Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks & Applescore: FA Cup R1: Charlton Athletic v Cray Valley (PM) (closes Monday teatime)
Comments
-
Applescore: 5 no diff to any Charlton Manager before him making wholesale changes
WALKER: 6 only one shot to save and that was in the 92nd min
ABANKWAH: 7 got forward very well
NESS: 5 If people think he should replace Hector watch this game
THOMAS: 6 his passing was poor but defended well
EDUN: 8 very good 60 mins
McGRANDLES: 7 decent in Dobson role broke up play well again good 60 mins
ANDERSON: 5 at fault for the goal lost the ball far to easy in mid
FRASER: 7 drove the mid but mass of green in front of him
C.CAMPBELL: 7 he was very good perhaps needed to improve his final ball but a real danger
TEDIĆ: 6 worked very hard unlucky with few efforts
KIRK: 5 not his night should have chipped the keeper
ASIIMWE: 6
T.WATSON: 6
MAY: 6
Referee: 4 . every 50/50 seemed to go to them14 -
Applescore: 4. Don’t blame him for picking the side he picked other than Shirk who he should already have known is a liability.
WALKER: 4 - not convincing
ABANKWAH: 4 some promise coming forward.
NESS: 2. Calamity.
THOMAS: 4. The usual from him.
EDUN: 3. Meh
McGRANDLES: 3. Not as bad as I expected
ANDERSON: 2. Terrible today
FRASER: 3. Not fit. Weak as piss.
C.CAMPBELL: 5. Best of a bad bunch.
TEDIĆ: 2. I trust whoever called me out the other day for suggesting he was a dud will now concede I was correct.
KIRK: 0 All been said already. An utter disgrace.
ASIIMWE: 3. Tried but like Bambi on ice.
T.WATSON: 3 Not on long enough to make an impact. At least he gave a fcuk.
MAY: 4. Love him but he had little impact.
Referee: 50 -
lancashire lad said:Applescore: 6 shockingly generous, but I'm in the 'that team should be good enough' camp. Calling for yet another managerial change is ridiculous... 22 since Curbs and where has it got us?
WALKER: 4 can't blame him for the goal but looked like... not a keeper
ABANKWAH: 4 send him back
NESS: 4 unlucky with the og, had to go for it, but worryingly bad elsewhere
THOMAS: 2 awful, awful performance. Would say the worst this season, but not even the worst this game
EDUN: 5 welcome back. Get better
McGRANDLES: 5 actually covered a lot of ground first half and a lot of mistakes from the defenders
ANDERSON: 5, first half 7, second half 3. Got worse every minute after a very strong start
FRASER: 6 not sure why he's the target for some people. Scored, put 2 on a plate, and looked far more composed than the rest
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5 MoM the only real regular threat
TEDIĆ: 4 just doesn't offer enough of anything.
KIRK: 1 a new low. He should be embarrassed with some of those challenges he avoided, as well as the chances he missed. I'd rather play... anyone really
ASIIMWE: 4 added nothing
T.WATSON: 4 also added nothing
MAY: 5 looked a bit more of a threat than the others, but clutching at straws here
Referee: 7
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
1 -
An embarrassmentlancashire lad said:Applescore: 2 got it all wrong tonight
WALKER: 5 did nothing wrong
ABANKWAH: 3 a few shakey mistakes and never really looked comfortable
NESS: 4 shocking own goal but positionally had a decent game
THOMAS: 3 awful tries stuff he knows he can't pull off
EDUN: 7 thought he was a bright spark down the left and made a lot happen, we looked a lot worse when he came off
McGRANDLES: 6 thought he was tidy tonight and didn't so much wrong
ANDERSON: 4 gave possession away for too often but was always willing
FRASER: 3 offered nothing bar the goal really
C.CAMPBELL: 4 tried and tried but didn't have the bottle to shoot at any point
TEDIĆ: 2 useless offered literally nothing
KIRK: -10 my least favourite Charlton player ever the sooner he fucks off the better, I blame him for us not scoring more and ultimately drawing against a much worse side than us
ASIIMWE: 3 was poor tonight
T.WATSON: 2 looks like a non league footballer
MAY: 4 not his best game but was out wide
Referee: 2 gave Cray valley everything they wanted second half showed 0 bottle
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a0 -
Applescore: 1
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 2
THOMAS: 4
EDUN: 3
McGRANDLES: 4.5
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 4 (includes .5 for the goal)
C.CAMPBELL: 5.5
TEDIĆ: 4 (includes .5 for leave for the goal)
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 4
Referee: 4
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
0 -
Applescore: 0 - write out 1000 times, never play a weakened team in cup matches
WALKER: 3
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 6
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 4
ANDERSON: 7
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 0
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 6
Referee: 7
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
1 -
Applescore: 2
WALKER: 5 didn't make mistakes, but didn't exactly ooze confidence either
ABANKWAH: 5 at least he tried
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 4
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 3 ineffective
KIRK: 1 not sure I've ever given a 1 before
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 4 ineffective as an attacking threat, but that was due to where he was played
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a0 -
Who gave Kirk 5 ffs , obviously a relative2
-
Appleton -1000
Players -1000
Cray 👏👏👏👏👏👏
To be clear, that is minus !!!0 -
CharltonApplescore: 1WALKER: 4ABANKWAH: 5NESS: 5THOMAS: 5EDUN: 5McGRANDLES: 4ANDERSON: 5FRASER: 7C.CAMPBELL: 6TEDIĆ: 7KIRK: 4ASIIMWE: 5T.WATSON: 5MAY: 6Referee: 50
-
Sponsored links:
-
At the game
WALKER: 6
ABANKWAH: 6
NESS: 6
THOMAS: 5.5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 6
FRASER: 6
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 5.5
KIRK: 5
ASIIMWE: 6
T.WATSON: 5.5
MAY: 5.5
Referee: 6
1 -
Applescore: 0 no wonder your a shit lower league journey man manager
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 2
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 2
EDUN: 2.5
McGRANDLES: 2
ANDERSON: 2.5
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 3
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 0.5 absolute shit shambles of a player
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 2
MAY: 5
0 -
lancashire lad said:Applescore: 3
WALKER: 3
ABANKWAH: 6
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 4.5
EDUN: 5.5
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 6 - 1 for goal
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5 MOM
TEDIĆ: 3
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5.5
Referee: 6
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
0 -
Applescore:3 eleven changes showed !
