Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
First game I went to this season, what a cracker. Can we get promotion? I don't see why not, Pompey always bottle it just like posh, Bolton and barnsley are not worldbeaters and we are only 4 points off the play offs. The real test is Bolton at home end of October. Beat them and many will start to believe.
A couple of people on the player mark thread have said that the ref missed a red and a player kicked out. When was this please as I dont remember this
I think what was being hinted at was when Hamilton ( I think) kicked TC in the head after they both ended up on the turf following a TC tackle by the AC stand touchline, the ref missed it, and the lino appeared to not want to get involved, the upshot was both booked, although why TC was booked is weird....🙄
TC went at him with hands raised. Felt like a clear 'yellow apiece' to me. Ref was really good, apparently he's done plenty of Championship games
Yep agree, probably retaliation by TC so yellow, but the kick was deliberate, and why TC retaliated in the first place, so could be argued maybe a red missed...🤷♂️
Great come back to get a point but disappointed to have been in that position to begin with. As said at half time, we were good but unspectacular and they were solid and playing the game well. We gifted them the two goals and our subs completely turned the game around, which is where the disappointment comes from.
Special mention for chucks, I like having a good old laugh with the cheat code stuff but he made such an impact and you can just see how desperate he his for a goal. Would keep him on the bench and playing that impact sub role though as there just isn't anyone else who can totally turn a team around like him.
Still plenty of work to do on the defence mind! Hector was great apart from that gift which sums up his season so far, just keeps having a moment in.a game where he forgets he's playing a competitive match 😅
Also, Appleton, hats off, we're playing well, scoring goals and picking up the points. Honestly, don't feel as worried or dejected when going behind as have done under other managers (and squads too) so far we've never looked out of game and even if we don't come back, the fact that we would have had a good go would make it easier to take, unlike the gutless roll over belly tickling we've seen all too often.
Looking forward to get over for a game!
Are you saying you WON'T mock me next time I call him a cheat code?
Leaburn is not a back to goal central striker. He is more of a Lyle Taylor type and needs to roam so he can get the ball to feet in a position to beat the defender.
Spot on, I said this after the Wycombe game and it was very evident today. His talents are completely wasted there.
Leaburn's last two goals have been when he took up a central position, maybe being a young player he just played poorly and he really isn't a Lyle Taylor type forward who is as comfortable out wide as central.
Appleton/any current Charlton Manager, should be cut some slack
He's got Leaburn coming back from a pre-season lay-off, so he can't do 90 mins/back to back games. He has Aneke, who can do even less game-time than Leaburn, or you risk losing him for months. So they have to be juggled. Leaburn would benefit so much if could play with Aneke, rather instead of. The upside for MA is that he does at least have both in a match day squad. Most teams in League One would kill for that.
That being said....Leaburn needs to show a lot more, when he plays CF on his own. He was second to most things today and when he did get there, he failed to hold the ball up. I agree with the poster who likened him to Taylor....another player happier on the half-turn....but Taylor was no slouch back-to-goal either. Leaburn has so much potential but his hold-up play will be a big question-mark with the scouts. I was really disappointed with his lack of physicality today and I feel that its definitely a missing component from his game.
As for the game, we could have gone on to win today and a better side would've done just that. Maybe...IF Aneke stays fit enough to feature regularly and he starts to score, we will be a team to be reckoned with.
I know Hector made a bad error but his overall play today was a class above League One. A decent manager (and I think we might have one) might well "get a tune out of him" I certainly wouldn't be thinking about dropping him.. I'd just be thinking how to get enough workhorses around him to keep him honest.
In summary, I felt that today was a strong indicator of where we are....midtable...but with so much potential to do well.
3-5-2 would allow us to get May and Leaburn (or Aneke) as a front 2, and then also have a midfield 3 of Watson, Dobson and Fraser.
It would mean CBT at wing back but probably a sacrifice worth making when we get the benefit of the other 5 on the pitch in their best roles, and we have no left back so it would reduce the demands on Thomas getting forward
NO, Corey Blackett-Taylor is on a scoring run and you want him to defend his box 🤷🏻♂️
3-5-2 with CBT at RWB, would see CBT injured in no time. He hasn't got the fitness to do that job. Today's formation is the best way to get the best out of him and he's such an important player.
3-5-2 would allow us to get May and Leaburn (or Aneke) as a front 2, and then also have a midfield 3 of Watson, Dobson and Fraser.
It would mean CBT at wing back but probably a sacrifice worth making when we get the benefit of the other 5 on the pitch in their best roles, and we have no left back so it would reduce the demands on Thomas getting forward
NO, Corey Blackett-Taylor is on a scoring run and you want him to defend his box 🤷🏻♂️
First game of the season against Orient he was at wing back and look at his average position. If Thomas is at LCB behind him then he doesn’t have to defend much at all. How else do we get Fraser, Watson, Dobson, Blackett-Taylor, Aneke/Leaburn and May all into the team?
3-5-2 would allow us to get May and Leaburn (or Aneke) as a front 2, and then also have a midfield 3 of Watson, Dobson and Fraser.
It would mean CBT at wing back but probably a sacrifice worth making when we get the benefit of the other 5 on the pitch in their best roles, and we have no left back so it would reduce the demands on Thomas getting forward
CBT IS NOT A WINGBACK. Would leave Thomas even more exposed. How about we play a left back at left back. Radical I know.
3-5-2 would allow us to get May and Leaburn (or Aneke) as a front 2, and then also have a midfield 3 of Watson, Dobson and Fraser.
