Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
January 2024 Transfer Rumours (D/day starts pg.263)
Comments
-
AberystwythAddick said:Regardless of its been asked before or not I think it is a valid question. If we are doomed for another nothing season and both players refuse to sign, should we cash in now?
Not when 6points from relegation with a recent record of one win in 10 against some of the poorest opposition in the division. What would we get £250-500k each absolute max. Not worth the risk to me.
On top of that, if these owners are really serious about building the club back to where it was as the real return for investors is as a PL club then not being unable to retain your two best players is a pretty poor reality!9 -
What other options do we have?Henry Irving said:
"Suck it up"DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
Wow, you really just told other fans who aren't happy to "suck it up"
Unbelievable.
Suck it up and try to support the club, and see what happens or don't go and spend your hard earned cash.
Think last night they delivered a message, they know they haven't got it right, they have made mistake, they know it isn't an easy fix, they are trying to correct the wrongs, they have owners who are willing to invest money in the playing side, and non-playing side.
I am frustrated as much as anyone how poor this season has been, how we have left ourselves short, how things don't seem to be going to plan this window.. But need to give them a chance, personally,
I don't we will see the really benefits for another 18months - 2 years in my opinion, it is a project!
13 -
So, anyone got any transfer rumours?10
-
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.10 -
Yeah I get that. I would say though if that is the ambition does it not need to be done in a sustainable way? Furthermore, no disrespect to the two players but do they just look good because the dross around them. Would either of them be starting regularly in Bows or Powell’s promotion winning teams?Athletico Charlton said:AberystwythAddick said:Regardless of its been asked before or not I think it is a valid question. If we are doomed for another nothing season and both players refuse to sign, should we cash in now?
Not when 6points from relegation with a recent record of one win in 10 against some of the poorest opposition in the division. What would we get £250-500k each absolute max. Not worth the risk to me.
On top of that, if these owners are really serious about building the club back to where it was as the real return for investors is as a PL club then being unable to retain your two best players is a pretty poor reality!1 -
Sick of this club being someone's project heard it all before and here we go again.8
-
Hold on.... not going to plan this window??DubaiCAFC said:
What other options do we have?Henry Irving said:
"Suck it up"DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
Wow, you really just told other fans who aren't happy to "suck it up"
Unbelievable.
Suck it up and try to support the club, and see what happens or don't go and spend your hard earned cash.
Think last night they delivered a message, they know they haven't got it right, they have made mistake, they know it isn't an easy fix, they are trying to correct the wrongs, they have owners who are willing to invest money in the playing side, and non-playing side.
I am frustrated as much as anyone how poor this season has been, how we have left ourselves short, how things don't seem to be going to plan this window.. But need to give them a chance, personally,
I don't we will see the really benefits for another 18months - 2 years in my opinion, it is a project!
But but but..... you said on Monday it was going to be a busy week!!!!
Quickest reversal since your last one!15 -
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.4 -
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we5 -
Sponsored links:
-
supaclive said:
Hold on.... not going to plan this window??DubaiCAFC said:
What other options do we have?Henry Irving said:
"Suck it up"DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
Wow, you really just told other fans who aren't happy to "suck it up"
Unbelievable.
Suck it up and try to support the club, and see what happens or don't go and spend your hard earned cash.
Think last night they delivered a message, they know they haven't got it right, they have made mistake, they know it isn't an easy fix, they are trying to correct the wrongs, they have owners who are willing to invest money in the playing side, and non-playing side.
I am frustrated as much as anyone how poor this season has been, how we have left ourselves short, how things don't seem to be going to plan this window.. But need to give them a chance, personally,
I don't we will see the really benefits for another 18months - 2 years in my opinion, it is a project!
But but but..... you said on Monday it was going to be a busy week!!!!
Quickest reversal since your last one!
It is football, things are always changing, players change minds more times than hot dinners.. Not everything does go to plan when recruiting players, and that's not only Charlton, that is clubs up and down the country!!
