Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Sheffield Utd (closes Sunday late luncheon)

24

Comments

  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 644

    KAMINSKI: 7.5 (9 for his saves, 6 for distribution)

    BREE: 6.5 Defended ok on his wrong side

    RAMSAY: 7 Good to have him back but a few hairy moments

    JONES: 7 String in the air but no so good on the ground. Bad tackle for his deserved booking

    GILLESPHEY: 6 Defended ok but passing awful

    CLARKE: 7.5 Decent debut looks a good addition.

    ANDERSON: 7 Kept the midfield turning over but don’t see a forward pass or want to shoot

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5 Ok and took one for the team in his booking

    KNIBBS: 6 Runs a lot but struggles to make an impact. Hope the injury isn’t too bad

    LEABURN: 7 Led the line well

    KELMAN: 5 Little impact

    Referee: 9.5 Well done for not bottling the red cards and decent throughout

    Subs: CAREY: 6.5 Good goal but his passing was poor

    CAMPBELL: 7.5 Made a diffference

    DYKES: 6.5 Decent debut


  • addick_for_life
    addick_for_life Posts: 267
    Kaminski 9
    Bree 4 hardly made a tackle and gave the ball away
    Ramsey 4 slowed the ball down too much
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 5 league one player
    Clarke 8 good debut 
    Anderson 6.5
    Rankin Costello 1 for turning up - never broke into a trot and kept telling everyone to slow the ball up - surely you should move the ball quicker against 9 
    Knibbs 6
    Leaburn 6.5
    Kelman 6.5
    Ref 9 
    Carey 7
    Campbell 8
    Dykes 8
     
  • charente addick
    charente addick Posts: 3,871
    lancashire lad said:

    sun's out and I have a good vibe about this one (written pre match!):

    KAMINSKI: 9

    BREE:4

    RAMSAY: 7

    JONES:7

    GILLESPHEY:6.5

    CLARKE:6.5

    ANDERSON:6.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:6.5

    KNIBBS:6

    LEABURN:7.5

    KELMAN:5

    Referee:7

    Subs: CAREY:7.5

    CAMPBELL:7.5

    DYKES:7

    GODDEN: n/a


  • DyerConsequences
    DyerConsequences Posts: 2,762
    KAMINSKI: 8
    BREE: 5.5
    RAMSAY: 6
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6.5
    CLARKE: 6.5
    ANDERSON: 6
    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
    KNIBBS: 6
    LEABURN: 7
    KELMAN: 7

    Referee: 10

    Subs: CAREY: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    DYKES: 7
  • Bailey
    Bailey Posts: 3,630
    edited January 17

    KAMINSKI:MOM 10, Shut some of the 'Mannion must play' wallies up, we wouldn't have been in it if not for him

    BREE:4, Played hopelessly out of position 

    RAMSAY:5, Clearly not match fit

    JONES:7, Kept his head when under the cosh

    GILLESPHEY:7, Another who kept at it 

    CLARKE:5, Got better but ring rusty 

    ANDERSON:7, Spent most of the first half defending 

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:7, As above 

    KNIBBS:5, Didn't see the ball before the tackle, not his fault, we didn't have it 

    LEABURN:5, As above

    KELMAN:5, And again 

    Referee:7, 

    Subs: CAREY:5, Extra point for the goal, serious lack of form 

    CAMPBELL:, 9, Just to annoy 'Ronnie' 

    DYKES:7, People were questioning his signing but he brings much needed physicality, good assist . 

  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,424
    KAMINSKI: 8 kept us in it first half

    BREE: 5

    RAMSAY: 6 Ok but one of his worst games for us

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    CLARKE: 6.5

    ANDERSON: 5.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 6.5

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 10

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 9 (+2 to counteract Ronnie's mark) 

    DYKES: 6.5

    GODDEN: n/a
  • covered_end_junior
    covered_end_junior Posts: 4,585

    KAMINSKI: 9

    BREE: 4

    RAMSAY: 7

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5.5

    KNIBBS: 4

    LEABURN: 6

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 7

    Subs: CAREY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 7

  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,344
    KAMINSKI: 8 Good saves but some scary distribution
    BREE: 5.5 Disappointing final appearance (probably) 
    RAMSAY: 5.5 Not up to the standards we expect from Kayne
    JONES: 7 Solid, silly booking
    GILLESPHEY: 6.5 Not bad but long aimless passes in the second half were unnecessary
    CLARKE: 7 Good debut. Well done for lasting the whole game
    ANDERSON: 5 Struggles at this level. This was a game for Doc. Is he injured?
    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 Pretty anonymous first half, better second
    KNIBBS: 6 Hope the injury isn't too bad
    LEABURN: 7 No outfield player did well in that first half but he at least worked hard.
    KELMAN:5 Disappointing

    Referee: 8

    Subs: CAREY:6 Good goal, not much else of note
    CAMPBELL: 6 Fisrt ten minutes of the second half very good but too negative after that
    DYKES: 7 An assist, put himself about. Could be a useful acquisition
  • altrinchamaddick
    altrinchamaddick Posts: 965
    KAMINSKI: 9

