Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
January Transfer Window - Jan 2023 (Deadline Day starts page 112)
Comments
-
Based in a rumour from Twitter you want to ditch Gallen? Okey dokeyJ BLOCK said:
This is such a great shout, never put 2+2 together. Gallen has used up his credits, can go with Martin and TS.Cafc43v3r said:
Funny that Gallen and Martin, who according to Thomas are always out scouting, are at every single one of our games...SELR_addicks said:Our scouts working wonders again.
Are they allowed to go out and watch other teams play? Or are they stuck watching archive footage from our own games?6 -
Alexa, show me the definition of a low bar.arny23394 said:He’s not very good, but he’s better than stockley. At least he can move.4 -
Did you say shooting below par?ken_shabby said:
Alexa, show me the definition of a low bar.arny23394 said:He’s not very good, but he’s better than stockley. At least he can move.
I am afraid there are multiple answers to that question, but may I introduce you to:
0 -
Please not Bonne again!! We have to do better than that!!4
-
What’s the rumour? I’m basing it on his track record which is clear and the fact he is pictured at the valley every single Charlton game.Swisdom said:
Based in a rumour from Twitter you want to ditch Gallen? Okey dokeyJ BLOCK said:
This is such a great shout, never put 2+2 together. Gallen has used up his credits, can go with Martin and TS.Cafc43v3r said:
Funny that Gallen and Martin, who according to Thomas are always out scouting, are at every single one of our games...SELR_addicks said:Our scouts working wonders again.
Are they allowed to go out and watch other teams play? Or are they stuck watching archive footage from our own games?4 -
All fair points. The thing that bugs me about it, and I realise nothing official has been announced, is that too many of our signings are like getting the band back together, but the trouble is the band wasn’t very good to begin with. Even a lot of summer signings were just Garner’s ex Swindon players. What exactly is this black box of Martin Sandgaard’s? Is it actually an office with no windows or electricity or internet access and he just has to sit in it and try to remember the names of players?Garrymanilow said:To be honest, if we signed Bonne, a player who scored 11 goals for us in the Championship and 12 for Ipswich in L1, for £200,00, sold him for up to £2m and then got him back on a free that's pretty incredible business.People seemed pretty happy with the idea of Nombe who scored 0 in 6 games the Championship and has 11 in 25 in L1 at the moment. Bonne scored 11 L1 goals in 15 games before tailing off last season and 5 in his first 8 Championship games for us (plus 3 after lockdown as he more or less single-handedly tried to score the goals to keep us up). He starts well and then tends to fall away but he's definitely scored goals which our miserable stack of nothings struggle with (Stockley 2 in 23, Chuks 1 in 9) so he'd be an improvement on what we have now. I've never really understood the animosity towards him to be honest, he got so much grief in the Championship but he scored, turned up and if we'd not been the victims of some ridiculous late Barnsley goals and Blackburn own goals we would have had him to thank more than most of the others in that team.I would like us to sign two strikers though, sadly moving Stockley out somewhere else to rebuild himself. Leaburn, Bonne and another plus the ghost of Chuks would be pretty handy.
Bonne isn’t the worst player in the world, and it’s definitely got a bit exaggerated how poor he was when here before, but it’s just not gong to get folks excited.1 -
There’s a few people claiming a left back and striker are close. Don’t necessarily need names but can one of you at least confirm/deny that Bonne is on his way back please?0
-
Bonne and Leaburn could work as a partnership (at least to keep us up) but if we're signing him as a lone striker option I'd be worried.0
-
Like most strikers at this level, he's only as good as the service he gets. Give him enough chances in the box, then by the law of averages he'll convert his 1-in-3.KentishAddick said:He's a better option than both Stockley and Aneke, and wouldn't be the most exciting signing but I'd take Bonne back. He definitely improves us.
What Bonne seems to lack is the link up play and awareness in the build up outside the box.
I don't see him as an effective lone forward either.
0 -
We have 2 coming in hopefully in the next few days18
- Sponsored links:
-
Plymouth have made 3 permanent signings already.0
-
Bonne is a bloody awful footballer, he missed more "sitters" than he scored goals for us. Selling him for what we got was one of the best pieces of business we ever did, hope we don't spoil that by bringing him back.6
-
Lots of people saying that Bonne is a better option than what we have now, that really doesn't take much. He'll probably want a signing on fee, plus wages, money that we can spend elsewhere. If there ever was a good player in there, it's been a while since it was last seen. He was invisible against us and against our youth.0
-
-
If we sign Bonne, biggest interest for me will be the length of his Contract.
Think a few are forgetting where we are in the League at the moment, we need signings sharpish to start moving away from the bottom four - As its already been said on here, we can (hopefully) have a proper rebuild in the summer, but ideally dont really want to have to worry about the likes of Bonne, even Ferguson really being on 3-4 year contracts, and unable to shift them later on down the line.
Contract till 2024 would be the max that I'd want to see given to either of them1 -
Gallen was not a few games back he was watching a playerJ BLOCK said:
This is such a great shout, never put 2+2 together. Gallen has used up his credits, can go with Martin and TS.Cafc43v3r said:
Funny that Gallen and Martin, who according to Thomas are always out scouting, are at every single one of our games...SELR_addicks said:Our scouts working wonders again.