It would mean CBT at wing back but probably a sacrifice worth making when we get the benefit of the other 5 on the pitch in their best roles, and we have no left back so it would reduce the demands on Thomas getting forward
CBT IS NOT A WINGBACK. Would leave Thomas even more exposed. How about we play a left back at left back. Radical I know.
If we had one that would be the answer, but we don’t
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
What is it then? He’s a right footed centre back with a better than average left foot, so LCB seems like it would be pretty natural to me
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
What is it then? He’s a right footed centre back with a better than average left foot, so LCB seems like it would be pretty natural to me
Well, RCB. Competent on the left side. But yeah I'll leave it as I care less than I'm coming across.
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
Maybe you could enlighten us oh fountain of knowledge, for t'was his own words that spoketh thus...
I noticed after Corey scored his goal, Dobbo sprinted to get the ball and told the others to hurry up with the celebrations so they could go for a third
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
Maybe you could enlighten us oh fountain of knowledge, for t'was his own words that spoketh thus...
Ah did Thomas say that was his natural position? If so then he's clearly confused and needs things explaining to him...
I do like how Thomas actually chooses to use his left foot when he could have used his right. It's like he's practising!
It's all very nice and soft. Getting predictable on the ball now and the opposition is just letting it go to him knowing there is likely to be any danger.
Lucas Ness looks a good young defender. Why doesn't he start if the others are so ropey?
I can agree with this regarding Thomas, but we must remember even he is playing LB when his natural position is LCB, Hector and Jones were ok, apart from one mistake that led to their second from Hector, all in all it is a bit of a makeshift defence as a whole really, be a bit better when Edun comes back...hopefully.
Thomas' natural position isn't LCB! Gonna keep saying it until the whole world knows 😂
Maybe you could enlighten us oh fountain of knowledge, for t'was his own words that spoketh thus...
Ah did Thomas say that was his natural position? If so then he's clearly confused and needs things explaining to him...
The teams promoted from this league keep a clean sheet in approximately 60-70% of their games. We have so far kept a clean sheet in 13% of our games. Pre-season (and also when the window closed) it was obvious that we weren't strong enough at CB to compete properly this season. Once again we've dominated the game, scored two and not come away with three points. It needn't be this hard with a proper defence.
If I ever read “A&Eke” again I’m going to lose it, bloke was an absolute colossus today. Charlton Athletic are a million times better with Chuks in the team. If he can only play 30 mins a game I couldn’t care less, if he could play 90 he would be at a top championship club. He was the catalyst (again) for that rousing end to the game. Also Alfie May is absolutely HIM, what a player cult hero status pending. I know it’s only a point at home but that was such an enjoyable day out.
Terrible first half, I'm quite ill but was nearly falling asleep. Their first goal came from nothing.
Thought when they went up 2 zip we were done for, fortunately Chuks did Chuks things and elevated players around him.
Take the draw but it wasn't a good performance, personally didn't see an improvement in playstyle from Shrewsbury & Exeter. Main thing I noticed was the lack of midfield control, genuinely think we had too many attacking players on the pitch and reckon Fraser on from kick-off would have helped us keep the ball.
Anyway the draw will do, CBTs goal was unbelievable and perked me up a bit
IF Aneke can stay as fit as he did in the 2020/21 season then we will make the play offs. He’s not even started scoring yet and is already winning us points every week
Comments
Can we get promotion? I don't see why not, Pompey always bottle it just like posh, Bolton and barnsley are not worldbeaters and we are only 4 points off the play offs. The real test is Bolton at home end of October. Beat them and many will start to believe.
No 🙂
Leaburn's last two goals have been when he took up a central position, maybe being a young player he just played poorly and he really isn't a Lyle Taylor type forward who is as comfortable out wide as central.
He's got Leaburn coming back from a pre-season lay-off, so he can't do 90 mins/back to back games. He has Aneke, who can do even less game-time than Leaburn, or you risk losing him for months. So they have to be juggled. Leaburn would benefit so much if could play with Aneke, rather instead of. The upside for MA is that he does at least have both in a match day squad. Most teams in League One would kill for that.
That being said....Leaburn needs to show a lot more, when he plays CF on his own. He was second to most things today and when he did get there, he failed to hold the ball up. I agree with the poster who likened him to Taylor....another player happier on the half-turn....but Taylor was no slouch back-to-goal either. Leaburn has so much potential but his hold-up play will be a big question-mark with the scouts. I was really disappointed with his lack of physicality today and I feel that its definitely a missing component from his game.
As for the game, we could have gone on to win today and a better side would've done just that. Maybe...IF Aneke stays fit enough to feature regularly and he starts to score, we will be a team to be reckoned with.
I know Hector made a bad error but his overall play today was a class above League One. A decent manager (and I think we might have one) might well "get a tune out of him" I certainly wouldn't be thinking about dropping him.. I'd just be thinking how to get enough workhorses around him to keep him honest.
In summary, I felt that today was a strong indicator of where we are....midtable...but with so much potential to do well.
NO, Corey Blackett-Taylor is on a scoring run and you want him to defend his box 🤷🏻♂️
Kidding, I admit defeat.
Terrible first half, I'm quite ill but was nearly falling asleep. Their first goal came from nothing.
Thought when they went up 2 zip we were done for, fortunately Chuks did Chuks things and elevated players around him.
Take the draw but it wasn't a good performance, personally didn't see an improvement in playstyle from Shrewsbury & Exeter. Main thing I noticed was the lack of midfield control, genuinely think we had too many attacking players on the pitch and reckon Fraser on from kick-off would have helped us keep the ball.
Anyway the draw will do, CBTs goal was unbelievable and perked me up a bit
Unreal when fit, such a shame it's only about 5 games a season
It’s a very big IF though