I am going to leave it here now..6 -
Oh look the plan the project let's wait years for it to get better whilst they suck us dry and let our best players leave sell our youngsters and don't sign decent players for the first team hardly progress is it we are free falling but yeah let's trust in them the results are showing so far lol.5
-
The true test of our recruitment is who we go for next, if JCH is a no go. If we go back in for someone like Humphry's great but if we end up with a last minute youngster on loan or an out of form player returning from injury who can be picked up a bit cheaper, the signs aren't good.2
-
They not .. they had two weeks in the summer and this one .. everything else had to be agreed through TS ..supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we7 -
More than 2 weeksRonnieMoore said:
They not .. they had two weeks in the summer and this one .. everything else had to be agreed through TS ..supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldKDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
They took over the club on the 21st July
You would be no good if they were your specialist subject on Mastermind. You would be playing serious catch up on the general knowledge round
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/global-football-partners-purchase-charlton-athletic
4 -
Peter Storrie said they'd set a budget with TS and the potential new ownersshirty5 said:
More than 2 weeksRonnieMoore said:
They not .. they had two weeks in the summer and this one .. everything else had to be agreed through TS ..supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldKDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
They took over the club on the 21st July
You would be no good if they were your specialist subject on Mastermind. You would be playing serious catch up on the general knowledge round
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/global-football-partners-purchase-charlton-athletic
The potential new owners were FULLY aware of any transfer dealings the club were involved in and ney, I reckon, had approval over them all !2 -
It is a valid question but at the time it was asked at Bromley Addicks the situation was different and my view was we should keep them for a promotion push.AberystwythAddick said:Regardless of its been asked before or not I think it is a valid question. If we are doomed for another nothing season and both players refuse to sign, should we cash in now?
Now, I tend to think that we could cash in we're not going up but we're also not safe from relegation so selling two of our best players might not be a great idea.
Remember New England Teamen and 1978 when we let Powell, Flan and Abrahams go around March and just avoided the drop.4 -
NOT a rumour, more a comment .. isn't this the type of young player that WE should be trying to get on loan, based in the south now loaned to Lincoln ?
Joe Taylor: Lincoln City sign Luton Town striker on loan - BBC Sport
1 -
May as well close the thread. The bloke has essentially tried to shift blame on fans for panic signings and managerial appointments.fenaddick said:So, anyone got any transfer rumours?
He's then suggested that it's the players fault for not signing, he's more or less said January is a no go for transfer movements, even tried to make a joke out of it by smugly saying he may as well wake up in the afternoon.
They're doing it on the cheap, if we don't sign JCH and that money isn't spent elsewhere to improve this team, which definitely needs improvement, I think the writing is on the wall.
I am now a bit more suspicious knowing of Rodwells links with Peterborough and 'DMAC'. Wouldn't it be funny that we were in for a Peterborough manager and one of Peterboroughs top players and rejected by both? It's not like this hasn't happened before when Dmac was allowing Southall to talk shit to keep Charlton fans on side.
The biggest indicator by a country mile on these lot will be by windows close. If we don't sign JCH or at least put those wages to good use and funds, which they have now confirmed they are able to, something is wrong.
Because either they don't have the money they are claiming to and the JCH bid was a media stunt to calm a disgruntled fan base down or, their scouting knowledge goes no further than approaching a top striker in our league to a club who want to sell. Either way not ideal imo.
That fans whatever you want to call it did nothing for me but made me think they're more tin pot than I already thought they were.
Disclaimer, these are all my views, none of these claims are fact and all my opinions based on what I have seen and heard. As always I hope I am wrong, but I have a feeling we will be warning another clubs fans about this mob like others fans warned us.15 -
Sponsored links:
-
Please stop saying Scott has had two windows already. Please!!!supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
window 1. He was working for sandgaard under a completely different brief. The owner wanted out and wanted to reduce costs. From sandgaards point of view, last January was a good window.
window 2. What percentage of the window had gone when the new owners took control? How many realistic targets had moved on by that stage?
window 3. This is the first full window Scott has had.Summary. As this is his first full window and I'll judge him come February.11 -
To be fair, the 21st July was two weeks before the season started!shirty5 said:
More than 2 weeksRonnieMoore said:
They not .. they had two weeks in the summer and this one .. everything else had to be agreed through TS ..supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldKDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
They took over the club on the 21st July
You would be no good if they were your specialist subject on Mastermind. You would be playing serious catch up on the general knowledge round
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/global-football-partners-purchase-charlton-athletic2 -
They done well by not letting Scott face questions.DubaiCAFC said:
What other options do we have?Henry Irving said:
"Suck it up"DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
Wow, you really just told other fans who aren't happy to "suck it up"
Unbelievable.
Suck it up and try to support the club, and see what happens or don't go and spend your hard earned cash.
