Players Marks: Charlton v Ipswich (closes Thursday lunchtime)
Comments
-
KAMINSKI; 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
JONES: 7
SICHENJE: 7
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;: 9
COVENTRY: 7
J R-C: 5
FEVRIER;: 7
CAMPBELL: 6
KELMAN: 5
Referee: 5
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5
DYKES: 5
CAREY : 5
GODDEN: 5
KNIBBS: 4
0 -
KAMINSKI; 7
GILLESPHEY: 4
JONES: 8
SICHENJE: 8
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY; 8.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
J R-C: 7
FEVRIER;: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
KELMAN: 7
Referee:
Subs: CHAMBERS: 6
DYKES: 6
CAREY : 6
GODDEN: 7
KNIBBS: 6
0 -
Kaminski 7
Sichenje 7
Jones 6.5
Gillesphey 6.5
Bell 6
Fevrier 6
Coventry 5.5
Docherty 7.5
Rankin Costello 6
Campbell 6
Kelman 4
Ref 5
Chambers 4
Carey 4
Dykes 4.5
Godden 4
Knibbs 50 -
KAMINSKI; 4
GILLESPHEY: 3
JONES: 6
SICHENJE: 7
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;: 8
COVENTRY: 6
J R-C: 5 what is he actually good at...?
FEVRIER;: 7
CAMPBELL: 6
KELMAN: 6
Referee: 3
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5
DYKES: 5 carthorse
CAREY : 5
GODDEN: 3 not his fault being injured. He actually hindered us staying on
KNIBBS: 40 -
KAMINSKI; 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 6
JONES: 6
SICHENJE: 7
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY; 7.5:
COVENTRY: 6.5
J R-C: 6
FEVRIER: 7
CAMPBELL:7
KELMAN:6
Referee:5.5
Subs:CHAMBERS: 6
DYKES: 6.5
CAREY : 6
GODDEN: 6
KNIBBS:5.5
0 -
KAMINSKI; 7
GILLESPHEY: 5
JONES:7
SICHENJE: 7
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;:8
COVENTRY: 6
J R-C: 6
FEVRIER: 8 (good attacking display)
CAMPBELL: 7
KELMAN: 6
Referee: 6
Subs: CHAMBERS:6.5
DYKES: 6
CAREY : 7
GODDEN: 5
KNIBBS: 50 -
KAMINSKI;7
GILLESPHEY:5.5
JONES:8
SICHENJE:7.5
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY:8.5
COVENTRY:7
J R-C:6
FEVRIER:7.5
CAMPBELL:7
KELMAN:5
Referee:5
Subs: CHAMBERS:6.5
DYKES:5
CAREY :6
GODDEN:5
KNIBBS:40 -
KAMINSKI; 6 - an excellent save deep into injury time but might have done better with a poorly placed penalty given that he went the right way
GILLESPHEY: 5 - he always has an error in him and his lack of pace is a liability at this level
JONES: 6 - fairly solid
SICHENJE: 6.5 - a very good first half, with his aggressive, front-footed defending. Tired towards the end
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY: 8: MoTM - excellent out of possession and tried to get things moving
COVENTRY: 6 - not progressive enough
J R-C: 5 - poor
FEVRIER;: 7 - did well, particularly in the first half
CAMPBELL: 6 - an uneven performance but his pace stretched Ipswich prior to being crocked
KELMAN: 5 - barely touched the ball. He is not, in my view, a Championship level player
Referee: 5
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5 - a bit weak and offers very little going forward
DYKES: 5 - struggled against strong and robust defenders
CAREY : 6 - tried to get things moving
GODDEN: 5 - was instantly fouled and injured. Really sad to see the poor guy hobbling around
KNIBBS: 5 - didn't notice him touching the ball1 -
KAMINSKI;6.5 -1 for the poor attempt at stopping the pen.
GILLESPHEY:5 -1 for the clumsy coming together with the forward once he was goal side.
JONES:7. Smashed in the face early which the Sky cameras didn't want to show and I thought it must be serious. Form has dipped a tad but hardly surprising with the carnage around him.
SICHENJE:6.5 had a really difficult job after a lay off and being inexperienced at this level. Won the First few duels with Philogene but lost the race leading to the 1st goal.
