Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Match Thread: Portsmouth v Charlton | Saturday 31st October 2020
Oggy Red
Posts: 44,956
Right here we go again, this time at Fratton Park.
We've got both Watson and Lurch suspended, Maddison injured to add to the usual missing.
We've got both Watson and Lurch suspended, Maddison injured to add to the usual missing.
Charlton: Amos; Maatsen, Famewo, Pratley, Gunter, Matthews; Williams, Forster-Caskey, Shinnie; Bogle, Washington
Subs: Maynard-Brewer, Purrington, Aneke, Morgan, Levitt, Smyth, Vennings
0
Comments
-
I’ve never believed in a player being Charltonised before... but the case of Marcus Maddison might be the one that changes my mind FFS!3
-
I hope we go 442.
Keep Pratley in midfield2 -
It’s a decent line up given what we have available but I’m just desperate to see us put out our strongest available XI sooner rather than later. Feels like that hasn’t been an option for us since August 2019 for various reasons.0
-
He twisted his ankle or something in that mock match, the one where Oshilaja got injured.Callumcafc said:I’ve never believed in a player being Charltonised before... but the case of Marcus Maddison might be the one that changes my mind FFS!
Sounds like he rolled it again in training yesterday. He wouldn't have been on the bench on Tuesday if he wasn't considered at least fit enough to play some part, Callum.
0 -
What's up with Maddison now?0
-
-
Pompey: MacGillivray, Johnson, Whatmough, Raggett, Brown, Williams, Naylor (c), Cannon, Curtis, Marquis, Harness
Subs: Bass, Nicolaisen, Pring, Morris, Close, Hiwula, Harrison0 -
Can't see it starting that way ...... the line up screams 3-5-2, at least IMO.blackpool72 said:I hope we go 442.
Keep Pratley in midfield
It's one thing for Gunter to play right sided CB in 3 at the back, but he's not really a CB - unless he's surprised a few in training.
So I wouldn't start him in at a flat 4 at the back.
Bowyer might think different, of course ha ha
2 -
Yeah, none of us saw Purrington as a Centre-Back for exampleOggy Red said:
Can't see it starting that way ...... the line up screams 3-5-2, at least IMO.blackpool72 said:I hope we go 442.
Keep Pratley in midfield
It's one thing for Gunter to play right sided CB in 3 at the back, but he's not really a CB - unless he's surprised a few in training.
So I wouldn't start him in at a flat 4 at the back.
Bowyer might think different, of course ha ha
Seems Gunter has played CB twelve times in his career with one of his five goals coming when he played there... Anytime scorer today?1 -
I’m just itching to see him play some proper minutes. A game like today he could really make the difference and it’s blow to not have him available in any capacity. I don’t think he has any kind injury history but somehow this happens when he signs a contract in SE7... typical eh!Oggy Red said:
He twisted his ankle or something in that mock match, the one where Oshilaja got injured.Callumcafc said:I’ve never believed in a player being Charltonised before... but the case of Marcus Maddison might be the one that changes my mind FFS!
Sounds like he rolled it again in training yesterday. He wouldn't have been on the bench on Tuesday if he wasn't considered at least fit enough to play some part, Callum.3 - Sponsored links:
-
No Morgan on the bench. Really out of favour, it seems.
Ignore me, I'm unwell.
Williams needs to make an impact, can't afford to carry him.
Up the Addicks5 -
According to twitter “Marcus Maddison sits out after picking up a minor knock in training on Friday”Weegie Addick said:What's up with Maddison now?0 -
Que?Henry Irving said:No Morgan on the bench. Really out of favour, it seems.
Williams needs to make an impact, can't afford to carry him.
Up the Addicks1 -
good selection,. Gunter in the middle and Matthews back at R Back .. come on youse Addicksssaaaa !!!!0
-
He is on the bench.Henry Irving said:No Morgan on the bench. Really out of favour, it seems.
Williams needs to make an impact, can't afford to carry him.
Up the Addicks1 -
Surprised Barker isn’t on the bench, not sure there’s need to have Levitt, Morgan and Vennings all there.6
-
iFollow have just shown Gunter at Right-Back with Matthews next to Famewo...2
-
He is, isn't he?Henry Irving said:No Morgan on the bench. Really out of favour, it seems.
Williams needs to make an impact, can't afford to carry him.
