Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Summer Window 2026 - Rumours and Discussion
Comments
-
In fairness he had a very good game. I remember joking to my brother ""who's this lad he looks decent"!LittleAddick said:
Must say I don't remember that happeningct_addick said:Gilbert ran the show for Boro v us at the Valley last season0 -
I don't know the circumstances surrounding the signing of Dykes & Coady so I couldn't say if we were smart or lucky? What I do know is NJ signed Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez because I assume he saw some value of having them in our squad. That worked well didn't it ? Come the end of August we'll have a better idea of whether we have been smart or not.fenaddick said:
So you agree we've got smarter since last summer but think we'd be lucky if we did well this summer?charltonbob said:
Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, + Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez, 2 free agents who joined after the summer window closed. How many of those would you consider to be smart signings ? Carey scored important goals for sure but fairly soon seemed to fade out of games, Bell was smart unlike NJ who thought he could play him as LWB when he got injured every time he played there. Bree started well but faded (Although I understand he was carrying an injury that prevented him taking free kicks i.e. kicking the ball, WTF was he doing in the team if his kicking was impaired?) I would agree as I've mentioned before, the January window was very good & without those incomings, most notably Conor Coady I think we would have been relegated. However, the January window can't be considered the summer which as per my post was the window I was referring to.fenaddick said:
I’d say Carey was smart. Bell was smart. Bree was smart. Then on top of that I think every signing in January was smart too. We just had a window where every single signing was a success to some degree. That is so rarecharltonbob said:fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
That would be great but I'm thinking of our transfer business last summer. How smart do you think we were then ?fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong3 -
Going up through the play offs and then having to recruit for a division higher made last summer very difficult. I think given the circumstances we did pretty well which is why we didn’t get relegatedcharltonbob said:
I don't know the circumstances surrounding the signing of Dykes & Coady so I couldn't say if we were smart or lucky? What I do know is NJ signed Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez because I assume he saw some value of having them in our squad. That worked well didn't it ? Come the end of August we'll have a better idea of whether we have been smart or not.fenaddick said:
So you agree we've got smarter since last summer but think we'd be lucky if we did well this summer?charltonbob said:
Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, + Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez, 2 free agents who joined after the summer window closed. How many of those would you consider to be smart signings ? Carey scored important goals for sure but fairly soon seemed to fade out of games, Bell was smart unlike NJ who thought he could play him as LWB when he got injured every time he played there. Bree started well but faded (Although I understand he was carrying an injury that prevented him taking free kicks i.e. kicking the ball, WTF was he doing in the team if his kicking was impaired?) I would agree as I've mentioned before, the January window was very good & without those incomings, most notably Conor Coady I think we would have been relegated. However, the January window can't be considered the summer which as per my post was the window I was referring to.fenaddick said:
I’d say Carey was smart. Bell was smart. Bree was smart. Then on top of that I think every signing in January was smart too. We just had a window where every single signing was a success to some degree. That is so rarecharltonbob said:fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
That would be great but I'm thinking of our transfer business last summer. How smart do you think we were then ?fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
We made some great signings, we made some alright signings and we made some bad signings. I’m sure we will do the same again this summer, as will every team in the country. Since Jones has taken over we’ve got more right than we’ve got wrong which is why we are now in the championship when we were looking over our shoulders in league 1 before that. You can’t make that kind of progress without good recruitment, and a few poor signings last summer when we had to rush things doesn’t change that33 -
