Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton 2-4 Notts County

13

Comments

  • Bill_Stumps
    Bill_Stumps Posts: 891
    Hamer 4
    Solly 6
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 5
    Wiggins 6
    Wagstaff 7
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 4
    Jackson 4
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 7
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,088
    If the name 'Francis' was there instead of 'Solly' or 'Wiggins', we'd be seeing 2s and 3s. Wagstaff can set up 1 and score 1 and run tirelessly when almost everyone else has given up. But he gets 4s and 5s.

    Whether you like a player or not shouldn't reflect on the score you give them.
  • Southendaddick
    Southendaddick Posts: 5,349
    Never underestimatte the weirdness of our support Rugby

    Cafcbrennans the best so far, Hamer more than Wagstaff, and BWP miles ahead for scoring and setting one up and looking up for it which describes Waggys second half quite well.

    Weird
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,693
    If the name 'Francis' was there instead of 'Solly' or 'Wiggins', we'd be seeing 2s and 3s. Wagstaff can set up 1 and score 1 and run tirelessly when almost everyone else has given up. But he gets 4s and 5s.

    Whether you like a player or not shouldn't reflect on the score you give them.
    Agree. Unfortunately some decided in pre-season that Green was "class" and Wagstaff a "headless chicken".

    Yet in the last couple of years we've seen both (if starting regularly) are capable of around 15 goals and assists, but neither look Championship standard at the moment.
  • davy macaddick
    davy macaddick Posts: 426
    Hamer 4
    Solly 6.5
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 5
    Wiggins 5
    Wagstaff 5
    Hollands 5.5
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 7
  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,314
    Hamer 5
    Solly 5.5
    Morrison 5.5
    Taylor 5.5
    Wiggins 6
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 5.5
    Stephens 5.5
    Jackson 5.5
    Kermorgant 5.5
    Wright Phillips 6.5

    referee - 4 - his dislike of Kermi not even subtle
    Notts Co - 8.5 - the best side we have played this season in my view
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,366
    Never underestimatte the weirdness of our support Rugby

    Cafcbrennans the best so far, Hamer more than Wagstaff, and BWP miles ahead for scoring and setting one up and looking up for it which describes Waggys second half quite well.

    Weird
    we should have brought waggy on before HT :-)



  • Redrobo
    Redrobo Posts: 11,338
    Hamer 5
    Solly 5
    Morrison 5
    Taylor 6
    Wiggins 6
    Wagstaff 7.5 MOM
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Wright Phillips 7
  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 16,663
    Hamer 5
    Solly 5
    Morrison 5
    Taylor 4 Looked lost
    Wiggins 4 One of those bad days
    Wagstaff 7.5 The only creative outlet
    Hollands 5 Anonymous
    Stephens 6 Better than Hollands
    Jackson 5 Not a captain's performance
    Kermorgant 5 Disappointing
    Wright Phillips 8 The only one still making an effort and trying to gee others up at 0-4
  • Mendonca In Asdas
    Mendonca In Asdas Posts: 22,706
    Hamer 3
    Solly 5
    Morrison 4
    Taylor 4
    Wiggins 4
    Wagstaff 7
    Hollands 4
    Stephens 4
    Jackson 4
    Kermorgant 5
    Wright Phillips 7

  • Sponsored links:



  • addickinsane
    addickinsane Posts: 41
    Hamer 5
    Solly 5
    Morrison 5
    Taylor 5
    Wiggins 5
    Wagstaff 7 MOM - ran his socks off
    Hollands 5.5
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 5
    Wright Phillips 6

    Bad day at the office...but much better 2nd half.
  • BigRedEvil
    BigRedEvil Posts: 11,125
    Hamer-5
    Solly-5
    Morrison-6
    Taylor-5
    Wiggins-5.5
    Wagstaff-7
    Hollands-6
    Stephens-6
    Jackson-6
    Kermorgant-6
    Wright Phillips-7
  • CatAddick
    CatAddick Posts: 2,395
    Hamer 4 - failed to command his area
    Solly 6
    Morrison 4.5 - Spent most of the match watching Taylor watching the ball
    Taylor 4 - Same as MM; reverse names
    Wiggins 4.5 - off day?
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 5.5
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5 - Still looks unfit following injury
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Wright Phillips 7.5
  • adamtheaddick
    adamtheaddick Posts: 8,664
    Hamer 4, you have the number one shirt, command your area take control do your job.
    Solly 6
    Morrison 5
    Taylor 5
    Wiggins 6
    Wagstaff 6
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 7
  • DRF
    DRF Posts: 2,455
    Hamer - 5
    Solly - 5 - his worst game this season
    Morrison - 5
    Taylor - 4
    Wiggins - 5
    Wagstaff - 4 - gets an extra point for a goal
    Hollands - 5.5
    Stephens - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 5.5
    Wright Phillips - 7.5 - extra point for goal and assist and looked really good and up for it second half
    Seriously you thought Waggy was a 3 without that goal? So setting up the other goal counts for nothing and he was worse than Hamer who shipped 4 goals?