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY:9 Thought the Doch was excellent especially 1st half and it was cruel that the well placed shot from Furlong went through his legs after being in the right place for a block.
COVENTRY:6.5 I always find it hard to score Conor as in the Championship it's always a mixed bag compared to the easier League 1 for him.
J R-C: 6 I saw him running around a lot but didn't impact the game unlike Docherty.
FEVRIER: 7.5 he gives everything even when double marked going forward.
CAMPBELL:7.5 had a decent 1st half until he was mullered by the defender.
KELMAN:6.5 he got into space and competed well and had a narrow angle for his shot.
Referee: 4 why no yellow for the foul on Charlie ? Also TC was crunched and he didn't even give a free kick
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5.5 did ok against tough opponents.
DYKES:5 couldn't beat the CB.
CAREY :7 had plenty of the ball when he came on but couldn't impact the game.
GODDEN:5 was fouled straight away and was then a passenger.
KNIBBS:5.5 This season has passed Harvey by for a myriad of reasons.0 -
KAMINSKI; 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
JONES: 7
SICHENJE: 7
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;: 9
COVENTRY: 8
J R-C: 5
FEVRIER;: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 6
KELMAN: 6
Referee: 4
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5
DYKES: 5
CAREY : 6
GODDEN: Injured
KNIBBS: 4 Did he touch the ball apart from one header?0 -
Sponsored links:
-
KAMINSKI; 7 Outstanding, bar the penalty. Contender for save of the season late on.
GILLESPHEY: 4 Was solid, but his lack of pace led to the penalty.
JONES: 7 Bog standard, dominant display
SICHENJE: 7.5 Excellent. Sure, he tired, but just coming back ftom injury, that was to be expected. One of the first names on the team sheet next season.
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY: 8 PotM Was everywhere, a proper captain's display. My mate said in the first half "He'll never keep up this pace!" He did.
COVENTRY: 7 I know many don't know how to score Conor, but, suffice to say, we play better with him in the team. One of the reasons being he doesn't dawdle on the ball.
J R-C: 5 An absolute passenger. Too slow to get forward when attacking, too slow to get back when defending. The game passed him by. We may as well have played with 10 men. And then, even saying that, he can't last 90 minutes...
FEVRIER: 7 Another decent all-action showing. Ran and ran and ran, with very little help on either flank, so ended up being doubled, and tripled up on.
CAMPBELL: 6 Was doing OK until crocked. When injured, the fear of his pace disappeared from the Ipswich defence. He does need to get his head up more.
KELMAN: 6 Plowing a lone furrow in the first half, to poor balls up to him. He needs channel balls, not ones where he's supposed to compete aerially.
Referee:
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5.5 Pretty meh. Defended OK, but did not put the work rate in going forward that Fevrier didDYKES: 6 Battled. That's about it. Looked tired.
CAREY : 5.5 Didn't really notice him
GODDEN: 6 It says something that Ipswich's first action was to crock him.KNIBBS: 5.5 Didn't really notice him.
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 3.5
JONES: 8
SICHENJE: 6.5
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY: 7
COVENTRY: 6.5
J R-C: 6
FEVRIER: 7
CAMPBELL: 6.5
KELMAN: 6.5
Referee: 5
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5
DYKES: 5.5
CAREY: 5
GODDEN: 5.5
KNIBBS: 50 -
KAMINSKI; 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 3
JONES: 6.5
SICHENJE: 6
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;: 8
COVENTRY: 6.5
J R-C: 3.5
FEVRIER;: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
KELMAN: 4
Referee: 4
Subs: CHAMBERS: 4
DYKES: 4.5
CAREY : 5.5
GODDEN: 5
KNIBBS: 50 -
lancashire lad said:
KAMINSKI;6 I could have saved that penalty
GILLESPHEY:5 Lacks pace , in fact lacks everything
JONES:7 We would be lost at the back without him
SICHENJE:6.5 Gives everything but faded badly last 20 minutes
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;:8 MOM . As good as I’ve seen him . Deserved goal
COVENTRY:6.5 much better but never offers much in an attacking sense
J R-C:5 started the game well but disappeared for long periods
FEVRIER;:7 looked up for it but not a lot came off
CAMPBELL: 5 did ok
KELMAN: 5 made some good runs early doors
Referee: 2 big Ipswich fan apparently
Subs: CHAMBERS: 4 too lightweight
DYKES: 4 nothing of note
CAREY : 6 did well
GODDEN: 5 difficult to mark as got injured as soon as he came on
KNIBBS:5!won a header but given as a foul incorrectly . He never seems to do a lot
0 -
KAMINSKI; 6 - should have saved that awful pen
GILLESPHEY: 5.5 - decent passing, but defending is sub par
JONES: - 6.5 - usual Jones.
