Penalty
Comments
-
Should be illegal. Police need to clamp down on these sorts of things.11
-
Maybe only a small dictator... ;0)Derek1952 said:Just been looking at the BBC sports website, and there,s a clip of South Korea taking a penalty.The person taking the kick touches the ball and another player from outside the box runs up to score.I did not think that was leagal.I know Pires tried a few seasons ago,so does this set a president for penalty taking.
Not sure Derek, never seen it happen before. Any experts out there? (silly question on CL I know...)0 -
It's not an illegal routine, except it's blatant encroaching by the 2nd player - he's near enough on the penalty spot when its rolled to him!0
-
Ajax done this in the 70's and Arsenal tried to do this in the Prem not to long ago0
-
Jesper Olsen and Johan Cruyff wasn't it?0
-
As long as the ball moves forward and the second players comes from outside the penalty area then I think it is ok.1
-
It doesn't need to move forward.LargeAddick said:As long as the ball moves forward and the second players comes from outside the penalty area then I think it is ok.
0 -
When Arsenal failed it was because Pires didn't actually touch the ball.0
-
...but it needs to move by at least 27 inchesguinnessaddick said:
It doesn't need to move forward.LargeAddick said:As long as the ball moves forward and the second players comes from outside the penalty area then I think it is ok.
0 - Sponsored links:
-
I think they did away with that a few years ago.Chizz said:
...but it needs to move by at least 27 inchesguinnessaddick said:
It doesn't need to move forward.LargeAddick said:As long as the ball moves forward and the second players comes from outside the penalty area then I think it is ok.
0 -
Yep. Used to be ball had to roll its circumference now just has to visibly move.
Would have been a legit penalty if not for the 2nd player encroaching before taker touched the ball.0 -
I never knew this.
So the penalty taker could pass the ball to his left or right, as long as it goes marginally forward, for someone to come in and larrup a moving ball ?
Why doesn't that happen more often ?0 -
Was thinking about this the other day.
How fricking ultra confident were they that they would win no matter what to try this.
0 -
Apologies for quoting myself, but this is it:lordromford said:Jesper Olsen and Johan Cruyff wasn't it?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJHN1mN5SCg 1 -
Could this not be interpreted as unsporting like conduct?0
-
Why? There's nothing unsporting going on. The ball can be played by anyone once it is kicked by the taker. No different to a player touching a free kick to the side before another player hits itcafc999 said:Could this not be interpreted as unsporting like conduct?
0 -
A free kick is just that though isn't it? A penalty is not a free kick.Garrymanilow said:
Why? There's nothing unsporting going on. The ball can be played by anyone once it is kicked by the taker. No different to a player touching a free kick to the side before another player hits itcafc999 said:Could this not be interpreted as unsporting like conduct?
It's a bit like when the striker does a feint in his run up to the penalty spot to put the keeper off. Some refs have said that performing that is unsporting yet they allow keepers to jump about.
I personally think it's great though0 -
This is correct. Only at kick off and the taking of a penalty does the ball have to be played forward.LargeAddick said:As long as the ball moves forward and the second players comes from outside the penalty area then I think it is ok.
0 -
If someone done that though they would be asking for a crunching tackle straight from kick off. Piss take.Garrymanilow said:
Why? There's nothing unsporting going on. The ball can be played by anyone once it is kicked by the taker. No different to a player touching a free kick to the side before another player hits itcafc999 said:Could this not be interpreted as unsporting like conduct?
0 - Sponsored links:
-
You know we would cock this up, right?3
-
not if we had Buyens running up and knocking the ball forwards allowing the on-rushing Simon Church to smash the ball into the net past the poor goalkeeper.AFKABartram said:You know we would cock this up, right?
1 -
Don't know why for one minute you would try to make a penalty any easier (if it does make it easier at all)
Its free shot into a large area 12yrds out, not very hard at all imo.
1 -
This was my first thought, doing little 'tricks' like this make it much, much harder, surely?Charltonparklane said:Don't know why for one minute you would try to make a penalty any easier (if it does make it easier at all)
Its free shot into a large area 12yrds out, not very hard at all imo.
0 -
I don't understand the need to do anything other thn have a direct shot on goal from a penalty. It's a 50/50 chance of scoring, so why risk cocking it up?
Nicky Bailey could show them a thing or two from the spot. That's if they find the ball from the Swindon play off game.2 -
98/02 chance of scoring.ricky_otto said:I don't understand the need to do anything other that have a direct shot on goal from a penalty. It's a 50/50 chance of scoring, so why jeopardise it?
anybody 50/50 chance of scoring would not be taking one for me!!!!
0 -
yeah this could be a great thing in a penalty shoot out, why not involve the whole team?0
-
Second pass offside?0
-
Or is it whoosh?0
