Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Huddersfield

124»

Comments

  • Pope - 5 Sorry never feel confident with him in goal
    Solly - 6 kept at it but not Captain material
    Fox - 4 At fault for first and doesn't have any pace BUT has no back up and no outlet on the left
    Bauer - 6 Did ok
    Sarr - 6 distribution good, looks comfortable on ball , first start in league so will not be too harsh.
    Gudmundsson - 4 awful to the usual high standard
    Kashi - 5 tried but i am not sure he is suited to these sort of home games when we need to unlock the opposition
    Ba - 5 shooting woeful but not quite as bad as some make out, we all want Cousins in middle but lets not make Ba out to be the scapegoat
    Cousins - 5 look disjointed when he is on the left, need his energy in the middle
    Makienok - 5.5 done ok with his back to goal and must get frustrated at our lack of wing play and crosses in the box ! Taken off because was suffering from a knock
    Watt- 4 awful but needs to keep going and trying to take people on albeit a little higher up the pitch - Think we are going to have games where he is going to look world class and others where he will look like he plays for the Red lion up on Blackheath.

    Bergdich - Gave more balance but think he needs a run at leftback, might get that chance as Fox went off with a knock
    McAleny n/a
  • Pope - 5
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 5.5
    Bauer - 6
    Sarr - 6
    Gudmundsson - 5.5
    Kashi - 6
    Ba - 5.5
    Cousins - 6
    Makienok - 6
    Watt- 6

    Bergdich - 6
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a
  • Pope - 5 Hero to zero, true Charlton style, what a player
    Solly - 6 All seemed a bit of a struggle
    Fox - 4 Awful
    Bauer - 6.5 Even the BFG seemed a little hesitant at times, its ok Paddy Heddo will be back soon, you will like playing with him. I hope.
    Sarr - 5 Took goal well, but don't understand why he was playing. Perhaps it was to rest an aging AD in an easy home game. Well that worked out then.
    Gudmundsson - 7 Kept plugging away
    Kashi - 7 I admire his urgency.
    Ba - 5 Moving on
    Cousins - 6 Out of position yet again
    Makienok - 6 Not sure if it's him or those around him. On last night evidence I am going to go the later. Jury is out.
    Watt- 5 Said it Saturday say it again, its not all about you Tony. When its your day fine, when its not, pass for Christ sake

    Bergdich - 6 Not sure about him to be honest

  • Pope - 4 they wouldn't have scored if hendo was fit.
    Solly - 4 up against a good player, but seemed out of position and slower.
    Fox - 3 being generous with mark. I watch him and actually think that with luck I could have played pro football. Want to see bergdich for next few games.
    Bauer - 7 didn't look same assured self. Probably still our best player.
    Sarr - 5 not helped by bad referee. At times made Miller look unplayable. Smash him back.
    Gudmundsson - 6 same move, cut in and look to shoot. Maybe look to change wings for short spells in game and Change it up.
    Kashi - 6 like his commitment but not as good as his first few games.
    Ba - 4 not good
    Cousins - 6 back to centre please ASAP.
    Makienok - 7 couple of duff shots but still most dangerous player. When he wins header we have no one running on to it. Should not have been subbed.
    Watt- 5 not his best. In defence of him I feel he is the only one who takes people on and can make something out of nothing. They did double up on him but that's where he needs to learn to adjust. Still love you man.

    Bergdich - 7 did nothing wrong. Would like to see him at left back please.
    McAleny - some nice touches, think he will do well.
    Vetokele n/a
  • Pope - 5 definite error for first goal, caught crosses well
    Solly - 6 looking slow but gets no cover from the icelandic poseur
    Fox - 5 poor decision contributed to first goal but exposed when Cousins goes walkabout
    Bauer - 6 coped adequately with troublesome Miller
    Sarr - 6 hardly noticed him which for defenders is usually good
    Gudmundsson - 3 awol for most of the game bottled most challenges needs serious attitude adjustment
    Kashi - 7 best player by a distance
    Ba - 4 contributed little
    Cousins - 5 wasted on left
    Makienok - 6 not on same wavelength as strike partners, honest endeavour, needs to learn from Miller how to be a proper nuisance with size
    Watt- 5 if he used his head he'd be twice as effective from half the effort

