Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Portsmouth (closes Sunday teatime)

13»

Comments

  • OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA:6.5

    SKIPP: 8

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6.5 

    GRANT: 7

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN:5

    Referee:4

  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 690
    wolfgang said:
    801912601 said:

    Referee: Thought he done ok until he overruled the AC Lino to give an offside against us that wasn’t and then gave us nothing for the rest of the game, as did the AC Lino. 

    What does AC lino mean? Is one lino AC and the other DC?
    Alan Curbishley stand
  • OKONKWO: 7.5
    MESIK: 6.5
    BINDEN: 6
    JONES: 7
    McNAMARA: 6
    SKIPP: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    ALLI: 6
    GRANT( 7
    LEABURN: 8
    KELMAN: 5
    Referee: 5
  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,429

    OKONKWO: 7 - one very good save and a reassuring presence. Distribution could improve but he does his principal job well

    MESIK: 6.5 - solid

    BINDEN: 6 - caught in possession again which could have cost us but thankfully nothing came of it. Hopefully he'll improve with time

    JONES: 7.5 - dominant as ever 

    McNAMARA: 6 - fine defensively but a couple of poor late crosses

    SKIPP: 7.5 - a fine performance. Will hopefully become increasingly influential as he settles into the club

    COVENTRY: 8 - very good in and out of possession. A promising partnership with Skipp

    CAMPBELL: 7.5 - as ever, caused the opposition a lot of problems

    ALLI: 6 - a few promising runs but missed the best chance of the game

    GRANT: 6.5 - worked hard

    LEABURN: 8 - played really well

    KELMAN: 5 - no time to make an impact

    Referee: 5

  • Pedro45
    Pedro45 Posts: 6,181

    OKONKWO: 8- Commanding and a very good save early in 2nd half

    MESIK: 7 - Decent game on his better side

    BINDEN: 5.5 - Battled, but some errors

    JONES: 7.5 - Very good all game

    McNAMARA: 7 - His defending is excellent; it's when he goes forward that the mistakes happen

    SKIPP: 7 - Got stuck in and did well

    COVENTRY: 7.5 - Very good again

    CAMPBELL: 6 - Double teamed and struggled to deliver but didn't give up

    ALLI: 5.5 - Tried hard but missed a sitter

    GRANT: 5 - Buzzed about but little end product

    LEABURN: 7.5 - Another excellent game from the big man, he just needs a goal

    KELMAN: 4 - Little impact

    Referee: 3 - Got pickier as the game went on and bottled the obvious penalty

  • OKONKWO: 7.5

    MESIK: 7.5

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    ALLI: 6

    GRANT 6

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 4

  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 20,180

    At the game

    OKONKWO:7

    MESIK:7

    BINDEN: 6

    JONES:7

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 7.5

    COVENTRY:7

    CAMPBELL:7

    ALLI:6

    GRANT 6.5

    LEABURN:7.5

    KELMAN: 6

  • 0.5 to 10.0 please

    OKONKWO: 7.5 Stopping very good. Some kicking woeful.

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 7

    JONES: 8

    McNAMARA: 6.5 Generally very good, but some misplaced passes

    SKIPP: 7 Solid

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 7.5

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 3 Absolute howler (along with his Linesman), missing the Leaburn pen

  • Brownie12
    Brownie12 Posts: 1,803
    edited September 13

    OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 7

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6

    GRANT 6.5

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN:6

  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 24,564
    edited September 13

    At the Game.

    OKONKWO:7.5  Great hands and good save by the post early into 2nd half. but stop taking the free kick on the half way line as two went straight behind for a goal kick! Also time stands still when the balls at his feet and Arthur is contemplating where to kick the ball too. No problem when we want a point but...

    MESIK:7 Ivan the warrier. Loves to be involved.

    BINDON: Has potential but he makes at least two mistakes most games that really should've led to a goal.

    JONES: 7 a normal match for Lloyd where he gets battered. So pleased he spent less time defending in his six yard box.

    McNAMARA:6.5 quite solid defensively but frustrating when he missed that final cross late on.

    SKIPP:7.5 Excellent tackle late on and he was a big reason why we kept a clean sheet. Not a sexy footballer but does his job well.

    COVENTRY: 7 Very hit and miss with his passing game but 100% effort and he had a great chance late on to win it with the shot from the edge of the box.

    CAMPBELL:7. Not for the want of trying but just the one cross found a CAFC shirt and Alli blazed the volley into the crowd. 

    ALLI:6.5 A typical winger with magic and tragic in equal measures but Milli has talented feet.

    GRANT6.5 Not much came off for Karlan but you can still see he is a Championship quality player. His corners never found a Charlton head but maybe good defending by Pompey.

    LEABURN:8 Led the attack so well and it's a battle every game. Just needs the goal that all number 9's crave. Miles did some brilliant defensive work as Well. MOM.

    KELMAN:6 No time to impact the game but great to see him back. Yes I guess he was rusty.

    Referee: 4 started well by giving a foul on Leaburn but like so many then bottles big decisions. Not helped by the Ass ref who got TC and Grant mixed up and gave an offside.


  • Sponsored links:



  • OKONKWO: 7 Finally have a keeper who inspires confidence. Needs to work on his free kicks further up the pitch.

    MESIK: 7.5 Great defending and was quite mobile.