Are they allowed to go out and watch other teams play? Or are they stuck watching archive footage from our own games?4 -
The point is, it was said he was always out scouting when actually he is almost always present at Charlton games.RonnieMoore said:
Gallen was not a few games back he was watching a playerJ BLOCK said:
This is such a great shout, never put 2+2 together. Gallen has used up his credits, can go with Martin and TS.Cafc43v3r said:
Funny that Gallen and Martin, who according to Thomas are always out scouting, are at every single one of our games...SELR_addicks said:Our scouts working wonders again.
Are they allowed to go out and watch other teams play? Or are they stuck watching archive footage from our own games?0 -
Absolutely. There can't be any teams who have re-signed as many players as we have in recent years. Bonne (if it happens), Cullen, Poyet, Aneke, Matthews, Famewo, Leko, Henderson, Amos, even Arter. Josh Parker was a player Gallen remembered from 10 years before. It feels like our scouting pool is absolutely tiny. Starting to feel like we actually signed a different Matt Smith by accident..Exiled_Addick said:
All fair points. The thing that bugs me about it, and I realise nothing official has been announced, is that too many of our signings are like getting the band back together, but the trouble is the band wasn’t very good to begin with. Even a lot of summer signings were just Garner’s ex Swindon players. What exactly is this black box of Martin Sandgaard’s? Is it actually an office with no windows or electricity or internet access and he just has to sit in it and try to remember the names of players?Garrymanilow said:To be honest, if we signed Bonne, a player who scored 11 goals for us in the Championship and 12 for Ipswich in L1, for £200,00, sold him for up to £2m and then got him back on a free that's pretty incredible business.People seemed pretty happy with the idea of Nombe who scored 0 in 6 games the Championship and has 11 in 25 in L1 at the moment. Bonne scored 11 L1 goals in 15 games before tailing off last season and 5 in his first 8 Championship games for us (plus 3 after lockdown as he more or less single-handedly tried to score the goals to keep us up). He starts well and then tends to fall away but he's definitely scored goals which our miserable stack of nothings struggle with (Stockley 2 in 23, Chuks 1 in 9) so he'd be an improvement on what we have now. I've never really understood the animosity towards him to be honest, he got so much grief in the Championship but he scored, turned up and if we'd not been the victims of some ridiculous late Barnsley goals and Blackburn own goals we would have had him to thank more than most of the others in that team.I would like us to sign two strikers though, sadly moving Stockley out somewhere else to rebuild himself. Leaburn, Bonne and another plus the ghost of Chuks would be pretty handy.
Bonne isn’t the worst player in the world, and it’s definitely got a bit exaggerated how poor he was when here before, but it’s just not gong to get folks excited.
2 -
This is precisely why I don't want him back9 - Sponsored links:
-
CAFCDAZ said:We have 2 coming in hopefully in the next few days
My two random guesses then.
Anthony Scully as forward not getting in at Wigan and we wanted previously plus a London lad.
Aaron Donnelly LB kid at Forest, purely cause Scott was there.7 -
Would love Scully but doubt we’ll get him.
Think Ferguson from Rotherham is more likely and tbh he’d be decent too.2 -
LB and striker are my feeling1
-
The priority must staying up though. Probably as cheaply as possible. I think with 7 days notice your asking a lot of the gang of 4. Next seasons planning starts in March by which time, hopefully, we will be safe and the ownership is resolved one way or the other.ShootersHillGuru said:
I was thinking or rather hoping that anybody we sign will be with a view to next season and hopefully getting a run at getting out of this league. Why waste money on wages for Bonne when you admit it’s only a short term fix. Spend that money to entice a real target we actually want and who can be an asset next season.Cafc43v3r said:
Well isn't that the point of this window?ShootersHillGuru said:We had QPR’s pants around their ankles when they took Bonne off our hands. Couldn’t get into their team back then and then had a loan at Ipswich who didn’t want him either. Might improve us slightly from a very low starting point but if Bonne is the total of our ambition we ain’t going anywhere.
I don't think it's realistic to start "the rebuild" now. A couple of Bonne and Ferguson type players that are out of contract in the summer anyway on short term deals and a couple of well chosen Premier League likely lads will be enough to keep us comfortably up.
As unpalatable as it maybe staying in this division is our number one priority and I never thought I would say that.
Of course if a BWP comes up and we get him that's a Brucie Bonus. Johnson and Eagles type signings is what I expect. Rather that than start dishing out 3 year contracts because we are desperate.1 -
Bowyer's coming back??? God this recruitment team really is taking the piss now!CAFCDAZ said:LB and striker are my feeling10 -
We haven’t signed anyone yet.
it does looks likely Bonne will return but no point getting pissed and banging on about recruitment until it’s on the official site0 -
I really hope Bonne isn’t coming back, like others, if he was the only striker that would be a huge let down, for me. Perhaps, if he was one and a n other and only a contract to the summer, then that may be acceptable.
I know Stockley is this years scapegoat and whipping boy but as said before he can score but as others have said before Garner was sacked the system didn’t suit his style. Maybe Holden will try and adapt to his strengths and if he could get back to last years form, then I'm sure he and Leaburn could do the trick.0 -
Why is everyone having kittens about this post?DDOUBLEE said:
This is precisely why I don't want him back
i don’t want him back because he’s a rubbish footballer. I’m pretty sure he was retaliating to half of charlton Twitter saying they didn’t want him.So we can give out banter, but can’t take it back?26 -
Does Holden have any targets from his old clubs - Stoke and Bristol City are outside our normal gene pool and might actually freshen things up a little, rather than recruiting retreads.2