    Bergdich - 4 lightweight and lacks bravery
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a
  • Pope - 5 - Powell knew he would be suspect hence they kept putting it in the box. Should have got his body behind the first and shouldn't have hidden behind the wall for the 2nd.
    Solly - 5 - Not a skipper. Looks to have lost a half yard of pace.
    Fox - 5 Apparently carrying a knock. Tackle for the 1st goal was woeful. Take the ball then the man if you have to. Did neither.
    Bauer - 6 - Not his usual self. Needs an experienced head alongside him while he is learning the division. Struggled with Miller's physicality
    Sarr - 5 Really tough debut against a colossus when attacking but a fucking fanny when touched. He'll have better games but he will also not play against many more physical strikers.
    Gudmundsson - 5.5 typical winger. Still exciting when on the ball but should have had that free kick all day long. Perfect position for him.
    Kashi - 6 - Energetic and tried to drive things - not his best game though
    Ba - 5 - Bad day at the office unfortunately.
    Cousins - 5 Make him skipper and put him in the middle
    Makienok - 6 Not fully fit. Not on the same wavelength as TWatt
    Watt- 4 - selfish and greedy. Really frustrating. Stop believing your own hype - play how you are asked to play.

    Bergdich - 5 - Jury very much out on him. Sometimes I see hints of a Giggs-type player in him, more often see hints of a Callum Harriot
    McAleny n/a Lively, nice feet. The fact he came on ahead of Igor speaks volumes
    Vetokele n/a He's broken. Offers nothing at the moment - hasn't for a while.

    Luzon - Resting Diarra probably cost us this game. We needed a bit of nous at the back - instead we went with two, young and inexperienced players against a beast. At the end they were playing 9 at the back and Miller on his own and they still looked more threatening than we did.
  • 1· Need a keeper.2 left back big time. 3. Left winger.and sarr dont no yet but y drop mom from sat.owell


  • Pope - 6
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 5
    Bauer - 6
    Sarr - 6
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Kashi - 6
    Ba - 6
    Cousins - 7.5
    Makienok - 6
    Watt- 6.5

    Bergdich - 6
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a

  • Pope - 5
    Solly - 5
    Fox - 5
    Bauer 6
    Sarr - 5
    Gudmundsson - 5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Ba - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Makienok - 5
    Watt- 5

    Bergdich - 5
  • edited September 2015
    Pope - 4 Cost us 1/3 points. A goalkeeper that can't stop low shots, I'm afraid is not good enough.
    Solly - 6 Battling performance in a tough game for him.
    Fox - 4.5 very poor same as Saturday.
    Bauer - 6 Worst game for us, but considering he had Sarr & Fox playing so badly alongside him, it's hardly surprising.
    Sarr - 4 ripped apart by Miller.
    Gudmundsson - 6 Did ok, although a bit too predictable
    Kashi - 6 Did Ok.
    Ba - 3.5 One of the worst performances for years. He couldn't pass the ball 5 yards and had a shot that went into the top tier of the South Stand, when unchallenged. Summed him up.
    Cousins - 6.5 MOM played well.
    Makienok - 6 Did ok, but like last season we are having to play injured players, because the squad isn't strong enough.
    Watt- 4.5 Pass the bloody ball you imbecile.
    Bergdich - 6 Did ok. He must start on the left, as opposed to Cousins.