    BINDEN: 7 Thought he had a good game bar one awful pass that nearly led to a goal

    JONES: 7.5 Usual consistent performance and brought the ball out well a few times

    McNAMARA: 7.5 Good defender. Not much will get past him. Offered very little to the attack

    SKIPP: 8 High work rate and touches of quality

    COVENTRY: 8.5 Was everywhere as usual. Distribution is improving. He and Skipp make a good pair at the base of midfield.

    CAMPBELL: 7 Yet again he offers the best chance of making something happen. Still needs to work on his end product though

    ALLI: 6.5 Marked down because of his second half showing. Was great first half. If he can replicate that for 90 mins he will be mustRD

    GRANT 7.5 High energy levels and and intelligent player. I like him but he is lacking as a No 10

    LEABURN: 8 Great performance. Was a handful for their defence all afternoon

    KELMAN: 6 Didn't affect the game in any way

    Referee: 3 Okay first half but then lost the plot. How was that not a pen at the end? I was so expecting him to point to the spot yet he turned away! I was fuming.

  • JustFloydRoad
    JustFloydRoad Posts: 2,752
    edited September 13

    OKONKWO:6

    MESIK:6

    BINDEN: 7

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA:6

    SKIPP:8

    COVENTRY:7

    CAMPBELL:6

    ALLI:6

    GRANT: 5.5

    LEABURN:5.5, should of had a penatly. 

    KELMAN: Good to see back

    Referee: Another game, another bad referee, another Lino looking at Jones "as if he (Jones) just volleyed his (the lino's) cat"




  • 0.5 to 10.0 please

    OKONKWO: 8.5

    MESIK: 8

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7.5

    McNAMARA: 7.5

    SKIPP: 7

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 8

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT( 7

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 5.5

    Referee: 2


  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,520

    OKONKWO: 6.5

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES:7.5

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    ALLI:6.5

    GRANT 6.5

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 5

  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 2,988

    OKONKWO: 8 

    MESIK: 8

    BINDEN: 7

    JONES: 7.5

    McNAMARA: 7

    SKIPP: 8

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 5

    GRANT: 6.5

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 4

  • Dansk_Red
    Dansk_Red Posts: 5,806

    OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 5

    JONES: 6.5

    McNAMARA: 5.5

    SKIPP: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 6.5

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 5.5

    Referee: 3.5



  • Chef_addick
    Chef_addick Posts: 2,219
    edited September 13
    OKONKWO: 7
    MESIK: 8
    BINDEN: 6.5
    JONES: 7.5
    McNAMARA: 6
    SKIPP: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 8.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    ALLI: 6
    GRANT: 7
    LEABURN: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    Referee: 5.5
  • OKONKWO: 8.5

    MESIK: 7.5

    BINDON: 6.8

    JONES: 8

    McNAMARA: 7

    SKIPP: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8.5

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 7

    LEABURN: 8

    KELMAN: n/a 

    Referee: 2 Started well ended shite 
  • rananegra
    rananegra Posts: 3,788

    OKONKWO: 7.5

    MESIK: 7.5

    BINDEN: 7

    JONES: 8

    McNAMARA: 7.5

    SKIPP: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    ALLI:6.5

    GRANT: 6.5

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 5 pleased he's back, didn't do much

    Referee: 5 less anti Charlton than the last 2 numpties, only missed penalty, got offside wrong and went along with the bizarre goal kick for a corner near the end.  

  • OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDON: 5.5

    JONES: 7.5

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 6

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 7

    LEABURN: 7.5

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 4


  • Sponsored links:



  • Killarahales
    Killarahales Posts: 1,205

    OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 6

    SKIPP: 8

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6

    GRANT 7

    LEABURN: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 5

  • OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 7

    SKIPP: 7

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 7

    LEABURN: 8

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 4.5

  • bromleyjohn
    bromleyjohn Posts: 6,036

    OKONKWO: 7

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 7

    SKIPP: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6

    GRANT( 7

    : 

    KELMAN:6

  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,686

    OKONKWO: 8

    MESIK: 7

    BINDEN: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 8

    COVENTRY: 8.5

    CAMPBELL: 7

    ALLI: 6.5

    GRANT: 6.5

    LEABURN: 8

    KELMAN: 5

    Referee: 5

  • addickson
    addickson Posts: 923

    OKONKWO: 8

    MESIK: 7.5

    BINDEN: 6

    JONES: 7

    McNAMARA: 6.5

    SKIPP: 6

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 8

    ALLI: 6

    GRANT: 6.5

    LEABURN: 8.5

    KELMAN: 6

    Referee: 4

  • SoundAsa£
    SoundAsa£ Posts: 23,020
    801912601 said:
    wolfgang said:
    801912601 said:

    Referee: Thought he done ok until he overruled the AC Lino to give an offside against us that wasn’t and then gave us nothing for the rest of the game, as did the AC Lino. 

    What does AC lino mean? Is one lino AC and the other DC?
    Alan Curbishley stand
    And DC…….what is that?
  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 690
    801912601 said:
    wolfgang said:
    801912601 said:

    Referee: Thought he done ok until he overruled the AC Lino to give an offside against us that wasn’t and then gave us nothing for the rest of the game, as did the AC Lino. 

    What does AC lino mean? Is one lino AC and the other DC?
    Alan Curbishley stand
    And DC…….what is that?
    Dirty Cnut maybe