Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Swansea 3-1 Charlton (closes Sunday lunchtime)

2»

Comments

  • CafcWest
    CafcWest Posts: 6,343

    KAMINSKI: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 6

    CHAMBERS: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    COADY: 5.5

    CLARKE: 5

    FEVRIER: 6.6

    KNIBBS: 5

    DYKES: 5.5

    Referee: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    CAREY: 6

    J R-C: 5

    BERRY: 6

    KELMAN:6

  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,398

    KAMINSKI: 6

    GILLESPHEY; 6

    JONES; 6.5

    BURKE:6.5

    CHAMBERS:7

    COVENTRY:6.5

    COADY:6

    CLARKE:5.5

    FEVRIER:5

    KNIBBS:5

    DYKES;6

    Referee:8

    LEABURN:7.5

    CAREY;6

    J R-C:6

    BERRY;4

    KELMAN:6

  • Kaminski 6
    Gillesphey 6
    Jones 7
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6
    Coventry 5
    Coady 6
    Clarke 6
    Fevrier 4
    Knibbs 6
    Dykes 5
    Ref 6
    Leaburn 7.5
    Carey 6.5
    Jrc 5
    Berry 7
    Kelman 6
  • Dugdaleclass
    Dugdaleclass Posts: 607

    KAMINSKI: 7 One very good save in the first half and no fault for any of Swansea's goals

    GILLESPHEY; 6 Solid enough in defending and unlucky with the deflection for their first

    JONES; 7.5 Battled away

    BURKE: 5 Did ok but so slow

    CHAMBERS: 8 Some top class defending in the first half particularly

    COVENTRY: 5 Kept on giving away free kicks in dangerous areas and, again, lacked a forward pass

    COADY: 8 Very calm and collected and was missed badly when he went off

    CLARKE: 5 Good throw ins but far too error prone

    FEVRIER: 4 Never given a chance to run at his opponents

    KNIBBS: 4 Tough afternoon and poor when crossing

    DYKES; 5 Lonely up front

    Referee: 8 Good 

    LEABURN: 8 Very impressive on his return but can he keep it up?

    CAREY; 5 Tried to inject some energy

    J R-C: 4 Doesn't appear to have any energy

    BERRY; 5 Thanks for last year's efforts

    KELMAN: 7 Looked eager to get on the scoresheet again

  • SaySomething
    SaySomething Posts: 2,625

    KAMINSKI: 6

    GILLESPHEY;6

    JONES;7

    BURKE:6

    CHAMBERS:7

    COVENTRY:6

    COADY:7

    CLARKE:4.5

    FEVRIER:6

    KNIBBS:4

    DYKES;5

    Referee:7

    LEABURN:7

    CAREY;5

    J R-C:6

    BERRY;6

    KELMAN:6

  • Eric_Dales
    Eric_Dales Posts: 436

    KAMINSKI: 5

    GILLESPHEY; 6

    JONES; 6

    BURKE: 6

    CHAMBERS: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 6

    COADY: 6

    CLARKE: 5

    FEVRIER: 6

    KNIBBS: 6

    DYKES; 5

    Referee: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    CAREY; 6

    J R-C: 5

    BERRY; 5

    KELMAN: 6



  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,897

    Watched on Sky:

    KAMINSKI: 6 played ok but still not convinced he's better than Mannion.

    GILLESPHEY; 6.5 Macca had a decent game

    JONES;7 The POTY can have a much needed rest after having 45 battles.

    BURKE:6.5 if he ever stayed fit we might be able to judge him.Can never seem to go the distance.

    CHAMBERS:7.5 He basically played in Under 21 or was injured before the loan and he is a competent footballer who can improve with games. His attacking Wing back play will improve in other teams more than CAFC.

    COVENTRY:6.5 put in a shift and was effective 1st half but with Burke and Coady going off the dam burst.

    COADY:6 Not his strongest game but a good loan from Wrexham.

    CLARKE:5 Harry game has become so erratic. Make poor decisions and has lost his Mojo.

    FEVRIER:5.Nothing like the impact of last week but he has talent and flair and that's in short supply at CAFC.

    KNIBBS:5.5 Harvey haven't impressed me on the ball yet but bags of energy. If he had held back a tad he would have buried a header on the edge of the six yard box.

    DYKES;6  lacks something but has given 100%

    Referee:7 maybe because the game had no jeopardy he did fine.

    LEABURN:7 hit the ground running and was livelier than recent times.

    CAREY;6.5 we know he has lost some form from the 1st 30 games of the season but he finishes in credit.

    J R-C:6 seems ok on the ball but haven't ripped up any trees.

    BERRY;6 was involved in a couple of good moves but has had no impact in this season.

    KELMAN:7 looked sharp but only given a small cameo.


  • JamesSeed
    JamesSeed Posts: 17,488
    edited May 4
    Kaminski 6
    Gillesphey 6
    Jones 7
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Coventry 6
    Coady 6
    Clarke 6
    Fevrier 6
    Knibbs 6
    Dykes 6
    Ref 6
    Leaburn 7
    Carey 6
    Jrc 6
    Berry 6
    Kelman 6
  • Longtimeaddicted
    Longtimeaddicted Posts: 611

    KAMINSKI: 6

    GILLESPHEY;4

    JONES;8

    BURKE:6

    CHAMBERS:7

    COVENTRY:6

    COADY:6

    CLARKE:5

    FEVRIER:8

    KNIBBS:7

    DYKES;4

    Referee:5

    LEABURN:7

    CAREY;5

    J R-C:7

    BERRY;4

    KELMAN:7

  • SDAddick
    SDAddick Posts: 14,841

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY; 6.5

    JONES; 7.5

    BURKE: 6

    CHAMBERS: 8

    COVENTRY: 6

    COADY: 6

    CLARKE: 6

    FEVRIER: 5.5

    KNIBBS: 5

    DYKES; 6

    Referee: 7

    LEABURN: 7.5

    CAREY; 6.5

    J R-C: 6.5

    BERRY; 6.5

    KELMAN: 6.5