Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

PLAYERS MARKS: Championship: Bristol City v Charlton (closes Sunday teatime)

2

Comments

  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,741
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5 
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 5 
    CAMPBELL: 6
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 8.5
    Referee: 5 - another clown
    Subs: LEABURN: 7
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • masicat
    masicat Posts: 5,008
    edited August 16

    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 7 give the bloke a break ffs
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    CAREY: 8.5
    APTER: 8.5
    NJ - 9
  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,272
    Had to watch on a tiny screen with no commentary in the first half so some marks may be even dumber than usual;

    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 8 
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 8 
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 8.5
    Referee: 6.5
    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
  • Julesnumber
    Julesnumber Posts: 95
    Being a resident of Bristol with one daughter into Rovers and the other into City, and having seen quite a lot of City last season, (and Rovers for that matter) this was a really good performance. City were dominated, with no ideas and clutching at their mid table straws by the end. Full marks to newly promoted Addix, a performance i would gauge as thoroughly top half. OK, a long way to go, and improvement will come, but very little to worry about two games in ....

    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 8
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 8.5
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 8
  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,467
    KAMINSKI: 7 - had very little to do
    RAMSAY: 10 - excellent
    BELL: 7
    JONES: 10 - Mr reliable 
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 9
    APTER: 9
    Referee: 7
    Subs: LEABURN: 7
  • Coveredendchoir
    Coveredendchoir Posts: 242
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7
    Referee: fussy 5
    Subs: LEABURN: 7
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,733
    KAMINSKI: 6.5 Not much to do
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 8.5
    JONES: 9
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN:6.5 Keep at it, it will come
    CAMPBELL: 8
    DOCHERTY: 6.5 Chasing the pace of the game at this level
    CAREY: 8.5
    APTER: 9
    Referee: 4
    Subs: LEABURN: 8.5 scared the proverbial out of them.
  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 57,829
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 6
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    KELMAN: 5.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    CAREY: 7.5
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 8
    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,222
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 9
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 8
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • eastterrace6168
    eastterrace6168 Posts: 22,586
    edited August 16
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    CAREY: 8
    APTER: 8.5
    Referee: 4
    Subs: LEABURN: 6
             OLAOFE: 6...I know he was n/a but deserved a mark anyway for his impact on the game...
  • Sponsored links:



  • CostaFortune
    CostaFortune Posts: 402
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 9
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    CAREY: 8
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 8
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • FULLERpromise
    FULLERpromise Posts: 340
    edited August 16
    KAMINSKI: 7 solid 
    RAMSAY: 10 faultless 
    BELL: 8 classy 
    JONES: 9 should be our captain 
    EDWARDS: 7 steady and solid 
    COVENTRY: 8 +1 for an excellent interception to stop a 1vs1
    KELMAN: 5.5 needs service to see him at best 
    CAMPBELL: 8 done v well in a tough game 
    DOCHERTY: 6 battles but the weak link 
    CAREY: 7.5 impressed with what seen so far 
    APTER: 8.5 dangerous and exciting 
    Referee: 8 overall one of best seen for a while 
    Subs: LEABURN: 8 excellent 
             OLAOFE: skilful and dangerous 
             KNIBBS: knows the runs to make 
             GILLESPHEY: steady short cameo
             ANDERSON: good energy 
  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,297
    edited August 16
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    CAREY: 7.5
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 7
    Subs: LEABURN: 7
  • Brownie12
    Brownie12 Posts: 1,528
    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8.
    BELL: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 5.5 (we really are starving him of service)
    CAMPBELL: 6
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY:7 
    APTER: 7.5
    Subs: LEABURN: 7



  • No.1 in South London
    No.1 in South London Posts: 3,961
    edited August 17
    KAMINSKI: 8
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 9
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 8
    APTER: 8.5
    Leaburn 7.5
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,079
    KAMINSKI: 7 clean sheet against a team that put 4 against Sheffield Utd last weekend. Nothing stupid. Dealt with everything well
    RAMSAY: 9.5 would be a ten, but deducted 0.5 has this performance will no doubt get other teams watching 
    BELL: 7 made me nervous last week holding on to the ball for too long. Solid today. Was comfortable 
    JONES: 7 solid as always. Comfortable 
    EDWARDS: 7.5 got down the wing well. Hopefully just a sore knee as opposed to anything serious 
    COVENTRY: 7 kept things ticking. Needs to back himself and take a shot. Was in a couple
    of decent positions today and looked for that extra pass
    KELMAN: 6 I actually thought he played well in a very tough game for a lone striker. Got into the game second half. Held the ball up well. Can’t believe he’s being written off already
    CAMPBELL: 7 improvement n last weekend. Would be a very good player if he just sorted out his final decision making 
    DOCHERTY: 7 dogged performance. Done the dirty work well that slowed the game down in our favour. That kinda work always goes unnoticed 
    CAREY: 6.5 not as involved as last week. Bit like Kelman, difficult game for him, and that’s down to how well set up Brizzle were 
    APTER: 8 you just feel that when he’s got the ball, something will happen. Felt that last week too
    Referee: 4 loved the sound of his whistle a bit too much. Gave them a free kick when TC closed the keeper down, and the keeper threw himself to the floor… and again when their player kicked Doc and went down. Shocking
    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5 worked hard. This was the game for him and Tanto. That physicality caused them issues 
             OLAOFE: n/a 
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a 

    subs done well when they came on
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 636
    edited August 17
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 5
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7.5
    Leaburn: 7
  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,235
    At the Game