Struggle to keep up on recent posts here Annapolis if already had this convo but thank god we got ahadme wages off the books at least - reckon he’ll sell olafe and let dykes go elsewhere and sign up front ??0
-
And see were linked with lundstrum from hull - decent player too but better than doc ??1
-
What makes you think that? He has gone on loan to Cambridge. We will still be paying what we contracted to pay him, less whatever Cambridge pay their players. So we will be paying between half and two-thirds of his wages here. And probably the following season too.Neil01 said:
... thank God we got Ahadme's wages off the books at least
5 -
Yes, ultimately to bring in proven Championship experience has to be the route to go down.ShootersHillGuru said:
It’s not just about that though. Plucking someone from the Slovenian league or elsewhere and plonking them into one of the most competitive leagues in the world is a big hope. Many will make the cut but many won’t. That’s not a criticism of our two (three with Sichenje) lads, it’s just such a big gamble. I fully understand why we’re doing it and physically and in terms of athleticism those three look the part but I’d still say maybe one more this window might be enough. Proven Championship players saved our season in January and I think it’s going to make or break us this coming season too.ElfsborgAddick said:
It could be a lot cheaper, plus if you bring players in from a similar culture like Scandinavia, Holland or Germany then moving and settling in could be less stressful.ShootersHillGuru said:I really like the fact we’ve targeted Europe for players but it also scares me. It’s such a huge gamble.1 -
-
Sponsored links:
-
Would be another experienced champ head and he did play 29 games for Hull last season on loan but I'd see it as another squad player. Think we are going more down the athleticism route than a yet another workhorse.wmcf123 said:0 -
charltonbob said:
I don't know the circumstances surrounding the signing of Dykes & Coady so I couldn't say if we were smart or lucky? What I do know is NJ signed Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez because I assume he saw some value of having them in our squad. That worked well didn't it ? Come the end of August we'll have a better idea of whether we have been smart or not.fenaddick said:
So you agree we've got smarter since last summer but think we'd be lucky if we did well this summer?charltonbob said:
Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, + Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez, 2 free agents who joined after the summer window closed. How many of those would you consider to be smart signings ? Carey scored important goals for sure but fairly soon seemed to fade out of games, Bell was smart unlike NJ who thought he could play him as LWB when he got injured every time he played there. Bree started well but faded (Although I understand he was carrying an injury that prevented him taking free kicks i.e. kicking the ball, WTF was he doing in the team if his kicking was impaired?) I would agree as I've mentioned before, the January window was very good & without those incomings, most notably Conor Coady I think we would have been relegated. However, the January window can't be considered the summer which as per my post was the window I was referring to.fenaddick said:
I’d say Carey was smart. Bell was smart. Bree was smart. Then on top of that I think every signing in January was smart too. We just had a window where every single signing was a success to some degree. That is so rarecharltonbob said:fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
That would be great but I'm thinking of our transfer business last summer. How smart do you think we were then ?fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
To be fair, we don't know the circumstances of the summer signings. We know we wanted Galbraith and seemingly Offiah. Galbraith just went for a lot of money, no idea about Offiah but he played the whole season for Preston. There will have been others we don't know about.
So Tanto and Apter etc could have been very low down on our list and the best players available at the wages we had to offer.
I thought last summer was disappointing and we clearly need to improve on that markedly to survive again this season but how much was down to NJ and how much was down to budget (and timings post play offs etc) I don't think we know.10 -
I think we will be willing to spend relatively big on a midfielder such as Jordan Holsgrove or Brian De Keersmaecker, problem is they will have a lot of options and we probably won't be their preferred choice. For this reason I think our budget/willingness to spend won't be the biggest obstacle to improving the first 11 with proven talent.
Suspect we will end up having to take a risk on League one and international talent and hope that our scouting team earns their crust. This will be alongside some proven championship players who are slightly past their sell by date.
