Players Marks: Huddersfield v Charlton (closes Monday evening)

Phillips: 6
Matthews: 6
Oshilaja: 4
Pearce: 5
Doughty: 5
Cullen: 6
Lapslie: 5
Oztumer: 4
McGeary: 1
Green: 3
Taylor: 5
Williams: 5.5
Bonne: 5
Referee: 5

Phillips: 6 - Doesnt deserve that today
Matthews: 6 - Best outfield player again today
Oshilaja: 5 - Good effort, but on that showing wont replace Lockyer
Pearce: 5 - Should have scored with a free header, wasnt that poor
Doughty: 4 - Needs to be taken out the team, especially in a back four
Cullen: 6 - Tried to bring the ball forward, closed down too much
Lapslie: 5.5 - Seems he needs to be more of a super sub
Oztumer: 4 - Really disappointing today, correct call to take him off
McGeady: 4 - Dithered on the ball far too much
Green: 6 - Ran about but had no service
Taylor: 6 - Same as Green, cant do anything with that sort of service

Williams: 6 - Gave us the drive we needed in Midfield, still wasnt enough
Bonne: 5 - Should have had a goal on a plate

Referee: 6 - Got in the way, messed up a potential handball, alright otherwise

lancashire lad said:

at John Smith's Stadium or a live stream your marks please:

Phillips: 6 Cant fault him.
Matthews: 7 our best player 
Oshilaja:  5 but that's being generous.
Pearce:  5 but 9 for effort. 
Doughty: 3. Sorry but he needs a break. 
Cullen:  6. 
Lapslie:  5
Oztumer:  5.5
McGeary:  4  Not impressed at all
Green:  5 His worst performance to date
Taylor:  6  Frustrated 
Williams: 7.
Bonne:  5
Referee:  7 Not that bad. 

Phillips: 5.5 Made a couple of saves but distribution poor again.
Matthews: 6.5 Our best player but still could have been better defensively
Oshilaja: 4.5 Played OK at times but three mistakes led to three. goals. That probably equals Naby's tally for the season
Pearce: 6 I thought he did OK
Doughty: 5.5 Lively, useful but should be rested
Cullen: 6 Still not up to the Cullen we've seen before
Lapslie: 5 First goal mainly George's fault
Oztumer: 4.5 Not good in the position he played today
McGeady: 4.5 Not as bad as some seem to think but still disappointing considering what we expected
Green: 4.5 A few runs but generally poor
Taylor: 5 Not a good day in the office for Lyle, though he didn't get much service
Williams: 6 Looked the player most likely to do something in the second half, but that's not saying much
Bonne: 4 Hardly saw him
Referee: 7 Didn't notice him much so that's a good sign.

Phillips: 6
Matthews: 6
Oshilaja: 5
Pearce: 6
Doughty: 6
Cullen: 6
Lapslie: 3
Oztumer: 4
McGeary: 1
Green: 5
Taylor: 6
Williams: 7.5
Bonne: 5
Referee: 6

Phillips:  6  
Matthews:  7
Oshilaja:  5
Pearce:  5
Doughty:  5
Cullen:  5.5
Lapslie: 5
Oztumer:   5.5
McGeary:   5.5
Green:  5 
Taylor: 5 
Williams: 6.5
Bonne: 5
Referee:  6 

Phillips: 6
Matthews: 6
Oshilaja: 3.5
Pearce: 3
Doughty: 3
Cullen: 6
Lapslie: 2.5
Oztumer: 3
McGeady: 1
Green: 3
Taylor: 4.5