    Pathetic.
  • RedArmySE7
    RedArmySE7 Posts: 5,407
    Hamer - 4
    Solly - 5.5
    Morrison - 5
    Taylor - 5
    Wiggins - 5
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 4.5
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 5
    Wright Phillips - 6
  • Dansk_Red
    Dansk_Red Posts: 5,741
    Hamer 5
    Solly 7
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 5
    Wiggins 6
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 6
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Wright Phillips 7.5
  • Greenie
    Greenie Posts: 9,174
    Hamer - 4
    Solly - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 4
    Wiggins - 6
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 4
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
    Wright Phillips - 7

    Bloke behind the goal who headed the ball - 9
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 26,344
    Hamer -3
    Solly - 6
    Morrison 5.5
    Taylor 4
    Wiggins 5
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Wright Phillips 6.5
  • Simonsen
    Simonsen Posts: 5,555
    Hamer - 5 Not great and and I wouldn't have a problem in Sullivan getting some games because he's a decent/brave keeper. Still like Hamer though...he's done ok this season.
    Solly - 6 Like most others he was bit off but still did some good things and never gave up.
    Morrison - 6 Not convinced he was especially bad.
    Taylor - 5 A bit hesitant but another strong character who will have recovered from bad games before.
    Wiggins - 5.5 Some mistakes but always gives everything.
    Wagstaff - 7 Had a really good spell but then faded. Ought to stay in the team for a bit now. Took his goal well (his first headed goal?)
    Hollands - 5 Never got going. All the games must be catching up with him.
    Stephens - 5.5 His shooting ability will always keep him in the game but he was out-gunned by County.
    Jackson 5 Surely not fit?
    Kermorgant - 6 As ever, most of his good work had to be done outside the box. Was well marked.
    Wright Phillips - 8 Zero service in the first half but never gave up. Well taken goal and smart cross for Wagstaff's header. Attitude 100% spot on and at least no-one is talking about his barren spell now.

    Powell - Wonder if he regrets not making two substitutions with 20 mins left. It just petered out when we should've had them under siege. Might have also been useful to give Hollands a bit of a rest and give Russell some game time.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Brunello
    Brunello Posts: 1,950
    edited March 2012
    Hamer 5
    Solly 4 - Very poor by his own high standards
    Morrison 6 - Tried to keep a flailing defence together
    Taylor 4 - Am I the only one who thought the goal was down to him?
    Wiggins 4 - So one footed it is criminal
    Wagstaff 6
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 7.5 - Thought he played the same as he has done recently. Very well with bags of effort
  • lolwray
    lolwray Posts: 4,929
    hamer 4
    solly 6
    taylor 4
    morro 6
    wiggins 5
    waggy 7
    hollands 6
    stevens 6
    jacko 4
    bwp 7
    kermit 7

    id stick with hamer because i dt think sullivan is any better id give cort a run of games,jacko isnt fit ,hes running through treacle so if green is fit id play him left side and put waggy on right same 2 upfront
  • lancashire lad
    lancashire lad Posts: 15,698
    This thread is now close for marks, stats will be out on Tuesday
  • McLovin
    McLovin Posts: 2,307
    edited March 2012
    Hamer - 4
    Solly - 6
    Taylor - 3
    Morrison - 6
    Wiggins - 5
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 5.5
    Stephens - 5.5
    Jackson - 4
    Wright - Phillips - 7
    kermorgant - 7

    Sorry, didn't read your comment before scoring LL. Points for fun only then.
  • incorruptible addick
    incorruptible addick Posts: 2,125
    If the name 'Francis' was there instead of 'Solly' or 'Wiggins', we'd be seeing 2s and 3s. Wagstaff can set up 1 and score 1 and run tirelessly when almost everyone else has given up. But he gets 4s and 5s.

    85 posts in the thread and only four people gave Waggy five or less. When LL puts up the stats tomorrow, I would expect Waggy to be in the top two with BWP. As for Francis, you are having a laugh. If he'd been playing we would probably have lost 6-2. He's helped Bournemouth to lose their last five games. We've only last our last two!

  • cafcbrennan
    cafcbrennan Posts: 24
    Hamer - 5
    Solly - 5 - his worst game this season
    Morrison - 5
    Taylor - 4
    Wiggins - 5
    Wagstaff - 4 - gets an extra point for a goal
    Hollands - 5.5
    Stephens - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 5.5
    Wright Phillips - 7.5 - extra point for goal and assist and looked really good and up for it second half
    Seriously you thought Waggy was a 3 without that goal? So setting up the other goal counts for nothing and he was worse than Hamer who shipped 4 goals?

    Pathetic.
    you can blame hamer for about 1 goal which was mainly taylors fault and waggys cross for the goal was poor way to near the keeper just really good play from wright-phillips and ill give him the header that was a good goal but apart from that he did nothing just gave the ball away all the time, he was dreadful!!
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,454
    Dreadful apart from the goal, the assist, the excellent cross kerno tried to punch in, our first shot on target and a couple more shots in the 2nd half, his running and hard work.

    Clearly marking based on your prejudices not on the performances on the day.
  • EastTerrace
    EastTerrace Posts: 3,968
    Not Waggy's biggest fan but probably the best of a bad bunch (first half though he was as bad as the rest of them).

    How Hamer can get a 5 is beyond me, apart from the goals he was terrible (didn't command and un-nerved the defence).... although he slightly improved in the second half.
  • scruffle
    scruffle Posts: 2,290
    Hamer - 5.5
    Solly - 5
    Morrison - 5
    Taylor - 5
    Wiggins - 6
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 5.5
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
    Wright Phillips - 7
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 44,990
    Dreadful apart from the goal, the assist, the excellent cross kerno tried to punch in, our first shot on target and a couple more shots in the 2nd half, his running and hard work.

    Clearly marking based on your prejudices not on the performances on the day.
    This.

    We all see things differently, granted ...... but some posters' marking is beyond credibility.

Categories

“Marketplace”