    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    BELL: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7.5

    Leaburn: 7
  • PhilFor54
    PhilFor54 Posts: 182
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10 Absolutely magnificent performance
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 9 Usual
    EDWARDS: 7.5 Hope he's OK but it didn't look good
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    CAREY: 8 Doing really well. Like him a lot
    APTER: 8 Excellent. Some good defensive work as well as his attacking flair
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • FinlandMatt
    FinlandMatt Posts: 34
    KAMINSKI: 7- Delt with everything
    RAMSAY: 10 MOTM - That was an unreal performance
    BELL: 9
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7 - First half he was a little slow with reactions for me, but second half much better, extra half point for clean sheet
    COVENTRY: 7 - Did well
    KELMAN:  6 - Hard to judge him because he is not getting the right kind of service for how he plays, he is trying you can see that.
    CAMPBELL: 7 - not bad, better this week
    DOCHERTY: 7.5 - Leader, some of what he does goes un-noticed
    CAREY: 7.5 - always wants to get involved
    APTER: 8 - what a player, loves cutting inside and has a peach of a cross on him
    Referee: 6 
    Subs: LEABURN: 7 - Suits us better then Kelman at the moment, more of a target man.
  • Sponsored links:



  • SE_7EVEN
    SE_7EVEN Posts: 288

    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 8
    APTER: 8 
    Referee: 6
    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,632
    edited August 17
    KAMINSKI: 7 Not a lot to do
    RAMSAY: 9.5 Class act, we need to stop bigging him up though before some bastard team nicks him off us before the window closes.
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS:7.5 
    COVENTRY:7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 7 
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7.5
    APTER: 8
    Subs: LEABURN 7.5 
  • Shrew
    Shrew Posts: 5,749
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 10
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    CAREY:8 
    APTER:8.5
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN:7
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • Taxi_Lad
    Taxi_Lad Posts: 3,772
    KAMINSKI:  6  nowt to do
    RAMSAY: 10 did everything well
    BELL: 7. Classy
    JONES: 8  leads by example
    EDWARDS: 7. Steady
    COVENTRY: 7. Steady
    KELMAN: 6  struggling to get much service but worked hard 
    CAMPBELL: 7.5. Looked good but still need more end product 
    DOCHERTY: 6.5. Battled but a little careless 
    CAREY: 7.5. Busy. Keeps the ball well
    APTER: 9. What a livewire & tenacious
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5. Got involved
  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 621
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 8.5
    JONES: 9.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    KELMAN: 4
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 6
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 7
    Subs: LEABURN: 9

    at the game crowd = 10
  • clive
    clive Posts: 19,471
    At the game

    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7.5
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 7
    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
  • ateamofcorygibbs
    ateamofcorygibbs Posts: 1,193
    edited August 17
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 9
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7
    Referee: 
    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
  • Addickted2TheReds
    Addickted2TheReds Posts: 7,736
    KAMINSKI: 7. Solid. Handling looks fantastic.

    RAMSAY: 10. Up there with the best performances I’ve ever seen for Charlton. Watched with some Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and City fans and they were all going mad for him. 

    BELL: 8. Great addition. Sentiments make me feel sorry for Macca but unfortunately for him this is an upgrade. 

    JONES: 8. Par for the course. 

    EDWARDS: 8. Taken the step up in his stride. 

    COVENTRY: 7. Very good. 

    KELMAN: 5. Very limited service and the negative comments about him are grating me. We do need to see an improvement but let’s give him time. 

    CAMPBELL: 7. Much better than Watford.

    DOCHERTY: 7. Snap.

    CAREY: 6. Didn’t think he was as good as last week. Looking at the other marks I seem to be on my own in thinking Doc had a better game than him so I might have got this wrong.

    APTER: 7.5. Exciting, feel like it’s just about to click. Daft booking, shouldn’t have got spun like that up the pitch and then obviously had to bring him down.

    Referee: 6

    Subs: LEABURN: 7. Would have been 10 but for the body language 😉.
  • scruffle
    scruffle Posts: 2,282
    edited August 16
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    BELL: 8
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    CAREY: 8
    APTER: 8
    Referee: 6
    Subs: LEABURN: 7
             OLAOFE: n/a
             KNIBBS: n/a
             GILLESPHEY: n/a
             ANDERSON: n/a
  • bristoladdick
    bristoladdick Posts: 1,147
    KAMINSKI: 7  
    RAMSAY: 8.5  
    BELL: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 7
    APTER: 7.5
    Referee: 6
    Subs: LEABURN: 7

Categories

“Marketplace”