  • Sponsored links:


  • Pope - 5 definite error for first goal, caught crosses well
    Solly - 6 looking slow but gets no cover from the icelandic poseur
    Fox - 5 poor decision contributed to first goal but exposed when Cousins goes walkabout
    Bauer - 6 coped adequately with troublesome Miller
    Sarr - 6 hardly noticed him which for defenders is usually good
    Gudmundsson - 3 awol for most of the game bottled most challenges needs serious attitude adjustment
    Kashi - 7 best player by a distance
    Ba - 4 contributed little
    Cousins - 5 wasted on left
    Makienok - 6 not on same wavelength as strike partners, honest endeavour, needs to learn from Miller how to be a proper nuisance with size
    Watt- 5 if he used his head he'd be twice as effective from half the effort

    Bergdich - 4 lightweight and lacks bravery
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a

    was gonna say, a StigThundercock ratings post after a defeat with no 0s or 1s? what's happened man? but aha - there it is: Gudmundsson 3. same StigThundercock, new season :)
  • colin1961 said:


    Sarr - 8 MOM

    Hahahahahahahahahaha.
    I know you should not comment. But Sarr MOM. So ridiculous it's untrue.
  • Pope - 5.5
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 6
    Bauer - 7.5
    Sarr - 6
    Gudmundsson - 5.5
    Kashi - 6
    Ba - 5.5
    Cousins - 8
    Makienok - 6
    Watt- 6

    Bergdich - 6
  • for those of you watching the match this evening your marks please and do try and keep to order of players below:

    Pope - 4
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 3.5
    Bauer - 6
    Sarr - 5.5
    Gudmundsson - 5.5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Ba - 4.5
    Cousins - 5
    Makienok - 5
    Watt- 3

    Bergdich - 5.5
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a

  • Pope - 4
    Solly - 5
    Fox - 4
    Bauer - 5
    Sarr - 5
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Kashi - 7
    Ba - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Makienok -5
    Watt- 5

    Bergdich - 5
  • Pope - 5
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 3
    Bauer - 7
    Sarr - 5
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Kashi - 6
    Ba - 4
    Cousins - 7
    Makienok - 6
    Watt- 4

    Bergdich - 5
    McAleny n/a
    Vetokele n/a
  • Pope 4 this time his howler cost us
    Solly 6 defended ok but little attacking threat
    Fox 6 as above, miss Wiggins in that respect
    Bauer 7 took a while to adjust to Millers physicality but then looked strong
    Sara 4 starting position poor, never really coped.
    Gudmusson 6 Looked most likely to score
    Kashi 7 never gave up
    Ba 5 looks like he has all the ingredients but doesn't deliver
    Cousins 6 played out of position again
    Makienok 6 less work rate than first two home games but should never have been subbed
    Watt 4 he has either been found out or lost half a yard of pace
    Bergdich 5 Didn't make an impact
  • Pope - 3
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 3
    Bauer - 6
    Sarr - 5
    Gudmundsson - 4
    Kashi - 4
    Bar - 4
    Cousins - 6
    Makienok - 5
    Watt- 4

    Bergdich - 5
  • Pope - 5.5
    Solly - 6.5
    Fox - 5.5
    Bauer - 6.5
    Sarr - 6
    Gudmundsson - 6.5
    Kashi - 7
    Ba - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Makienok - 6
    Watt- 5.5

    Bergdich - 6
  • hope TWW doesnt read this site as he is a magnificent player on his day and will be shocked by the brutality of some "supporters".bring back church?
  • Sponsored links:


  • timken said:

    hope TWW doesnt read this site as he is a magnificent player on his day and will be shocked by the brutality of some "supporters".bring back church?

    Hope he does. He might start to pass the ball, the greedy ####### .
  • timken said:

    hope TWW doesnt read this site as he is a magnificent player on his day and will be shocked by the brutality of some "supporters".bring back church?

    On his day are the three key words here. Bar his 45 against QPR, he hasn't played well this season. Hangs onto the ball for far too long and seems keen to reinvent himself as a number 10. He takes too many touches on the ball for and his constant standing offside is becoming deeply irritating. Pity Igor is either unfit or useless currently too.

    Don't get me wrong, the watt of February / March is a fantastic player but it doesn't look like he has the mindset to reproduce that form
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!