Think last night they delivered a message, they know they haven't got it right, they have made mistake, they know it isn't an easy fix, they are trying to correct the wrongs, they have owners who are willing to invest money in the playing side, and non-playing side.
I am frustrated as much as anyone how poor this season has been, how we have left ourselves short, how things don't seem to be going to plan this window.. But need to give them a chance, personally,
I don't we will see the really benefits for another 18months - 2 years in my opinion, it is a project!
2 -
This is his 3rd window (The 2nd one not a full one as highlighted below)Todds_right_hook said:
Please stop saying Scott has had two windows already. Please!!!supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
window 1. He was working for sandgaard under a completely different brief. The owner wanted out and wanted to reduce costs. From sandgaards point of view, last January was a good window.
window 2. What percentage of the window had gone when the new owners took control? How many realistic targets had moved on by that stage?
window 3. This is the first full window Scott has had.Summary. As this is his first full window and I'll judge him come February.
The whole of January last year
From the 21st July when his group that he’s employed by took over the club. His last 4 signings shown to be panic stations and 2 of those already thrown back
And 11 days into this one now and very likely to still be charge by the end of it6 -
Fine if that's what you want to discuss and how you feel but it's still got barely anything to do with rumours. I get sucked in by other conversation on this thread myself and understand we're all a bit bored with no rumours but there's already a thread about the meeting last night and if you want to start one about what was said about transfers specifically then I'm sure you know how to start your own threadBraziliance said:
May as well close the thread. The bloke has essentially tried to shift blame on fans for panic signings and managerial appointments.fenaddick said:So, anyone got any transfer rumours?
He's then suggested that it's the players fault for not signing, he's more or less said January is a no go for transfer movements, even tried to make a joke out of it by smugly saying he may as well wake up in the afternoon.
They're doing it on the cheap, if we don't sign JCH and that money isn't spent elsewhere to improve this team, which definitely needs improvement, I think the writing is on the wall.
I am now a bit more suspicious knowing of Rodwells links with Peterborough and 'DMAC'. Wouldn't it be funny that we were in for a Peterborough manager and one of Peterboroughs top players and rejected by both? It's not like this hasn't happened before when Dmac was allowing Southall to talk shit to keep Charlton fans on side.
The biggest indicator by a country mile on these lot will be by windows close. If we don't sign JCH or at least put those wages to good use and funds, which they have now confirmed they are able to, something is wrong.
Because either they don't have the money they are claiming to and the JCH bid was a media stunt to calm a disgruntled fan base down or, their scouting knowledge goes no further than approaching a top striker in our league to a club who want to sell. Either way not ideal imo.
That fans whatever you want to call it did nothing for me but made me think they're more tin pot than I already thought they were.
Disclaimer, these are all my views, none of these claims are fact and all my opinions based on what I have seen and heard. As always I hope I am wrong, but I have a feeling we will be warning another clubs fans about this mob like others fans warned us.6 -
There isn't a straight forward answer really, as it depends on where we are in the table, and who else we bring in. Back in December, promotion was still a realistic aspiration, and it's possible that one or both of Dobson and CBT might have resigned if we were a Championship club next season. Now there's no chance of that, but a small but genuine chance of relegation.Henry Irving said:
It is a valid question but at the time it was asked at Bromley Addicks the situation was different and my view was we should keep them for a promotion push.AberystwythAddick said:Regardless of its been asked before or not I think it is a valid question. If we are doomed for another nothing season and both players refuse to sign, should we cash in now?
Now, I tend to think that we could cash in we're not going up but we're also not safe from relegation so selling two of our best players might not be a great idea.
Remember New England Teamen and 1978 when we let Powell, Flan and Abrahams go around March and just avoided the drop.
We're trying to bring in JCH who Posh are wanting to sell because his contract is running out, so it's a common decision in football post Bosman.
1 -
Exactly this.Todds_right_hook said:
Please stop saying Scott has had two windows already. Please!!!supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
window 1. He was working for sandgaard under a completely different brief. The owner wanted out and wanted to reduce costs. From sandgaards point of view, last January was a good window.
window 2. What percentage of the window had gone when the new owners took control? How many realistic targets had moved on by that stage?
window 3. This is the first full window Scott has had.Summary. As this is his first full window and I'll judge him come February.4 -
Some wobbler that….enjoyed reading.Braziliance said:
May as well close the thread. The bloke has essentially tried to shift blame on fans for panic signings and managerial appointments.fenaddick said:So, anyone got any transfer rumours?
