back" after he went back to us. Poor old Sasa, when he was good he was very good but when he was bad.....
  • adamtheaddick
    adamtheaddick Posts: 8,664
    he played in there london masters team... 
  • Gravesend_Addick
    Gravesend_Addick Posts: 7,334
    Jorge Costa was the best loan signing by a mile!
  • Rizzo
    Rizzo Posts: 6,468

    carlton cole was ok wen with us

    Carlton Cole was utter shite when he was with us.
  • AddickedAthletic
    AddickedAthletic Posts: 834
    Cole was pants, Song was class, Costa was simply the best
  • Rizzo
    Rizzo Posts: 6,468
    Also, wasn't it supposed to be part of the Parker deal that we got Cole back on loan for the next season - until he told us to fuck off.
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,438
    I'm doing mine based on the impact they had on the team rather than overall ability, so no Noubles or Ikemes in mine. Costa, Carson and Smertin were the best for me. Cook, Cranie and Halford the worst. Halford scored a few but cost us twice as many. Between them those three cost us so many points
  • peteshep1905
    peteshep1905 Posts: 491

    carlton cole was ok wen with us

    Carlton Cole was utter shite when he was with us.

    i was a mere 13 year old who loved strikers... my memory isnt great from then, just thort id put it out there
  • paulbaconsarnie
    paulbaconsarnie Posts: 9,436
    dennis bailey failed to live up to the 'hat-trick at old trafford' billing.

Categories

“Marketplace”