SICHENJE: 6 - strong and quick, but got beat for their first goal. also his first touch let him down.
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY;: 8 - twas everywhere
COVENTRY: 6 - keeps ball moving in midfield, but doesnt gamble enough with runs or incisive passing
J R-C: - 5.5 - good first 15min, then faded.
FEVRIER;: 6.5 - great first half, then awful second half. hesitant to whip a cross in
CAMPBELL: 6 - involved early then faded away. his body language on the field is questionable.
KELMAN: 6 - tried his best at being a CF, but couldnt bring the ball down enough to keep possession
Referee: 2 - just awful. baited into ipswich being soft.
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5 - no offensive threat. decent defending, but still gets beaten occasionally
DYKES: 5 - no linkup play
CAREY : 5 - short cameo where i dont remember him doing much
GODDEN: 5.5 - injured but played on
KNIBBS: 5.5 - offers a combative option in midfield, but didnt get on the ball much in his limited minutes0 -
-
KAMINSKI; 6GILLESPHEY: 5JONES: 6.5SICHENJE: 6.5BELL: n/aDOCHERTY;: 8.5COVENTRY: 6.5J R-C: 6FEVRIER;: 6.5CAMPBELL: 6KELMAN: 5.5Referee: 4Subs: CHAMBERS: 5.5
DYKES: 5
CAREY : 6.5GODDEN: 5KNIBBS: 50 -
KAMINSKI; 7
GILLESPHEY: 4.5
JONES: 7
SICHENJE: 7.5
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY: 8 MOTM
COVENTRY: 7
J R-C: 6
FEVRIER: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7
KELMAN: 6.5
Referee: 3
Subs: CHAMBERS: 6
DYKES: 5.5
CAREY: 6
GODDEN: 6 (gets a +2 for staying out there when injured)
KNIBBS: 5.50 -
Totally agree with comments about JRC - worse player that I have seen in a Charlton shirt for the last 5 years - why have you given him 5 - more like a 1 for turning upSteveACS said:KAMINSKI; 7 Outstanding, bar the penalty. Contender for save of the season late on.
GILLESPHEY: 4 Was solid, but his lack of pace led to the penalty.
JONES: 7 Bog standard, dominant display
SICHENJE: 7.5 Excellent. Sure, he tired, but just coming back ftom injury, that was to be expected. One of the first names on the team sheet next season.
BELL: n/a
DOCHERTY: 8 PotM Was everywhere, a proper captain's display. My mate said in the first half "He'll never keep up this pace!" He did.
COVENTRY: 7 I know many don't know how to score Conor, but, suffice to say, we play better with him in the team. One of the reasons being he doesn't dawdle on the ball.
J R-C: 5 An absolute passenger. Too slow to get forward when attacking, too slow to get back when defending. The game passed him by. We may as well have played with 10 men. And then, even saying that, he can't last 90 minutes...
FEVRIER: 7 Another decent all-action showing. Ran and ran and ran, with very little help on either flank, so ended up being doubled, and tripled up on.
CAMPBELL: 6 Was doing OK until crocked. When injured, the fear of his pace disappeared from the Ipswich defence. He does need to get his head up more.
KELMAN: 6 Plowing a lone furrow in the first half, to poor balls up to him. He needs channel balls, not ones where he's supposed to compete aerially.
Referee:
Subs: CHAMBERS: 5.5 Pretty meh. Defended OK, but did not put the work rate in going forward that Fevrier didDYKES: 6 Battled. That's about it. Looked tired.
CAREY : 5.5 Didn't really notice him
GODDEN: 6 It says something that Ipswich's first action was to crock him.KNIBBS: 5.5 Didn't really notice him.
0