    BREE: 4.5

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 5

    CLARKE: 5.5

    ANDERSON:4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:5

    KNIBBS:5

    LEABURN:6.5

    KELMAN:5.5

    Referee:7

    Subs: CAREY:6

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 7
  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,722

    KAMINSKI:  8

    BREE: 6

    RAMSAY: 5.5

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 5.5

    CLARKE: 6 

    ANDERSON:4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:5

    KNIBBS:5

    LEABURN:6.5

    KELMAN:4

    Referee:

    Subs: CAREY:4

    CAMPBELL:5

    DYKES:6.5


  • Sponsored links:



  • DamoNorthStand
    DamoNorthStand Posts: 11,520

    KAMINSKI: 9.5 MOM - single handedly the reason we weren’t 3 or 4 down at halftime 

    BREE: 4.5 Not a left back - that much we now know 

    RAMSAY: 5.5 Looked rusty to say the least 

    JONES: 7.5 Won everything he needed to and the only one who looked like being able to take the aerial fight to them 

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5 Ok

    CLARKE: 6.5 Solid debut and was screaming for the ball second half when he had acres of space. Think he will be ok

    ANDERSON: 3.5 Not great - that’s all I will say

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4.5 looked slow and a bit ponderous 

    KNIBBS: 5 was doing ok in a dire first half team performance before the injury 

    LEABURN: 6.5 only player who looked able to compete in the first half 

    KELMAN: 5 lots of misplaced passes which isn’t like him first half. Would have been gutted to go off at half time until he saw how we were playing 

    Referee: 

    Subs: CAREY: 6 extra point for a great finish

    CAMPBELL: 6.5 Defintiely better off the bench. Wanted to see him commit to taking on their full back more but maybe that’s what he was asked to do

    DYKES: 7 Good assist and will be an asset

    GODDEN: n/a

  • DONVANVLIET
    DONVANVLIET Posts: 249

    KAMINSKI: 9 MOM

    BREE: 7

    RAMSAY: 5 Far too negtaive at times, taking safety first options only

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 5 Lucky to have not given away a penalty with that push in the box. No creative spark.

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7 Pick of our midfielders

    KNIBBS: 5 Passenger until that awful foul

    LEABURN: 7.5 Another good shift

    KELMAN: 6 Little service

    Referee: 7 Got most of the big calls right

    Subs: CAREY: 6 Good goal but erratic with his passing

    CAMPBELL: 8 A real handful. Hope he starts on Tuesday

    DYKES: 7.5 Also a handful

    GODDEN: n/a

  • Addictedoldgit
    Addictedoldgit Posts: 1,858
    From TV.

    KAMINSKI:     8.5

    BREE:              4.5     

    RAMSAY:         5.5

    JONES:             6.5

    GILLESPHEY:   6

    CLARKE:            7

    ANDERSON:      4.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS:               5.5

    LEABURN:            6.5

    KELMAN:               5

    Referee:         7

    Subs: CAREY:        7

    CAMPBELL:            7.5

    DYKES:                     7

    GODDEN: n/a


  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,103

    KAMINSKI: 9 made at least 3 top top saves first half that kept us in the game.

    BREE: 4 didn’t work on the left for him

    RAMSAY: 4 only wanted to pass the ball back and didn’t even get that right  

    JONES: 6 held a shaky defence together

    GILLESPHEY: 5 not a Championship player. Too slow

    CLARKE: 6.5 put in 4 wicked crosses. Was rusty but got better

    ANDERSON: 3 was lost first half. Left them so much space. Couldn’t pass even when playing 9 men. Just wanted to play it safe and that didn’t always work

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 tried. Spent a lot of the time cleaning up Karoys mess

    KNIBBS: 5 tough first half for the attacking players. I thought he was lucky to stay on the pitch. The tackle on his was disgusting and I think that’s his season done

    LEABURN: 8 the only player first half to try and get things moving in the right direction. Should have scored

    KELMAN: 6 not his game. No service. Is never going to win an aerial dual against Tanganga

    Referee: 7 both sending offs were the correct decision. When their man played the ball through and it hit him was comedy at its finest

    Subs: CAREY: 7 got the goal

    CAMPBELL: 7 scared them. They doubled up on him but we were so bad that we didn’t capitalise on the space that created 

    DYKES: 7 solid. Got an assist

    GODDEN: n/a 

  • clive
    clive Posts: 19,929

    At the game

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 6

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    CLARKE: 6.5

    ANDERSON: 6

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS:6

    LEABURN: 6

    KELMAN: 5.5

    Referee: 7

    Subs: CAREY:6

    CAMPBELL:6.5

    DYKES:6

  • Southbank
    Southbank Posts: 5,564

    KAMINSKI: 8 Our saviour

    BREE: 4

    RAMSAY:5 Rusty

    JONES:7 Second saviour

    GILLESPHEY: 4

    CLARKE:5

    ANDERSON:4 Never again, cannot control or pass the ball. League One level

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 Slow slow slow

    KNIBBS: 4 Terrible tackle, but hopeless before that

    LEABURN: 6 Some nice touches

    KELMAN: 4 Useless

    Referee: 5

    Subs: CAREY: 5.5 The goal then nothing

    CAMPBELL: 7 Without him we have literally no creative outlet.

