Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Sam Field promoted and relegated on the same night?
RodneyCharltonTrotta
Posts: 14,834
Can't happen that often?
10
Comments
-
Was impressed with the way he came back after the lockdown and got stuck in for the cause after a long injury. I didn't think he would and he looked good when he played. Can't see him playing much for WBA but he'll get a good Championship club come in for him.14
-
One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club
4 -
Tidy player. Great attitude. Would like to keep. No chance we can though. Wish him well.
1 -
Pretty average to be honest, maybe harsh but overrated by a lot on here because he’s surrounded by shite2
-
Would have liked to have loaned him and Leko again next season1
-
My thoughts too.cafcsinger said:Pretty average to be honest, maybe harsh but overrated by a lot on here because he’s surrounded by shite0 -
However has a great attitude. Also a nice lad wish him well.1
-
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club0 -
more chance of that than all of our problems being sorted !Cafc43v3r said:
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club0 -
I put this in the player marks, the millwall game I think.billysboots said:
more chance of that than all of our problems being sorted !Cafc43v3r said:
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club
If you ask any Charlton fan "who was better Field or Cullen" 90+% would say Cullen but I would happily wager that Field plays many more top flight games. He needs 1 more championship season, maybe 2 if WBA come straight back down, but he will play in the top flight for years.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
A bit harsh, though I admit Leeds performance was a bit of an eyeopener when you saw the way their midfield playedcafcsinger said:Pretty average to be honest, maybe harsh but overrated by a lot on here because he’s surrounded by shite0 -
Darren Ward was the same for us in 2009 when Wolves went up .1
-
Agree 100% with this , injuries permittingCafc43v3r said:
I put this in the player marks, the millwall game I think.billysboots said:
more chance of that than all of our problems being sorted !Cafc43v3r said:
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club
If you ask any Charlton fan "who was better Field or Cullen" 90+% would say Cullen but I would happily wager that Field plays many more top flight games. He needs 1 more championship season, maybe 2 if WBA come straight back down, but he will play in the top flight for years.1 -
TBF Field is 2 years younger and has already played 18 more top flight games than CullenCafc43v3r said:
I put this in the player marks, the millwall game I think.billysboots said:
more chance of that than all of our problems being sorted !Cafc43v3r said:
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club
If you ask any Charlton fan "who was better Field or Cullen" 90+% would say Cullen but I would happily wager that Field plays many more top flight games. He needs 1 more championship season, maybe 2 if WBA come straight back down, but he will play in the top flight for years.
But Cullen has been a consistent performer of 2 seasons players over 65 league games in that time for us
Field looked good when he played but only managed 17 games due to injury this season.
So if someone said now you could have 1 of them back next season which would it be, I would pick Cullen easily2 -
Not impressed by Field at all. Much preferred Pratley in the team.
Field still has much to learn.0 -
Lacks pace.....can't head the ball. He broke up play and got stuck in. Championship or L1 player IMO0
-
Looked good at times, seems to be a bit injury prone though0
-
Certainly won’t be getting any games for West Brom in the PL. I’d take him in League One, not sure about the Championship.0
-
I don’t think we saw the best of him. Needs a long run of games and to play in a more settled team with proper attacking threats in midfield and up front. Can see enough potential to at least be a good reliable Championship player.0
-
I would take Cullen over Field for next season.paulie8290 said:
TBF Field is 2 years younger and has already played 18 more top flight games than CullenCafc43v3r said:
I put this in the player marks, the millwall game I think.billysboots said:
more chance of that than all of our problems being sorted !Cafc43v3r said:
If WBA would sell him....billysboots said:One that I would like to have seen us keep
- if we had the money
- if we were allowed to sign players by the EFL
- if we knew who our owners were
- if we had a long term plan that didn’t involve crooks and or administration
- if we had Bows at the wheel
What the hell is going on at our club
If you ask any Charlton fan "who was better Field or Cullen" 90+% would say Cullen but I would happily wager that Field plays many more top flight games. He needs 1 more championship season, maybe 2 if WBA come straight back down, but he will play in the top flight for years.
But Cullen has been a consistent performer of 2 seasons players over 65 league games in that time for us
Field looked good when he played but only managed 17 games due to injury this season.
So if someone said now you could have 1 of them back next season which would it be, I would pick Cullen easily
I would take Jamie Vardy over Mason Greenwood for next season as well.
I am don't think Field is a better player today than Cullen I just think he will, when looked back apon, have more successful career.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Queens Park Rangers have signed midfielder Sam Field from West Bromwich Albion for an undisclosed fee.
Field, 23, joins on a permanent basis having spent the second half of the season on loan in west London, where he scored one goal in 19 appearances.
He has agreed a three-year contract with Rangers, who have an option to extend the deal by a further 12 months.
0 -
I liked Field and thought he was just settling with us when he got injured at Bristol (what a choker of a night that was)17
-
excellent player, would be exactly what we need right now in place of Watson/Pratley7
-
At 1-0 up we were 2nd for almost 20 minutes. Definitely the moment when the season went down hill.AFKABartram said:I liked Field and thought he was just settling with us when he got injured at Bristol (what a choker of a night that was)5 -
I thought he was great and would’ve loved to sign him permanently. QPR have done very well there.2
-
Great signing for QPR. Real shame we never got to see him fully fit and more of him in the team. He is the sort of player who makes a real difference.1
-
Championship seems his level, if QPR can sign Austin permanently they'll have a decent season as they've been very good in recent months0
-
Sam Field is a Championship standard defensive midfielder, unfortunately another player who had too many injuries while at the Valley so we only saw glimpses of his talent. Loved a tackle and block, and a tidy short passer.
1 -
Good player I thought. Would have liked to have seen more of him.0
