Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Sherlock
Comments
-
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
0 -
NNNNNNNNNNNNOBODY EXPECTS THE SPAINI- hang on.Lincsaddick said:
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
People tend to have reasons for disliking things, why do you think it's childish rubbish?0 -
@LucyMangan: This Sunday's Sherlock is beyond brilliant. Beyond. Brilliant. #Sherlock0
-
kentaddick said:
NNNNNNNNNNNNOBODY EXPECTS THE SPAINI- hang on.Lincsaddick said:
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
People tend to have reasons for disliking things, why do you think it's childish rubbish?
because the programme had/has that element of .. childish rubbish .. it is probably an age thing .. old(ish) connoisseurs such as my good self, those with impeccable taste .. we know tut when we view it .. it has that certain je ne sais quoi .. if you get me drift
0 -
Why ? Are there a couple of Charlton supporters in the Sherlock cast ?Redskin said:I think it speaks volumes that there are five pages on the Big Brother thread and just the one on Sherlock
0 -
Cheese, diamonds, bollocks ...Lincsaddick said:kentaddick said:
NNNNNNNNNNNNOBODY EXPECTS THE SPAINI- hang on.Lincsaddick said:
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
People tend to have reasons for disliking things, why do you think it's childish rubbish?
because the programme had/has that element of .. childish rubbish .. it is probably an age thing .. old(ish) connoisseurs such as my good self, those with impeccable taste .. we know tut when we view it .. it has that certain je ne sais quoi .. if you get me drift
You still can't answer the question.0 -
who the fuck asked you .. push off ((:>)Redskin said:
Cheese, diamonds, bollocks ...Lincsaddick said:kentaddick said:
NNNNNNNNNNNNOBODY EXPECTS THE SPAINI- hang on.Lincsaddick said:
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
People tend to have reasons for disliking things, why do you think it's childish rubbish?
because the programme had/has that element of .. childish rubbish .. it is probably an age thing .. old(ish) connoisseurs such as my good self, those with impeccable taste .. we know tut when we view it .. it has that certain je ne sais quoi .. if you get me drift
You still can't answer the question.
-1 -
Cheese, diamonds, bollocks, pissed .Lincsaddick said:
who the fuck asked you .. push off ((:>)Redskin said:
Cheese, diamonds, bollocks ...Lincsaddick said:kentaddick said:
NNNNNNNNNNNNOBODY EXPECTS THE SPAINI- hang on.Lincsaddick said:
anyone would think you were the Spanish inquisition ((:>) .. why? .. because after 20 mins of 'The Hearse etc etc', I exclaimed .. 'what a load of old childish rubbish' .. and turned it off .. how does one define 'cheese' or 'diamond', how does one define 'childish' .. you either know what it is .. or you don't .. good viewing !-!kentaddick said:
Okay, why do you think so?Lincsaddick said:for me .. this is childish rubbish tarted up in a very glossy wrapper .. but I am sure I will be in a minority here.
People tend to have reasons for disliking things, why do you think it's childish rubbish?
because the programme had/has that element of .. childish rubbish .. it is probably an age thing .. old(ish) connoisseurs such as my good self, those with impeccable taste .. we know tut when we view it .. it has that certain je ne sais quoi .. if you get me drift
You still can't answer the question.
I was here first...
Answer the question.
0 -
^^^ h g wells will be turning in his grave0
-
Sleep it off, old man.Lincsaddick said:^^^ h g wells will be turning in his grave
0 - Sponsored links:
-
So you're still rocking the 'get a life' comeback... Do you still quote Wayne's World too?Riviera said:
Yeah, and a life unlike you obviously.JiMMy 85 said:
That all you got troll?Riviera said:
Oh dear.......JiMMy 85 said:
Skyfall, however, wasn't just full of holes - how did a man get shot, drown, and end up drinking tequila - but it had a story and resolution without integrity. Not only was the ending utterly nonsensical, but it undid the fine work that started with Casino Royale!0 -
-
schwing1
-
The posts on this thread are MUCH longer though. And some taking themselves too seriously.Bedsaddick said:
Why ? Are there a couple of Charlton supporters in the Sherlock cast ?Redskin said:I think it speaks volumes that there are five pages on the Big Brother thread and just the one on Sherlock
0 -
Hmmmmm.....0
-
It was very good. No longer, it's gone too silly.0
-
Liked the first two episodes this series but was lost and bored with tonight's.
0 -
I loved it!0
-
I feel the exact opposite, NLN ! Didn't really enjoy the last 2 - too contrived for me.North Lower Neil said:Liked the first two episodes this series but was lost and bored with tonight's.
Thought tonight's was quite brilliant & kept me wondering what would happen next right to the very end.
0 -
Agreed. Thought the second episode was dreadful but tonights was brilliant!Fanny Fanackapan said:
I feel the exact opposite, NLN ! Didn't really enjoy the last 2 - too contrived for me.North Lower Neil said:Liked the first two episodes this series but was lost and bored with tonight's.
Thought tonight's was quite brilliant & kept me wondering what would happen next right to the very end.1 - Sponsored links:
-
Though the baddie was good, bit just couldn't get into it!0
-
I thought the ending with the broadcast message was an overused Dr Who cliche.0
-
Dropped off last week.
Hooked tonight.0 -
Enjoyed it. I'm new to this incarnation of Holmes but will now dig out the previous ones of this production.
Excellent Timeshift documentary on BBC4 tonight about all the different versions of Holmes. Well worth catching up with on BBC i-player if you missed it. It's got me interested again in the whole Holmes phenomenon.
I have a box set of the Basil Rathbone films and fancy revisiting them. Also I loved the Billy Wilder film from the 70's with Robert Stephens and Colin Blakely.0 -
I thought that was really good, pretty dark subject matter too
The ending was a bit Doctor Whoish I concede, but a clever cliffhanger for Series 4 (whenever that might be!)0 -
Found myself feeling glad that this series is only 3 episodes. Trying to be too clever and shocking. Needs to get back to basics with solving intriguing cases.
Has it jumped the shark or a brief lull in quality.?0 -
Fell asleep so watching again tonight. Did have to rewind a few times when we were awake as we 'didn't get it'. Hoping the last half hour makes things clearer!0
-
Thought it was good. Certainly the best out the 3. Martin Freeman is a terrific actor.
The cliffhangers good, but the fact that bill boards were showing (it) was ridiculous.0 -
This is where I am at. It's very good at what it does, but it's hardly Sherlock Holmes any more. There has only been one proper mystery for him to solve in all three episodes (the killer in episode 2), it seems to me that the writers have fallen in love with their own writing a bit. This cliffhanger is a good example - SPOILER WARNING yes very dramatic and clever, but both Holmes and Moriarity (apparently) died, but oh no not really. So why the hell should we believe next time will be any kind of real conclusion?MrOneLung said:Found myself feeling glad that this series is only 3 episodes. Trying to be too clever and shocking. Needs to get back to basics with solving intriguing cases.
Has it jumped the shark or a brief lull in quality.?0 -
Sherlock Holmes never lived so he cannot die.
A line from the BBC4 doc last night.0
![[Deleted User]](https://charltonlife.vanillacommunity.com/applications/dashboard/design/images/defaulticon.png)