WALKER: 4 looked rusty
ABANKWAH: 5 is he a CB ? He did try.
NESS: 3 had a mare
THOMAS: 5 didn't command
EDUN: 5 rusty but did ok
McGRANDLES: 5 he had a decent 1st half with the water carrying.
ANDERSON: 6 good 1st half
FRASER: 4 +1 for his goal but so easy to be knocked off the ball
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5 lively
TEDIĆ: 5 he should be bossing their CB
KIRK: 2 THE LOWEST score I have ever given in 9 years on CL. Poor in every department and looks scared to tackle so Charlie just doesn't bother.
ASIIMWE: 5 he tried
T.WATSON: 4 struggled on wrong side.
MAY: 6 brought on too late to impact.
Referee: 6 can't blame him for our shortcomings.
0 -
Applescore: 0.5 pathetic. 11 changes is never, ever going to go well. Completely disrespected Cray and completely disrespected the fans that turned up.
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 3
C.CAMPBELL: 5
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 4
Referee: 6
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
Cba to comment on individual players. Quite frankly pathetic. Lacked any fight. Not fit to play for Charlton on that performance.Well done Cray Valley PM0 -
walker 1
wanko 1
edur 2
ness 2
mcgrandles 2
anderson 3
fraser 3
campbell 5
tedic 1
kirk FUCK OFF
leaburn 0
asimwe 3
may 2
watson 1
watson 1
appleton 00 -
WALKER: 4.5
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 2
THOMAS: 2
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 2.5
ANDERSON: 2
FRASER: 4
C.CAMPBELL: 4
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 0.5
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 4
Referee: 5
embarrassing0 -
lancashire lad said:Applescore: 0
WALKER: 3
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 4.5
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 4
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 6
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 3
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5
Referee:
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
0 -
Applescore: 3
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 5.5
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 5
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 4
KIRK: 2
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 3
Referee: 4
LEABURN: n/a
L.WATSON: n/a
honking0 -
Applescore:6 Gonna take shit for the result but he had to play certain players.
WALKER: 6, Did ok
ABANKWAH: 7, Didn't think he was that bad
NESS: 5, Guilty of overplaying on numerous occasions
THOMAS: 5, As above
EDUN: 6, Good to have him back, needed this game
McGRANDLES: 7, As above, was tidy and did nothing wrong
ANDERSON: 5, Another who overplayed so many times and lost out for the goal
FRASER: 8, Got 100 mins out of him and looked our most likely player
C.CAMPBELL:7, Why he hasn't made at least the bench more often is a mystery
TEDIĆ: 5, People on here said he would be better playing in his correct position............so
KIRK: 5, The one on one sums it up, leave it everyone else to rip him to shreds
ASIIMWE: 6, Did ok
T.WATSON: 5, Didn't do ok
MAY: 6, Didn't see much of him
Referee: 7, Did ok
5 -
Sponsored links:
-
Applescore: 4 - I thought the 11 he put out would be good enough but that proved very wrong. The performance illustrated how reliant we are on our soon to be out of contract players, Dobbo and CBT
WALKER: 5 - not much to do
ABANKWAH: 6 - very raw, but decent physicality and I thought he did ok
NESS: 4 - very poor. Gave the ball away three times in the first half in dangerous positions with misplaced passes.
THOMAS: 5 - his passing was extremely poor
EDUN: 6 - did ok and got a useful hour under his belt.
