Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
The Scapegoats XI

thai malaysia addick
Posts: 18,333
I'm trying to put together a team of scapegoats from players who have played since 2000 and have left the club. To be a scapegoat, a player needs to have played a decent number of games. It's tricky. Any improvements (or the opposite, perhaps)?
Thuram
Francis
Doherty
McCarthy
Evina
Green
Ambrose
Faye
McLeod
Abbott
Gray
Thuram
Francis
Doherty
McCarthy
Evina
Green
Ambrose
Faye
McLeod
Abbott
Gray
1
Comments
-
McCormack
Butterfield0 -
Can you class Faye as a scapegoat...wasn't he just awful?3
-
Good point. McCormack should get his place in my original 11.Busterblitz said:Can you class Faye as a scapegoat...wasn't he just awful?
0 -
Varney2
-
I agree Faye is definitely not a scapegoat. He's simply the worst player ever to put the shirt on.
I would add Kevin Lisbie & David Mooney to that list ahead of Gray.1 -
Llera
Fox
Wilson
Church0 -
I'd have Traore in front of Evina at left back0
-
Being not very good does not make a scapegoat. Being ok but getting the blame unfairly is nearer the mark.
I nominate Wagstaff, Varney and more recently Fox as candidates. Most of those mentioned above were just not very good.3 -
after the way people have been speaking about him over the past 2 years Church should be ahead of Gray0
-
Agreedpaulie8290 said:after the way people have been speaking about him over the past 2 years Church should be ahead of Gray
0 - Sponsored links:
-
I did say players who had left the Club otherwise Church would have made the team.paulie8290 said:after the way people have been speaking about him over the past 2 years Church should be ahead of Gray
0 -
He's another that was just shit though.MartinhoCAFC said:I'd have Traore in front of Evina at left back
2 -
Don't forget Kish ....... only Curbs, Len Glover and me could see what he brought to the team.
;o)
1 -
sorry missed thatthai malaysia addick said:
I did say players who had left the Club otherwise Church would have made the team.paulie8290 said:after the way people have been speaking about him over the past 2 years Church should be ahead of Gray
0 -
Thuram
Francis - Doherty - McCarthy - Fox
Wilson - Buyens - Ambrose - Green
Church - Abbott0 -
Scandalously even John Robinson could make that list . He was treated badly by an idiotic section of fans at the back end of his Charlton career along with Kish.0
-
Is it safe to assume that Alan Pardew gets the nod as Manager?0
-
Kishishev and Lisbie were perpetually scapegoated.1
-
Lloyd Sam would have to be there surely.3
-
If we are talking a fair number of games Hamer must be a candidate for keeper.
I saw a fair few Covered End Upper dwellers with foam flecked spittle around their mouths shout venom at him!0 - Sponsored links:
-
i have developed a nervous twitch just reading those names above ...its bringing it all back /its going all dark and grey ,i dont feel happy ...where s me pills ?!!!!!1
-
Bryan Hughes5
-
Nick Weaver
Mark Hudson
Miguel Llera
Ceddy
Nicky Bailey
Marvin Sordell
Callum Harriot
1 -
Elliot (blamed playing behind a poor defence)
Solly (yes, too short)
Kish (no idea why)
Waggy (not being Green)
Jackson (legs gone for the past three seasons)
Fox (give him a chance)
Pritchard (very effective but some never liked him)
Yann (blamed for being on the end of long balls he had no control over)
0 -
Bryan Hughes is a great shout. Scored some handy goals for us and generally did well but is mostly remembered as being rubbish.
Does Matt Holland qualify? Gets called Captain Cleanshorts despite the fact he was one of the most committed players around3 -
It's beginning to look like quite a strong team to me1
-
Nicky Weaver is a good shout. Nicky Bailey not so good.Pedro45 said:Nick Weaver
Mark Hudson
Miguel Llera
Ceddy
Nicky Bailey
Marvin Sordell
Callum Harriot1 -
Hamer
Francis
Llera
Fortune
Youga
Sam
Kishishev
McCormack
Ambrose
Lisbie
Mooney0 -
Good call, but I would have thought Fortune was considered pretty reliable by most. Varney and Wagstaff must be on the subs bench, I would have thought.LenGlover said:Hamer
Francis
Llera
Fortune
Youga
Sam
Kishishev
McCormack
Ambrose
Lisbie
Mooney0 -
Mervyn Day as coach, as he never seemed to get the respect Curbs and Peacock got?0