6 -
I don’t think people can grasp how difficult it was to recruit for such a competitive league with the 3rd worst budget (or they don’t want to understand), especially when we had to overhaul most of the L1 squad. We would’ve been at the back of the queue for all signings, not being able to offer wages remotely close to the rest of the league. Our only choice would’ve been high risk signings, and the real scraps of the market too. Had we been relegated then there might been some merit to the criticism, but we weren’t ever in a relegation scrap and were ultimately successful. There was a high wastage in the recruitment but I believe that would have been in the plan. What do you want, a no risk recruitment policy and a return to L1, I don’t?charltonbob said:
I don't know the circumstances surrounding the signing of Dykes & Coady so I couldn't say if we were smart or lucky? What I do know is NJ signed Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez because I assume he saw some value of having them in our squad. That worked well didn't it ? Come the end of August we'll have a better idea of whether we have been smart or not.fenaddick said:
So you agree we've got smarter since last summer but think we'd be lucky if we did well this summer?charltonbob said:
Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, + Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez, 2 free agents who joined after the summer window closed. How many of those would you consider to be smart signings ? Carey scored important goals for sure but fairly soon seemed to fade out of games, Bell was smart unlike NJ who thought he could play him as LWB when he got injured every time he played there. Bree started well but faded (Although I understand he was carrying an injury that prevented him taking free kicks i.e. kicking the ball, WTF was he doing in the team if his kicking was impaired?) I would agree as I've mentioned before, the January window was very good & without those incomings, most notably Conor Coady I think we would have been relegated. However, the January window can't be considered the summer which as per my post was the window I was referring to.fenaddick said:
I’d say Carey was smart. Bell was smart. Bree was smart. Then on top of that I think every signing in January was smart too. We just had a window where every single signing was a success to some degree. That is so rarecharltonbob said:fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
That would be great but I'm thinking of our transfer business last summer. How smart do you think we were then ?fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong28 -
Cmon St Johnstone where r ya0
-
Think they're in Perth Scotland.9
-
That’s the second time in this thread you’ve posted that and I still have no idea what you mean.Charlton43 said:Cmon St Johnstone where r ya2 -
Has the world stopped turning ?
Where are you all ? Usually I log on at lunchtime & there are pages of chat.
Today, just 3 (THREE) posts between 10am & 2pm.
Or has everyone died due to the heat ?6 -
Ownership have cut the amount of posters like they have the budget.golfaddick said:Has the world stopped turning ?
Where are you all ? Usually I log on at lunchtime & there are pages of chat.
Today, just 3 (THREE) posts between 10am & 2pm.
Or has everyone died due to the heat ?
Lots going on, on the women's CharltonLife though.14 -
Sponsored links:
-
AFKA said to have stormed out of a meeting with the other adminsFishCostaFortune said:
Ownership have cut the amount of posters like they have the budget.golfaddick said:Has the world stopped turning ?
Where are you all ? Usually I log on at lunchtime & there are pages of chat.
Today, just 3 (THREE) posts between 10am & 2pm.
Or has everyone died due to the heat ?
Lots going on, on the women's CharltonLife though.29 -
I agree with recent comments re.. rather buy (say) 2 quality players for large fees than 4 or 5 'squad members', spreading the cash too thinly .. though (e.g.) the Galbraith move shows that £10 Million doesn't go very far in the current player transfer market0
-
Well said.NabySarr said:
Going up through the play offs and then having to recruit for a division higher made last summer very difficult. I think given the circumstances we did pretty well which is why we didn’t get relegatedcharltonbob said:
I don't know the circumstances surrounding the signing of Dykes & Coady so I couldn't say if we were smart or lucky? What I do know is NJ signed Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez because I assume he saw some value of having them in our squad. That worked well didn't it ? Come the end of August we'll have a better idea of whether we have been smart or not.fenaddick said:
So you agree we've got smarter since last summer but think we'd be lucky if we did well this summer?charltonbob said:
Rob Apter, Harvey Knibbs, Isaac Olaofe, Joe Rankin-Costello, Reece Burke, + Jerome Roussillon & Onel Hernandez, 2 free agents who joined after the summer window closed. How many of those would you consider to be smart signings ? Carey scored important goals for sure but fairly soon seemed to fade out of games, Bell was smart unlike NJ who thought he could play him as LWB when he got injured every time he played there. Bree started well but faded (Although I understand he was carrying an injury that prevented him taking free kicks i.e. kicking the ball, WTF was he doing in the team if his kicking was impaired?) I would agree as I've mentioned before, the January window was very good & without those incomings, most notably Conor Coady I think we would have been relegated. However, the January window can't be considered the summer which as per my post was the window I was referring to.fenaddick said:
I’d say Carey was smart. Bell was smart. Bree was smart. Then on top of that I think every signing in January was smart too. We just had a window where every single signing was a success to some degree. That is so rarecharltonbob said:fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
That would be great but I'm thinking of our transfer business last summer. How smart do you think we were then ?fenaddick said:
Why do we need to get lucky? Why can’t we be smart?charltonbob said:
You have me worried now cabblescabbles said:
Completely agree.Southbank said:I think all of our midfielders are good enough for a relegation struggle, as they showed last season, but even that depended on Coady being brought in.