    DYKES: 6 Good assist and directed headers. Learn from that Miles

  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,611

    KAMINSKI: 9

    BREE:6.5

    RAMSAY 6.5:

    JONES:7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 6.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 8

    KELMAN: 6.5

    Referee: 7

    Subs: CAREY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    DYKES: 7.5

  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,530

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 5

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    CLARKE: 6.5

    ANDERSON: 4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS: 4

    LEABURN: 6

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 8

    Subs: CAREY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 6.5


  • Taxi_Lad
    Taxi_Lad Posts: 3,837

    KAMINSKI: 9  some big saves first half 

    BREE: 4  

    RAMSAY: 6  looked shaky but got away with it

    JONES: 9  with TK pick the bunch 1st half

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    CLARKE: 7  some good balls into the box 

    ANDERSON: 6  some decent harassing but some careless passes

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 7.5  only outlet  battled away

    KELMAN: 5  not in it

    Referee: 

    Subs: CAREY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    DYKES: 7


  • Longtimeaddicted
    Longtimeaddicted Posts: 597

    KAMINSKI: 9

    BREE: 2WTF was he doing on the left didn’t work 

    RAMSAY: 5 quiet 

    JONES: 8.5

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    CLARKE: 5 first game excuses lots 🤞

    ANDERSON: 6 busy but prefer CC in that role

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 

    KNIBBS: 4 that midfield 3 untried and looked dreadful 

    LEABURN: 7 grafted hard

    KELMAN: 4 zero service

    Referee: 8 lovely chap 

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 8 our most positive outlet but final ball??

    DYKES: 7 great impact good assist


  • Sponsored links:



  • kilian_om
    kilian_om Posts: 57

    KAMINSKI:9.5

    BREE: 4

    RAMSAY:5

    JONES:6

    GILLESPHEY:6

    CLARKE:6

    ANDERSON:5.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:6

    KNIBBS:5

    LEABURN:7

    KELMAN:6

    Referee:

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5 

    DYKES:7

    GODDEN: n/a



  • jose
    jose Posts: 951
    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 5

    RAMSAY: 5.5

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    CLARKE: 6

    ANDERSON: 6

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5.5

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 6

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 7

  • BertieB
    BertieB Posts: 884
    edited January 17

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 6

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 5

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 10 100% pass completion to Kaminski

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5

    KNIBBS: 5

    LEABURN: 6

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 10 motm

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6

    DYKES: 7

  • roseandcrown
    roseandcrown Posts: 7,594

    KAMINSKI: 8.5

    BREE: 7

    RAMSAY: 7.5

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 7

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5

    KNIBBS: 6.5

    LEABURN: 6.5

    KELMAN: 6.5

    Referee: 8

    Subs: CAREY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    DYKES:7.5

  • mendonca
    mendonca Posts: 9,516

    KAMINSKI: 9
    BREE: 4
    RAMSAY: 5
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    CLARKE: 7
    ANDERSON: 5
    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
    KNIBBS: 5
    LEABURN: 6
    KELMAN: 5
    Referee: 9
    Subs:
    CAREY: 7
    CAMPBELL: 8
    DYKES: 8
  • AddickNL88
    AddickNL88 Posts: 213
    KAMINSKI: 7

    BREE: 5

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 5

    GILLESPHEY: 5

    CLARKE: 6

    ANDERSON: 4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5

    KNIBBS: 5

    LEABURN: 6

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee:

    Subs: CAREY: 6

    CAMPBELL: 6

    DYKES: 6
  • Jdredsox
    Jdredsox Posts: 555
    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 6

    RAMSAY: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 5

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 5.5

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 8

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    DYKES: 7

    GODDEN: n/a
  • AddicksAddict
    AddicksAddict Posts: 16,033

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 5

    RAMSAY: 6.5

    JONES: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 3

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5

    KNIBBS: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 9

    Subs: CAREY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 7.5


  • Viewfinder
    Viewfinder Posts: 4,933

    KAMINSKI:  6.5

    BREE:  3.5

    RAMSAY:  4

    JONES:  6

    GILLESPHEY:  4

    CLARKE:  5

    ANDERSON:  4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO:  3.5

    KNIBBS:  3.5

    LEABURN:  5.5

    KELMAN:  5.5

    Referee:  7

    Subs: CAREY:  5.5

    CAMPBELL:  5

    DYKES:  4.5

    GODDEN: n/a

  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,572

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BREE: 6

    RAMSAY: 6.5

    JONES: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    CLARKE: 7

    ANDERSON: 4

    RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

    KNIBBS: 5.5

    LEABURN: 6.5

    KELMAN: 5.5

    Referee: 7

    Subs: CAREY: 6

    CAMPBELL: 7

    DYKES: 7

    GODDEN: n/a 

Categories

“Marketplace”