McGRANDLES: 6.5 - competent and assured. Looked like an experienced professional
ANDERSON: 5.5 - a good assist and decent first half but, like the rest of the side, fell away in the second
FRASER: 5 - a nice goal but flattered to deceive thereafter and ran out of steam
C.CAMPBELL: 5 - a couple of good bursts of speed but an uneven performance and yet to convince
TEDIĆ: 5 - had a couple of decent efforts but generally unimpressive
KIRK: 2 - missed our two best chances after they equalised and looks like he no longer has the stomach for professional football. I can’t see him getting a loan in January
ASIIMWE: 4.5 - I like him as a player but the 5 or 6 fouls he committed after his introduction contributed to our complete lack of momentum in the latter stages. He was probably over eager and made bad decisions as a result
T.WATSON: 5 - didn’t add anything
MAY: 6 - tried to get things going but to no avail
Referee: 6 - he was fine
LEABURN: n/a - a few good moments but tried to do too much on a couple of occasions
L.WATSON: n/a - unable to prise open a hard working and highly committed defence2 -
Appleton 1- for not putting out a stronger line up. 11 changes FFS. (Unless trying to prove how useless squad is).WALKER: 4 - Not much to do, but what he did have to do, was not done well.
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 3 - really poor and got worse as the game went along. Was it the formation ?
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 5 - scored a goal
C.CAMPBELL: 6 - made an effort all the way through
TEDIĆ: 4 - Not impressed
KIRK: 2 - What is his strength ? - not a striker, not a winger, doesn't tackle and not much of a midfielder. Needs to end time at club and start somewhere else. Negotiations should start ASAP, for good of him and club.
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5 - tried but introduced too late
Referee: 5
LEABURN: n/a - had impact but tried to do it all himself and gave away some unnecessary free kicks.
L.WATSON: n/a - should have started
0 -
Applescore: 3
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 6
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 5
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
Referee: 4
0 -
Apple score 2
Walker 6
Abankwah 4
Ness 4
Thomas 4
Edun 4.5
Mcgrandles 5.5
Anderson 4
Fraser 5
C Campbell 5
Tedic 4
Kirk 4
Asiimwe 4
T Watson 4
May 5
Ref 40 -
WALKER: 6 had nothing to do
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 6
ANDERSON: 5
FRASER: 5 started well and then faded and faded….
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5 probably our best player
TEDIĆ: 5.5
KIRK: 1 thought I saw the worst ever performance at Lincoln by a professional footballer 2 years ago - it was him, and today be beat that. An embarrassment of a football. Hope we never see him again in a CAFC shirt.
ASIIMWE: 5
T.WATSON: 5
MAY: 5.
Referee: 4
0 -
Applescore: 0
WALKER: 6
ABANKWAH: 5
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 4
EDUN: 6
McGRANDLES: 4
ANDERSON: 4.5
FRASER: 6 (plus one for the goal.)
C.CAMPBELL: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 2
ASIIMWE: 6.5
T.WATSON: 6
MAY: 6
Referee: 6
0 -
Applescore: 4
WALKER: 4
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 4
THOMAS: 5
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 3
FRASER: 7
C.CAMPBELL: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 0 never given zero before😊
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 5
Referee: 60 -
APPLES 1
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 3
NESS: 2
THOMAS: 3
EDUN: 4
McGRANDLES: 3
ANDERSON: 2
FRASER: 4
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 2
KIRK: 0
ASIIMWE: 3
T.WATSON: 3
MAY: 4
Referee: 5
0 -
Applescore: 1
WALKER: 5
ABANKWAH: 4
NESS: 3
THOMAS: 3.5
EDUN: 5
McGRANDLES: 5
ANDERSON: 4
FRASER: 4.5
C.CAMPBELL: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
KIRK: 1
ASIIMWE: 4
T.WATSON: 4
MAY: 4
Referee: 5
0 -
Applescore: 6 not his fault the team he picked didn't turn up for large parts of the game. Made subs to change it and they were just as bad, unfortunatelyWALKER: 6 flapped at a cross early and punched another one. Couldn't do anything about the equaliser, not much else to doABANKWAH: 4 skinned for the goal and didn't do an awful lot elseNESS: 2 weak, stupid decision making, poor in possession and scored an own goalTHOMAS: 4 so much momentum is gained or lost through the passing out from the back and he was so negative all gameEDUN: 6 thought he did ok todayMcGRANDLES: 6 kept the ball ticking over and made a few challengesANDERSON: 6.5 looked energetic in midfieldFRASER: 6 scored the goal, should have had an assist, but not a captain and disappointed in the second halfC.CAMPBELL: 6 looked quite lively, needs to shoot earlier and more oftenTEDIĆ: 5 nice step over/dummy for the goal, powerful shot in the first half, did nothing all second halfKIRK: 4 not as bad as most are making out, calling him a disgrace etc when no-one else covered themselves in glory, but he really needed to take one of his chances.ASIIMWE: 6.5 an upgrade on Abankwah, was strong and attackingT.WATSON: 2.5 a downgrade on Edun, everything he touched turned to shitMAY: 5 didn't do a lot reallyReferee: 6 should have dealt with time wasting soonerLEABURN: n/a special mention for looking lazy and greedy tonight, at one point had the ball for about 10 seconds trying to dribble through their defence, and didn't look up onceL.WATSON: n/a0