He's then suggested that it's the players fault for not signing, he's more or less said January is a no go for transfer movements, even tried to make a joke out of it by smugly saying he may as well wake up in the afternoon.
They're doing it on the cheap, if we don't sign JCH and that money isn't spent elsewhere to improve this team, which definitely needs improvement, I think the writing is on the wall.
I am now a bit more suspicious knowing of Rodwells links with Peterborough and 'DMAC'. Wouldn't it be funny that we were in for a Peterborough manager and one of Peterboroughs top players and rejected by both? It's not like this hasn't happened before when Dmac was allowing Southall to talk shit to keep Charlton fans on side.
The biggest indicator by a country mile on these lot will be by windows close. If we don't sign JCH or at least put those wages to good use and funds, which they have now confirmed they are able to, something is wrong.
Because either they don't have the money they are claiming to and the JCH bid was a media stunt to calm a disgruntled fan base down or, their scouting knowledge goes no further than approaching a top striker in our league to a club who want to sell. Either way not ideal imo.
That fans whatever you want to call it did nothing for me but made me think they're more tin pot than I already thought they were.
Disclaimer, these are all my views, none of these claims are fact and all my opinions based on what I have seen and heard. As always I hope I am wrong, but I have a feeling we will be warning another clubs fans about this mob like others fans warned us.9 -
So the club are looking at better quality players.
If they approached me, I’d have reservations.Sign now, Appleton/Scott sell it to you with the ‘5 year plan’, but you can see we are on a bad run of results. I don’t care what they state, no wins in January and Appleton might be gone (surely he would go then) and you are then risking yet another new Manager who you might not get on with.
The club is in a very difficult position to attract any permanent signings right now.
Will be easier in the summer once we know what league we are in and you have time to plan properly for early summer signings.0 -
If you want to count the first one, then do.. But when was Scott appointed, wasn't right at the end of December, so there would have been no plan, and was still working with Gallen, and Martin S.. So not as straight forward as you think.. Summer was the same as well.. This is first real run at it, on his own, making decision without people from the other side to go through..shirty5 said:
This is his 3rd window (The 2nd one not a full one as highlighted below)Todds_right_hook said:
Please stop saying Scott has had two windows already. Please!!!supaclive said:
Two more windowsDubaiCAFC said:
Scott hasn't got it right, everyone knows and the owners know that as well.. Let's see what happens over the next 2 windows, then make a real judgement!supaclive said:
Andy Scott is on the record as saying we have a squad to compete for top 6.DubaiCAFC said:
Won't happen over night.. It takes time!supaclive said:
But Charlie said it wasn't hard with better management to reduce the losses to £1.5m - £2m per year and establish ourselves as a top half Championship side.DubaiCAFC said:
Club is a mess.. It is no quick fix! this years of damage.. And if you are not going to allow time, it will never be fixed!supaclive said:
As they shouldDubaiCAFC said:
Na... they will just blame the owners!!Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Dobson leaves then it’s all Bromley Addicks fault.
Simple as that.
Same goes for CBT too.
If we were top 6, winning games, with a real chance of promotion and the club made them a good offer, they'd sign.
I wouldn't re-sign for us based on the current footballing prospects at CAFC
They must be crazy though- what with Appleton being the best coach in the world and all that...
Super hero Varney isn't coming to the rescue.. suck it up, and support! We have little option..
If it's not hard how comes we're making it look quite difficult being a top half Division 3 side??...
He said failure stops now
Methven said you only have to be better than previous owners to dramatically cut losses and establish ourselves in the top half of the Championship.
They were completely wrong or they aren't very good at their jobs.
Of course it would take time regardless of the manager etc
Right now though, we are lightyears away.
As I said, it won't happen over night!
We are not looking to scrap the bottom of the barrel now.
On top of the last two he's had some say in, plus this one?
FIVE WINDOWS?
We are really setting the bar low aren't we
window 1. He was working for sandgaard under a completely different brief. The owner wanted out and wanted to reduce costs. From sandgaards point of view, last January was a good window.
window 2. What percentage of the window had gone when the new owners took control? How many realistic targets had moved on by that stage?
window 3. This is the first full window Scott has had.Summary. As this is his first full window and I'll judge him come February.
The whole of January last year
From the 21st July when his group that he’s employed by took over the club. His last 4 signings shown to be panic stations and 2 of those already thrown back
And 11 days into this one now and very likely to still be charge by the end of it1