I don,'t think any of our current midfield, individually or collectively, are good enough to be regulars in a successful Champ side. That for me is the dilemma facing NJ. Where are the quality players coming from?We really need to see at least one player who is a real threat on the ball and the type the opposition back off when he has it. TC hasn’t proven if he’s capable of delivering at this level yet (yes, I know he plays off the striker as opposed to midfield, but he’s the only player in our team who comes close to fitting that mould), so we can’t say for certain he’s that pacey/creative outlet.Carey’s goals were priceless, but for me he faded well before the end of the season, and take away his goals, he can be anonymous. Knibbs, no idea whether or not he will deliver based on how little we saw of him last season and his injury. Docherty is a great pro and he put in a shift last season, but if he’s starting regularly, are we really kicking on? Obviously Coventry is the deepest lying of the midfielders and I would like to see an upgrade, but with regards to his role, it’s that pacy unit needed who can get about, break up play and move the ball to start attacks quickly
after that we’re in the peripherals. JRC, technically solid and showed some glimpses, but not that attacking force we require. Anderson, I just don’t think he’s able to step up to this level unfortunately. Fullah shows promise, but this is without any sort of football league loan under his belt, and Mwamba although highly rated, is further back than Fullah in terms of experience
............... sadly I agree with all you say. With regards to TC he's certainly pacy, unfortunately just not very creative or a natural goal scorer. We need to get very lucky in this transfer window or we'll find ourselves back in the third division. We have to hope that Jones & Ramsay sign new deals to at least keep our defence relatively strong
We made some great signings, we made some alright signings and we made some bad signings. I’m sure we will do the same again this summer, as will every team in the country. Since Jones has taken over we’ve got more right than we’ve got wrong which is why we are now in the championship when we were looking over our shoulders in league 1 before that. You can’t make that kind of progress without good recruitment, and a few poor signings last summer when we had to rush things doesn’t change that2 -
We're all posting on CharltonLife+ now. £4.99 per month, well worth it.golfaddick said:Has the world stopped turning ?
Where are you all ? Usually I log on at lunchtime & there are pages of chat.
Today, just 3 (THREE) posts between 10am & 2pm.
Or has everyone died due to the heat ?29 -
Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games1
-
Just out of interest, how many loan players, did we bring in last season?TheAddicks4Ever said:Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games
1 -
1 in the summer (Bree) and 4 in January (Clarke, Fevrier, Chambers, Coady)Mendonca In Asdas said:
Just out of interest, how many loan players, did we bring in last season?TheAddicks4Ever said:Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games2 -
fenaddick said:
1 in the summer (Bree) and 4 in January (Clarke, Fevrier, Chambers, Coady)Mendonca In Asdas said:
Just out of interest, how many loan players, did we bring in last season?TheAddicks4Ever said:Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games
Definitely need to make better use of the loan system. The right players (Cullen, Gallagher etc) can have a huge impact and save transfer budget that can be spent elsewhere.1 -
Hopefully we look more attractive to clubs and loanees nowDamoNorthStand said:fenaddick said:
1 in the summer (Bree) and 4 in January (Clarke, Fevrier, Chambers, Coady)Mendonca In Asdas said:
Just out of interest, how many loan players, did we bring in last season?TheAddicks4Ever said:Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games
Definitely need to make better use of the loan system. The right players (Cullen, Gallagher etc) can have a huge impact and save transfer budget that can be spent elsewhere.1 -
Don't underestimate the Lee Bowyer pullDamoNorthStand said:fenaddick said:
1 in the summer (Bree) and 4 in January (Clarke, Fevrier, Chambers, Coady)Mendonca In Asdas said:
Just out of interest, how many loan players, did we bring in last season?TheAddicks4Ever said:Loan players are going to be key for us this year. Unfortunately they are likely to come late in the transfer window due to distractions of the World Cup for many prem clubs and when they have to submit their squad. We did bring in some solid loan last season so hopefully a little better this year and clubs will want to work with us especially as we played loan players in most games
Definitely need to make better use of the loan system. The right players (Cullen, Gallagher etc) can have a huge impact and save transfer budget that can be spent elsewhere.2