Up the Addicks1 -
Doncaster v Lincoln the other big game towards the top of the table today
Sunderland currently struggling @ Gillingham0 -
Agree all the way, Callum. I kind have imagined he'd either start instead of Williams at AM ..... or play wide on the right in a 4-3-3.Callumcafc said:
I’m just itching to see him play some proper minutes. A game like today he could really make the difference and it’s blow to not have him available in any capacity. I don’t think he has any kind injury history but somehow this happens when he signs a contract in SE7... typical eh!Oggy Red said:
He twisted his ankle or something in that mock match, the one where Oshilaja got injured.Callumcafc said:I’ve never believed in a player being Charltonised before... but the case of Marcus Maddison might be the one that changes my mind FFS!
Sounds like he rolled it again in training yesterday. He wouldn't have been on the bench on Tuesday if he wasn't considered at least fit enough to play some part, Callum.
No doubt in my mind, if he'd been fit he would have started.
Today we needed his creativity, pin point crossing and perhaps even a goal from outside the box.
0 - Sponsored links:
-
LB rates Matthews a lot.
I don't think this is a game for JFC in a storm, I'd rather start Levitt but let's see. Come on boys a win today would really be showing the rest.
Surprised Barker aint even a sub. Let's hope we get no injuries/sending off CB position0 -
This was always going to be a tough one without two key players. Looks like it’ll be five at the back, which it should be given that Gunter isn’t actually a centre half and is only one for playing in the middle as part of a three. I don’t think this line up gets the best out of everyone if it is 3-5-2. You’re asking a lot of JFC defensively, asking Gunter and Pratley to play slightly out of position and putting Washington in a role where he’s a bit less effective than he is coming off the wing. It will be interesting to see how we perform without two of the players who have been such a key part of our clean sheets. I suspect that might end today so let’s hope Bogle and Williams can get their first goals for us as I think we’ll need more than one1
-
Team formation per the iFollow coverage:
Maybe Gunter and Matthews switched round, Old Man Prats slightly deeper at centre-half-back, and Willo slightly further upfield at centre-half-forward.2 -
Sounds a bit like a lot of the games in this division - after 70 minutes both sides have had ONE shot on target!ForeverAddickted said:Doncaster v Lincoln the other big game towards the top of the table today
Sunderland currently struggling @ Gillingham1 -
Make you right about Williams, he really needs to turn up todayHenry Irving said:No Morgan on the bench. Really out of favour, it seems.
Ignore me, I'm unwell.
Williams needs to make an impact, can't afford to carry him.
Up the Addicks1 -
Williams really needs to boss this game.Big moment for him.Shame about Maddison.0
-
Has made me chuckle what with Levitt struggling and Forster-Caskey "impressing" last weekendorpingtonRED said:LB rates Matthews a lot.
I don't think this is a game for JFC in a storm, I'd rather start Levitt but let's see. Come on boys a win today would really be showing the rest.
Surprised Barker aint even a sub. Let's hope we get no injuries/sending off CB position
Sun appears to be breaking out down there too which is good0 -
Don’t agree about Washington, he made his name as a striker. I’m sure we’ll see him move out to the left and hopefully combine well with Maatsen.Garrymanilow said:This was always going to be a tough one without two key players. Looks like it’ll be five at the back, which it should be given that Gunter isn’t actually a centre half and is only one for playing in the middle as part of a three. I don’t think this line up gets the best out of everyone if it is 3-5-2. You’re asking a lot of JFC defensively, asking Gunter and Pratley to play slightly out of position and putting Washington in a role where he’s a bit less effective than he is coming off the wing. It will be interesting to see how we perform without two of the players who have been such a key part of our clean sheets. I suspect that might end today so let’s hope Bogle and Williams can get their first goals for us as I think we’ll need more than one0 -
Shinnie on the left can't be right surely.Briston_Addick said:Team formation per the iFollow coverage:
Maybe Gunter and Matthews switched round, Old Man Prats slightly deeper at centre-half-back, and Willo slightly further upfield at centre-half-forward.0 -
iFollow really don't have a clue when it comes to formations do theyBriston_Addick said:Team formation per the iFollow coverage:
Maybe Gunter and Matthews switched round, Old Man Prats slightly deeper at centre-half-back, and Willo slightly further upfield at centre-half-forward.0
This discussion has been closed.