Williams: 6
Bonne: 4

Referee: 6

Phillips: 6 made some good saves, let down by poor team performance 
Matthews: 6.5 mom, steady and reliable in a ponderous back 4
Oshilaja: 4, some crucial mistakes 
Pearce: 6 poor first half, better in the second
Doughty: 5, good coming forward but not good at defending, should not play in a back four as too risky 
Cullen: 6, generally did ok and as ever good on the ball
Lapslie: 5.5, effort was there and a few good tackles but largely anonymous 
Oztumer: 5 tidy on the ball but played out of position on the right and largely anonymous 
McGeadie: 5, a few glimpses but gave ball away in key positions several time
Green: 5 not much service
Taylor: 5.5 ditto
Williams: 6 tried hard when came in but kept on getting taken out
Bonne: 5.5 ditto with Taylor
Referee: 6 seen worse but let a bit too much go

Phillips: 5
Matthews: 7
Oshilaja: 3
Pearce: 4
Doughty: 4
Cullen: 5
Lapslie: 5
Oztumer: 4
MCGeady: 3
Green: 3
Taylor: 5
Williams: 6
Bonne: 5
Referee: 7

Phillips: 6 - conceded 4 didn't really do anything wrong
Matthews: 7 marked his man well , tried to overlap
Oshilaja: 4 i dont know what needs more improvement decision making or tackling,  one of the worst defenders ive ever seen play for Charlton 
Pearce: 5 cant carry a defence is ok when surrounded by more commanding defenders 
Doughty: 3 - needs loaning out 
Cullen: 5 a rare poor display
Lapslie: 6.5 love his desire and  passion
Oztumer: 5.5 hmmmm
Mcgreedy: 2 what a pig
Green: 5 a luxury player baso
Taylor: 7 give everything
Williams: 6.5 class 

Bonne: 5 will be quality if we go down

lancashire lad said:

at John Smith's Stadium or a live stream your marks please:

Phillips: 5 poor kicking today but some good saves
Matthews: 6 our best player
Oshilaja: 4 poor
Pearce: 4 poor
Doughty: 2 his worst game I reckon
Cullen: 5 ineffective but tried
Lapslie: 3 too raw, his passback they led to grants goal
Oztumer: 2 ineffective
McGeary: 1 didn’t care
Green: 3 shite poor touch but better in second half
Taylor: 5 tried but frustrated
Williams: 5.5 made a difference until their 2nd
Bonne: 5 meh
Referee: 5 not the worst but not strong either 

Hemed: 1 made us even worse

Phillips: 6 ( + Made good saves again - poor distribution)

Matthews: 6.5 (+ Best defender in possession and wins his battles - couldn't stop Karlan cutting inside)

Oshilaja: 5 ( + won his aerial battles - awful in possession and makes lots of poor decisions)

Pearce: 5 ( + made some good blocks - slow individual errors)

Doughty: 5.5 ( + pace hard to beat - 60% pass completion no end product)

Cullen: 6 ( + wins and retains possession - can't dictate tempo due to lack of support)

Lapslie: 5.5 (+ made some tackles - game passed him by not one shot, dribble, key pass) 

Oztumer: 5 ( + can't think of any - not Williams)

McGeady: 5.5 ( + made some key passes - holds onto the ball too long, out of position) 

Green: 5.5 ( + look a threat on the counter - played about 10 passes lost the ball a lot)

Taylor: 6.5 ( + didn't give the ball away linked up play when attacking - zero support and service) 

Williams: 6 ( + game changer having a midfielder who receives on the diagonal and runs at players, plays forward passes and makes good runs.)

Bonne: 5.5 ( + intent was there - again zero support and service)

Referee: 6.5 (Let a lot go opposite to the one at Wednesday, Williams got fouled 7 times before a booking was shown.)

At the game (but wished I wasn't)

Phillips: 6
Matthews: 7
Oshilaja: 5
Pearce: 5
Doughty: 4
Cullen: 5
Lapslie: 5
Oztumer: 5
McGeady: 3
Green: 3
Taylor: 5
Williams: 6
Bonne: 5
Referee: 6

Phillips: 5
Matthews: 5
Oshilaja: 4
Pearce: 4
Doughty: 4
Cullen: 4
Lapslie: 4
Oztumer: 4
McGeary: 3
Green: 5
Taylor: 4
Williams: 6
Bonne: 5
Referee: 6